In this transformative moment in human history, Dr. Abou El Fadl recounts the ways in the last three decades since the publication of his book, The Authoritative and Authoritarian in Islamic Discourses, that the methodology of justice, beauty and reason he advocated came under attack as a source of "fitnah" (creating discord and dissent). As Muslims, we learned from well known shuyukh that many things like music, art, pictures, relations with non-Muslims and other things identified as "from the West" were haram (forbidden). Suddenly, overnight, the same shaykhs who claimed such "incontrovertible truths" have reversed their positions without any evidentiary basis, nor any reference to Islamic law or jurisprudence. He reminds us that God gave us a religion of fitrah (intuition, innateness and natural instinct), and that messages of Islam from the lands of despotism and hypocrisy in the Middle East have become intolerable. It is time for Muslims in the West to liberate themselves from the Islam coming from the colonized, dominated and subjugated Middle East, and rethink anew what the Islam of justice and beauty should entail as pioneers in our current times. He encourages Muslims to become pious and trust in the intuitive attraction to goodness, justice and beauty that God gave all human beings. Delivered 15 February 2019.
Timestamp:
Islam is the religion of intuition and instinct (fitra) and should appeal to morally sound hearts, and should seem unappealing to evil ones.
5:20 - Remembering the social dynamics 30 years ago when "The Authoritative and Authoritarian in Islam" was released and received negative criticism, because music was called totally haraam, and art, and friendship with non-Muslims, and Muslims were encouraged to resist adopting any of the cultural practices of the west.
11:33 - Remarking on the ways in which the same scholars from 30 years ago who called Dr. El Fadl "westernized" and "liberal" are now totally ok with worse things than he himself would ever be ok with, they changed their opinions overnight without explanation.
17:06 - Remarking on the ways Mecca is being destroyed to appeal to rich westerners, and the ways Islamic laws are being modified to appeal to Islamophobes.
22:31 - Thank God, the hypocrisy and the despotism of these foreign Islams (from places like Egypt and Saudi) is crumbling.
27:43 - Remarking on the hypocrisy of the Pope coming to meet with despotic, evil Muslim leaders who are authorizing and justifying the murder and torturing of innocents.
35:33 - Final dua.