Our heroines must miss the theater, as they attempt some wardrobe tracking in this episode (turns out they are out of practice). Also, they catch a blast from the tech-past, question the capabilities of this neighborhood's police, and make a discography discovery.

Bloody Mary (and Toledo, OH) haunt our heroines' past as they venture into this episode featuring a childhood legend, not to be confused with a character of musical theater fame. And poor Charlie just can't seem to catch a break.

For the fourth episode (which 40 is a multiple of 4...that will make sense later), our heroines start to rethink their past and future flights of their own lives while watching a fake-flying professional crash not one, but two planes. It's ok, he has an excuse...he was possessed by a demon.

Our heroines fawn over this episode (and its guest stars), and can't for the life of them remember the names of the characters in play. A real-life fear of water colors one of their points of view, and a soft-spot is developed for Dean, despite his poorly disguised endeavors.

In this episode, our heroines find out what grinds their gears when it comes to boys and camping, and do not give Dean a break in his constant quest for....well, we'll leave that unsaid.

The first episode of the first season of "Supernatural!" Our heroines discuss how and why they got into the show in the first place, how theater can sneak into even TV media, and fawn over Sarah Shahi of "L Word" fame.