Scream Creeps

In this episode of Scream Creeps, the hosts discuss the movie The Nun 2. They start by watching the trailer and then share their initial reactions and expectations. They provide background information on the production of the film and discuss the plot and storytelling. The hosts also mention the post-credit scene and speculate about the future of the franchise. They talk about the visuals and scary moments in the movie and share their overall impressions and conclusion. In this episode of Scream Creeps, the hosts discuss a surprising revelation about the location of the demons. They reflect on the conversation and express their enjoyment of having everyone involved again.

Takeaways

• The Nun 2 is a sequel to the 2018 film The Nun and is part of the Conjuring Universe franchise.
• The movie received mixed reviews from critics but was generally considered an improvement over its predecessor.
• The film features historical accuracy in its portrayal of St. Lucia and incorporates elements from real-life events.
• The hosts enjoyed the visual effects and scary moments in the movie and appreciated the overall storytelling.

Chapters

00:00 Introduction and Trailer

04:18 Background and Production

06:21 Initial Reactions and Expectations

10:45 Plot and Storytelling

19:17 Post-Credit Scene and Future of the Franchise

23:31 Visuals and Scary Moments

26:21 Overall Impressions and Conclusion

55:05 Revelation of the Location

55:15 Reflection on the Conversation

The conversation revolves around the movie Poltergeist and covers various aspects such as relating to the characters, the consistency of the characters, the success of the movie, analyzing the characters' choices, the realism of the movie, discussion of other horror movies, a recommendation to watch Poltergeist, and upcoming review of 'Heir of the Witch'.

Chapters

00:00 Relating to the Characters

27:27 Consistency of Characters

28:22 Success of the Movie

29:17 Analyzing the Characters' Choices

30:51 Realism of the Movie

32:23 Discussion of Other Horror Movies

35:09 Recommendation to Watch Poltergeist

39:10 Upcoming Review of 'Heir of the Witch'

40:47 Closing Remarks

In this episode of Scream Creeps, Jeremy and Josh return to discuss the viral horror sensation Terrifier 2. Following up on their review of the first film, the hosts dive into the 2022 sequel that shocked audiences and became a massive box office success (earning $15 million on a $250k budget).

The conversation is dominated by the film's extreme gore, which the hosts agree far surpasses the original. They break down the most notorious moments, including the "bedroom scene" involving Allie, which was so brutal it reportedly caused theatergoers to vomit. Josh admits the movie was so gross he likely won't watch it again. However, they praise the practical effects and the performance of David Howard Thornton, noting that Art the Clown leans more into his "clown" persona this time around. They also discuss the introduction of the new final girl, Sienna Shaw, the supernatural elements surrounding Art's resurrection, and the bizarre mid-credits scene involving the first film's survivor, Victoria.

Key Highlights
[01:36] Box Office Miracle: The hosts discuss the massive financial success of the film and the announcement of Terrifier 3 with a bigger budget.
[05:41] The Laundromat Scene: A look at the bizarre and disturbing scene where a naked Art the Clown plays patty-cake with a supernatural entity.
[12:42] The Bedroom Scene: A deep dive into the movie's most infamous kill sequence involving Allie, featuring scalping, bleach, and bone-breaking that pushed the boundaries of the slasher genre.
[21:57] The Shotgun Kill: The crew reacts to the shocking moment Art uses a sawed-off shotgun to blow the mom's face off, subverting the expectation of a knife kill.
[25:43] Supernatural Elements: A discussion on the confusing lore, including Sienna's resurrection, the magical sword, and why Art targeted her family specifically.
[28:53] The Mid-Credits Scene: The hosts break down the grotesque ending where Victoria gives birth to Art the Clown's living head in a mental institution.

In this episode of Scream Creeps, Jeremy and Josh return to review the 2016 cult horror film Terrifier. This marks their first foray into the franchise before tackling the viral sensation Terrifier 2.

The discussion focuses on the film's gritty, low-budget aesthetic (reminiscent of 80s grindhouse cinema) and the terrifying silent performance of Art the Clown. Josh compares Art's silence to a mime, noting it makes him uniquely unsettling compared to other slashers like Freddy or even Jason. The hosts break down the film's lack of a deep plot—it's essentially a relentless night of killing—but praise the practical effects and gore. Specifically, they dissect the infamous "hacksaw scene," which Josh calls the goriest kill in the movie, where a character is sawed in half from the groin up. They also touch on the bizarre opening interview scene, the "dead cat" twist (wait, wrong movie—they reference a ring from a vending machine here), and the surreal ending where Art shoots himself but survives.

Key Highlights
[00:46] The Origin: Introduction to Terrifier, its low budget of $35,000, and director Damien Leone's background with the character in All Hallow's Eve.
[04:22] Silent Killer: A discussion on Art the Clown’s unique persona—he doesn't speak, grunt, or make noise, acting more like a deadly mime than a traditional slasher villain.
[06:42] The Aesthetic: The crew notes the film's gritty look, comparing it to old 80s/90s slashers with its film grain and practical effects.
[13:15] The Hacksaw Scene: A deep dive into the movie's most notorious kill—Dawn being sawed in half upside down—which the hosts agree is the highlight for gorehounds.
[16:24] The Scalping: Josh recounts the bizarre scene where Art wears the skin/breasts of a homeless woman to taunt the protagonist, highlighting the film's disturbing humor.
[19:06] The Gun Twist: The team laughs at the scene where Art, after a brutal physical fight, simply pulls out a gun and shoots the final girl, subverting slasher expectations.

In this episode of Scream Creeps, Jeremy, Josh, and Elaine return after a hiatus to review the 2022 psychological horror hit Smile. The team is unanimous in their praise, calling it arguably the creepiest movie they’ve watched for the podcast so far.

The discussion centers on the film's effective use of sound design and cinematography to create a constant sense of dread. Josh highlights the "party chat" viewing experience where the audio immersion made the jump scares even more effective. They break down the central metaphor of trauma passing from person to person, the terrifying visual of the "smile," and the gruesome ending that didn't pull any punches. Key scenes discussed include the birthday party "dead cat" reveal, the head-drop scene in the car, and the final creature reveal which terrified Elaine. They also touch on Sosie Bacon’s performance and how the film compares to other recent horror entries like Nope (which they didn't love).

Key Highlights
[01:05] The Setup: Introduction to Smile, directed by Parker Finn and starring Sosie Bacon (Kevin Bacon’s daughter), and its premise of a curse passed through witnessing suicide.
[02:14] The Creep Factor: The hosts agree this is the creepiest movie they've reviewed, citing the unnerving nature of a silent, smiling figure staring at you.
[08:43] The Jump Scares: A discussion on the effective jump scares, particularly the "head drop" scene with the sister at the car window, which got everyone.
[09:53] The Dead Cat: The crew reacts to the brutal birthday party scene where the main character gifts her nephew a dead cat, sealing the "trauma" metaphor.
[13:05] The Detective's Mistake: Josh criticizes the detective/ex-boyfriend for leaving the protagonist alone despite knowing the pattern of the curse.
[25:23] Creepo-Meter Ratings: A rare unanimous 10/10 on the "Creepo-Meter" for its genuine ability to unsettle the hosts, surpassing previous favorites like Sinister.

In this episode of Scream Creeps, Jeremy, Josh, and Elaine dive into The Black Phone, the supernatural horror thriller directed by Scott Derrickson and starring Ethan Hawke. The crew is nearly unanimous in their praise, rating the film a 9 or 10 out of 10. They discuss how the film, despite its low budget (~$16-18 million), delivers high-quality scares and a compelling story.

The conversation centers on Ethan Hawke’s chilling performance as "The Grabber," a serial killer who abducts a teenage boy named Finney. They analyze the unique supernatural element of the disconnected black phone in the basement, which allows Finney to communicate with the killer's previous victims. The hosts break down the clever ways Finney uses the ghosts' clues to plot his escape, the satisfying character arc of him finding his courage, and the standout performance of Madeleine McGraw as Finney's psychic sister, Gwen. They also touch on the film's 70s setting, the "stranger danger" vibes, and the brutal reality of the abuse depicted in the film.

Key Highlights
[00:46] Director & Cast: A look at Scott Derrickson's direction (known for Sinister and Doctor Strange) and the cast, including Ethan Hawke as the villain.
[04:22] The Grabber: A discussion on Ethan Hawke's character, his creepy masks, and the "naughty boy" games he plays with his victims. [07:08] The Supernatural Phone: The crew explains the premise of the disconnected phone and how the ghosts of past victims help Finney survive.
[07:58] Gwen's Role: Praise for the character of Gwen (the sister), her psychic visions, and her hilarious yet heartbreaking scene in the principal's office.
[19:14] The Escape: A breakdown of the climax, detailing how Finney uses every clue (the grate, the cable, the dirt) to trap and kill The Grabber. [28:24] Final Rating: The group gives the movie high marks (9/10), calling it one of the best horror films they've seen recently due to its tight pacing and lack of plot holes.

In this episode of Scream Creeps, Jeremy, Josh, and Elaine tackle Scream (2022), the fifth installment in the franchise and the first not directed by the late Wes Craven. The crew discusses how this "re-quel" balances nostalgia with a new generation of victims.

The conversation highlights the updated opening scene involving Jenna Ortega and a landline (in 2022?), the return of legacy characters Sidney, Gale, and Dewey, and the meta-commentary on "toxic fandom." Josh takes issue with the physics of a certain major death scene, arguing that a 100-pound teenager shouldn't be able to overpower a grown man like Dewey. The group also praises the suspenseful death of Dylan Minnette's character and debates whether the new killers, Richie and Amber, lived up to the legacy of Ghostface. They conclude by looking ahead to Scream 6 and the news of Neve Campbell's departure.

Key Highlights
[00:08] The Re-quel Begins: Introduction to Scream (2022) as a direct sequel to Scream 4 and a tribute to Wes Craven.
[02:00] The Landline Logic: The crew laughs at the opening scene where a Gen Z character answers a landline, debating if it's a believable trope in 2022.
[08:00] Predicting the Killers: Josh claims he pegged the killers (Richie and Amber) early on, noting the clues dropped throughout the film. [14:17] The Best Kill: A breakdown of the suspenseful death of Wes (Dylan Minnette), praising the tension building with the fridge door and the sudden execution.
[16:22] Dewey's Death: A heated discussion on the controversial decision to kill off Dewey, with Josh criticizing the realism of Amber overpowering him.
[20:37] Neve Campbell's Exit: The team discusses the news that Neve Campbell won't return for Scream 6 due to a pay dispute and what that means for the franchise.

In this episode of Scream Creeps, Jeremy, Josh, and Elaine wrap up their coverage of the Netflix Fear Street trilogy with Part Three: 1666. The crew agrees this is the strongest entry in the series, praising how it ties all the loose ends from 1994 and 1978 together in a satisfying conclusion.

The discussion explores the unique format of the film, which spends the first half in 1666 explaining the "witch" origin story before jumping back to 1994 for the final showdown. The team highlights the clever use of the same actors from previous films playing their ancestors (or "mirror" characters) in the 1666 timeline—such as Kiana Madeira as Sarah Fier and Ashley Zukerman as Solomon Goode. Major plot points discussed include the reveal that the Goode family was behind the curse all along (sacrificing Shady Siders to keep Sunnyvale prosperous) and the tragic, misunderstood nature of Sarah Fier. They also touch on the "open" ending with the book being snatched mid-credits.

Key Highlights
[00:52] The Structure: A breakdown of how the movie splits its runtime between the origin story in 1666 and the resolution in 1994.
[02:51] The Best of the Three: Josh argues this is the best film of the trilogy because it wraps up every plot thread and explains the "why" behind the killings.
[09:57] The True Villain Revealed: The group discusses the twist that Nick Goode (and his ancestor Solomon Goode) were the real villains, sacrificing innocent people to Satan to maintain power.
[19:14] RL Stine's Influence: A conversation on how the movie adapts the spirit of the Fear Street books—darker than Goosebumps but still aimed at a teen audience—while mixing in historical elements like the Salem Witch Trials.
[26:05] The "Mirror" Characters: Elaine points out the smart casting choice of having the actors from 1994 and 1978 play roles in 1666 that mirror their modern-day dynamics (e.g., Deena/Sam as Sarah/Hannah).
[31:54] Final Rating: The crew gives the trilogy high marks, with Josh rating it an 8 or 9 out of 10 for its inventive storytelling and cohesive plot.

In this episode of Scream Creeps, Jeremy, Josh, and Elaine continue their journey through the Fear Street trilogy with Part Two: 1978. Released shortly after their review of 1994, the team dives into this prequel/sequel that pays heavy homage to classic summer camp slashers like Friday the 13th and Sleepaway Camp.

The discussion focuses on the shift in tone from the 90s mall setting to the 70s Camp Nightwing. Josh and Elaine debate whether this entry surpasses the first, noting that while the kills felt slightly less "standout" than the bread slicer scene in 1994, the lore building was superior. They analyze the killers—specifically Tommy Slater (the axe-wielding, bag-head maniac)—and the tragic backstory of the Berman sisters, Ziggy and Cindy. The crew also touches on the unique release schedule, the "curse" of Sarah Fier, and how the film sets the stage for the final chapter, 1666.

Key Highlights
[01:01] Back to Camp: The hosts discuss the setting shift to 1978 and how it perfectly captures the Friday the 13th aesthetic with Camp Nightwing.
[06:03] The Killers: A breakdown of the villains, including Tommy Slater and the creepy "milkman" killer, and how the film introduces the concept of multiple killers from different eras.
[10:46] The Berman Sisters Twist: The group discusses the reveal that Ziggy is actually C. Berman (the survivor who calls Sam in the first movie) and the confusion over her "death" and revival.
[12:37] The Sheriff’s Secret: A look at Sheriff Nick Goode's role, his dismissal of the supernatural events, and the friction it causes with Ziggy. [21:21] The Mean Girl Trope: Josh laughs at the hypocrisy of the "stoner chick" character who bullies Cindy relentlessly but immediately begs for help once she gets injured. [26:50] Creepo-Meter Ratings: The team struggles to rate it high on the "Creepo-Meter" because, like many slashers, the kills are predictable if you know the genre.

In this episode of Scream Creeps, the team takes a detour from their "Science of Scare" list to dive into Netflix's Fear Street Part One: 1994. Jeremy, Josh, and Elaine explore the first installment of the trilogy based on R.L. Stine's book series.

The hosts praise the film for its 90s aesthetic, noting the spot-on soundtrack and mall setting (reminiscent of their own teenage years). Josh highlights the film's "world-building," appreciating how it sets up the curse of Sarah Fier and the history of Shady Side vs. Sunnyvale. The discussion inevitably turns to the gore, with the crew marveling at the shocking intensity of the kills—particularly the bread slicer scene—which far exceeded their expectations for a "teen" horror movie. They also touch on the unique release strategy of dropping three films back-to-back and debate the logic behind Sam's possession at the end.

Key Highlights
[00:46] Introducing the Trilogy: The hosts explain the Fear Street release format, with parts set in 1994, 1978, and 1666 released weekly on Netflix.
[02:45] R.L. Stine for Adults?: A discussion on how the film adapts the book series, noting it feels like a "Goosebumps for adults" with significantly more violence.
[06:50] The Netflix Model: The team discusses how the weekly release strategy helped build hype, comparing it to the traditional theatrical model.
[11:06] 90s Nostalgia: The crew enjoys the 90s references, from the Software Etc. store in the mall to the era-appropriate soundtrack.
[11:58] The Bread Slicer Kill: A breakdown of the movie's most brutal scene, where a character is pushed through a bread slicer, marking a high point for the "Goro-Meter."
[23:04] Creepo-Meter Ratings: The group agrees that while not necessarily "creepy" or scary in a dread-inducing way, the film scores high on watchability and gore, making it a solid modern horror entry.