
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


We have talked about how Flexner's imprint on US health care leaves doctors as unthinking pimps for the drug companies. Doctors rarely independently evaluate interventions and tests, nor is their gaze patient-specific. Rather, they are apt to listen to "experts," many of whom are either directly or indirectly (in terms of their academic funding and research opportunities) beholden to drug companies. Doctors also listen to "authoritative" groups like the CDC or American Diabetes Association, all of which too receive the bulk of their funding and leadership from the pharmaceutical industry. Rather than read studies, digest the pros and cons of purported "life saving" drugs an tests and treatments, and treat each patient as a complex nuanced individual, doctors rely on protocols typically scripted by drug-company tinged companies or doctors. They essentially become robots, reciting the company line and not actually using their own brains. This is most apparent when a doctor uses a calculator to tell you whether you are at risk from a certain ailment or should take this drug or that. Calculators like this seem precise, but they are programmed with bogus data of which the doctor is unaware, and typically they are drug-company created. Doctors don't know about this; they simply use the calculators as though they are factual and spit out the conclusions as thought they are unassailable. These are robot doctors, and we will discuss more about them, as they can be very deceptive and dangerous.
We have been told that picking up cancers early and fixing them will save lives. But does it? It depends on the cancer. For breast and colon cancer, for instance, lifetime screening saves 1/1000 people from cancer deaths compared to those never screened. Other cancers, such as ovarian and pancreatic, are so aggressive that screening is not of value, since once these cancers are visible they have already spread. Prostate Cancer is the opposite. It effects 35% of all men, but kills only 1% of them. It grows so slowly that early treatment doesn't impact the rate of death; if you're unlucky enough to have the rare and severe form, treatment won't help. Doing PSA blood tests will pick up prostate cancers, lead to biopsies and tests, lead to aggressive and harmful treatments, but save no lives. Then, why do we do it? It costs our health care system tens of billions of dollars every year, feeds doctors and other members of the Medical Industrial Complex with lots of money, and gives men the illusion that their lives are saved, but causes far more harm than good. Listen to why PSA tells us a lot about our nation's doctors and health care system and why we need to fear both.
Since the publication of Ansel Keys landmark and fraudulent Seven Countries Study over 50 years ago, our nation has been on an anti-cholesterol kick. We ascribe almost God-like meaning to the cholesterol measurement--especially Big Bad LDL--and are hell bent in doing whatever is necessary to bring it below some magically drug-industry defined threshold either with medicines or by sticking to a low fat diet. What we have known for decades, and what a recent article reinforced (https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2022/03/220314120702.htm#:~:text=2-,Link%20between%20high%20cholesterol%20and,'inconsistent'%2C%20new%20study%20finds&text=Summary%3A,as%20strong%20as%20previously%20) is that cholesterol is a meaningless measurement. By focusing on it, we have over-medicated Americans to the tune of likely a trillion dollars of wasted treatment, we have glorified a low fat diet that is both dangerous and ineffective, and we have effectively slaughtered millions of people and disabled hundreds of millions more by passing out bad advice about cholesterol. And what is most tragic is that our Flexnerian trained doctors have not relented, still measuring cholesterol, still deluging patients with often toxic and typically ineffective pills, and still thinking that the low-fat dogma is good medical care. It's not, and in this podcast we'll explain why. Our Flexnerian obsession with finding a number that defines us, and then "fixing" that number, has led us down many very dangerous and expensive roads, but cholesterol is the road that should be most disturbing only because of how heavily traveled it is.
I have discussed this too in a video on my practice website and in a blog i wrote for my practice website, but it's also in all my books and several articles that can be found on my general website www.andylazris.com.
video, look for cholesterol: https://www.personalphysiciancare.net/video-gallery
Blog: https://www.personalphysiciancare.net/post/unlocking-the-cholesterol-myth
From the seeds of Flexner's Report grew the biostate in which we currently live. COVID certainly was the biostate on steroids, although the biostate has been part of our lives for decades thanks to Flexner.
What are the ingredients of a biostate? First and foremost, I don't want it to sound like some conspiratorial James Bond Villainy type of creation. In fact, the biostate is multifactorial, not controlled by some nefarious government, but rather driven by a health care system constructed under Flexner that encompasses industry, physicians, hospitals, government agencies, private agencies, and all citizen of the nation henceforth called "patients."
The biostate has transformed our society into a medicalized dystopia, with everyone leaping from doctor to doctor, taking drug after drug, test after test, procedure after procedure, to "fix" all the abnormalities and address their frightening diagnoses, all done under false pretenses, with drug companies providing the false data, the media using drug company data to scare people into submission, and doctors acting as the pimps of drug companies.
As our biostate spends more and more money tricking people into giving our their bodies and money to robotic swindlers with an MD after their name, as they wear masks and swallow handfuls of pills with a religious-live submission to those who preach medicalized myths, we are living shorter than virtually every advanced nation in the world. We spend the most, and we do the worst, and even so, all the patients promised cure, those who stent their arteries and suck down pills, those who trust their specialists and believe that their lives are being saved, they are the willing accomplices to the Flexnerian nightmare in which we live.
To understand our dysfunctional, self-serving, and nefarious health care system, you have to understand Flexner and the biostate it created. We will explore the concept here, and then move on in subsequent podcasts analyzin
We have already heard how the Flexner Report in 1911 reduced doctors to robotic drones, beholden to corporate America, under the strict rule of AMA policies and dictates, who were taught that patients are nothing more than a series of numbers to be measured and fixed. The blueprint of Flexner--drawn up by corporate tycoons, eugenic doctors, and the AMA brass--sought to homogenize American medicine, make it subservient to corporate America, and reduce it to a one-right-answer "science" in which human nuance, individual choice, and the breath of scientific knowledge is bulldozed by dogmatic absolutism, much as we are seeing with COVID but which has been present since 1911 when the report was published. The critical thinking and humanistic patient-centered gaze advocated by William Osler collapsed in the face of what we have today: doctors following protocols, treating numbers, and acting as unwitting pimps of the pharmaceutical industry, all while touting that they are scientific and patient-oriented. Sadly, Flexner did to our doctors what the German educational system--upon which the Flexner Report was based--did to its doctors, the majority of whom became enthusiastic Nazi's. Really, there is little difference between us and them.
One lost legacy of Flexner is how the report essentially--and intentionally--decimated the black physician professional class and relegated all black Americans to potential spreaders of disease to whites whose contagion had to be contained. The Report--which is still the foundation of our health care system today and how medical students are trained--devoted several pages to describing its anti-black position, claiming it to be necessary, and which the AMA had been already practicing for decades. The Report's recommendations closed all but two black medical schools, depriving them of funding and seeking to transform them into institutions to train black health-workers whose sole job was to keep black Americans from spreading disease to whites.
As the decades progressed, the exclusion and marginalization of blacks within our health care system only worsened, and black physicians had to fund their own schools and create their own medical organization--the NMA--merely to survive. Black Americans have suffered the consequences of this horrific policy. Only recently did the AMA apologize for its racist past, but the gears of that racism inscribed into the Flexner Report still drive our entire medical-industrial complex today.
Part 3 of our Flexner podcast mini-series is a bit long and taken from the final project I completed as a student at University of Maryland last year, where I am working toward a Masters of History. While this is a bit of a detour from the theme of the podcast, it's crucial to know just how deeply racism is embedded in our health care system even today, and understand the roots of its perfidy, the very roots that drive the cogs of the doctors who you trust so much but who remain shackled by the handcuffs of Flexner.
In part 2 of our look at the Flexner Report, we explore the nuts and bolts of the report and show how an insignificant educator, a fledgling medical organization, and a Eugenicist at Hopkins conspired with industry to reshape the entire medical industrial complex. The Report determined which medical schools would live and die. To survive the onslaught schools had to shift their curriculum to one that was formulaic, number-focused, taught by full time research faculty, and dependent on the largess of the Rockefeller and Carnegie Foundations. Osler was bulldozed as medical schools were now set up to train drones focused not on patients and using real doctors and patients to teach students but rather on one-right-answer absolutism, where number fixing and dogmatic protocols became the norm. We show how this report grew and thrived, and begin to explain how its imprint--and even the details of its blueprint--define American health care today.
In 1911 the medical world redirected itself with the publication of the Flexner Report, a legacy we still live with today. Everything we discuss in this podcast--from putting numbers over people, to doctors being pimps of drug companies, to industry infiltrating every aspect of health care, to people being bamboozled by false promises and expensive treatments--was born out of the womb of Flexner. In the first of a four part podcast, we will explore how the patient-centric, critical thinking, scientific, and humanistic creed of William Osler fell prey to the Flexner alliance. With the report, eugenic medical thinking--in which all people could be reduced to fixable measurements--, industry, academia, and the AMA all joined forces to gain everlasting hegemony over doctors and the entire health care system. From now all, all doctors must be trained and licensed under the centralized top-down claws of the AMA, academic centers had to follow strict AMA protocols, and industry financed and controlled the whole thing. While we think that our health care system is scientific and caring, in fact it is just the opposite, and by understanding Flexner we'll learn why. My colleague and I, Alan Roth, have written a book about the role of the Flexner Report in poisoning our health care system, a book likely due out in a year. This is a sneak peak! You can see a bit about it on our website, https://www.andylazris.com/a-fork-in-the-road-at-hopkins
When doctors uses deception and tricks to convince you to think that all the tests, drugs, and procedures they sell to you are "necessary and lifesaving," it's also crucial that they sell you on a fiction even more crucial to their role as unwitting pimps for the drug and device companies. They have to convince you that their snake-oil remedies are safe! Of course, they have tricks up their sleeve to do that, but studies show that most doctors don't need tricks, since 90% of doctors don't even know the dangers of the drugs they're prescribing or the tests and procedures they are being paid handsomely to push on you. Doctors get the majority of their knowledge from the media, from specialty society guidelines, and from drug-company sponsored studies. And to them, drugs and procedure are all good. If blood thinners help 0.6% of people with afib avoid meaningful strokes and kill 0.6% of people, to a doctor that means: "You better take this medicine or you'll get a stroke, and there are really very few side effects." We will dissect some of this deceptive thinking and provide you with tools that you had better bring to your doctor lest you become a victim of the number fixing game. Remember, in the world of modern medicine, your numbers and diagnoses are more important that you are. And in many cases, for patients not aware of the risks, that formula can well be debilitating and even fatal.
When we have a medical society hell-bent on measuring and fixing your numbers, you'll get a lot of tests, procedures, and drugs all designed to find abnormal numbers and fix them. But really, we need to base our tests and treatments on clinically meaningful outcomes: does the intervention actually help you. That help may be subjective and not subject to be measured ("I have less pain from that medicine," or "My depression is much better since I started therapy."), or it may be measurable such as having fewer fractures, fewer heart attacks, fewer strokes, less confusion, or less chance of dying. However, even there our doctors and their drug-company pimps have tossed a trick in . For instance, drugs for atrial fibrillation may reduce strokes by 5%, but since we don't notice the vast majority of strokes that hit us, we care about strokes we actually notice, and on that score these drugs only cut the risk by 0.6%, of clinically relevant strokes, something your cardiologist won't tell you and likely doesn't even understand. Similarly, certain drugs can reduce the chance of your getting a compression fracture of your back, and that's what the doctor will say. But fractures aren't clinically meaningful unless you notice them, unless they hurt, and on that score, very very few clinically relevant back fractures are prevented with these drugs, even if the doctor will tell you otherwise based on the fact that your x-ray looks better. When we start looking at tests and procedures and medicines--from opening blocked arteries to fixing your bone density to treating your dementia to lowering your sugar--the only outcomes we care about are clinically relevant outcomes, outcomes that improve your health or quality of life in some way, and this is something your doctor will almost never talk with you (or likely you won't buy their snake-oils), but something you need to know about before you dive into all these worthless tests and interventions deemed as "necessary and lifesaving" by your myth-peddling doctor.
As we delve into the dysfunction of our health care system, the most salient problem is that of numbers. We as doctors and as a profit-driven health care mega-complex have reduced patients into a series of measurements that, if abnormal, label them with defined diseases and subject them to number-fixing treatments. Whether medicines to lower sugars and cholesterol, stents to fix blocked arteries, medicines to "fix" low bone density, or going on blood thinners to cure afib, we are tabulated into numerical disease states and carved up and treated. Patients love this stuff; it fits well into their cognitive biases that everything is measurable and fixable. I mean, who would want to walk aroud with a 90% heart blockage or a bad bone density if they can be fixed, and why not get the sugar and blood pressure as low as possible? Sadly, though, none of this helps the person being "fixed." Doctors don't care if patients get sick in the process, if they feel horrid, if they become more medicalized and anxious; the drive to slice people into numbers and fix those numbers is ingrained into the very ethos of American health care. And what's worse, we keep changing the "normal" numbers so more and more people are abnormal, more people think they are sick, thus creating "numerical epidemics" like diabetes and hypertension that leads to more drugs and tests and procedures and more $$$ for doctors and industry at the expense of longevity and quality of life. To understand everything wrong with health care, you must first understand just how dangerous it is to treat people as numbers.
From the publisher's feed