Send a text

In Guffey, Colorado, just outside Colorado Springs officers respond to a wellness check and find 60 y.o. Carl Dutcher on the kitchen floor dead with at least 2 gunshot wounds
Carl’s wife JoAnna was found dead in the bathroom. Their grandson Tony was missing.

What lead to this almost beggars belief. What drove Tony's childhood friend Isaac Grimes to commit these unspeakable acts? What happened to Tony? And why did it all revolve around teenager Simon Sue?

In this episode, Willow dives into a New Year's Eve murder and a cult.

Support this podcast, get extra episodes with zero ads and much more! Join the Cruel Tea Party at patreon.com/crueltea

Want to see what else we do? Check out our art, writing, music and more: https://linktr.ee/crueltea

--- Support this podcast: https://anchor.fm/cruelteapod/support

Support the show