A teenage narrator goes on Omegle as a joke, then later finds a painted rock and hears knocks at the gated back door while his dogs panic, making him fear a real stalker may be involved.

The episode also revisits past horrors: a threatening anonymous call claiming to be the devil and a black dog that follows them, plus a vivid account of living with a disturbing, erratic housemate whose behavior escalates into cruelty and harassment.