Craig and Michaelle dive headfirst into Taylor Swift’s The Life of a Showgirl, sharing their first impressions, favorite tracks, and a few skips along the way. Craig can’t stop replaying Opalite, Cancelled, and Actually Romantic, but admits that Eldest Daughter, Father Figure, and Honey aren’t on heavy rotation. The music video gets a full yes from both, and they debate what the next single should be — Craig’s betting on Opalite.
To wrap things up, they wade into the Swiftie chaos, ranking the album among Taylor’s discography, weighing in on all the variant releases (marketing genius or just too much?), and sharing whether Showgirl makes them want to revisit her past albums.