Send us Fan Mail
Can Darwin's theory of evolution deepen our understanding of God rather than simply challenge it?
Evolution has often been portrayed as a threat to Christian faith. Its long history of struggle, predation, suffering, death, and extinction seems to intensify one of theology's most difficult questions: How can such a world be reconciled with belief in a God who is all-loving, all-powerful, and all-knowing?
In this episode, Richard Randolph speaks with United Methodist deacon and theologian Charissa Jaeger-Sanders about the first chapter of her dissertation, which approaches that question from a strikingly different direction. Rather than treating Darwin only as a challenge to Christianity and other faiths, Charissa explores how evolutionary biology may also become a theological gift.
Their conversation considers nature's deep ambiguity. Competition and suffering are undeniably part of the evolutionary story, but so are cooperation, mutualism, adaptability, care, interdependence, novelty, and wonder. This fuller vision of nature opens the way toward understanding creation not as a finished and static product, but as a dynamic, relational process of ongoing becoming.
In This Conversation
· Evolutionary suffering creates such a profound challenges for Christian traditional ideas of Divine omnipotence, omniscience, and love
· Why nature cannot be characterized as simply hostile or harmonious
· Evolution reveals novelty, emergence, increasing complexity, interdependence, and ongoing becoming
· How Charissa incorporates the Wesleyan Quadrilateral of Scripture, tradition, experience, and reason in her theological analysis and reflection on Darwinian evolution
· How Charissa integrates the Wesleyan Quadrilateral into her comparative constructive theology and thealogy
· Theological reflection should attend to the experience and agency of the more-than-human world
· Creation's freedom to participate in its own becoming makes possible both suffering and flourishing
Why This Conversation Matters
Public debates often force an unnecessary choice between accepting evolutionary science and affirming religious faith. Charissa's work refuses that false choice. She takes the suffering disclosed by evolutionary biology seriously, without treating suffering as the whole story of nature or retreating from the difficult theological questions it raises.
The result is a constructive account of creation in which divine love works through empowerment rather than coercion. Evolution does not provide a simple solution to the problem of suffering, but it can enlarge our understanding of God's relationship with a creation that possesses genuine freedom, creativity, and the capacity to become something new. This perspective also creates space for fruitful conversation between Christianity and other religious traditions.
A Central Insight
Darwin's gift is a vision of creation as unfinished, interconnected, and alive with possibility. God empowers creation to participate in its own becoming, bringing the risk of suffering and decay, but also the emergence of diversity, complexity, relationship, flourishing, freedom and wonder.
About the Guest
Charissa Jaeger-Sanders brings evolutionary biology into conversation with Christian theology and Hindu Sakta thealogy. Her work uses comparative constructive theology and the Wesleyan Quadrilateral to explore the relationship between the Divine, materiality, creaturely agency, and suffering.
About the Podcast
The Science and Spirituality for the Curious podcast seeks to provide resources and opportunities that help individuals and faith communities develop their own informed understanding of how science and spirituality relate to one another. The podcast pursues this mission through different formats. Some episodes feature conversations with specialists in science, spirituality, theology, history, and related fields. Others feature reflections by Richard Randolph, the podcast’s host, on various aspects of science and spirituality.
Links
· To make a donation supporting the development of faith-based resources on AI technology, click here: https://scienceandspirituality.org/support
· For the free subscription to Richard Randolph’s Substack block, click here: https://scienceandspiritualityblog.substack.com/
For Further Reading
· Abram, David. “On Being Human in a More-Than-Human World.” Center for Humans & Nature, July 22, 2012.
· Ayala, Francisco J. Darwin’s Gift to Science and Religion. Washington, DC: Joseph Henry Press, 2007.
· Haught, John F. God After Darwin: A Theology of Evolution. 2nd ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 2008.
· Jaeger-Sanders, Charissa. “Weaving Webs of Wisdom: How Our Interconnectedness with the Divine, Creation, and One Another Matters.” Journal of Hindu-Christian Studies 38 (2026): Article 3.
· Johnson, Elizabeth A. Ask the Beasts: Darwin and the God of Love. London: Bloomsbury, 2014.
· Southgate, Christopher. The Groaning of Creation: God, Evolution, and the Problem of Evil. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press, 2008.
This episode’s title is a play on the title of the Ayala book.
Chat GPT assisted in the development of these Show Notes.
To financially support this podcast series, go to www.scienceandspirituality.org/support
To access Richard’s new Substack reflections, https://scienceandspiritualityblog.substack.com