This week on the show, Aaron and Andrew discuss the Paramount decree (3:48), review "An American Pickle" (11:17), rate Best Ever Seth Rogen movies (31:13), go on a SiftQuest about the origins of SiftPop (52:31), then finish up with Buried Treasure (1:00:52).

Aaron and Andrew stick around to talk spoilers on "Relic"!

Aaron and Andrew stick around to talk spoilers on "The Rental"!

It's a horror show this week! Aaron and Andrew review "The Rental" (3:11) and "Relic" (17:41), rate Best Ever movies with one-word "R" titles (33:41), then finish up with Buried Treasure (49:39).

Aaron and Andrew stick around to talk spoilers on "First Cow"!

This week on the show, Aaron and Andrew review "First Cow" (3:28) and "Showbiz Kids" (25:10), rate Best Ever movies with animals in the title (47:48), then finish up with Buried Treasure (1:08:37).

This week on the show, Aaron and Andrew review "Greyhound" (6:23) and "Palm Springs" (26:57), rank Best Ever SNL alum movies (59:14), and then finish up with Buried Treasure (1:23:54).

Aaron and Andrew stick around to talk spoilers on "The Old Guard"!

Aaron and Andrew welcome Lo onto the show this week! First, they review "Hamilton" (4:49), then review "The Old Guard" (40:30), rank Best Ever movies adapted from the stage (1:05:02), and then finish up with Buried Treasure (1:34:48).

Aaron and Andrew stick around to talk spoilers on "Irresistible"!