Happy Easter! Carmen tells John how Easter is different in Spain. The duo then relates who got more gifts for Christmas before Carmen turns everything into a nightmare as she regales all in the story of the Tooth Fairy in Spain. Spoiler alert: it's a rat. Plus, Easter means spring cleaning which leads John and Carmen to go back in time when John discovers old mix tapes from ex-girlfriends. Of course this leads to Carmen role playing as John's exes. Of course.