Read Max

Talking with John Ganz about J.D. Vance, Peter Thiel and the tech right


Listen Later

Greetings from Read Max HQ! Ongoing request alert: I’m still looking for stories and examples of A.I. slop, wherever you encounter it: On platforms! In your workplace! On the subway! In the library! In the background of movies! I will take any and all anecdotes and samples of weird, shoddy, uncanny, annoying A.I. crap in your day to day life. If you have any good leads or stories, email me: [email protected]. I have gotten a bunch of good images and stories already and am eager for more! (And if you’ve sent something in I haven’t responded to your email to thank you--sorry!)

This week’s newsletter has two parts: First, a new collaborative episode of the Read Max Experimental Audio Product: a “crossover event” with (literal!) bestselling author John Ganz of Unpopular Front. Like me, Ganz is fascinated and repelled by the “tech right,” and has written some excellent pieces about its fascoid tendencies, and like me, Ganz has been engrossed by Trump’s selection of J.D. Vance as his running mate. We talked on Thursday afternoon about, among other things, “the vibe shift,” the different fractions of capital in the Valley, the presence-in-absence of Peter Thiel, and what’s going on with David Sacks and Marc Andreessen. You can listen above, or on any of the fine platforms where you find your podcasts.

Second, below you can read a short few paragraphs following up (triumphantly) on last week’s newsletter about Tyler Cowen’s “vibe shift” anti-cope.

A reminder: Read Max is almost fully funded by paying subscribers, who recognize and fairly compensate the mechanical and psychic labor it involves to read so many things about repellent people like J.D. Vance. If you like Read Max, which produces eight newsletters and between 15,000 and 20,000 words a month, about the same as you like “one cold beer at your local bar,” please consider becoming a paying subscriber, for the low, beer-like price of $5/month or $50/year.

The vibe shifted, again

Last week I wrote about the economist-blogger Tyler Cowen’s analysis of what at the time--in the wake of the assassination attempt on former president Trump and in the midst of the Republican National Convention at which Ohio Senator J.D. Vance was nominated as Trump’s running mate--appeared to be a major “vibe shift” in favor of Trump and an ascendant Silicon Valley right. Cowen elaborated 19 more-or-less structural reasons or causes for this vibe shift, among them “10. The Woke gambit has proven deeply unpopular.” and “6. The ongoing feminization of society has driven more and more men, including black and Latino men, into the Republican camp. The Democratic Party became too much the party of unmarried women.”

As I wrote at the time, Cowen’s list seemed too dependent on a reading of Twitter sentiment, rather than on a broader and more diverse survey of American public opinion(s), and as a consequence it sounded like

a kind of “anti-cope”--an attempt to rationalize and explain good news that might have been arbitrarily delivered and ultimately transient. Where “cope” is how you convince yourself it’s not actually so over, anti-cope is how you convince yourself that we’re so back for good this time, that we’re not just suffering another vibes volatility cycle, that there’s something more going on to success than “old guy + higher prices.” (Another word for cope and anti-cope is: Ideology.)

I wish a bit I’d held back and saved the topic for this week, since “the vibes” have unquestionably shifted yet again, happily proving my point, in the aftermath of President Biden’s resignation announcement and Vice President Kamala Harris’ assumption of the Democratic nomination: Democrats immediately raised a record-breaking amount of money, polls showed her in a dead heat with Trump, and Republicans began to anonymously complain about Vance.

Now, I could come up with a long, Cowen-like list explaining how and why the Twitter vibes have suddenly shifted (“1. Americans deeply dislike juiceless Silicon Valley podcast reactionaries of the kind that keep appearing at the RNC”). But this would just be making the same mistake: backfilling Twitter sentiment volatility with whatever structural or statistical (or simply “sounds-right”) rationalization I can lay my hands on. Have the vibes changed because “The Woke gambit” has now proven deeply popular, suddenly? Or were the vibes not really related to these broader structural shifts in ideology the first place and connected more superficially to candidate perception? Or were the vibes just doing what “vibes on Twitter” do, which is change, constantly?

Like I wrote last week: “It is the most volatile social network more or less by design and function”; all the optimism Democrats are feeling right now will be replaced by a sensation of doom and chaos at least once, and probably several times, between now and election day. (Just wait till Harris announces Josh Shapiro as her running mate!) You will not catch me attempting to account for those vibe shifts with anything but the most superficial analysis.



Get full access to Read Max at maxread.substack.com/subscribe
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Read MaxBy Max Read

  • 4.5
  • 4.5
  • 4.5
  • 4.5
  • 4.5

4.5

15 ratings


More shows like Read Max

View all
Jacobin Radio by Jacobin

Jacobin Radio

1,407 Listeners

Chapo Trap House by Chapo Trap House

Chapo Trap House

8,771 Listeners

Citations Needed by Nima Shirazi and Adam Johnson

Citations Needed

3,865 Listeners

Posting Through It by Jared Holt & Michael Edison Hayden

Posting Through It

383 Listeners

Know Your Enemy by Matthew Sitman

Know Your Enemy

1,895 Listeners

TrueAnon by TrueAnon

TrueAnon

3,125 Listeners

5-4 by Prologue Projects

5-4

3,323 Listeners

Blowback by Blowback

Blowback

2,916 Listeners

Tech Won't Save Us by Paris Marx

Tech Won't Save Us

476 Listeners

Time To Say Goodbye by Time To Say Goodbye

Time To Say Goodbye

388 Listeners

Joshua Citarella by Joshua Citarella

Joshua Citarella

126 Listeners

Unclear and Present Danger by Jamelle Bouie and John Ganz

Unclear and Present Danger

558 Listeners

Better Offline by Cool Zone Media and iHeartPodcasts

Better Offline

457 Listeners

Power User with Taylor Lorenz by Taylor Lorenz

Power User with Taylor Lorenz

211 Listeners

System Crash by System Crash

System Crash

33 Listeners