
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Start Now
Start Now · Part 18. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
The second job runs on different rules, and this chapter lays them out.
Everything so far has been about the accumulation years. Spending the money down is a different problem. Buy, hold, and never sell is what built it; that rule, on its own, does not tell you how to live on it. This chapter does.
While you’re saving, you’re a buyer. When the market falls, your next contribution buys more shares for the same money, and those cheaper shares have years to recover and grow. Once you retire and start living on your savings, you’re a seller. Now a falling market can force you to sell shares at low prices to pay your bills, and the shares you sell at the bottom are gone: they can never recover or compound again. Two retirees can earn the same average return over thirty years and end up in very different places, depending only on when the bad years arrive. Planners call this sequence-of-returns risk. It’s the real reason to hold some cash and bonds in retirement: not because they’re the better investment, but because they’re what you spend from, so a decline never forces you to sell stocks.
A crash at the wrong moment shows what that means. A severe downturn right as you begin drawing the money down can strain even a sound retirement plan, because you are selling shares to fund the 4 percent distribution into a falling market. The U.S. “lost decade” of 2000–2009 is the cautionary case. The index returned about negative 0.9 percent a year, a total-return figure: the price fell about 2.7 percent a year, and reinvested dividends added back about 1.8%. That turned $10,000 into roughly $9,000 over a full decade, the only negative decade since the 1930s. A retiree who drew an income through that stretch from U.S. stocks alone would have felt real pain. The defenses are familiar: keep a cash cushion, stay flexible spending in bad years, and know that the S&P 500 isn’t the whole world: in that decade, smaller companies and foreign stocks held up better. Chapter 10 shows how to add them if you want.
This is why a prudent investor adds ballast as retirement nears. A slice of the portfolio shifts into safe, low-volatility assets, short-term bonds or cash, earmarked for the next few years of spending. A downturn is then funded from those reserves rather than by selling stocks at the bottom. The withdrawal research does this with a balanced portfolio, roughly half stocks and half bonds. This book does it more simply: keep the long-term money in stocks, and set aside a few years of spending in cash and short-term bonds, so a bad market never forces you to sell. The two-bucket plan below shows how. Accumulating and drawing down are simply not the same job.
The chart below follows one saver across both jobs.
Read the green and red paths against each other. They earn identical returns: 6 percent in twenty-eight years, and the same two bad years. The only difference is when the bad years come. Meet them at the end, after twenty-eight years of growth, and she still holds about $4.1 million at 100. Meet them at the beginning, while the balance is largest and the withdrawals bite hardest, and she holds about $98,000. About four million dollars separates the two, and nothing produced it but the order of the returns.
What the research found
The Trinity Study ran every thirty-year retirement between 1926 and 1995. A portfolio of half stocks and half bonds, drawn at 4 percent in the first year and raised each year with inflation, lasted the full thirty years in 39 of the 41 periods. Two ran out.31
Those two deserve to be taken seriously. They are also the product of two assumptions that no real retiree lives by.
The first is that the retiree never adjusts. The simulation raises the withdrawal by the inflation rate every single year without exception, including the year after the portfolio has fallen thirty percent. Nobody behaves that way. Skipping one inflation raise after a bad year, or trimming spending modestly for a year or two, repairs most of what the fixed-rule simulation records as failure. The 4 percent rule was built as a planning benchmark, not as a set of instructions to be followed off a cliff.
The second is that spending rises with inflation for thirty straight years. It does not. Household survey data shows real spending in retirement falling by roughly 1 percent a year through most of it, as travel, restaurants and other discretionary spending taper off. A household starting at $100,000 a year reaches a real low near age 84 at about $74,000, a decline of roughly a quarter. Later it turns back up as health costs rise, which is why researchers call the shape the retirement spending smile.32 A retiree who takes the inflation raise only in the years they actually need it is running a materially safer plan than the one the simulation tested.
What to do about it
None of this argues against the plan. It argues that the plan has a second half, and that the second half runs on different rules.
Hold several years of spending in something that isn’t stocks. Short-term bonds or cash, earmarked for exactly that. In a bad market you spend from the reserve and leave the shares alone. This is the whole defense. The withdrawal research protected retirees by keeping about half their money in bonds. The cash bucket gives the same protection with only two or three years of spending out of stocks.
Take the inflation raise only when you need it. This is the single cheapest defense available, and it costs nothing in years when your spending was going to fall anyway.
Build your cash bucket in the account you’ll spend from first. The tax-smart order is to draw down taxable and Traditional accounts before the Roth, so that’s where the cash belongs, and moving to cash inside a Traditional IRA or 401(k) costs nothing in tax. Keep the Roth in stocks the longest: its growth is the only growth that’s never taxed. If nearly all your savings are in a Roth, as in this book’s plan, build the bucket there; moving to cash inside a Roth costs nothing either.
And notice what is not on this list: predicting the market. You cannot know whether your bad years arrive at 71 or at 91. All you can do is set up your plan so that, whenever they come, they hurt less.
The test this book had not run: a bad decade at the finish
The stress tests in the second half of this book put the crash at the start of a working life: Tokyo in 1989, New York in 1929, the dot-com peak. That is the easy case. A young saver keeps buying through the wreckage, and the wreckage becomes the engine. The hard case is the mirror image, a bad decade in the last ten years before the money is needed, when the balance is largest and the contributions are too small to matter. That is the test a retiree actually fears, and it deserves the same honest arithmetic.
So run it. Take the floor case from Chapter 3: forty years of contributions at 8 percent, finishing near $2.15 million. Now replace the last ten of those years, ages 60 to 69, with the actual returns of 2000 through 2009, the worst decade in modern American history. The result at 70 is about $940,000, well under half. A single 2008 in the final year alone takes it to about $1.26 million. These are the numbers a plan built on all stocks must be able to look at.
Two things follow, and the second is the one that matters. First, no reshuffling of the portfolio undoes it: even a full shift from all stocks to a balanced mix across those ten years, far more than this book asks for, still ends near $1.08 million, because a balanced portfolio also fell in 2008. Second, and this is the real defense, the finish line is not fixed. The saver who met that lost decade at 60 and kept working and contributing to 75, through the five strong years that history actually delivered next, ends at about $1.97 million, 92 percent of the floor case. Ch…
Start Now
Start Now · Part 17. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
The ten chapters behind you are the plan for building the money. The two ahead are about the shape of the whole thing, and about the other half of the job, spending it well. Start with a picture. Years ago, as our eldest was heading off to college, I wrote him a list of what I knew about money (it closes Book One, under the title “How to Become Wealthy, and Stay That Way”), and a couple of years later I came across an idea from economics that became that list’s companion: a single picture of a complete financial life. I have been drawing that picture, the chart below, for young people ever since, because something reliable happens when you see it. Many of the points on the list stop needing argument. Live below your means, carry no debt, save first, start early: once you see the shape, they become almost self-evident.
Look at the chart below. It is not about the market. It is about you.
You begin your working life owning almost nothing and holding one enormous asset: the years ahead of you. Economists call it human capital, the value today of every paycheck you have not yet earned. No statement reports it. No app tracks it. And particularly early in your working life, for most people it is their single most valuable asset.
The chart above draws two lines. The navy line is your human capital, the value of all the earning years still ahead of you. The gold line is your financial capital, the money your saving and compounding have built. And what those two lines trace together is bigger than a portfolio: it is the complete shape of a financial life cycle, the story of the first line slowly becoming the second.
Start at the left. In the learning years, the gold line is below zero. That is not failure; it is strategy. A student loan is a borrowing against the earnings to come, and a degree, within reason, raises the navy line by more than it costs. Not every year in a classroom does that; the test is whether the learning adds earning power. You are investing in the asset nobody can see. And the curve is not drawn once: a return to school, a new skill, a change of career can redraw its shape in midlife.
Then the long middle. Every paycheck is your human capital paying out, year by year, like an owner drawing income from a business. Much of it you live on. Converting the rest is your job: human capital in, financial capital out, one contribution at a time. Live below your means and the conversion runs fast. This is all Chapter 10’s routine really is, a machine for making the conversion automatic.
Here is the part almost nobody is taught. Your future paychecks are not just an income; they are an asset with a personality. A teacher’s or professor’s earnings arrive steadily for decades, like interest on a bond, and tenure, when it comes, turns the bond into something close to a guarantee. The finance professor Moshe Milevsky put it memorably: some of us are stocks, and some of us are bonds.† The startup founder’s could have huge upside or potentially be worthless, like a concentrated stock position. A surgeon’s cost a decade and a mountain of tuition debt to switch on, then flow like an annuity. This is why a 25-year-old on a steady career path can hold an all-stock portfolio without recklessness: she already owns the steadiest bond there is, her own next forty years of work. Her paycheck is the safe asset. Her portfolio can do the growing. If your earnings are the volatile kind, the same logic runs in reverse, and a larger cushion of safe assets is not timidity but balance. That cushion is really an emergency fund, sized to the swings in your income, and a topic this book leaves for another day.
† Moshe A. Milevsky, Are You a Stock or a Bond? (FT Press, 2008). The research behind it is Roger G. Ibbotson, Moshe A. Milevsky, Peng Chen and Kevin X. Zhu, Lifetime Financial Advice: Human Capital, Asset Allocation, and Insurance (CFA Institute Research Foundation, 2007), free at cfainstitute.org.
Then, some day in your fifties, or earlier if you save hard, the lines cross, and you will probably never know which day it was. Your portfolio quietly becomes worth more than all your future paychecks combined. Nothing announces it, but you have entered new territory. The portfolio is now the main engine: decades of compounding have finally given it the size to do the heavy lifting, and it grows exponentially larger on its own, as long as you protect it. Protecting it mostly means two things: guarding against lifestyle creep, and not doing a big stupid, the one dramatic act that undoes a decade of quiet ones: borrowing against it for something shiny, betting the pile on a single idea, panic-selling a crash. Your contributions continue, and they certainly help. But compounding now does more and more of the work.
Where the navy line reaches the bottom of the chart, human capital is mostly spent. That is what retirement is. From there the task is a glide path, drawing the gold line down slowly enough that it outlasts you. These are the spending years, and they are meant to be enjoyed. You built it precisely so you could enjoy it wonderfully in this chapter of your life. But enjoying them takes a roadmap drawn in advance. Without one it is hard to protect the lifestyle, and harder still to be certain the money lasts as long as you do.
Many people keep earning for a stretch, bumping the navy line off the bottom; the sums are usually smaller, and the work, at its best, is done because it matters to you, whatever the paycheck. The gold line lands not at zero but on a buffer: the insurance you never had to use, which becomes the gift you leave behind.
Chapter 8 told you the rules flip at the boundary where human capital is mostly spent and the drawdown begins; the next chapter shows exactly how. This chart is why they flip.
This frame has a name: life-cycle finance. Franco Modigliani won the 1985 Nobel Prize in economics largely for it, and Robert Merton and Zvi Bodie later extended it to the asset this page is built on, human capital.33 The theory runs deeper than one page, and we may return to it in the future. For now, and for this book, you need only the picture: a lifetime of earning power on one side, a compounding portfolio on the other, and a plan, the one in these pages, for converting the first into the second on purpose.
Two hills, one life
One hill you're handed: your earning power, spent down a little every working year. The other you build yourself, one contribution at a time, so that it's tall enough to carry you once the first is gone. Everything before this chapter was about building that second hill. The last chapter is about what you do once you're standing on top of it.
✦
Coming next: 12 · Building It and Spending It Are Different Jobs
Want the rest as it’s written?
New chapters arrive every Sunday, free. Subscribe and each one lands in your inbox.
A NOTE FROM THE AUTHOR
Start Now is free to read and free to share. A new part publishes free every Sunday. Subscribe to get each part in your inbox as it goes out.
If you find that it helps you, the kindest thing you can do is pass it forward to one person who needs it.
And if you’d like to give back, pay it forward: donate any amount to a cause you believe in. Your money goes straight to the charity you choose. If you’d like a suggestion, I support the Zach Moses Music, Love & Light Fund at the Sweet Relief Musicians Fund, which feeds musicians in need. sweetrelief.org/zachmoses →
If these pages have moved you to act, and you’ve opened the account, bought the fund, or set up the transfer, tell me about it: what did you do, what got in the way, what surprised you? Leave a comment or just reply to this email. First name, or none. I read every one.
Start Now is educational, not investment, tax, or legal advice. Nothing in it is a recommendation to buy or sel…
Start Now
Start Now · Part 17. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
What if you have debt? First, clear the runway
When our son Samuel read an early draft, he asked whether the book ever addresses what someone with debt is supposed to do. It is the question most people under thirty would ask when they reach this point in the plan. The plan says fund the Roth as fully as you can; where does that money come from when you already owe it to someone else, a student loan, a car payment, a balance on the card? The answer is that debt is not a reason to skip the plan. Dealing with it is the first step of the plan.
A generation ago, most people started their working lives with no debt to speak of. That is no longer the norm. School costs more, and student loans are common. Cars are financed. A phone, a laptop, a pair of shoes can each be split into four payments at checkout. Almost everything is a subscription. None of this makes the plan in this book wrong. It does mean a lot of readers will look at “fund it as fully as you can” and reasonably ask: with what?
So here is how to think about the order of things. It is not advice for your situation, which I do not know. It is the way the math works, and one idea sits underneath all of it: paying off a debt is a guaranteed return equal to its interest rate.
Pay down a credit card charging 22 percent and you have earned 22 percent, risk-free and tax-free, and no investment in this book can promise that.
Compare every debt you carry to the 8 percent floor, and the order mostly decides itself.
And keep one other number in view while you read what follows. A maxed Roth is $7,500 a year: $625 a month, about $288 out of every biweekly paycheck, roughly $20 a day. That is the yardstick. Every subscription, every card payment, every “four easy installments” below can be measured against it.
* One month of expenses in an emergency savings account, before anything else. Many planners say three months. Get to one first. Give it its own account, and name it, so it is not money you see when you look at your balance. Without it, the next flat tire or dental bill goes on the card at 22 percent, and that undoes everything below.
* The employer match, always, even while you are in debt. A dollar matched fifty cents or a dollar is an instant 50 or 100 percent return. No debt on earth costs that much. Contribute up to the match, and not a dollar past it until step 3 is done.
* Anything charging more than the floor gets paid off first. Credit cards, which run 20 percent and up. Buy-now-pay-later plans once a payment is missed. Payday loans. Most private student loans, at 8 to 12 percent. Paying the highest rate first has the most financial impact. Paying the smallest balance first builds momentum, because clearing that first debt proves it can be done. Either order beats neither.
* Anything charging less than the floor gets the minimum payment, and the Roth gets the rest. Federal student loans at 4 to 7 percent. Most car loans. A mortgage. Over thirty years the floor beats them in expectation, and there is a second reason that is specific to the Roth: the contribution window closes every year.You can always pay a 5 percent loan off faster in 2030. You can never go back and fund your 2026 Roth. Even fifty dollars a month keeps that door open.
* Between about 5 and 8 percent is a judgment call, and splitting is fine. Half to the debt, half to the Roth. Nobody gets this exactly right, and nobody needs to.
Take Grace, the café owner from Chapter 5, and suppose she starts with $6,000 on a card at 22 percent and a $15,000 car loan at 6 percent. First, a month of expenses, about $4,500, into the emergency account. Then everything spare goes at the card, about $1,000 a month, and it is gone in six months; the car loan gets its minimum, because 6 percent is below the floor. Through all of that she puts $100 a month into the Roth, not because the math says so but because the contribution window closes every year and the habit is worth more than the arithmetic. With the card gone, she builds the cushion out, and because a café’s income rises and falls with the economy, she builds it further than a salaried worker would, closer to six months than three. Then the Roth goes to the max. From a standing start with $21,000 of debt, that is about three years. It is not fast, and it is not the only reasonable order. But it is a well-reasoned one for her situation, the income risk she carries that an employee does not, and the math, and every step of it counts.
Now take Dana, a nurse, whose situation is closer to most people's: a salary, a hospital retirement plan that matches 4 percent, $3,000 on a card, and $40,000 of federal student loans at 5.5 percent. Her order is shorter. The month of expenses first. Then the 4 percent into the plan from her next paycheck, because the match doubles it on the spot and nothing else on this list can. Then the card, gone in three months. The student loans sit in the judgment zone between 5 and 8 percent, so she splits: minimum payments plus a little extra, and the rest into the Roth. Her cushion stops at three months, because a paycheck is steadier than a café. From there the Roth goes to the max while the loans run down on schedule. Start to full speed, about eighteen months. Same order, different distances, and in both cases the account is open and compounding from the first year.
Once the high-rate debt is gone, go back and build the cushion out, three months for most people, more if your income is the kind that swings. Then the routine in this chapter takes over.
Two things worth saying that nobody needed to say a generation ago.
* Subscriptions. Most people in their twenties carry eight to twelve of them: streaming, music, storage, an app or two, a gym, a delivery plan, an AI assistant, each anywhere from five to sixty dollars a month. Some are simply the cost of living now, and that is fine. But no single one is noticeable, and together they are often $150 to $300 a month, a quarter to a half of that yardstick. The money for the Roth frequently already exists in the budget but it is leaving in pieces too small to see. Make one list of every recurring charge. Most people cancel a third of it on the spot.
* Buy now, pay later. A $160 pair of running shoes shows up at checkout as “four payments of $40”, and $40 is the number your brain approves. Do that a few times and you are carrying six or eight overlapping payment schedules whose total you have never once seen. The answer here is older than the app, and it is the one I was taught: if you cannot pay for it out of your checking account today, or put it on a credit card you will pay in full this month, you cannot afford it yet. Wait, and save up for it. The shoes will still be there.
One last fact, and it is one of the most commonly misunderstood things about the Roth. Most people believe every dollar is locked up until 59½. It is not. The dollars you contribute can be taken back out at any time, at any age, with no tax and no penalty. You already paid tax on them, and the IRS does not tax them twice. Only the growth is locked, until 59½ and five years after your first contribution.35 Withdrawals are counted as coming from your contributions first, so a thirty-year-old who has put in $20,000 that has grown to $28,000 could take out up to $20,000 tomorrow with nothing owed. That is why, once the first month of expenses is banked, the Roth can serve as your backup emergency fund, and why you do not have to wait until every dollar of your life is settled to open one. But treat it as breaking the glass, not opening a door. Dollars you take out can never be put back; that year’s room is gone for good. The real penalty is not a tax. It is every year of compounding those dollars would have earned, and taken out young, that is the most expensive money you will ever spend. A dollar pul…
Start Now
Start Now · Part 16. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
You’ve probably heard of the marshmallow test. A researcher sits a four-year-old down in front of a marshmallow and makes an offer. You can eat this one now, or you can wait about fifteen minutes by yourself, and then you can have two. Then the adult leaves the room.
For decades the story we told about that experiment was a story about willpower. The children who waited were said to have done better in life, and the lesson was that self-control is destiny.
That version hasn’t held up especially well. When researchers repeated the study with a larger and more varied group of children, most of the advantage turned out to be explained by other things.
But something else in that research did hold up, and it’s the part worth knowing. Whether a child waits depends a great deal on whether the adults in that child’s life have been reliable. Children who had been promised things before and then let down ate the marshmallow right away. They weren’t weak. They were being sensible. Waiting only makes sense if you have some reason to believe the second marshmallow is actually coming.
That’s the whole of this chapter, and most of this book.
What follows takes about fifteen minutes to set up and then asks you to leave it alone for thirty years or more, which is the longest fifteen minutes in personal finance. Buying and selling is more interesting. It feels like doing something. Owning one index fund and then doing nothing feels like doing nothing, because it is.
So I’m not going to ask you to be more disciplined than the next person. I’m going to tell you that the second marshmallow is real, and everything in this book is the evidence for it.
✦
The analysis in this book is the hard part. The doing is simple, almost boringly so. But simple isn’t the same as easy: the mechanics take minutes a year; holding your nerve through the declines along the way is the real test, and very nearly the only thing the whole plan asks of you. Stripped of jargon, the entire strategy reduces to a short routine that requires no market knowledge, no forecasting, and no ongoing decisions.
1. Open the account. Open a Roth IRA at any major low-cost brokerage. It takes a few minutes online, and there’s no fee to have one.
2. Fund it as early as you can. Each year, move the contribution in as soon as you have the cash, ideally the full annual maximum early in the year rather than waiting until the following April. (The IRS sets each year’s limit the previous autumn, so the maximum is already fixed and known the moment January arrives. There’s nothing to wait and see.) Every month the money sits outside the account is a month it is not compounding. If you can’t fund it all at once, set up an automatic transfer every payday so it happens without your having to think about it.
3. Invest it immediately: don’t let it sit as cash. This is the step people most often miss. Money you contribute to a Roth is not invested by default; it lands in the account as cash and stays there, earning almost nothing, until you actually buy something. Put it straight into a single low-cost index fund that tracks the S&P 500 or the total U.S. stock market (or the whole world; section 10.3 shows both).19 One fund is enough: you don’t need a basket of holdings to do this well.
4. Then leave it alone. Don’t check it daily. Don’t sell when the market falls. Don’t chase whatever did best last year. The discipline to do nothing, for decades, is the entire skill, and it’s harder than it sounds.
First things first. The Whole Plan’s “Do this first” box comes before these four steps: a month of expenses in savings, building toward three; any debt charging more than about 8 percent paid off (Part two of this chapter gives the order); the full match if your job offers a 401(k) (see the note right after Chapter 2, “If Your Job Has a 401(k)”); and basic protection: disability insurance through work, term life insurance if anyone depends on your income, and a named beneficiary on every account. Then run these four steps with your Roth.
10.1
Invest a lump sum all at once
When you have a lump available, a year-end bonus, a gift, the new year’s contribution, the historical evidence favors investing it all at once, rather than feeding it in over several months. Across decades of market data, putting a lump sum to work immediately beat spreading it out about two-thirds of the time, simply because the market rises more often than it falls, so money left waiting on the sidelines usually misses gains.20Spreading purchases out over time, called dollar-cost averaging, isn’t a mistake; the automatic per-payday approach in step 2 is itself a mild form of it, and it can ease the anxiety of investing right before a possible dip. But understand the trade: it’s a comfort measure, not a return-booster. The real enemy is neither method. It’s paralysis, waiting for a perfect entry point that never comes.
10.2
Why all stocks, and no bonds or cash
For money you truly won’t touch for decades, holding bonds or a large cash cushion mainly does one thing: it lowers your long-run return in exchange for smoothing out swings you don’t actually need smoothed. You’re not going to spend this money soon, so its value bouncing around along the way doesn’t matter, only where it ends up at the finish. Recall that even the worst long stretch for U.S. stocks still compounded near 8% a year. A long-horizon Roth, funded and left untouched, is the textbook case for staying fully invested in stocks and letting time absorb the volatility.
NOTE
All stocks - until you near retirement
The all-stock approach belongs to the long accumulation years, and it asks one thing in return: the discipline to hold through deep declines, including drops of 30% or more, without selling.
As you near the years you’ll actually live on the money, the logic reverses. A crash while you’re still adding is a gift; a crash just as you begin to withdraw is the opposite: you’d be selling shares into the decline to fund your spending, locking in losses instead of riding them back up. Economists call this sequence-of-returns risk. So as you get close to retirement, the sensible move is to build up a cushion, enough in bonds and cash to cover a few years of spending, so you never have to sell stocks into a bear market, and can simply hold on through it until the market recovers. That’s also a good moment, if you don’t already have one, to sit down with a financial advisor who can help you plan the transition.
If holding no cash at all feels too stark, a small allocation is a reasonable middle ground. Warren Buffett’s own instruction for the money he leaves his family, 90 percent in a low-cost S&P 500 fund and 10 percent in short-term government bonds, is one well-known version. Keeping, say, 5 to 10 percent in risk-free assets like short-term Treasuries or money-market funds costs little over a long horizon. Its real value is mostly psychological: a little dry powder means that when the market falls hard you can do something, put cash to work at lower prices, instead of only watching. But be clear-eyed about how much that changes. If you’re still in the saving phase and adding money on a schedule, your contributions are already buying the dip for you. The next downturn, and the one after that, simply become the moments your regular Roth contributions pick up more shares of the same index fund for the same dollars. That’s dollar-cost averaging doing its quiet work, no cash pile required.
And this book is an illustration of how compounding works, not personalized investment advice. How much risk suits you is a personal decision that depends on your circumstances and temperament.
10.3
Which fund: use a low-cost ETF
Any low-cost fund that tracks the S&P 500, or the total U.S. market, will do, and the most convenient form is an exchange-traded fund (ETF)…
Start Now
Start Now · Part 15. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
The floor was the plan. The rest is upside.
The case studies use the 10% average, but the plan was built to hold up on far less. At the 8% floor, the most unlucky investing lifetime on record, a maxed-out Roth still turns roughly $322,000 of contributions into just under a million dollars of tax-free spending power in today’s money. Even on the worst case the market has produced on record, the plan works.
That foundation has a consequence almost no financial plan can claim: nearly all of the surprises run in your favor. Because it already succeeds at the bottom of the range, almost any outcome you actually get (the 10 percent average, or anything close to it) can only make things better. This chapter is about how much better, and why that asymmetry, not any single forecast, is the real reason to start.
What could push returns higher
The last chapter named the forces that could drag returns down; several could just as plausibly push them up, and some are already underway. AI could raise productivity the way electricity and the computer once did, and shareholders own that growth. The structural advantages from Chapter 8 and Can America Keep Winning? (deep capital markets, the rule of law, the immigrant-founder pipeline) are all reasons the floor may prove too cautious. And as billions more consumers reach the middle class, much of what they spend flows back to the multinationals you already own.
None of these is a promise. Each is a plausible reason the unlucky-investor case we planned around is, in fact, unlikely.
9.4
The upside you control
Here is the part most books bury. The market’s return is not in your control, but the three levers that matter most are, and all three have uncapped upside.
* Starting earlier. Every year you move your start date forward adds a year on the far end, where the doublings are largest. Beginning at 25 instead of 30 doesn’t add a sixth more money. At the floor it adds far more, because that early dollar earns one extra doubling.
* Contributing more as you can. We modeled flat contributions. In the real world the IRS limit drifts upward, raises happen, and the same disciplined habit applied to a slightly larger number compounds into a materially larger result.
* Working and contributing a little longer. Retirement is not a fixed date, and we are living longer, healthier lives. Moving the finish line from 70 to 75 (five more years of contributions, five more years of compounding before you touch a dollar) lifts the floor outcome from just under a million in today’s money to about $1.3 million, a gain of more than a third in the worst case on record. At the typical and average rates the jump is larger still. Those may be five years you would happily work anyway.
Retire at 75 instead of 70, today’s dollars
8% floor: $975K → $1.32M · 10% average: $1.69M → $2.48M
Starting earlier, contributing more as you can, working and contributing a little longer. These are not market bets. They are personal choices. And unlike the forecasts, their upside sits entirely in your hands.
9.5
Don’t plan on the upside
The risk chapter ended with a rule: don’t let the unactionable catastrophes drive your decisions. The upside has a mirror-image rule, and it matters just as much. Don’t plan on it. It is tempting to look at the better outcomes and think that if the market will probably beat 8 percent, I can afford to put in less. Do the opposite. Build the entire plan on the floor. Fund it as though 8 percent is all you will ever get. And then let every better outcome be exactly what it should be: a surprise you never needed.
That is the shape of the bet this book asks you to make. You have seen the numbers: even in the worst case ever recorded, you retire with just under a million of today’s dollars, and every better outcome, from the typical lifetime to the long-run average, simply hands you more. Past results do not guarantee future ones, but the historical margin of safety is wide, and the only thing the bet asks of you is that you start now.
✦
Coming next: Putting It Into Practice, Part one: Open the Account, Buy the Fund
Want the rest as it’s written?
New chapters arrive every Sunday, free. Subscribe and each one lands in your inbox.
A NOTE FROM THE AUTHOR
Start Now is free to read and free to share. A new part publishes free every Sunday. Subscribe to get each part in your inbox as it goes out.
If you find that it helps you, the kindest thing you can do is pass it forward to one person who needs it.
And if you’d like to give back, pay it forward: donate any amount to a cause you believe in. Your money goes straight to the charity you choose. If you’d like a suggestion, I support the Zach Moses Music, Love & Light Fund at the Sweet Relief Musicians Fund, which feeds musicians in need. sweetrelief.org/zachmoses →
If these pages have moved you to act, and you’ve opened the account, bought the fund, or set up the transfer, tell me about it: what did you do, what got in the way, what surprised you? Leave a comment or just reply to this email. First name, or none. I read every one.
Start Now is educational, not investment, tax, or legal advice. Nothing in it is a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own situation, and talk to a professional where it matters.
Start Now
Start Now · Part 14. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
8.2
The Truly Big Risks: How to Think About Them
Beyond markets sit the genuine catastrophes: a great-power war, a pandemic far worse than the last, an environmental shock, some dislocation no one has named yet. The useful move here is to sort every risk in this chapter into two piles.
Pile one lowers your return. A stretched starting valuation, mean reversion, the end of American exceptionalism, a return of serious inflation. These are the risks that turn 10 percent into 8, or, in a future worse than any on record, 8 into 6. They are real, and the response to all of them is the same: expect less than the rosy case, stay diversified, and keep contributing.
Pile two breaks the world. A civilization-ending war is real too, but it is not a portfolio problem, because if it happens, a diversified index fund is the least of anyone’s concerns, and no savings strategy protects against it. There is no asset allocation for the end of the world. Naming that plainly is what lets you stop worrying about it: it’s not actionable, so it should not drive your decisions.
And it is worth remembering what the historical record already contains. The 1928–2025 data that produced these returns includes the Great Depression (an 86 percent collapse), a world war, the stagflation of the 1970s, the dot-com bust, the 2008 financial crisis (a 57 percent collapse), and a global pandemic. All of that is already inside the numbers, and the worst 30-year window still cleared roughly 8 percent. The plan was not built assuming calm. It was built on top of a century of disasters.
8.3
How much of the world to own
Most of the risks above are survived with discipline, and the rest cannot be acted on by anyone. But several of the largest ones share a feature: they are specifically American. The end of U.S. exceptionalism, a Japan-style lost decade, a stretched U.S. valuation, the federal debt.
Against American-specific risk there is exactly one hedge: owning more of the world beyond the United States.
In practice, the two choices are closer than they look. A single global index fund is still about two-thirds American, because that is the United States’ share of the world’s stock market. And even the S&P 500 alone is a global portfolio through the back door, since a quarter to two-fifths of its revenue is earned abroad. The historical record across thirty-five countries says that spreading globally usually beats staying home. The one glaring exception is the United States: an American who owned only U.S. stocks did better than one who owned the world, because for a century the U.S. market was the best-performing major market anywhere. Bogle and Buffett were looking at that record.
There is no wrong answer here, only a tradeoff to make with open eyes: a U.S. tilt bets on the continuation of the most remarkable run in financial history; a global fund bets that no single country, however exceptional, stays on top forever. Knowing which bet you are making, and why, is the entire point of this chapter.
Every terrible starting point, measured the same way
It is fair to ask whether the numbers in this book depend on a lucky starting date. So here are the worst entry points in the history of the two largest developed markets, each measured two ways: buying once at the top and holding, and continuing to invest every year.
Nominal unless noted. What If You Start at the Worst Possible Moment? shows each of these in full. The pattern is the point: the worst moments on record still cleared, or nearly cleared, the 8 percent floor, and in every single case the investor who kept contributing did far better than the one who bought once.
Notice what is doing the work. It is not the starting date, which was the worst available in each case. It is whether the investor kept going.
The plan needs three things from you
Where this leaves you.
A chapter spent cataloguing everything that could go wrong, you might expect to end in caution. It ends in the opposite, because of one fact: the plan does not depend on the long-run average of about 10 percent that this book shows alongside. Even the worst investing lifetime the market has delivered on record still funds a secure retirement.
It doesn’t need America to stay number one. It does not need the bull market to continue, or the next decade to be kind, or your timing to be good. It needs three things, all of which are up to you:
* That you start.
* That you keep contributing even when it’s frightening.
* That you own a broad enough basket of companies, ones whose revenues already span the world economy, that no single bet can sink you.
Most of the risks in these pages are either survivable by steady saving or unactionable by anyone alive, and the plan is built on the worst 30-year outcome those survivable risks have ever produced. So the conclusion is exactly the same as the rest of the book, only now you’ve looked the dangers in the eye and chosen it anyway: start now, keep going, own broadly, and let time do the work.
✦
Coming next: 9 · What Could Go Right?
Want the rest as it’s written?
New chapters arrive every Sunday, free. Subscribe and each one lands in your inbox.
A NOTE FROM THE AUTHOR
Start Now is free to read and free to share. A new part publishes free every Sunday. Subscribe to get each part in your inbox as it goes out.
If you find that it helps you, the kindest thing you can do is pass it forward to one person who needs it.
And if you’d like to give back, pay it forward: donate any amount to a cause you believe in. Your money goes straight to the charity you choose. If you’d like a suggestion, I support the Zach Moses Music, Love & Light Fund at the Sweet Relief Musicians Fund, which feeds musicians in need. sweetrelief.org/zachmoses →
If these pages have moved you to act, and you’ve opened the account, bought the fund, or set up the transfer, tell me about it: what did you do, what got in the way, what surprised you? Leave a comment or just reply to this email. First name, or none. I read every one.
Start Now is educational, not investment, tax, or legal advice. Nothing in it is a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own situation, and talk to a professional where it matters.
Start Now · Part 12. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
Every dollar figure in this book rests on one assumption: that a broad basket of American stocks will continue to compound somewhere between 8 and 13.6 percent a year over a future 30-year timeframe, as it has over the last century. An earlier chapter already stress-tested the plan against a bad market by turning the return dial all the way down to the floor, and the plan still worked. This chapter does something harder. It asks whether the historical record can be trusted at all, and what, in the real world, could break it.
The short answer is that the plan is more robust than any single risk that threatens it, but only because it is built on the worst the market has ever done, not because the risks are small. They are not. It is worth looking straight at them.
8.1
The four serious objections
Four objections are serious enough to deserve a full hearing. Here they are in brief, with the answer to each.
The average return may be flattering itself. Across the 69 rolling 30-year windows since 1928, the worst compounded at about 8 percent and the mean of the windows was 11 percent. But those windows overlap heavily, the booming 1950s, 80s and 90s each get counted inside dozens of them, so a few great stretches do most of the lifting. Strip the overlap away and the data holds only about three separate investing lifetimes. That is exactly why this book does not lean on that 11 percent: it is an average of heavily overlapping windows, not what any one investor earns over a single lifetime. So the case studies are illustrated at 10 percent, the market’s full-period compound return, and every conclusion is built on the 8 percent floor beneath even that.
A major market could disappoint for a generation. Japan’s Nikkei peaked in 1989 and did not regain that level for 34 years, which fed the popular story of Japan’s “lost decades.” If it happened there, it can happen here. But the “lost decades” are a price-only story. The Japanese investor who kept buying through the wreckage (dividends reinvested, new money every year) still earned roughly 6 percent a year. And 6 percent was no consolation prize. It was several times what the safe alternatives in Japan paid: bank and postal savings drifted to essentially zero, and government bonds sank from 7 percent toward nothing. So the lost decades were real. The loss just fell on the people who thought they were playing it safe. This book’s exact method, tested against the worst developed-market crash in modern history, still worked.
America may stop winning. These returns rest on American exceptionalism: the deepest capital markets in the world, the rule of law, the dollar as the world’s reserve currency, and an innovation engine of universities feeding venture capital that no rival has reproduced. That edge is structural rather than lucky, though it still has to be earned again in every generation.
The national debt. It is real, and it is large: roughly $300,000 for every household in the country, and climbing. It has been paid off only once, in 1835, and was back within two years. No one serious expects it to be repaid now. But the failure it produces is not the one most people picture. A government that borrows in a currency it issues does not have to default, and in the century since the Federal Reserve was created in 1913, it has not. What it has done instead, again and again, is let inflation shrink the debt: the government kept borrowing in dollars, and the dollars kept getting smaller. That is a genuine risk to your plan, but it is a risk to the value of dollars, not to the existence of American businesses. And it argues for owning assets rather than holding cash, which is what this book already tells you to do.
Four objections down, one to go
Each of the four objections is real, and none of them breaks the plan. The average may flatter itself, but the plan is built on the floor beneath it. A market can disappoint for a generation, but the saver who keeps investing through it, year after year, can still earn a respectable return and build meaningful wealth. America’s edge has to be earned again in every generation. And the debt will most likely be inflated away rather than defaulted on, which argues for owning assets rather than holding cash. The fifth risk is the one no chart can show, because it isn’t the market at all; it’s you.
Even if the market delivers, you might not. This is the risk most likely to actually bite you, and the only one that is almost entirely within your control. For an investor in their twenties or thirties, a crash is not the enemy. A market that falls early in your investing life hands you the opportunity to buy companies on sale. Over a working lifetime, an early crash is a gift, and the right instinct is to lean into it, not run from it. The real danger is the behavior gap: selling in fear, sitting in cash, missing the handful of days that carry a decade. That costs ordinary investors more than any market risk ever has. And the falls that trigger the fear are not rare disasters to be dreaded. They are the ordinary weather of investing: a correction most years, a bear market every several years, each one temporary, each one a discount if you keep buying. But a crash arriving just as you begin to withdraw is different, and it is a genuine problem. That is a question for your sixties, and you solve it then by adding ballast as you near the finish, not by flinching now.
That is the whole map: four risks in the market, all survivable on a plan built for the worst the market has done, and one in the mirror that only you can manage. Next, that fifth risk up close, in a single month I have not forgotten: March 2020.
Coming next: What Could Go Wrong? Part two: The Fifth Risk, March 2020
Want the rest as it’s written?
New chapters arrive every Sunday, free. Subscribe and each one lands in your inbox.
Subscribe free →
A NOTE FROM THE AUTHOR
Start Now is free to read and free to share. Subscribe to get each new part in your inbox as it goes out.
If you find that it helps you, the kindest thing you can do is pass it forward to one person who needs it.
And if you’d like to give back, pay it forward: donate any amount to a cause you believe in. Your money goes straight to the charity you choose. If you’d like a suggestion, I support the Zach Moses Music, Love & Light Fund at the Sweet Relief Musicians Fund, which feeds musicians in need. sweetrelief.org/zachmoses →
If these pages have moved you to act, and you’ve opened the account, bought the fund, or set up the transfer, tell me about it: what did you do, what got in the way, what surprised you? Leave a comment or just reply to this email. First name, or none. I read every one.
Start Now is educational, not investment, tax, or legal advice. Nothing in it is a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Consider your own situation, and talk to a professional where it matters.
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
Start Now
Start Now · Part 11. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
A quick note on who this chapter is for. Everything else in this book is written to you, the person doing the saving. This chapter is the exception: it’s the one worth sharing.If a parent, grandparent, or other relative is in a position to help, funding your Roth is one of the most powerful gifts they can give, and often they simply don’t know it’s possible. So read it to understand the strategy, and if it fits your family, pass it along to the person who might help. What follows speaks to that giver, but the person who benefits is you.
Everything in this book points to the same conclusion: the earlier money goes into a Roth, the more time it has to compound. One lesser-known way to act on that is for anyone in a position to help, a parent, grandparent, or other relative, to give a young American the cash to fund a Roth they might not otherwise prioritize.It is a simple, legal, and powerful way to help the next generation start early, and it costs the giver very little in tax terms.
The most common case: a young adult just starting out.
Case Study · Emma, 22
Emma is 22, a working musician with gig income, no steady employer, and certainly no 401(k). She’s stretched, covering rent, gear, and the cost of becoming independent, and she assumes retirement saving can wait, because there’s simply no room for it now. But she’s earning, which is all a Roth requires, so her grandfather John funds one for her, to compound for fifty years, long before she’d have thought to start herself.
Yet those early years are the highest-leverage ones in this entire book: a dollar saved at 25 has the longest runway to compound, and that window never comes back. A parent’s or relative’s gift lets a young person capture those irreplaceable years without sacrificing the independence they are building. They keep their own paycheck for living expenses while the gift funds the Roth. And because it grows inside a Roth, the government never takes a share of what it becomes. Once the young person is more established, they take over the contributions themselves and carry the account for the next thirty or forty years. It is a modest gift that decades of tax-free compounding can turn into a fortune.
The core move turns on a simple fact: money is fungible. You can give the young person cash and let them make the contribution, or you can help them by contributing directly: the IRS does not care where the dollars came from, only that the contribution stays within the limits below. The practical effect is that your gift funds the Roth while the young person’s own paycheck stays in their pocket.
The one change worth making
There’s a quiet reorder hiding in this. Families who give often default to the easy thing: cash that gets spent, or a plain savings or brokerage account, to keep it simple. The better move is to fund the Roth first. Put in up to what the young person earned that year, and only then send anything left over wherever else you like. The size of the gift matters far less than the order: even a small amount, routed into a Roth early, becomes the most valuable dollar you could give. It’s the gift most people don’t realize they’ve been giving backwards.
The one binding constraint is earned income. This is the rule that trips people up. To contribute to a Roth, the recipient must have earned income (wages, salary, or self-employment income) for the year, and the contribution is capped at the lesser of the annual limit ($7,500 in 2026 for those under 50) or their total earnings16. So a young person who earned $4,000 can contribute at most $4,000, no matter how large the gift. Someone with no earned income cannot contribute at all that year. Allowances, investment income, and the gift itself do not count as earned income.
The gift sits well within tax-free gift limits. For 2026 you can give up to $19,000 per recipient ($38,000 for a married couple who split the gift) without using any of your lifetime gift and estate tax exemption or filing a gift tax return17. Since a full Roth contribution is $7,500, a gift to fund one sits comfortably inside the annual exclusion.
Why it is worth knowing. One $7,500 gift, made at age 20 and never touched, passes half a million dollars by 75 even at the floor, about $174,000 in today’s purchasing power. The age at which it is given changes everything. Three such gifts, at 20, 21, and 22, $22,500 in all, reach $1.4 million at the floor: nearly $500,000 in today’s dollars, twenty-two times the money given. That would be the worst case the market has produced on record. At the long-run average, the same three gifts reach nearly $4 million, about $1.3 million in today's dollars, fifty-nine times the gift. For a family, it is among the most efficient and powerful ways to pass wealth along. The gift is small enough to be tax-free to the giver, and every dollar of growth it produces is tax-free to the recipient. Roth assets generally pass to heirs tax-free as well, as Section 2 noted.
A single $7,500 contribution, held to age 75, shown in nominal dollars and in today’s purchasing power (2% inflation). Every dollar of it tax-free, from one contribution.
Notice the rule hiding in the table: every five years of delay costs about a third of the result. Twenty to twenty-five, twenty-five to thirty, thirty to thirty-five. Each five-year wait gives up about a third of what the gift would have become, roughly 32% less at the 8% floor and 38% less at the 10% average. The exact percentage moves with the return you assume, but the compounding logic behind it does not.
Emma is seventy-five. The gigs came and went; the account did not. The single $7,500 contribution John made for her, in a year she could not have spared the money herself, is worth about $1.2 million at the long-run average and about $443,000 even at the worst case the market has ever produced. That is about $410,000 and $155,000 in today’s purchasing power, every dollar of it tax-free.30 John spent $7,500 once. What he actually gave her was fifty-three years, which is the one thing in this book that cannot be bought later.
What if the young person is a minor? A working minor with a part-time or summer job can still have a Roth: a parent or guardian opens a custodial Roth IRAand funds it up to the minor’s earned income, with control passing to the child at the age of majority in their state. Either way, keep a simple record. Because the contribution depends on earned income, it is worth documenting what the young person earned: a W-2, or for informal work like babysitting or yard work, a note of who paid what and when, in case the contribution is ever questioned.
What about 529 plans and 530A accounts? Two other accounts come up when people talk about saving for a child, and both are worth a moment, if only to see why the Roth still wins. A 529 plan takes after-tax money, grows it tax-free, and pays out tax-free, but only for qualified education, such as tuition. Spent on anything else, the earnings are taxed and penalized. It’s an excellent tool for financing higher education, but it does nothing for retirement. However, leftover 529 money can now be rolled into the child’s Roth, within limits. That makes it a useful bridge between the two.
A 530A account (also known as a Trump account), created in 2025, is newer and more flexible. The federal government seeds one with $1,000 for every U.S. child born from 2025 through 2028, and families can add up to $5,000 a year. The money sits in low-cost, broad stock index funds: index investing by design. But watch the tax treatment. Contributions go in after tax, the account grows tax-deferred, and at 18 it converts to a Traditional IRA, so the gains are eventually taxed as ordinary income on the way out.18It is, in effect, a nondeductible Traditional IRA for children, and it carries the exact dis…
Start Now
Start Now · Part 10. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
The Bigger Picture · Chapter Six
The body of this book shows how to build retirement wealth. This section steps back to ask why that job falls so squarely on the individual in America in the first place, because understanding the why is part of the reason to start early. The short answer is that the United States has chosen, by design and by drift, a retirement model that leans on personal saving more than almost any other wealthy nation.
✦
A Story · Two Careers, Fifty Years Apart
Picture two people. Neither one is real, but almost everyone knows someone like both of them.
Ray went to work in 1975 and stayed at the same company for thirty-one years. He was not an investor and would have laughed at the word. He never chose a contribution rate. He never picked a fund. He could not have told you what a fund was. He signed a form on his first day and did not think about it again. When he retired, a check arrived every month, and it kept arriving. He retired in 2006, and by then the company had long since stopped offering that pension to anyone hired after him.
He had also bought a house in 1978. That part was a decision, though he made it for the ordinary reasons people made it then. He wanted somewhere to live, and that was simply what you did. Thirty years of payments later it was his. He never once described it as a savings plan, and he never chose one. The savings plan came disguised as a place to live.
So Ray’s retirement had three parts, and he had deliberately built none of them. A pension he was enrolled in. A house he bought because he needed somewhere to live. Social Security, withheld before he ever saw it. His entire retirement was assembled out of decisions he made for other reasons.
His granddaughter Abby started work in 2025, in the same line of work, at a company he would not recognize. On her first day, human resources sent her a welcome packet with a login to a benefits website run by an outside firm she had never heard of. She has not been enrolled in anything. She has been handed a door.
Behind the door is a 401(k) she is eligible for. Having access to it is not the same as putting money in it, and nothing goes in until she says so. It is an account with her name on it and nothing in it. The company is not hiding anything: there is a PDF explaining the match, a menu of about twenty funds with names that mean nothing to her, and a field asking what percentage of each paycheck she would like to contribute. Everything she needs is there. It is simply written for someone who already knows the answer.
And nobody is going to make her decide. Newer plans are now required to sign people up automatically and start the contributions for them. Her employer’s plan is older than that rule, so it is exempt: nothing happens unless she acts. If she never opens that email, the account sits there exactly as it is: available, correct, and empty. In 2025, about 72 percent of private-sector workers had a retirement plan available to them at work, and about 53 percent were actually in one.29 The gap between those two numbers, roughly one worker in five, had the plan sitting right there and never started it.
If she does start, the decisions do not stop. She has to choose which funds to buy and in what proportions, decide whether to change that mix as she gets older, and keep contributing through every downturn along the way. She carries the risk if the market falls in the wrong decade. And there is no guaranteed amount waiting at the end, because nobody is promising her one.
The house may not be there either. On her salary, in her city, the down payment is years away and moving away from her.
Here is the part that is easy to miss. Abby is not being cheated. She takes home more of every paycheck than her counterpart in France or the Netherlands, where the state pension replaces far more income and the tax bill is far larger. What she has been handed is not a smaller share. It is a different job.
Ray’s plan ran whether or not he understood it. Abby’s runs only if she starts it, and then keeps running it.
The work that used to be done for Ray is now Abby’s own work. That is not a complaint. It is a job description, and it is fair to think the job is harder than it needs to be. She can do that job the complicated way or the simple way, and the simple way is what the rest of this book is about. Her benefits website will show her the options. It will not tell her which one to pick.
✦
6.1
The American bargain: lower taxes, more responsibility
In much of Europe, and across the OECD, the public pension replaces far more income. The average net replacement rate for a full-career earner is about 63%, versus roughly 50% in the United States, and several countries, the Netherlands and Portugal among them, exceed 90%9. Many also provide universal healthcare and subsidized elder care, the costs that rise most steeply with age. They pay for it with far higher taxes. The United States collects only about 25% of its economic output in taxes, near the bottom of the developed world, against an OECD average of roughly 34% and about 44% in France10. Lower taxation is the counterpart to a smaller state: an American keeps more of each paycheck but must accumulate more private wealth to reach the same security. That extra take-home pay is precisely the raw material. Redirected into a Roth rather than spent, that becomes the private pension the state does not provide.
None of this is a modern failure; it is historically normal. Funded retirement is largely a 20th-century invention that has already crested. In 1980, about 38% of private-sector workers were covered by a traditional defined-benefit pension, the kind that pays a guaranteed income for life. By 2008 that had fallen to roughly 20%, replaced by defined-contribution accounts: the 401(k) and the IRA, in which the worker contributes, chooses the investments, and bears all of the risk11. The guarantee, in other words, moved from the employer to you. And in much of Asia the model was never funded pensions at all, but a cultural expectation that adult children support their aging parents, a reminder that “the individual saves for retirement in financial markets” is a choice America made, not a fact of nature. It is simply the one we live inside, which is why, if your job offers no plan, the IRA, the account you can open yourself, is the vehicle that puts a real retirement within reach.
It helps to see where that account sits inside the whole American retirement system. The table below lays out the entire landscape, roughly $47.6 trillion, sorted by size. Two things stand out. First, individual IRAs are the single largest pool, about 38% of everything, and they are the one account almost anyone with earned income can open on their own, with no employer required. That is why this book builds everything around them. Second, most of the rest of the system is tied to where you work: a 401(k) at a company, a 403(b) at a school or nonprofit, the TSP if you are federal or military, a traditional pension if you are lucky enough to still have one. If you have one of those, use it, especially for any employer match. (The $9.9 trillion in 401(k)s counts both kinds, traditional and Roth 401(k); the short note after Chapter 2 walks through how to use them.)40
Source: Investment Company Institute, Quarterly Retirement Market Data, First Quarter 2026; Traditional/Roth shares from ICI research (SEP and SIMPLE IRAs make up the remainder). Totals may not sum exactly due to rounding.
The Roth is still the smallest pool on this map, not because it is the weakest but because most people have never heard the case for it. Now you have.
6.2
Home equity used to be the plan, but it’s slipping out of reach
For most of the last century, the way an ordinary American family built wealth wasn’t the stock m…
Start Now
Start Now · Part 13. A free book, published one piece at a time: how ordinary earners build lasting wealth and financial freedom. New here? Start here →
Greg M. Ostroff, CFA
A Story · March 2020
In March of 2020 I did the one thing I had spent decades telling other people never to do, and I want to tell you about it, because I had every possible reason to know better.
I had been investing in markets for nearly fifty years at that point. I spent nearly twenty years on Wall Street, though I had been gone for almost twenty more by then. I became a Chartered Financial Analyst in 1988. I have been through a lot of market cycles, including some genuinely horrific bear markets and crashes, including both Japan and the dot-com bubble. And I have never thought of myself as a trader. My philosophy has always been to invest for the long run and to choose my entry and exit points, rather than letting the market do that for me.
So for the first seven weeks, as Covid spread and the market moved lower, I was the calm one. The news had been building since the end of January, and all through February and into March, as friends and family called to talk about the markets, I told them what I believed: valuations were reasonable, this was genuinely unprecedented, and it still looked like a short-term event. Stay the course.
The market had already fallen about twenty-five percent. I had cash on the side and, as it fell, I put a good chunk of it to work. That felt like the right move, and in the accumulation years of my life it would have been. But this was not that cash. I was no longer adding to my investments; I was living off them. That money was my buffer, the reserve I spend out of so that I never have to sell into a bad market. I treated a preservation-phase reserve like an accumulation-phase opportunity fund, and I never once framed the decision that way.
It did something else for me too, which I didn’t appreciate at the time. It gave the nervousness somewhere to go. When you have new money to invest, a falling market is an opportunity, and buying into it feels like doing something. It feels good. The urge to act gets an outlet, but one that actually helps you.
But then the buffer was gone. I was fully invested, watching prices fall, with no income arriving and no reserve left. The only remaining source of cash was the portfolio itself.
Somewhere in there an investor I knew started sending me messages. He had sold this. He had sold that. I never asked him what he was doing. He simply kept sending messages, unsolicited. He traded a lot, far more than I ever did, quick to move in and out of things, and I had told him for years that his approach did not work for me, partly because our tax situations were nothing alike. I knew his strategy was not mine. Still, I kept getting these messages. Then I started checking the financial news, which I hadn’t really bothered with in years. I can’t tell you now whether that came before or after what happened next, which tells you something about how clearly I was thinking. Then a message came from him that said something like: this is about capital preservation now.
What happened next is that I sold something. Not for any good reason. I sold my weakest position because I felt compelled to do something, and by then selling was the only something left. The market continued to fall.
Once you have started, it is easier to continue. I began reading what the Wall Street strategists were writing about where the market would bottom. Their targets were another twenty or thirty percent below where we had already fallen. I couldn’t tell you where those numbers came from. I read them anyway. Then I started watching the overseas markets at night, and the futures before the open, and somewhere in there I stopped behaving like an investor and started reacting like a trader.
One morning I woke to a hedge fund manager on the news urgently arguing that the stock market should be closed. I knew that was foolish, but I suspected he was talking his own book, trying to frighten prices down so he could buy more cheaply.
Here is the trap, and it is not the one you would expect. I was probably right about him. And being right is what moved me. If people like that were driving prices lower, then lower prices were coming, and lower prices are an opportunity. I wanted to be there for it. Seeing through the noise is not the same as being immune to it. Sometimes it is the very thing that pulls you in.
I had also built myself a very intelligent argument. This was not an ordinary recession, I reasoned, and not an ordinary bear market. Those are unknown unknowns. This was a known unknown. The government had deliberately put the economy on ice. There would be some level of pain at which policymakers would step in, but I was convinced that level was much lower than where we were. More pain had to come first.
But I had no new money arriving, and the cash on the side was long gone. If I wanted to buy anything, I needed cash available, and since I was tapped out, that meant selling.
So I started selling positions, to create the cash to buy a bottom I was sure was still ahead.
A few trading days later the Treasury Secretary and the Fed Chair made it clear they would do whatever was required. By then the market had already fallen about halfway to the level I had been waiting for. But it never got the rest of the way. It gapped up about ten percent that day, and I missed it. I was away from my desk when the news came out, sitting with cash.
Then I made it worse, which is the part I would most like to skip. The right response was obvious. Two of the most powerful officials in the country had just changed the fundamentals in front of me, and the honest move was to admit I had been wrong and reverse immediately. That is what a rational trader would have done. Instead I went looking for new reasons. I told myself I had missed that move, but that given the depth of the problem, the markets would move lower still. And I didn’t simply keep the argument I had started with. I built new ones, more of them than I had needed to make the decision in the first place, and every one of them kept me out a little longer and got me back in a little higher. It is easier to defend a mistake than to admit one, and defending it is what makes it expensive. For weeks the market ground higher. I kept waiting for the pressure to return. It didn’t. By the time I was fully invested again, stocks had risen roughly thirty percent above where I had been selling. I had missed a couple of years’ worth of good performance, handed over for nothing.
I am an investor, not a trader — I simply wasn’t being one in those weeks.
The money is not the part I regret most. I told people what I had done. For those seven weeks I had been the calm one, telling friends and family to hold. When I reversed myself, I said so. I have no way of knowing what anyone did with that knowledge. Some of them may have raised cash because I had. The embarrassment is not the point. Being wrong with my own money cost me a couple of years of returns, and I can measure that. Being wrong out loud, to people who took my judgment seriously, may have cost them something I will never be able to measure at all. That is what I would take back first.
So what stops me from doing it again?
Not resolve. I had seven weeks of it, and it held right up until the day I had nothing left to buy with. The honest answer is structural, and it has two parts depending on where you stand.
If you are still adding money, this is a far easier problem than it looks, and you already have the solution. Over my investing career I have been very stoic through market corrections, even crashes, holding my positions and adding to them with new cash coming in. I was not braver then. Having a paycheck allowed me to add to my positions or build new ones at lower prices. Every pay period bought more shares, so a falling market arrived as a discount rather than a threat, and the urge to …