
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Scott and Peter tackle another roller-coaster week in New York sports, breaking down the Giants’ late collapse against Washington, the Jets’ missed opportunities in Kansas City, and the NFL trade deadline’s biggest moves—and non-moves. Then it’s around the NBA, from Karl-Anthony Towns’ standout play and the Knicks’ sluggish start to Steph Curry, Luka Dončić, and the contenders taking shape across the league.
In the Lightning Round, the guys dig into the NFL’s “Peanut Punch” craze and check in on baseball’s hot stove as a potential lockout looms. Plus: National Pickle Day, a steakhouse visit for Kirk Herbstreit’s dog, and a New York City bucket list featuring the Apollo Theater, DUMBO, the High Line, and a little cheesecake debate.
Listen, subscribe, and share your feedback at whynotuspod.com.
Scott and Peter bring Halloween spirit to Episode 15 of S&P’s Why Not Us?, breaking down the first-place Giants, the struggling Jets, and NFL trade-deadline possibilities. They celebrate the Brewers’ first World Series title, preview baseball’s hot stove, and assess the Rangers’ goaltending woes and the Knicks’ sluggish start. Plus: a tribute to 25 years of Pardon the Interruption, Jaylen Brown’s upcoming showdown with Boston, and childhood Halloween memories that still haunt them.
S&P's Why Not Us? — Episode #14
Scott and Peter are back with a loaded lineup. First, Peter introduces the NBA's new flopping crackdown and the "STEM" acronym heading into the season (7:46). Then Scott breaks down the cardiac New York Giants' wild start, including Jameis Winston's historic numbers, Malik Nabers' emergence, and a look ahead to the Saints (9:19). Peter follows with his Jets — a bounce-back win over Cleveland, a rising defense, and a Week 6 showdown in New England (13:48). They zoom out on the NFL: the quiet dominance of the 4-0 Chiefs, Travis Kelce chasing history, and a big Sunday nighter between Dallas and Green Bay (18:11).
The guys pivot to the MLB playoffs, where they've been rooting hard for the Milwaukee Brewers — celebrating a historic sweep of the Dodgers, Jake Bowers' breakout, and the one-and-only Pat Murphy (21:27). They check in on the ALCS, Cleveland's lead, and a weather-delayed schedule (25:50).
In the NBA season preview, Scott and Peter play fill-in-the-blank: the biggest threat to the Knicks in the East (Scott says Boston, Peter goes off the board with Toronto), and what it'll take for the Knicks to return to the Finals (27:31).
Finally, an ode to Snoopy in honor of Peanuts' 75th anniversary — TV specials, Macy's Parade floats, alter egos from the World War I Flying Ace to the Beagle Scout, and a deep dive into Snoopy's baseball career on Charlie Brown's team (35:26). The boys close it out and put Episode #14 in the books (45:50).
Episode Summary
Scott and Peter dive into the NFL (Giants, Jets, and a sliding-doors QB story), preview the MLB playoffs in both leagues, share a World Series wish cast, then hit the lightning round with a Verlander farewell, a historic Rangers goalie goal, and a jersey-number thought exercise. They close with their TV Mount Rushmore picks inspired by The New York Times' top 100 shows of the 21st century.
Connect
Subscribe to S&P's Why Not Us on your favorite podcast player or visit whynotuspod.com.
1. Cold Open — Lane Kiffin & LSU vs. Ole Miss Scott opens with the drama of Lane Kiffin leaving Ole Miss for LSU, signing former Ole Miss NFL players, quarterback injury gamesmanship, and a comparison to Bill Belichick's infamous Jets napkin resignation.
2. NFL Week 1 Recap
3. Baseball — Final Week of the Regular Season
4. Lightning Round
5. Pop Culture — Atari 2600's 49th Anniversary Nostalgia deep-dive on classic Atari games: Space Invaders, Missile Command, Adventure, Night Driver, and the Activision Sports series (hockey, skiing, tennis). Peter shares a Polaroid of his near-perfect slalom run. Scott nearly ordered a retro console.
S&P's Why Not Us — Episode Outline
0:00 — Cold open: Australia opener logistics and fan draw debate 1:32 — Show intro 3:45 — Snoopy Bowl recap: Jets vs. Giants preseason finale, OBJ's return 6:54 — NFL team previews: Jets (Geno Smith, Garrett Wilson, Breece Hall) and Giants (Jaxson Dart, Malik Nabers, David Bailey), Week 1 predictions 10:50 — US Open tennis roundup: Sabalenka, Alcaraz, wrist watch, Shelton, Tiafoe, Gauff, Pegula, Jovic vs. Eala, Williams sisters 17:25 — Lightning round begins 17:40 — Francisco Lindor's Mets legacy and Cooperstown case 19:10 — NHL storylines: Hellebuyck trade request, McDavid's deal, Canada's Cup drought 21:42 — All-time favorite tennis players: Jimmy Connors vs. Roger Federer 27:33 — Mayor Greenhut's Platform: noise enforcement, subway upgrades, libraries, trash bins, theme weeks, bike lanes, theaters
Lineup/Segment 1: MLB (Discussion)
Segment 2: NFL (Discussion/Conversational-based)
Lightning:
Sections
In this episode:
Subscribe to S&P's Why Not Us? on your favorite podcast player. Questions, comments, or a P.S. topic idea? Head to whynotuspod.com.
World Cup Discussion: US exit; Remaining Teams; NBA Off-season - who are the big players moving teams. what happens to Lebron; MLB Trade Deadline Predictions; Look at Mets and Yankees; Part 1 of mini-series exploring life as a Jet Fan. Lighting Round: Wimbledon wrap up; PS: Mistakes to avoid if you are visiting NYC