John Anthony gives Andrea a stern talking-to after Andrea comes back from her Valentine's Day trip with a sparkly surprise. Is this her villain origin story? Or is she just refusing to take off those rose-tinted glasses? This leads to a discussion between our two hopeless romantics about the life they've envisioned for themselves versus.... reality. This week we talk Andrea's season 1 arc, J.Lo's Marry Me, Janth's first love, and musical theater dreams.