Welcome back, Robert and Aaron!

- Favorite NON-MOVIE Pop Culture Moment or Thing of 2023 (8:35)

- Movies that Let You Down (15:46)

- Movies that Surprised You In a Good Way (33:29)

- Movies that Just Weren't For You (48:50)

- Movies that Just Weren't For Them (1:18:38)

- Top 5 TV shows of 2023 (1:31:42)

Back by popular demand, Aaron is filling out his Critics' Choice ballot LIVE on the show this week for you to hear! Listen in as he makes his picks in advance of the show on The CW this Sunday night.

Aaron and Andrew welcome DeVaughn back to the show!

- Movie Review - American Fiction (3:30)

- Movie Review - Poor Things (25:15)

- Best Ever Challenge - Emma Stone movies (45:54)

- Buried Treasure (1:04:07)

Aaron and Andrew welcome Jon Paula back to the show!

- Reckoning with our most 2023 most anticipated movies (3:31)

- Movies we're excited to see each month (9:27)

- Top 3 most anticipated movies in 2024 (1:15:57)

- Buried Treasure (1:24:06)

Aaron and Andrew welcome Alice-Ginevra Micheli back to the show!

- Movie Review - Maestro (4:37)

- Movie Review - Wonka (37:30)

- Best Ever Challenge - Timothée Chalamet movies (54:14)

- Buried Treasure (1:11:15)

It's a quick Aaron and Andrew only show this week!

- Movie Review - Godzilla Minus One (7:39)

- Movie Review - Napoleon (25:14)

- Buried Treasure (37:09)

Aaron's doing a SiftSwift this week! He's talking through where things stand with this year's award contenders.

Aaron and Andrew welcome Susan Kamyab Stephens back to the show!

- Movie Review - The Marvels (5:08)

- Movie Review - Quiz Lady (26:22)

- Best Ever Challenge - Brie Larson movies (37:37)

- Buried Treasure (54:41)

Aaron, Andrew and Ian stick around to talk spoilers on "Anatomy of a Fall"!

Aaron and Andrew welcome Ian back to the show!

- Movie Review - Five Nights at Freddy's (2:46)

- Movie Review - Anatomy of a Fall (21:18)

- Best Ever Challenge - French films (43:23)

- Buried Treasure (1:01:16)