A detailed look at the disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie in Catalina Foothills, focusing on the early-morning timeline, a disabled doorbell camera, a pacemaker connection loss, blood on the porch, and recovered footage showing a masked person.

The episode lays out confirmed facts, key evidence, investigative leads and timelines, and separates verified information from plausible theories about motive and offender profiles.

Discord

In this episode the hosts debate the authenticity of viral paranormal videos—ranging from creepy Japanese apparitions to attic peeks and baby hands—while weighing CGI and staged fakes against convincing evidence.

They also recount their own investigations at St. Luke's, sharing recordings, strange photos, a theory about a hidden basement or crematorium, and plans for future investigations, emphasizing an open-minded but skeptical approach.

A teenage narrator goes on Omegle as a joke, then later finds a painted rock and hears knocks at the gated back door while his dogs panic, making him fear a real stalker may be involved.

The episode also revisits past horrors: a threatening anonymous call claiming to be the devil and a black dog that follows them, plus a vivid account of living with a disturbing, erratic housemate whose behavior escalates into cruelty and harassment.

Discord

You wake up after a transplant to strange tastes, sudden cravings, and vivid memories you never lived — and are told those feelings might belong to the person who saved your life.

This episode explores real cases like Claire Sylvia and Sonny Graham, examines the controversial theory of cellular memory, and weighs reported changes against medical and psychological explanations.

We probe what it would mean if organs carry echoes of the dead: a haunting medical mystery that forces us to rethink identity, grief, and the cost of survival.

Discord

Investigators spend a raw session in the haunted section of a house, noting humidity and background noise while probing for EVPs.

They capture whispers, a little-girl humming, strange screeches, and a loud knock/table bang that appears tied to the homeowner.

The team asks questions, encourages the spirit to use a mic, and plans to review and enhance the audio to confirm what was recorded.

A woman recounts two unsettling events: a rain stick bought in Mexico that unleashed a vision of tribal fires and a white fog in her apartment, prompting attempts at spiritual cleansing before the object was stolen, and a later night when three loud bangs shook her front door, leaving the family terrified and with no reasonable explanation.

Both incidents leave questions about spirits, possible hauntings, and whether the cause was supernatural or mundane, while family history of unexplained occurrences deepens the mystery.

Chloe Williams, 23, was reported missing in February 2024 in Orangeburg County, South Carolina. Human remains discovered on March 13, 2025, off Highway 4 were later ruled a gunshot homicide; no arrests have been made.

Investigators renewed a public call for tips in January 2026, asking anyone with information — no matter how small — to come forward. Tips can be reported to the Orangeburg County Communication Center at 803-534-3550.

In this episode the hosts read and debunk classic urban legends, then share true crimes that inspired them — from organ theft and bodies hidden in mattresses to accidental hangings at haunted attractions, intruders living in walls, and parasitic ear infestations.

They also riff on UFOs, Area 51 conspiracies, and the idea that the government hides alien technology, while asking listeners to share favorite episodes and their takes on these creepy topics.

This episode exposes Cambodia’s scam compounds—guarded operations where people are trafficked, forced to run long‑con investment scams (often called pig butchering), and subjected to forced labor, violence, and torture. It explains how these facilities operate like factories, the human toll on victims inside the compounds, and the financial devastation suffered by targets worldwide.

The episode also outlines why Cambodia became a hub for this industry, international responses and sanctions, and practical red flags and steps to protect yourself: stop sending money, preserve evidence, tell someone you trust, and report the crime. The goal is to raise awareness about the trafficking and fraud machine behind these scams.

Hosts discuss the Urfa Man — a 9,000 BC life‑size statue with black obsidian eyes — and explore whether it connects to modern reports of black‑eyed children. They cover unsettling videos, theories (demons, aliens, other dimensions), safety advice about not letting unknown children inside, the lack of solid evidence, and a listener shoutout to Echo; a follow‑up deep dive is promised.