I’m sure Mary would have preferred to give birth to her son at home. I bet Joseph had used his skills as a carpenter to build the perfect crib for Jesus too, but the parents of Our Lord had to settle for a manger, the animals’ feeding trough, to lay their newborn child. Really, most anywhere would have been a more suitable place to give birth. Just take a look at our nativity scene here, or maybe you have one at home. These scenes look beautiful, but a barn is no place to give birth and certainly falls short of giving Jesus the honour he deserved. In Bethlehem, away from their home and the help of loved ones, Joseph and Mary found themselves in conditions that were far from ideal.
This Christmas, I think of the events that led Mary and Joseph to that place and into that situation. Our Gospel today tells us how the emperor at the time decreed that the people of the Roman Empire be registered. For this, all were required to make a trip to their ancestral home. Some maybe didn’t have to travel far, but for others, like Mary and Joseph, the trip was much longer. There was no choice. To varying degrees, the lives of all were affected by an outside power, the command of the emperor.
Today, I think of how we have all been affected by an outside power too: a pandemic that continues to make all kinds of demands on all. Masks and vaccine mandates, capacity restrictions and social distancing, lockdowns, inflation and fear afflicts us all, creating conditions and situations that are far from ideal. In this time, the limits of optimism are certainly being tested.
Optimism does have limits after-all. Optimism declares that the world will be better if the right leader is elected. It promises happiness with the right job or a padded bank account. Optimism claims that with the right technological developments, legal backing or skillset, the peace we all long for can be attained under our own power. Indeed, we should be optimistic. Optimism has fueled lots of creativity and invention and so much of what we enjoy exists thanks to optimism.
But there are limits to optimism. When our leaders let us down and fail to keep promises, when someone in the hospital fails to heal or a loved one dies, when the new job is cut, prices go up in the grocery store or a tiny virus disrupts almost every part of life, the limits of optimism are tested and sometimes found. Yes, we should be optimistic. But it’s not optimism that gathers us here. Today, we gather in hope.
While hope and optimism share many similarities, there is one big difference: optimism claims that tomorrow will be better thanks to our own power. Hope, on the other hand, says that tomorrow will be better thanks to God’s power. Optimism depends on our success and falls apart . Hope relies completely on the power and love of God.
I think of those shepherds who were first to visit Jesus. Before the angels proclaimed the Good News to the shepherds, things may have looked fairly bleak. They had the worst job possible, a job usually reserved for the lowest member of the family. The pay was poor, working conditions unacceptable and the shepherds probably stank too. There was no union to back them up, so the shepherds were truly at the mercy of many powers. Under their own power, the shepherds had little reason to be optimistic.
But then something new and unexpected happened: something the shepherds would never have imagined or expected. A choir of angels appeared to deliver a message of Good News: God had entered the world to save his people. Their status in the world may have given them little reason to be optimistic, but God gave them every reason to be hopeful.
Hope makes a difference in our world. Inspired by hope, we’re told that the shepherds went with haste to the stable to...