
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In the eleventh instalment of Harneys’ Substance on Substance series, Philip Graham and Josh Mangeot summarise the presentation which representatives from the BVI Government, BVI Finance and the International Tax Authority (ITA) delivered to BVI industry participants on 16 October 2019.
Key takeaways:
• The ITA Rules were formally published on 9 October 2019. The rules with statutory effect under the BVI Beneficial Ownership (Secure Search System) Act 2017 (BOSS) will come into effect when a further amendment to BOSS is enacted. This is expected to be passed by the BVI House of Assembly in one sitting within the next few days, as the proposed changes are purely for clarification.
• We expect a revised Rules “v2.0” later this year reflecting consequential legislative changes (for example, to the BVI Business Companies Act 2004 and the Limited Partnership Act 2017) referred to in earlier ITA guidance and to clarify the format and timing of reporting via the updated BOSS system.
• We also expect industry communications regarding funds and collective investment vehicles and the revised BOSS IT system before the end of 2019. Regulated BVI funds are not expected to be within the scope of the economic substance legislation.
• The ITA confirmed that every legal entity must identify whether it carries on any relevant activity and report this via its BVI registered agent (RA), even if wishes to claim it is “non-resident” under Part 4 of the Rules – “nil returns” will be required and there is expected to be an annual filing obligation.
• The obligation to identify this and the other prescribed economic substance information under BOSS falls on the entity (rather than the RA). The ITA encourages BVI entities to seek appropriate legal advice if they are at all uncertain regarding their classification and expects they will have maintained a clear record of the basis for their classification (including by reference to advice, where required). This reflects an ongoing obligation under section 9 of BOSS (from 1 October 2019 onwards) to identify whether the entity carries on any “relevant activity”, unless the entity has a “reasonable cause” not to have done so. The ITA expressed the view that the primary legislation passed in January 2019 and the draft guidance available since April 2019 should have allowed entities to classify themselves in most cases but that, in circumstances where the final Rules have changed or clients have reasonably relied on legal advice with which the ITA disagrees, this should be taken into account.
• It was confirmed that entities will have six months from the end of the relevant “financial period” to submit the prescribed economic substance information to their RA, to be uploaded to the BOSS system. The filing timings will be set out in Regulations.
• Entities carrying on a relevant activity requiring substance in the BVI (other than “non-resident entities” and most passive “pure equity holding entities”) which are moving their business and employees to the BVI do need to consider any applicable obligations under the BVI’s trade or financial services business licensing requirements and employee-related obligations (such as work permits, payroll tax and other contributions). The Premier confirmed that the BVI Government is standing ready to assist BVI entities to make that process as efficient as possible. Where an entity wishes to outsource activity within the BVI (for example, via their RA), it was noted that such outsourcing providers will have appropriate licenses and permits for their business and employees already.
• There is further clarification around the obligations of entities in liquidation, which we will address in a future recording.
This episode was recorded on 16 October 2019.
Stay tuned for more Substance on Substance.
Classify, Classify, Classify
In the tenth instalment of Harneys’ Substance on Substance series, Philip Graham and Josh Mangeot discuss the release of the final version of the guidance formerly known as the “Code”, which was published by the ITA on 9 October 2019 as its newly-titled Rules and explanatory notes (the Rules).
Key Takeaways
• With the certainty provided by the final Rules, it is vital that all directors and operators of BVI entities classify their entities as a matter of priority, if they have not already done so. There is an ongoing legal obligation on BVI entities under the Beneficial Ownership (Secure Search System) Act 2017, as amended with effect from 1 October 2019, to determine whether they are carrying on a relevant activity and the first compliance periods have started for all companies and other relevant legal entities.
•Harneys online economic substance classification solution remains available for use at https://economicsubstance.vg and provides formal legal advice for a fixed fee – the solution reflects the final Rules and classifications received by users who have previously classified their entities using the solution are unaffected, subject to some minor cross-references to the numbering used in the final Rules.
• the ITA released a useful summary document of the relatively minor amendments made to the last public published by the ITA. The key changes include:
o where an entity wishes to be treated as provisionally “non-resident” due to its tax status under foreign laws, the “reasonable period” in which to provide the ITA with evidence of such status will be two “financial periods”
o BVI entities in liquidation are still generally expected to comply with the substance requirements
o the presumptions of non-compliance for BVI entities that are carrying on IP business have been made more difficult to rebut (ie disprove) and are subject to expanded reporting and evidentiary requirements
• Economic substance reporting for each BVI entity will generally begin in 2020 at the end of the current financial period, so all BVI entities should determine any economic substance compliance requirements for the current period.
This episode was recorded on 10 October 2019.
In the ninth instalment of Harneys’ Substance on Substance series, Philip Graham and Josh Mangeot discuss points to consider if your BVI entity may hold intellectual property (IP).
Key takeaways:
• A key focus of the EU and OECD has been on IP, as part of the base erosion and profit-shifting (BEPS) initiative.
• The BVI definition of IP rights includes the typical types of IP (eg, copyrights, patents, trademarks, brand and technical know-how) although the list is non-exhaustive. If you are in doubt as to whether an asset may be IP, we recommend that you take legal advice.
• It is important to note that the BVI “intellectual property business” definition requires an IP right in an intangible asset from which identifiable “income” accrues to the business (so if no identifiable income accrues there is no IP asset at all, for these purposes). Such income must also be separately identifiable from any income generated from any tangible asset in which the right subsists, if relevant. In practice, this probably requires consideration of the entity’s accounts or financial records in the first instance.
• In practical terms, the primary focus of the economic substance legislation is on IP that has been artificially transferred to, or diverts income to, an offshore vehicle (eg, for tax planning purposes). That is really what the BEPS initiative is directed at – it is not aimed at IP that is held protectively or IP which is part of a separate business. “Income” is defined broadly but many entities will hold IP as part of an adjunct to their actual business and which does not generate any identifiable income itself but simply contributes to the general profitability of the business.
• If you have some form of IP within your BVI entity we recommend that you speak to a Harneys lawyer. The penalties and fines around “high risk IP legal entities” in particular are potentially significant (and range up to US$400,000). There are also certain presumptions of non-compliance which may arise, where there is an “intellectual property business”.
• The final version of the BVI International Tax Authority’s economic substance Code is scheduled for release on 30 September 2019.
This episode was recorded on 26 September 2019.
Stay tuned for more Substance on Substance.
In the eighth instalment of the Harneys Substance on Substance series, Philip Graham and Ross Munro discuss Substance Solutions in the BVI.
Episode Eight
Phil and Ross highlight the options available to BVI entities once they have classified themselves under the Economic Substance legislation and have determined that they need to put substance in place in the BVI.
Key takeaways:
• After the classification process is completed, BVI entities who have determined that they are conducting “holding business” will ask whether their current set up in the BVI is enough to meet their Economic Substance obligations.
• There are a large number of entities in the BVI that would describe themselves as “holding companies” if asked, but will not actually be conducting “holding business” for the purposes of this legislation. We have touched on this in earlier podcasts.
• Companies which are classified as conducting “holding business” are required to comply with their statutory obligations and have adequate premises and employees in the BVI. In most cases, adequate premises and employees will be satisfied by the registered office and registered agent function they already have in the BVI. However, this is not an absolute certainty. If a company conducting “holding business” is very active, then it might need to put additional substance in place.
• Harneys are offering various degrees of health checks for BVI entities to ensure that all holding businesses are meeting their statutory obligations. This is something they should be doing anyway.
• For the other relevant activities, BVI entities will need to establish the nature and scope of that relevant activity before determining what substance is required. Harneys Fiduciary can provide a number of different services including:
o directorships to help with the direction and management requirement;
o outsourcing services to perform the core income generating activity;
o administration to provide accounting services and record keeping;
o premises (shared and dedicated premises space); and
o immigration, labour and work permit support, as well as the secondment of Harneys’ staff for certain activities.
This episode was recorded on 10 September 2019.
Stay tuned for more Substance on Substance.
In the seventh instalment of Harneys’ Substance on Substance series, Philip Graham and Joshua Mangeot give an update on timing of the ITA Code and consider some FAQs around the “holding business” and “finance and leasing business” definitions.
Episode Seven
Phil and Josh discuss the “holding business” and “finance and leasing business” definitions under the economic substance legislation and provide some practical examples of how Harneys considers the law will be applied in practice.
Key takeaways:
• We are waiting for the International Tax Authority (ITA) to publish its final Code. We understand the enabling legislation required for this to happen has been read in the BVI House of Assembly, and should appear in the official Gazette soon. The Code will then be released by the ITA.
• We are receiving a number of queries regarding how to apply the narrow “pure equity holding entity” definition. Very broadly, Harneys’ view is that
• Reading the definition purposively, a current account (whether or not it is interest-bearing) which is operated to receive dividends or capital gains and to pay the entity’s expenses should not be viewed as taking an entity outside the definition
• Conversely, having a bank account which holds significant cash sums received from other sources of income, generates interest or holds sums of a significant value in proportion to the value of the equity participations held by the entity (for example, as part of a broader reinvestment or working capital strategy) may mean that the narrow definition is not met
• The majority of brokerage accounts held by BVI entities that we have encountered are not of a type which would bring the entity within the narrow definition of “holding business”
• Many people are also asking how to apply the “finance and leasing business” definition. This is a highly complex area and the definition is very broad on its face – if you are in doubt, please speak to a lawyer. It is worth noting though that it is the current Harneys’ view that many simple intercompany debt arrangements which are non-interest bearing are unlikely to constitute a “finance and leasing business”.
This episode was recorded on 4 September 2019.
Stay tuned for more Substance on Substance.
In the sixth episode of Harneys’ Substance on Substance series, Philip Graham and Joshua Mangeot examine good governance principles for BVI entities in the context of the classification process and what entities should be doing now in light of their statutory obligations
Episode Six
Phil and Josh discuss the release of the BVI Economic Substance Code (the Code) and the responsibilities of directors of BVI companies.
Key takeaways:
• The House of Assembly postponed the second and third reading of the Beneficial Ownership Secure Search System (Amendment) No 2 Act, 2019 due to Hurricane Dorian; they will meet next week to pass the law into effect
• Following on from that, the International Tax Authority (ITA) will then finalise the Code
• The day-to-day responsibility for managing the business and affairs of BVI companies falls on its directors, who are subject to various statutory and fiduciary duties – as such, they need to ensure they have classified their company and understood its obligations under the law as the first compliance periods have started and there are potentially onerous consequences for non-compliance
• There are provisions in the BVI Business Companies Act 2004 (BCA) which broadly allow directors to rely upon expert advice when discharging their duties
• The ITA has made it clear that it will expect to see robust documentary evidence of the basis of the classification, such as board resolutions (which will typically be provided to the registered agent in some form as part of instructing it to make the relevant filings under the BOSS system) – these can also be used to record that the board sought expert legal advice
• There are existing statutory obligations under the BCA for BVI companies to keep records and underlying documents that enable the financial position to be determined at any point in time with reasonable accuracy – these include a statement of assets and liabilities and records of receipts and expenditure. If the ITA is unable to determine a clear basis for the classification, there is a risk that companies (or their registered agent, directors or other functionaries) may incur additional scrutiny in the event of an ITA investigation if they are unable to produce the required evidence promptly on request
This episode was recorded on 28 August 2019.
Stay tuned for more Substance on Substance.
In the fifth episode of Harneys’ Substance on Substance series, Philip Graham and Joshua Mangeot confirm that the first economic substance (ES) compliance “financial period” has commenced for all BVI companies and other relevant legal entities and also address some common misunderstandings regarding the ES timetable.
Episode Five
Phil and Josh discuss the release of the finalised International Tax Authority (ITA) ES Code, confusion on classification and compliance deadlines, and to which types of entity the ES requirements apply.
Key takeaways:
• The final form of the ITA Code is known and it should be available for formal release to the public by the end of August (as it requires enabling legislation)
• The BVI ES legislation had immediate effect from 1 January 2019 for companies or limited partnerships with legal personality incorporated or registered in the BVI (legal entities) on or after that date
• There was a grace period until 30 June 2019 for legal entities existing before 1 January 2019 – this has not been extended
• As a result every legal entity is now in its first compliance “financial period” and needs to have classified its activities
• There have been references to an October date but this point is of narrow application and relates to a delay to some new reporting obligations – it was not a change to the commencement dates for legal entities’ “financial period”
• All BVI legal entities should be classified regardless of whether they are perceived to be out-of-scope – “nil returns” will be required in 2020
• Based on statements by the ITA regarding the exercise of its investigation powers, entities should maintain a robust written record of the basis of their classification
• Affected legal entities with relevant activities (which are not “non resident” for tax purposes) should be taking steps to become compliant or reorganise themselves if the ES requirements necessitate it
This episode was recorded on 21 August 2019.
Stay tuned for more Substance on Substance.
In the fourth episode of Harneys’ Substance on Substance series, Philip Graham and Josh Mangeot discuss the option of continuing a BVI entity out of the jurisdiction (sometimes called a “re-domiciliation” or “migration”) as a response to the economic substance legislation.
Episode Four
Phil and Josh discuss (a) the global trend towards adopting economic substance (ES) requirements, (b) the need to classify individual entities’ activities and tax status to determine whether they are subject to the BVI ES requirements at all, and (c) the importance of that classification and properly weighing the costs of compliance against the transaction costs and ongoing operating costs resulting from the proposed re-domiciliation.
Key takeaways:
• Like any fundamental business decision, a re-domiciliation requires proper consideration of the transaction costs and other ongoing liabilities and obligations involved.
• The key first step is to classify the BVI entity’s existing activities. Once entities are properly classified, in many cases they may discover that they:
• do not have any “relevant activity” (and so are not subject to the ES requirements at all)
• are an entirely passive “pure equity holding entity”, for whom the existing BVI registered agent and registered office arrangements may be adequate, or
• can undertake simple reorganisational steps such that their business ceases to comprise any “relevant activity”, as defined.
• Even where there is a “relevant activity”, many entities may be exempt from the ES requirements by virtue of their tax residence or tax status (ie, where the entity or the participators in the entity are chargeable to tax on the entity’s income under foreign tax laws).
• Where proper classification has not been undertaken, we are seeing real-life examples of situations where entities may be incurring considerable expense and increases to their cost of business unnecessarily – in some cases based on a misunderstanding of the BVI requirements.
• Compliance can be straightforward for many BVI entities. For some, their existing arrangements may be sufficient to comply with the legislation – in other cases, the changes required to achieve compliance are very simple and can be achieved without significant changes.
All reputable international financial centres are adopting ES requirements as required by the EU and OECD, whose Forum on Harmful Tax Practice group has confirmed the BVI’s legislation meets the global standard.
This episode was recorded on 13 August 2019.
Stay tuned for more Substance on Substance.
In the third installment of Harneys’ SOS Series, Phil Graham and Josh Mangeot examine the implications of the first reading of the BOSS (Amendment) No 2 Act, 2019 in the House of Assembly, which is the enabling legislation for bringing into force the International Tax Authority (ITA)’s economic substance Code in the BVI. It is expected that the second and third reading will take place in the House as soon as possible, and will come into law shortly thereafter.
Episode Three
Phil and Josh discuss the process involved in the Code being finalised in the BVI and what steps entities should be taking right now – particularly if they may be in breach of the Economic Substance (Companies and Limited Partnerships) Act, 2018, given that the first compliance period has now started.
Key takeaways:
• The first compliance period has commenced for all BVI registered companies and limited partnerships with legal personality.
• Such entities are now in their first “financial period” for compliance purposes and need to classify their activities (and to consider their tax status, if they carry on any “relevant activity”) and take steps to ensure that they are compliant as soon as possible, if they have not done so already.
• Nil returns” will be required for all BVI entities.
• The ITA is expected to provide further clarification around what “evidence” will be accepted where an entity wishes to claim it is “non resident” for tax purposes.
This episode was recorded on 19 July 2019.
Harneys’ online classification solution Harneys’ Economic Substance online classification solution provides a cost effective way for BVI companies and limited partnerships with legal personality to demonstrate formally that they have considered their position under the economic substance legislation. The automated classification solution provides tailored real-time legal advice, provided by Harneys, for a flat fee of USD $250. For further information, please visit https://economicsubstance.vg Stay tuned for more Substance on Substance.
The SOS series was launched to provide our audience with the latest news on developments in the Economic Substance space, cutting through the confusion to deliver expert guidance from our Economic Substance Analysis team.
Episode 2
In the second episode, Phil Graham and Josh Mangeot discuss the key aspects of an industry update provided by BVI Finance on 12 July 2019. The update clarified that the commencement dates for entities’ first “financial period” remain unchanged and discussed the BVI International Tax Authority (ITA)’s stated approach to the use of its investigation powers as they relate to BVI entities, registered agents and other corporate service providers.
Key takeaways:
• The first compliance “financial period” has commenced for all BVI companies and limited partnerships with legal personality as set out in section 4(1) of the Economic Substance (Companies and Limited Partnerships) Act, 2018 – in particular, the 30 June 2019 commencement date for entities formed or registered before 2019 remains unaffected
• All BVI companies and relevant entities should have conducted an entity classification to determine whether they carry on any relevant activities and, if so, to determine their compliance and reporting obligations
• The ITA has stated that the manner in which a legal entity determines its classification should be formalised in such detail so as to allow the ITA to make a determination of compliance or non-compliance and, as part of its investigation and enforcement powers, it will be expected that registered agents will retain the relevant details and documentation to ensure the timely provision of that information
This episode was recorded on 19 July 2019.
Harneys’ online classification solution
Harneys’ Economic Substance online classification solution provides a cost effective way for BVI companies and limited partnerships with legal personality to demonstrate formally that they have considered their position under the economic substance legislation. The automated classification solution provides tailored real-time legal advice, provided by Harneys, for a flat fee of USD $250. For further information, please visit https://economicsubstance.vg
Stay tuned for more Substance on Substance.