Session 12
Dr. Chung is a solo private practice Facial Plastic Surgeon. He discusses his path through ENT residency and what he likes and dislikes about his job.
Today's guest on Specialty Stories is a solo private practice facial plastic surgeon. It's a great specialty, super sub-specialized specialty of ear, nose, and throat surgeons, or otolaryngology. And Victor, or Dr. Chung, is going to join us and tell us all about it.
[02:15] A Personal Choice to Be in Private Practice
Dr. Chung practices facial plastics and reconstructive surgery as a subspecialty of otolaryngology; ear, nose and throat surgery. He considers himself as one of the rare breed of private practice, truly private practice solo by himself, the only physician in the office which is an interesting kind of hybrid situation. As a specialist, he is affiliated with a number of the hospitals in the San Diego area, however, he’s not officially on staff who who has to be in the hospital all the time. Nevertheless, he does consultation and coverage for call and operate at those sites.
Out of all the fellows who graduated in his year, only two of them went into true private practice and are opening practices. The majority are either joining multi-specialty practice groups. He thinks even looking for academic jobs was a tradition that's fallen by the wayside.
As to why he chose private practice, Dr. Chung had his personal reasons. He had phenomenal training and wanted to practice medicine the way he was trained to do.
“When you become part of a bigger group or even as small as a partnership, there's a level of compromise. Otherwise, there's no way for you to be successful.”
He further explains that what he likes in private practice is having that freedom to practice without restriction in the sense of delivering care to the best of his ability that gets to order the more expensive supplies and equipment or employ a technique he knows well. So his choice was natural for him and he sees being in a personal situation that he could do it is a luxury.
Although joining a bigger group or academics is not a complete compromise, Dr. Chung says that oftentimes, you find that your patient population or the group you're in will dictate your niche and your future. Then you may start doing things that don't make you necessarily happy anymore in medicine. You start doing fewer of the cases that you like to do or take care of the patients that you like. You can find that ideal situation in academics in larger groups, but it's just more challenging.
Victor has been out in his own practice just over twelve months. It actually took him a number of months just to get his place set up which involved a lot of logistics as well as a lot of things they don't teach you in medical school, or residency, or fellowship about applying for business licenses, insurance, and all the other type of regulations that are necessary to own and run a successful and safe business.
[05:36] His Interest in Facial Plastic Surgery
Victor always knew he was going to do surgery when he was in medical school. He enjoyed the aspect of thinking, being hands-on, its culture, and the lifestyle. But honing into a particular specialty was tough. He was looking at a number of sub-specialties that operate in the areas of ophthalmology, neurosurgery, plastic surgery craniomaxillofacial, and the ENT subspecialty, which he found very appealing.
“Even within a single focus of the human body, it was challenging. And although facial plastics is a sub-sub-specialty within it, it's still an integrated part.”
You will go out in the community and meet physicians who are ENT-trained, but not fellowship-trained, but they are still practicing as facial plastic surgeons. This is actually encouraged by the overall academy. The types of procedures can be reconstructing cancer that may have been excised on just the skin level, but others are doing larger reconstructions or rhinoplasty and face lift based on their skillset and their comfort level.
Victor adds that the specialty overall gives you all the skillsets you need, As an individual, you get to pick the things that you are comfortable with or you really enjoy doing and focus on those. Additionally, you'll meet other physicians in your community who like doing the other procedures that you may feel less comfortable with or ones you don't like as much. Victor points out the good camaraderie that goes on there and you're a lot happier treating the disease states and doing the surgeries that you like to do.
[07:50] Traits of a Good Facial Plastic Surgeon
Victor explains that you need to be both left brain and right brain. On one hand, you need to be analytical, be very objective, and be able to understand proportions and direct measures and changes. On the other hand, you have to be someone who has an artistic component in how you think about things and how you view them.
When Victor performs a rhinoplasty surgery, he is not only looking at this overall picture. So it's just not just a nose and a good-shaped nose, but he has the entire face prepped in the field exposed. He looks at the relationship of the nose to the chin, the forehead, proportions to how wide the eyes are, and that overall aesthetic. Moreover, as a confirmatory measure, he does all these different measurements as to how far the nose projects out, the angles, and those that are within accepted values. So you need to be able to mind both sides and not be locked into either one. It's right in the middle of your face, it's very obvious, so the stakes are a little bit higher.
[09:28] Other Specialties in Mind
Victor had not picked his residency specialty until very late in the process. He had gone through most of the clinical clerkships of my third year thinking that he was leaning toward orthopedic surgery as just a specialty within surgery. He didn't think he was going to do general surgery, but he knew it was some sort of surgical hands-on one.
At that time too, interventional procedures were getting big. Interventional radiologists and cardiologists have very hands-on and very three-dimensional stereotactic type specialties as well. But thinking about which one to hone in on, Victor wasn’t exposed to it until the last quarter of the third year clinical clerkships. And it did turn around having interacted with some very stimulating cases as well as with nice residents and attending physicians who were open to sharing what they were doing and allowing him to participate.
If you’re considering ENT, Victor recommends that you see if you're okay with boogers and earwax and all those bodily fluids. If you have no problem with them then you'll be okay. He explains how people have aversions to different things. So you have to pick what you’re comfortable with seeing everyday. You can't just base that purely on a good experience. You need to figure out what is the day-to-day kind of drudgery.
“Pick what you are comfortable with seeing day to day, because if you don't like your day to day, you're not going to enjoy the highlights any more.”
Victor tells students all the time check out the really dizzy patient that is struggling and you can't get a good exam on, but you still try to figure out how to treat them. It’s really, really tough sometimes to figure out if they're surgical or non-surgical, and yet they can take up more than a full appointment visit. So regardless of your specialty, be sure to examine, find those highlights, but also find what are the low points and if you're okay with those.
[12:20] Patient Types and Typical Day in the Life of a Facial Plastic Surgeon
Victor sees all kinds of patients, which is something that keeps him captivated and stimulated in his specialty. His patients range from very minor, very cosmetic to no medical emergency about it whatsoever, there's no urgency, it's purely elective, the changes are super subtle, super small, there's no life threatening thing that you're changing. Nevertheless, people gain quite a bit of benefit from them. Their attitudes change and their self-esteems improve with the subtle thing that bothered them that maybe no one else noticed.
Moreover, Victor still participates in general ENT call. He does tracheostomies for people who have lost their airway or reconstructions for people who have lost major tissue from skin cancers or other disease or trauma. These are very drastic changes to improve someone's function and there's very little cosmetic aspect of that. So Victor likes that spectrum and he doesn’t see himself giving up on doing all those things. Overall, he likes the full gamut of complexity and simplicity because you can gain benefit for your patient on both ends.
Being new in his practice, every day for him is pretty variable at this point in time. The idea is a clinic, a private-based practice, and so the majority of his patients would be seen in the office setting in a combination of consultations, follow-up visits, minor procedures, injections- injectables. Those types of visits are all in the office.
“As the trends go, more and more surgeons are doing things in the office.“
Typically, a surgeon in his specialty will have block time or days set aside where they would be operating, maybe two days a week being in the operating room doing a number of cases. But the majority of them would be on the outpatient setting so most of those patients are going home. A select amount would be seen in the hospital as an inpatient and seen on multiple visits in the hospital before they're released.
Moreover, Victor stresses how a lot of students and doctors don’t realize the business side of it. You can fill an entire day with administrative tasks, but it is about prioritizing and compartmentalizing. In his case, he picks one night a week where he does it until late of night and he doesn’t go home until everything on the administrative side is done then for the rest of the week, he sets up tasks and completes as many as he can. But when those tasks pile up, they will get all done on that one day. Otherwise, you can get pretty overwhelmed going from task to task to task so it's nice to have some structure in your day.
[15:35] Taking Calls
As a plastic surgeon, you don't have to take a lot of calls. It actually depends on where you are geographically located. Some hospitals require you to take a certain amount of call depending on the size of the call pool and how busy the hospitals are.
But Victor is not required to take any call whatsoever, but it also depends. He explains that there are some financial compensation at some sites while others don’t so it's just part of requirement-maintaining privileges. Although there is no requirement in the San Diego area where he is practicing, Victor is participating.
In terms of the percentage of patients he sees ending up in the operating room, his goal is close to 100%. He has seen surgeons who are well-established and basically they are turning patients away.
“You want to get to that point in your career where you are selecting patients who they're the most appropriate, that you can exercise and perform the best surgeries for the best results.”
Victor has patients who are not good candidates and he tells them that they are not appropriately going to be surgical patients. But he enjoys the fact that he gets to educate a lot of the patients coming in. He spends over an hour in his consultations with patients giving them all the facts including the raw details and the scary things that can happen in surgery in order for them to make an informed decision.
At this point, he doesn’t feel that half of them are going to the operating room because they're just still in that information gathering stage. But as careers progress and you become very well known for particular surgeries or techniques, a lot of patients coming in have already done their homework and research. Especially with the availability of resources on the Internet, they've done their background on you. They know where you trained, they know what technique you do, and they've come specifically for that technique or procedure, and that ratio of conversion is much higher.
[18:10] Work-Life Balance
Victor describes having a good work-life balance whenever he chooses to have a good work- life balance. And that is very different from a lot of other physicians who are at the beck and call of their pager or their schedule, and therefore they don't have the same freedoms as he does. He can choose to work incredibly long hours or he can also choose not to be working those hours based on his specialty.
There are still emergencies and so he won't operate for weeks before he goes out of town and out of the country on vacation, but that's the only limitation. Nevertheless, he can choose within his personal setting to take time off to tend to himself and his health. However, he is also participating in community volunteering and spends time with his wife which he thinks are two very important things.
“When you start sacrificing your own personal health, your interpersonal relationships, then you're not going to be as healthy of an individual and therefore not a good doctor over the long run.”
You're just going to get burned out, and that's an increasingly common phenomenon. Victor adds that good diet, nutrition, exercise, health maintenance, time with family, downtime are all things that should be scheduled and be consciously part of your day-to-day instead of things that are added on if you have time.
[20:35] Residency and Fellowship
Before you graduate to an otolaryngology head and neck surgery residency, it used to be an early match, and for many years now it's on time with everyone else's. It’s basically a five-year program which has an intern year but it's considered an integrated intern year. Typically at the same institution that you're doing residency, it does have general surgery components and rotations, however, increasingly more focused toward an ENT residency.
The elective months would be Anesthesiology. You'll be in the ER and you'll be doing surgical ICU, all geared toward skillsets that will be beneficial for your residency versus a standalone general surgery or where you are on rotations that are purely dictated by the general surgery department. This is commonly seen in orthopedics and other surgical subspecialties.
After which, there will be four years of ENT training. This may involve time at a children's hospital, at a VA institution, maybe a research block, but you'll be rotating through different sites and every year you're increasing your skillset. You're learning about all the systems, the ear, the nose, the throat, the different types of surgeries, seeing patients in clinic, and operating as well. But as you go through each year, your level of responsibility, and then as a Chief, you'll be running the service teaching and mentoring junior residents, and before you graduate you'll apply to a fellowship. This is typically within your fourth year.
There are a number of fellowships you can pursue such as pediatrics, neuroethology, head and neck cancer, microvascular reconstruction, facial plastic reconstruction, and sleep medicine even. So the fourth year is an application that goes in around January through March and you interview between March and end of May, and then you'll match to a one-year fellowship program that would go after your graduation from your ENT residency.
[23:37] An Alternative Route to Facial Plastic Surgery Outside of ENT
Victor explains that if you wanted to just do plastics in the face area, you could definitely reach that goal through an alternative route, which is through plastic surgery. There are two pathways through plastic surgery. The first one is to complete general surgery and then apply to a plastic surgery program. The second one is an integrated plastic surgery program that you match right out of medical school knowing you're doing plastic surgery and that has a general surgery component to it. These programs are typically longer with research years as well. Victor believes it can last as long as seven years to finish those residencies. And then most individuals who want to operate in the face area will go ahead and do an additional fellowship on top of that.
“You can reach the same goal in a sense, the same practicing setting, but you'll just have other skillsets bringing to that job as well.”
[25:00] Competitiveness in Matching
Victor describes matching in ENT has gotten to be one of the more competitive subspecialties to match.
“I think all of the surgical sub-specialties have gotten difficult because it's just a pure numbers game, just from any type of academic application.”
Kids are applying to more colleges. College students are applying to more medical schools. Medical students are applying to more residencies. Even when he was applying, he met people who applied to every single ENT residency in the country just to play the numbers. And so it's more applications on the Residency Director's table to leaf through and make a selection.
In Victor’s case, they had a pretty small program. Only two residents are accepted per year, and maybe thirty people were applying per spot. Some programs only have one resident while big programs have four to five residents. And although some may say thirty people may not be a lot, but each one of those individuals have published research, phenomenal USMLE Step 1 score, letters of recommendation from the Chairman, have done research rotations, have really stacked their binder full of accolades.
There’s now an ENT student interest group that starts guiding students from the first day they get to medical school. And so it has gotten increasingly competitive to apply to any of these residencies. Victor feels ENT has a popular swing recently. It had a big swing before he applied, but it's always been up there along with the other types of subspecialties that are maybe competitive to get into.
[27:32] How to Be a Competitive Applicant
Victor outlines that in order to be competitive goes down to all the basic things that everyone is always striving for. This means maintaining good grades regardless if you're a pass or fail system. Getting into AOA as another marker on your application showing that you stand higher in your class than other students. Then the USMLE Step 1 score.
Before it was just about generally trying to get in some research but if you can get on a research project that is related to the residency that you want to apply to, that can only help more. Publications, participation, posters, presentations, attending meetings, getting involved in the department, attending conferences because there's always academic conferences every week within that department. Just make a personal connection with the attendings in that department. All of those things can make you more visible and create a level of investment, not necessarily to get you accepted into your home school's department, but also, they may be invested in getting you into their alma mater, or another program that they're aware of that would be a good match for you, or a geography that you're interested in.
“It is a time investment because you're spending so much time already studying and trying to do all those basic things. But by investing yourself personally, that will give you an additional edge.”
But there's also a gamble. Victors knows of people who've done that and...
