This week on Tel Aviv Diary, Marc Schulman sits down with Ruthie Blum—journalist, and commentator —for a wide-ranging conversation that begins with biography and ends in the fog of history-in-the-making. Schulman and Bloom first met as on-air foils on i24News—“the right-wing woman” and “the left-wing man,” as Bloom puts it—but their discussion quickly shows how much the political map has shifted, and how often today’s arguments scramble old labels. What emerges is not a debate for sport, but a candid conversation between two people who disagree on some fundamentals, yet share a sense that the ground has moved beneath everyone’s feet.
Bloom recounts a life shaped by New York’s intellectual world and by her parents, Norman Podhoretz and Midge Decter, figures associated with the original neoconservative turn—liberals who migrated toward conservatism in the late Cold War era. Her own political instincts, she says, were formed early: a suspicion of elite hypocrisy, a preference for merit, and an impatience with fashionable ideology. She describes arriving in Israel in 1977 intending a single year at Hebrew University—and then staying, building a life that took her from Jerusalem to Tel Aviv and from “Dear Ruthie” at The Jerusalem Post to editing roles and ultimately to her current work at Jewish News Syndicate, alongside a weekly video podcast with former ambassador Mark Regev (“Israel Undiplomatic”). Along the way, Schulman and Bloom spar and converge on a theme that recurs throughout the episode: equality of opportunity versus equality of outcome—and what happens when a country’s opportunities are shaped by geography, class, and war.
From there, the discussion widens to Israel’s immediate strategic uncertainty. With Iran dominating Israeli attention, the episode captures a society living on alert—sandals by the bed, jokes about shelters, and a sense that “unfinished business” hangs in every direction even after the return of most hostages. Schulman and Bloom treat predictions with skepticism, emphasizing how hard it is to understand events while they are still unfolding—and why Israelis, in particular, have learned to live inside contingency. They discuss how Iran’s trajectory could reshape the region’s other arenas—from Hezbollah to Gaza—without claiming certainty about what comes next.
The conversation then turns to Qatargate, leaks, and the way foreign money and influence seem to seep through multiple systems—Israeli politics, Western universities, and media ecosystems. Bloom, who worked briefly inside the Prime Minister’s Office before and after October 7, offers dry humor and sharp skepticism, while Schulman presses on accountability and institutional trust. Their disagreement here is real, but so is their shared frustration: Israel’s governance battles, they suggest, are intensified by structural problems—no constitution, unclear boundaries between branches, and power vacuums that politics rushes to fill.
Finally, the episode shifts to America, where both hosts express deep concern over the mainstreaming of antisemitism—first on the left and now increasingly on the right. Bloom outlines how figures with large platforms have normalized or echoed antisemitic tropes, and why that matters more than fringe theatrics. Schulman asks the historian’s question—how did this travel from the margins to the semi-mainstream?—and Bloom traces a combustible mix: resentment politics, isolationism, and conspiratorial narratives that now circulate with alarming speed.
The episode closes on a rare note of optimism—Bloom recounts her son, a Gaza veteran, telling younger coworkers that despite the exhaustion and trauma, Israel has also achieved outcomes that would have seemed impossible before October 7. It’s a complicated hope, not a cheerful one—but it is the kind Israelis recognize: measured, hard-earned, and spoken without illusion.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit marcschulman.substack.com/subscribe