
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In 429 BC, Sparta and its allies walled in the small town of Plataea. Inside were a few hundred men who had decided to stay. Two winters later, on a night of rain and wind, 212 of them climbed out over the siege wall on ladders they had built by counting the bricks.
This is the story of that siege, told from Thucydides, who wrote it down within a few years of it happening.
π΅ Music: Original soundtrack created for this documentary
βββββ
Sources
βββββ
Ancient Texts
- Thucydides β History of the Peloponnesian War, 2.2-2.6, 2.12.5, 2.71-2.78, 3.20-3.24, 3.52, 3.68, 5.17.2, 5.32.1, trans. Richard Crawley (1874).
- Herodotus β Histories 6.108, 7.233, 9.85, trans. G. C. Macaulay (1890) and A. D. Godley (Loeb, 1920).
- Pausanias β Description of Greece 3.9.3, 4.1.4, 9.1.4-8, 9.2.1, 9.2.5-7, trans. A. R. Shilleto (1886).
- Plutarch β Life of Aristides 21, trans. Bernadotte Perrin (1914).
- Diodorus Siculus β Library of History 12.41, 12.47, 12.56.
- Lysias 23, Against Pancleon, trans. W. R. M. Lamb (1930), via Perseus.
- Isocrates 12.94 and 14, Plataicus.
- [Demosthenes] 59, Against Neaera.
- Aeneas Tacticus β Poliorketika 2.3-6, Illinois Greek Club translation (Loeb, 1928).
- Hellanicus, fragment 171.
- Suda, epsilon 3954 and epsilon 1282, Suda On Line, translations by Tony Natoli and David Whitehead.
Excavation Reports
- Waldstein β "Discoveries at Plataia in 1890. I. General Report," AJA 6.4 (1890), 445-448.
- Washington β "II. Detailed Report on the Excavations," AJA 6.4 (1890), 448-452.
- Washington β "III. Description of the Site and Walls of Plataia," AJA 6.4 (1890), 452-462.
- Hunt β "IV. Notes on the Battlefield of Plataia," AJA 6.4 (1890), 463-475.
- Waldstein and Washington β "Excavations by the American School at Plataia in 1891. Discovery of a Temple of Archaic Plan," AJA 7.4 (1891), 390-405.
- Richardson β "Discoveries by the American School at Plataia in 1890. VI. Votive Inscription," AJA 7.4 (1891), 406-420.
- Aravantinos, Konecny and Marchese β "Plataiai in Boiotia: A Preliminary Report of the 1996-2001 Campaigns," Hesperia 72 (2003), 281-320.
- Plate XXIII, the 1890 site map.
Academic
- Paul Christesen β "Herodotus 9.85 and Spartiate Burial Customs," Classica et Mediaevalia 69 (2020), 1-72.
- K. Scarlett Kingsley β "Plataea on the Pyre: Anaxagoras A 44 and Thucydides 2.77," Classical Quarterly 70.2 (2020), 541-557.
- V. L. Menage β "The Serpent Column in Ottoman Sources," Anatolian Studies 14 (1964), 169-173.
- "Athens, Thebes and Plataia and the End of the Sixth Century BCE," Journal of Ancient History, doi 10.1515/jah-2017-0013.
- Konecny, Aravantinos, Marchese and Boyd β Plataiai: ArchΓ€ologie und Geschichte einer boiotischen Polis (2013).
- Whitbread and Boyd β geophysical prospection, in Hesperia 72 (2003), 315-316.
- Canevaro (2010) on the decree at [Demosthenes] 59.104 as a late forgery, and Kapparis (1995) defending it.
- Commentaries on Thucydides: Charles F. Smith on Book 3, chapters 20 and 22 (1894); E. C. Marchant on Book 2, chapter 4.
Cross-verification
- Perseus, LacusCurtius, ToposText, Livius, Wikisource, Project Gutenberg, Internet Archive and the ASCSA archives index, used to locate texts and check claims. No claim rests on any of them.
Accuracy Notes
- The escapers were not barefoot. Each man went over with the left foot shod and the right bare, Thucydides 3.22.2.
- Plataea surrendered in the summer of 427, not 428, Thucydides 3.52.1.
- The people on the roofs on the first night were women and household slaves, Thucydides 2.4.2. The children belong to Diodorus.
- The women were enslaved, not sold, Thucydides 3.68.2.
- Not fewer than two hundred men were executed. That is a floor, not a count, and twenty-five Athenians died with them.
- Thucydides gives three hundred Thebans in the first attack, 2.2.1. Herodotus gives four hundred, 7.233. Both figures stand.
- Thucydides does not call the fire the greatest in history. He calls it the greatest anyone had yet seen made by human hands.
- The Spartan siege wall has never been found. Three seasons of geophysical survey, 1998 to 2000, looked for it and its ditches and identified nothing. It was mudbrick and has gone back into the ground.
Image Credits
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art (Open Access)
- J. Paul Getty Museum (Open Content)
- Art Institute of Chicago, coin of Thebes, 1922.4250 (CC0)
- Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division
- Wellcome Collection
- Biblioteca Medicea Laurenziana, Florence, Plut. 69.2
- Royal Ontario Museum
- Engravings and plates by H. W. Williams, W. Miller, J. Stewart, Edward Dodwell, Simone Pomardi, O. M. von Stackelberg, Spruner and Menke, G. W. Cox, via Wikimedia Commons
- W. M. Leake, Topography of Plataea (1836)
- William R. Shepherd, Historical Atlas (1911)
- Internet Archive
On 20 November 1820, a sperm whale rammed the Nantucket whaleship Essex twice in the open South Pacific and sank her, leaving twenty men in three small whaleboats roughly 2,000 nautical miles from South America.
Captain George Pollard Jr. was on his first command. First mate Owen Chase was twenty-one. Cabin boy Thomas Nickerson was fourteen. After a month at sea the boats reached uninhabited Henderson Island, where three men chose to stay behind; they were rescued the following April. The remaining seventeen set out again for the coast of South America and endured dehydration, starvation, and exposure. The survivors resorted to cannibalism, and in Pollard's boat the choice of who would die was settled by drawing lots. Of those seventeen, five were alive when rescue came in February 1821. Eight men survived the ordeal in total. Chase published his account the same year, and Nickerson wrote his own decades later; it was lost until the 1980s. Herman Melville read Chase's narrative at sea and later met Pollard on Nantucket.
π΅ Music: Original soundtrack created for this documentary
βββββ
Sources
βββββ
Published Testimony & Primary Documents
- Owen Chase β Narrative of the Most Extraordinary and Distressing Shipwreck of the Whale-Ship Essex (New York, 1821). The first mate's account, published within a year of the rescue.
- Thomas Nickerson β "The Loss of the Ship Essex Sunk by a Whale and the Ordeal of the Crew in Open Boats," written late in his life. The manuscript was lost for over a century and not rediscovered until 1980-81; first published thereafter.
- Thomas Chappel β second mate's account, one of the three contemporary narratives.
- George Pollard Jr. β accounts attributed to the captain, including interviews given after his return.
- Herman Melville's annotated copy of Chase's Narrative, with his handwritten notes, held and digitized by Harvard's Houghton Library.
- Letters sent back to Nantucket when the first survivors reached South America.
Books
- Thomas Philbrick, ed. β The Loss of the Ship Essex, Sunk by a Whale: First-Person Accounts (Penguin Classics). Collects Chase's and Nickerson's narratives alongside Melville's notes and related documents.
- Narratives of the Wreck of the Whale-Ship Essex (Dover). Reprints the Chase, Pollard, and Chappel accounts together.
- Nathaniel Philbrick β In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship Essex (2000).
Archives & Official Records
- Nantucket Historical Association β crew records and biographical material on the Essex complement.
Cross-verification
- Wikipedia's "Essex (whaleship)" entry and the Carleton College shipwrecks project, cross-checked against the Penguin and Dover primary-source editions for crew numbers, dates, and survivor names.
Accuracy Notes
- The whale's length is given as roughly 85 feet in the published accounts, which is exceptionally large for a sperm whale and rests on the crew's own estimate from the deck.
- Chase's 1821 Narrative was most likely ghost-written from his account of events rather than composed by him directly. Where this film quotes or follows Chase, that caveat applies.
- Nickerson's narrative was written many decades after the events, from memory, and differs from Chase's on some details. Modern editions print both rather than reconciling them.
- The number of days adrift varies with how it is counted: Chase's boat was picked up after 93 days; the commonly cited figure of 90 days refers to the ordeal more generally.
- Eight men survived in total: five from the boats rescued in February 1821, and three who had remained on Henderson Island and were taken off in April. Survivor lists name George Pollard, Charles Ramsdell, Owen Chase, Benjamin Lawrence, Thomas Nickerson, William Wright, Thomas Chappel, and Seth Weeks.
- Nickerson's age is given as fourteen in some sources and fifteen in others, depending on whether it is counted at sailing or at the time of the sinking.
In May 1925, Sozerko Malsagov and four other prisoners walked out of the Kem transit camp on Popov Island and crossed four hundred versts of Karelian bog to reach Finland.
Malsagov, an Ingush cavalry officer, and Yuri Bezsonov, formerly of the Caucasian Divisional Cavalry, reached the Finnish frontier after thirty-six days on foot, together with Kalinka, Osnova, and Vasily Pribludin. Both men published what they had seen: An Island Hell in London in 1926, and Twenty-Six Prisons and an Escape from Solovki in Paris in 1928.
π΅ Music: Original soundtrack created for this documentary
βββββ
Sources
βββββ
Archives & Official Records
- Murmansk Railway construction administration β official account (Petrograd, 1916).
- Governor S. D. Bibikov of Arkhangelsk β secret inspection report on the Kem barracks (1915).
- Ingush State Museum β the Kuusamo photograph, taken a fortnight after the crossing.
- Ministry of Culture of Ingushetia β the memorial obelisks at Altievo.
Published Testimony & Primary Documents
- Sozerko Malsagov β An Island Hell: A Soviet Prison in the Far North, trans. F. H. Lyon (1926).
- Yuri Bezsonov β Twenty-Six Prisons and an Escape from Solovki (Paris, 1928), with the diary he pencilled into a New Testament on the march.
- A. Klinger β "Solovetsky Hard Labour," Archive of the Russian Revolution (Berlin, 1928).
- Maxim Gorky β published account of his visit to Solovki, June 1929.
- Maryam Yandieva, Ingush Research Institute β family record and Malsagov's letters to his daughter Madina.
- Yakub Oziev β letter from America, 25 February 1976, the day Malsagov died.
- Skibniewska β sworn statement on Malsagov's Polish service from 1930 and the pseudonym Kazbek.
Books
- M. M. Prishvin β In the Land of Unfrightened Birds (1907).
- M. M. Prishvin β Behind the Magic Kolobok (1908), White Sea and Kola, June 1907.
- S. V. Maximov β A Year in the North (1859).
- V. I. Nemirovich-Danchenko β "Solovki," Vestnik Evropy (1874).
- F. M. Dostoevsky β Notes from the House of the Dead, read against Bezsonov's own account.
Academic
- Elena Soini β Finnish archival research on the escapers' reception.
Press
- Segodnya (Riga) β Malsagov's original serialisation, November to December 1925.
Cross-verification
- Malsagov's and Bezsonov's accounts read against each other stage by stage.
Accuracy Notes
- This was not an escape from Solovetsky Island. The five men broke out of the Kem transit point on Popov Island, six miles from Kem and forty miles from the monastery. Most retellings get this wrong.
- The frontier river is not named. Neither escapee recorded it. "Pistojoki" is a later attribution and is not used.
- The snowstorm fell 21-26 May, not in June.
- Malsagov's leg injuries were cold injuries, not wounds.
- Bezsonov served in the Caucasian Divisional Cavalry, not the Life Guards Dragoons. Malsagov's own book has this wrong.
- "Buried in Portland" is a garble of Portland House, his address in Ashton-under-Lyne. His burial place is not publicly recorded.
- Every Malsagov quotation is F. H. Lyon's 1926 English. The 1925 Russian original has not been recovered, and the Russian versions online are back-translations from Lyon.
- The escape fund rests on Bezsonov alone: he wrote that Malsagov held the money and drank it. Malsagov never answered the charge.
- Where the two accounts diverge, both are given and neither resolved: the release of the guards, who struck which man, the food in the hay-makers' hut, the men at the farmstead, the river crossing.
- Malsagov's camp statistics, a ninety per cent death rate and a hundred thousand shot, are uncorroborated, flagged as exaggerations in the scholarly record, and not used.
- The claim that Rudyard Kipling praised Malsagov's book is a fabrication. It appears in no Kipling index or correspondence.
- Malsagov's birth year is unresolved. 1892, 1893 and 1895 all appear, so no age is given.
- Bezsonov's death year follows the ledger, 1950. One modern edition prints 1959 with a query.
- Kalinka, Osnova and Vasily Pribludin have no documented fate after 1925.
- Distances, camp populations and daily rates are the witnesses' own reckonings. The thirty-six days is Malsagov's figure.
- Elias LΓΆnnrot's Viena Karelia journals were examined and excluded. None of his journeys falls in June.
- The Finnish border-post records reach this film through Elena Soini, not from the documents themselves.
- Prishvin, Maximov and Nemirovich-Danchenko describe the same country in other years, attributed by author and date, never as the experience of the five men.
- The clinical literature describes these conditions in general and is not used to diagnose anyone named.
In December 1710, the merchant ship Nottingham Galley wrecked on Boon Island off the coast of Maine with fourteen sailors aboard, triggering a survival ordeal that ended in death, starvation, and impossible choices that have been debated for three centuries.
Captain John Deane's vessel broke apart on the rock during a gale. Over twelve days the crew endured freezing conditions, chronic exposure, and the deaths of their companions. The five survivors were rescued by fishermen from Portsmouth, New Hampshire. Two competing accounts, Deane's narrative and the sworn depositions of three crew members, disagree fundamentally on what happened, and the wreck's cause was never established.
π΅ Music: Original soundtrack created for this documentary
βββββ
Sources
βββββ
Archives & Official Records
- UK National Archives: Board of Trade inquiry files (BT 369/16-30).
- Lloyd's Register classification records.
- Portsmouth, New Hampshire: sworn depositions before Samuel Penhallow, 9 February 1710/11.
- London: sworn depositions before W. Withers, 1 August 1711.
- Historic England listing 1246778: tomb of Captain Deane, St Wilfrid's Church, Wilford, Nottinghamshire, 1761.
Published Testimony & Primary Documents
- John Deane β A Narrative of the Sufferings, Preservation and Deliverance of Capt. John Dean and Company (London: R. Tookey, 1711; ESTC T135539).
- Christopher Langman, Nicholas Mellen, George White β A True Account of the Voyage of the Nottingham-Galley of London, John Dean Commander (London: S. Popping, 1711; ESTC T117834).
- Cotton Mather β Compassions Called For (Boston: B. Green, 1711).
- John Deane β expanded narrative (1738 edition).
- John Winthrop β Journal (1630, establishing the name "Boon Island").
Books
- Richard H. Warner β "Captain John Deane: Mercenary, Diplomat, and Spy," The Northern Mariner XVIII/3-4 (2008).
- Paul Erickson β The New England Quarterly 48/1 (1995).
- Andrew Vietze & Paul Erickson β Boon Island: A True Story of Mutiny, Shipwreck, and Cannibalism (2012).
- Adam Nightingale β The Shipwreck Cannibals (History Press, 2013).
- Wreck of the Nottingham Galley: A Documentary History (Library of Early Maine Literature).
Academic
- Warren C. Riess β "Nottingham Galley at Boon Island: History, Archaeology, and Novel," The Northern Mariner XVIII/3-4 (July-Oct 2008).
- Ole L. Frantzen β "Finbankers," Journal of the Ordnance Society 13 (2001).
Forensic / Scientific
- Leuci, Melau, Messina, Tipton & Carenzo β "Beyond Hypothermia: Mechanisms of Death, Rescue, and Prevention in Cold Water Immersion," Journal of Applied Physiology (2026).
- Farstad & Dunn β "Cold Water Immersion and Rescue," Wilderness & Environmental Medicine (2019).
- Golden & Hervey β rewarming shock and afterdrop physiology (1981).
- Hollis & Holdgate β "Starvation and the Refeeding Syndrome," Emergency Medicine 9 (1997).
Cross-verification
- Jeremy D'Entremont β New England Lighthouses: A Virtual Guide and U.S. Lighthouse Society archives.
- Robert Thayer Sterling β Lighthouses of the Maine Coast and the Men Who Keep Them.
- U.S. Lighthouse Society podcast (Eldridge & Berry, 1978 evacuation, episode 125, 27 June 2021).
- Robert Mellors β Old Nottingham Suburbs Then and Now (1914).
Accuracy Notes
- The wreck's cause was never established and no one was ever punished for anything.
- Two competing first-hand accounts survive: Deane's narrative and the sworn crew depositions. They disagree fundamentally on critical events.
- The carpenter is unnamed in every account; the cook (Martin Downs) is named only by Cotton Mather.
- The ship's ten guns were raised by archaeologists in 1995 (nine recovered, identified as Swedish). Artifacts are curated at the Maine State Museum, Augusta.
- Kenneth Roberts's 1956 novel Boon Island is fiction and is not used in this film.
- The insurance figures cited by crew members are unverified hearsay; no underwriting record survives.
In 1740, Commodore George Anson sailed from England with nearly 1,900 men to take a Spanish treasure galleon. Four years later, 188 came home. Two of them had been killed in battle.
The rest were lost to scurvy, to storms off Cape Horn, to shipwreck and to desertion. The squadron was crewed in part with Chelsea Pensioners, old soldiers too frail to march, carried aboard on stretchers because no fit men could be spared. Of the Centurion, one ship of eight, enough men survived to keep sailing west, and in 1743 she met the galleon off the Philippines.
From the publisher's feed