Uehiro Oxford Institute

Sacred Values and the Sanctity of Life


Listen Later

OUC-Ethox Seminar. Steve Clarke discusses Ronald Dworkin's account of sacred values in his work 'Life's Dominion' and furthers the argument that the assertion 'life is sacred' is tenable by both liberals and conservatives. In his Life’s Dominion (1993) Ronald Dworkin developed an original approach to understanding public debates between liberals and conservatives about the morality of abortion and euthanasia. Conservative opponents of abortion and euthanasia usually invoke the ‘sanctity of life doctrine’ and these debates have often been characterized as turning on whether we should accept that that all human life is sacred, as this doctrine implies. However, Dworkin argued that all mainstream participants in public (but not academic) debates about the morality of abortion and euthanasia accept that life is sacred and that these public debates should be characterized as being over the relative merits of competing liberal and conservative accounts of what the assertion ‘life is sacred’ means and what follows from it. When Life’s Dominion appeared in 1993 it attracted a lot of attention, but most who attended to it, were not won over. A sticking point was Dworkin’s account of sacred values, which was idiosyncratic and unrelated to any of the existing treatments of sacred values, due to theologians, anthropologists, or psychologists. Here I offer a qualified defense of Dworkin. I’ll argue that recent work on sacred values, in anthropology, psychology and neuroscience, gives us good grounds for thinking that the view that life is sacred is held by very many liberals, as well as by mainstream conservatives, and that it is plausible to characterize public debates about abortion and euthanasia as turning on the relative plausibility of competing accounts of what the assertion ‘life is sacred’ means.
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Uehiro Oxford InstituteBy Oxford University

  • 3.8
  • 3.8
  • 3.8
  • 3.8
  • 3.8

3.8

4 ratings


More shows like Uehiro Oxford Institute

View all
Philosophy for Beginners by Oxford University

Philosophy for Beginners

332 Listeners

Approaching Shakespeare by Oxford University

Approaching Shakespeare

334 Listeners

General Philosophy by Oxford University

General Philosophy

70 Listeners

Anthropology by Oxford University

Anthropology

73 Listeners

Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art lectures by Oxford University

Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art lectures

75 Listeners

Theoretical Physics - From Outer Space to Plasma by Oxford University

Theoretical Physics - From Outer Space to Plasma

58 Listeners

Critical Reasoning: A Romp Through the Foothills of Logic by Oxford University

Critical Reasoning: A Romp Through the Foothills of Logic

37 Listeners

The Secrets of Mathematics by Oxford University

The Secrets of Mathematics

42 Listeners

Critical Reasoning for Beginners by Oxford University

Critical Reasoning for Beginners

30 Listeners

CortexCast - A Neuroscience Podcast by Oxford University

CortexCast - A Neuroscience Podcast

4 Listeners