What makes a great board game collection—and how do you start one without getting overwhelmed? In this episode of Positively Board Gaming, Mitchell and Jamey explore the joys and pitfalls of beginning a board game collection, and how weather (and s’mores) can’t stop a great game night.

Despite a thunderstorm, 12 guests showed up for Jamey’s game night, prompting a heartfelt conversation about what motivates us to play—rain or shine. Mitchell dives into how to thoughtfully build a game collection from scratch, including practical tips on avoiding overwhelming purchases, playing with your group in mind, and choosing games that are fun, portable, and easy to table.

The duo also exchange recent game night stories and sweet treats—from licorice-infused Icelandic chocolate, to s’mores-flavored Nothing Bundt Cakes. Jamey shares his first experience playing Night of the Ninja—a recommendation from Mitchell—and how the game’s rotating allegiances made it a hit. They wrap with reflections on the joy of recommending a game that really clicks and tease what’s to come in episode 13: their rebellious teenage phase.

0:00 – Intro banter & rebellious episode tease

2:12 – How bad does weather need to be to cancel game night?

8:19 – Game night food & the Nothing Bundt Cake experience

13:45 – Icelandic licorice chocolate and candy chat

19:20 – Starting your board game collection

30:25 – Jamey's first board games & Mitchell’s beginner picks

43:18 – Avoiding game overload and enjoying your collection

51:00 – The joy of recommending games that land

58:42 – Jamey finally plays Night of the Ninja

1:06:10 – Why rotating teams work so well

1:14:01 – What’s next & comments request

“Just make sure you’re acquiring games at a pace that you’re able to enjoy.” — Mitchell Whitfield

“I think one of the best feelings is recommending a game and watching it really click for someone.” — Jamey Stegmaier

board game collection tips, beginner board games, Night of the Ninja review, how to start a board game collection, best gateway games, board game podcast, licorice chocolate Iceland, Nothing Bundt Cakes s’mores, social deduction games, family board games, board game podcast, Jamey Stegmaier, Mitchell Whitfield