The Case That Has Divided America
The Family Routine, The Mental-Health Crisis, And A Case That Has Become A Test Of Criminal Responsibility
On the morning of January twenty-fourth, two thousand and twenty-three, Lindsay Clancy takes her five-year-old daughter Cora to a medical appointment.
They return to the family's home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, where snow covers the ground. Cora and her three-year-old brother Dawson play outside. Lindsay takes photographs and sends them to family.
Inside the house is their baby brother, Callan, eight months old. Lindsay's husband, Patrick Clancy, is working from a home office. The family is together. There is nothing unusual about needing medicine for a child, ordering dinner or discussing which restaurant to use.
But Lindsay's ordinary routines are taking place against something far less ordinary. For months, she has been struggling with severe insomnia, anxiety, intrusive thoughts, changes in medication and repeated contacts with mental-health professionals. Members of her family have become increasingly worried about her. Lindsay herself has repeatedly sought help.
What happens inside the Clancy home that evening will ultimately force doctors, lawyers and a jury to confront a difficult question. It is not simply a question of what Lindsay Clancy did.
It is a question about the state of her mind when she did it — and how far criminal responsibility can extend when severe mental illness is alleged.