The Commentary Booth

Supergirl Review


Listen Later

After nearly two decades of development hell across Warner Bros., Sony, and Netflix, the film finally landed on Amazon Studios—but does Masters of the Universe live up to the hype and legacy?

James Gunn's rebooted DC Universe continues with Supergirl, the second cinematic chapter following the success of Superman, but does Kara Zor-El's solo adventure soar to the same heights?

On this episode of The Commentary Booth, Jamie Apps is joined by Todd Eastman to break down Craig Gillespie's cosmic superhero adventure starring Australian actress Milly Alcock as Kara Zor-El. Together, they explore how Supergirl delivers a vastly different experience to Superman, trading bright optimism for a darker, more personal story centred on grief, identity, revenge, and belonging.

Jamie and Todd discuss Milly Alcock's standout performance, the emotional depth she brings to a character carrying the trauma of Krypton's destruction, and why her rebellious interpretation of Supergirl offers a fascinating contrast to David Corenswet's hopeful Superman. They also examine the film's strengths, including its world-building, the introduction of different-coloured suns, emotional character moments, and surprising humour.

Highlights Breakdown:

- Milly Alcock's star-making performance as Supergirl

- Why Kara Zor-El is the perfect foil to Superman

- The emotional themes of grief, heritage, legacy and belonging

- Jason Momoa's first appearance as Lobo

- The introduction of red, yellow and green suns in the DCU

- Did the film suffer from major editing cuts?

- The future of the DCU and upcoming projects including Lanterns and Clayface

The boys go deep on what makes this one different from Superman — for better and for worse — and come out the other side with a verdict that's more generous than the critical pile-on suggested it deserved.

This week’s episode is brought to you by

Australian Wrestling Cards

Check out more great content from Pario Magazine on our website.

-------------------------------------------------------------

SUPPORT PARIO MAGAZINE & THE COMMENTARY BOOTH

- PATREON

- BUY MERCH

- AMAZON PRIME VIDEO

- TUBEBUDDY

- Subscribe to AEW Plus using my code (q0yydoz) to earn $10 in FITE credit

- Shop Online With Honey

- Shop Online With Satechi

MY EQUIPMENT

- Elgato Facecam

- Rode PodMic

- Elgato Wave Mic Arm LP

- Streamlabs Talk Studio

FOLLOW JAMIE ON SOCIAL MEDIA

- Twitter

- Facebook

- Instagram

- TikTok

FOLLOW PARIO MAGAZINE ON SOCIAL MEDIA

- Twitter

- Facebook

- Instagram

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The Commentary BoothBy Pario Magazine

  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9
  • 4.9

4.9

17 ratings


More shows like The Commentary Booth

View all
The Boys and Invincible: A Podcast from TV Podcast Industries by TV Podcast Industries

The Boys and Invincible: A Podcast from TV Podcast Industries

75 Listeners

The Ringer-Verse by The Ringer

The Ringer-Verse

3,214 Listeners

BingetownTV - House of the Dragon & FROM by BingetownTV

BingetownTV - House of the Dragon & FROM

69 Listeners

The TV Terminal by Adam Vale Senior Editor @ thekoalition.com + host of "I am Negan" a TWD podcast

The TV Terminal

30 Listeners