It’s birthday time in Stars Hollow! In this episode, we dive into the first half of Rory’s Birthday Parties — the one where Lorelai bakes cakes, Emily takes over, and Rory’s world gets a little more complicated. Join us (two sisters and lifelong Gilmore Girls fans!) as we unpack the early chaos of Rory’s 16th, cringe at fancy dinner drama, and gush over the sweet Lorelai-Rory moments we’ll never get tired of. Grab a cup of coffee (or two) and celebrate with us — it’s party prep time!

In this episode of So, There’s This Episode…, Emily and Alyssa tackle Gilmore Girls Season 1, Episode 5, Cinnamon’s Wake—the one where a cat’s funeral low-key wrecks everyone’s emotions. The sisters break down how a seemingly minor event in Stars Hollow somehow turns into a full-on therapy session for half the town (and maybe themselves too).

They unpack the messy tension between Lorelai and Max, Rory’s awkward confession to her crush, and the surprisingly deep impact of Cinnamon the cat’s dramatic send-off. From Babette and Morey’s eccentric charm to Sookie’s chaotic dinner party planning, Emily and Alyssa cover it all—complete with their usual sisterly debates, wild tangents, and caffeinated commentary.

Get ready to laugh, cry, and maybe pour one out for Cinnamon—because this episode proves even a cat funeral can hit you right in the feels.

WHERE YOU CAN FIND US:

All social media: @sotheresthisepisodepod

Email: [email protected]

Episode 5: The Deer Hunters

In this episode of So, There’s This Episode…, Emily and Alyssa break down Gilmore Girls Season 1, Episode 4, The Deer Hunters. Rory’s first Chilton meltdown takes center stage as she scrambles to ace a big test—only to be derailed by, you guessed it, a rogue deer. The sisters dive into the hilarity and heartbreak of Rory’s bad day, Lorelai’s unfiltered support, and Chilton’s pressure-cooker environment.  

Expect heated hot takes on Max Medina’s swoon-worthy but problematic charm, Lorelai’s wardrobe choices, and the iconic “You don’t understand. I got hit by a deer!” meltdown. Plus, Emily and Alyssa debate whether they’d be team Rory’s calm composure or Lorelai’s fiery protectiveness in the principal’s office. With sharp commentary, sibling laughs, and a side of caffeine, this episode will have you rooting for Rory—and maybe even a little for that deer!

FACT CHECKING OURSELVES:

WHERE YOU CAN FIND US:

All social media: @sotheresthisepisodepod

Email: [email protected]

SOURCES:

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0588202/?ref_=tttrv_ov

https://gilmorereferences.wordpress.com/season-1/

Gilmore Girls Season 1 DVD Box Set

In this episode of So, There’s This Episode…, Emily and Alyssa dive into Gilmore Girls Season 1, Episode 3, Kill Me Now. The sisters dissect the hilariously tense dynamic between Lorelai and Emily as they clash over Richard taking Rory to the country club. Meanwhile, Rory’s bonding time with her grandfather gives Emily and Alyssa plenty to debate, from etiquette lessons to swan-filled golf courses.

They also take a closer look at Lorelai’s over-the-top reaction to Rory's budding relationship with Richard, Michel’s sass-filled one-liners, and the first glimpse of Sookie’s chaotic genius in the kitchen. As always, the commentary is packed with witty observations, sisterly banter, and hot takes that may just have you questioning your own opinions. So brew another cup, because this episode is as sharp and satisfying as Lorelai’s caffeine-fueled wit!

FACT CHECKING OURSELVES:

The mother of the “twin brides” (Mrs. Shales) is played by Meagen Fay

WHERE YOU CAN FIND US:

All social media: @sotheresthisepisodepod

Email: [email protected]

In this episode of So There’s This Episode…, Emily and Alyssa tackle Gilmore Girls Season 1, Episode 2, The Lorelais' First Day at Chilton. Big changes are happening—both in Stars Hollow and on the podcast! The sisters announce their switch to longer-form content, saying goodbye to splitting episodes into shorter segments. This means more banter, more deep dives, and even more of the unfiltered sisterly fun you love, all in one sitting.  

As they dig into this episode, they cover everything from Lorelai’s iconic (and embarrassing) outfit choice to Rory’s rocky start at Chilton. They dish on Emily Gilmore’s relentless meddling, and, of course, Paris’s unforgettable first impression. Packed with witty hot takes, heartfelt moments, and plenty of laughs, this extended episode gives you more of the couch-side commentary you’ve been craving. Pour yourself an extra-large cup of coffee—this one’s worth savoring!

FACT CHECKING OURSELVES:

Carole Goldman  - Miss James “He handles everything but bulimia and pregnancy”

Jackson Douglas, who played Jackson on the show (convenient), was originally meant to feature in just two episodes as a guest role. When creators saw the chemistry he had with Melissa McCarthy (Sookie), they made him a regular character. - https://abisworldblog.wordpress.com/2021/05/24/fun-facts-about-gilmore-girls/

Drella (played by Alex Borstein) is in episodes 1-4

Gilmore Girls aired in 2000 (not 2002, lol).

WHERE YOU CAN FIND US:

All social media: @sotheresthisepisodepod

Email: [email protected]

Emily and Alyssa are back on the couch to dive into part two of the Gilmore Girls pilot in this episode of So There's This Episode… Picking up where they left off, the sisters continue their breakdown of the small-town magic and drama unfolding in Stars Hollow. From Lorelai's awkward encounters with Luke to Rory’s budding romance with “the new kid” Dean, no moment is left untouched. The sisters share their takes on Emily Gilmore’s grand entrance, and the complicated family dynamics. Expect plenty of laughs, light-hearted rants, and a few classic sisterly debates about the characters we love (and love to hate). Grab a cozy blanket and settle in!

In the very first episode of So There's This Episode…, sisters Emily and Alyssa kick off their deep dive into Gilmore Girls with part one of the iconic pilot episode. Join the duo as they introduce themselves and explain why Gilmore Girls is their ultimate comfort show. They break down the first impressions of Stars Hollow, meet the unforgettable Lorelai and Rory, and explore the quirky charm that makes this small town feel like a second home. Alongside their witty commentary and playful banter, expect hot takes on the mother-daughter dynamic, a heartfelt analysis of Lorelai’s coffee addiction, and some classic sisterly debates. So grab your favorite mug and settle in for a cozy, laugh-out-loud recap—because no scene, coffee cup, or witty comeback goes unanalyzed!