That Sounds Terrifying

In the chilling debut of our Terrifying Short Tales series, a forgotten box of home videos unravels a past that was never meant to be uncovered. What begins as nostalgia quickly descends into something far darker phantom figures in the background, a stranger in the role of father, and a horrifying truth buried beneath holiday lights and static. Some tapes should never be played, because once you press play… you can never go back.

About Terrifying Short Tales The TSTs within TSTTerrifying Short Tales is a mini-series from That Sounds Terrifying, delivering bite-sized but bone-chilling stories inspired by real accounts, folklore, and the darkest corners of the internet. Perfect for when you crave a quick scare—but beware, even the shortest tales can linger the longest.

*This tale was Produced and Edited by Ashlyn Dugdale, TST Intern.

We Need Your Terrifying TalesShare your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at [email protected]

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying.

That Sounds Terrifying: A Podcast with Nick and JessArt Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan – mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:

https://soundcloud.com/

Individual sound effects used or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGPT, and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use.

Nick and Jess unravel unsettling tales where time doesn’t play by the rules, from a lifeguard’s chilling poolside encounter to a family’s strange detour. Explore some time slips, vanishing figures, and ghostly scenes that feel too real to ignore.Strange things happen. Are you paying attention or are you too short on time?

We Need Your Terrifying Tales

Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at [email protected]

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:

That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. 

Copyright & Credits:

This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. Reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and That Sounds Terrifying Podcast.

That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site.

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:

https://soundcloud.com/

Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com 

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use. 

Nick and Jess return with a collection of supernatural tales that blur the line between reality. From portal guardians and a shadowy figure lurking on a mysterious floor of an apartment building to a basketball mysteriously dribbling in a basement of a childhood home. These are stories of encounters that will leave you questioning what’s hiding in the spaces we sometimes overlook.

We Need Your Terrifying Tales

Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at ⁠[email protected]⁠

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:

That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. 

Copyright & Credits:

This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. Reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and That Sounds Terrifying Podcast.

That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  ⁠mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site⁠.

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:

⁠https://soundcloud.com/⁠

Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at ⁠https://freesound.org/⁠ and ⁠www.101soundboards.com⁠ 

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use. 

In this soulful and spooky episode, Nick and Jess are joined by their friend and fellow improv performer Catie for a conversation that touches on everything from comedy and ghost stories to the mysteries of reincarnation and spiritual energy. Together, they share chilling tales of supernatural encounters from a grandmother’s spirit appearing on a familiar road, to a haunting drive involving a tan pickup truck that wouldn’t disappear. Along the way, the group also gets personal discussing faith, loss, life lessons, and the power of love and community to keep dark forces at bay. 👻 From dark roads and light-up dolls to Smashing Pumpkins and Dante’s Inferno, this episode proves that even the weirdest stories connect us in the most unexpected ways.

More about our Guest Catie:

Catie is a Long Island native with a deep appreciation for the spooky and the spiritual. A former criminal justice student turned improv performer, she brings a sharp wit with her amazing improv and a love of storytelling to every stage she steps on. After meeting her husband at the University at Buffalo, Catie’s journey took her from New York to Pennsylvania and Philly, with stops in East Meadow and Montauk, before returning upstate when her husband and brother-in-law took over Fox’s Deli in Henrietta. With a lifelong curiosity about the paranormal and a talent for comedy, Catie blends heart, humor, and a healthy dose of the unexplained wherever she goes.

We Need Your Terrifying Tales

Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at [email protected]

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:

That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. 

Copyright & Credits:

This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. Reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and That Sounds Terrifying Podcast.

That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site.

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:

https://soundcloud.com/

Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com 

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use. 

In this weird and winding episode, Nick and Jess dive into everything from audio mishaps and awkward AIM screen names to concert plans in duplicity. Along the way, they spiral into three chilling tales around creepy office vibes, the terrifying truth about tech, and a shadowy intruder in a wide-brimmed hat. Blending fun banter with dark fears, this episode proves that even the most casual conversations can take a terrifying and hilarious turns.

We Need Your Terrifying Tales

Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at [email protected]

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:

That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. 

Copyright & Credits:

This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. Reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and That Sounds Terrifying Podcast.

That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site.

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:

https://soundcloud.com/

Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com 

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use. 

In this special episode of That Sounds Terrifying, Nick and Jess speak to Stephen for an in-depth conversation about his spiritual journey and deep ties to Rochester’s rich supernatural history. From chilling childhood encounters in a historic home to his current work with the Rochester Spiritual Society, Stephen shares personal experiences, stories, and insights into the city's spiritualist legacy. Together, the trio discuss the lingering energies of the Union Tavern, the Irondequoit Cemetery, and the hidden history of the Fox Sisters. Whether you're curious about mediumship, fascinated by ghost stories, or drawn to the roots of America's spiritualist movement, this episode will leave you wondering what lies just beyond the veil.

About Guest, Stephen Patrick

Website: www.StephenPatrickSpiritualist.com

Instagram: www.instagram.com/StephenPatrickSpiritualist

Rochester Spiritual Society: www.facebook.com/RochesterSpiritualistSociety

Stephen is a Spiritualist Medium and founding member of the Rochester Spiritualist Society and serves as its Vice-President and Education Director. He facilitates discussion groups and classes on the subject of Spiritualism, and also leads a monthly mediumship development group. Stephen is also a historian of the Spiritualist Movement and has been working for the last several years on researching and documenting the history of the Spiritualist movement in Rochester, New York.

We Need Your Terrifying Tales

Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at [email protected]

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:

That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. 

Copyright & Credits:

This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. Reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and That Sounds Terrifying Podcast.

That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site.

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:

https://soundcloud.com/

Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com 

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use. 

Hosts Nick Koziol, Christine Smith, and Jess DeCotis team up for a special crossover episode of That Sounds Terrific in the 585 and That Sounds Terrifying, joined by creative writer/producer Kendrick Foxx. Born in small-town Alabama and forged in the high-stakes world of L.A. film production, Kendrick shares his fascinating journey from engineering student to streaming-feature filmmaker. The episode takes a turn as Kendrick dives into his passion for the paranormal sharing intense research and a personal encounter with a legendary cryptid known as the “dogman.” So whether it’s building a film studio in Henrietta or chasing werewolf legends in the Finger Lakes, Kendrick is blending art, industry, and mystery in ways that both inspire and terrify. This crossover is packed with creativity, curiosity, and the kind of goosebump-inducing stories that will make you want to keep the lights on.

We Need Your Terrifying Tales

Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at [email protected]

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:

That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. 

Copyright & Credits:

This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. Reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and That Sounds Terrifying Podcast.

That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site.

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:

https://soundcloud.com/

Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com 

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use. 

Has a place ever filled you with overwhelming sadness or fear? If so, you won’t want to miss this episode. Co-host Nick opens up about a personal story he’s long kept private—one that reveals a deep emotional connection to a tragic event. Jess dives into two chilling Reddit tales featuring faceless figures and towering shadowy entities. It’s a raw, resonant conversation about ghostly encounters and the strange, sometimes painful ways we connect to the unknown.

We Need Your Terrifying Tales

Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at [email protected]

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:

That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. 

Copyright & Credits:

This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. Reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and That Sounds Terrifying Podcast.

That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site.

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:

https://soundcloud.com/

Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com 

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use. 

#Paranormal #GhostStories #supernatural

In this unique crossover episode, worlds collide as That Sounds Terrific in the 585 teams up with That Sounds Terrifying for a dynamic and thought-provoking conversation. Hosted by the terrific Chris Lindstrom—Co-Founder of the Lunchador Podcast Network and long-time champion of Rochester’s food scene—this episode flips the script as Chris interviews Nick Koziol, Christine Smith, and Jess DeCotis about their experiences as co-hosts, community engagers, story tellers, and podcasting partners.

Then the tables soon turn, and the trio get their chance to ask Chris about his passion for podcasting, his uplifting of small and minority-owned restaurants, his decade-long journey with Food About Town, and how the Lunchador Podcast Network is creating an equitable collective to amplify voices that make Rochester terrific.

It’s real talk, deep laughs, and a whole lot of passion for the 585.

We Need Your Terrifying Tales

Share your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at [email protected]

About Chris Lindstrom, Co-Founder - Lunchador Podcast Network, Host - Food About Town Podcast

Email: [email protected]

www.linkedin.com/in/chris-lindstrom-6b014235

Instagram: www.instagram.com/stromie

Chris Lindstrom is the Co-Founder of the Lunchador Podcast Network and the long time host of the Food About Town Podcast. He has covered the Rochester food and drink scene for over a decade with a focus on small, minority owned restaurants and places with passion. Chris and his Co-Founder Matt Austin have made LPN into an equitable collective where the people who do the work to make Rochester a better place in their own way can express their dedication to the community.

Follow the Lunchador Podcast Network

www.lunchador.org

Instagram: www.instagram.com/lunchadorodcasts

Tiktok: www.tiktok.com/@lunchadorpodcasts

Food About Town Podcast:

www.foodabouttown.com

Instagram: www.instagram.com/foodabouttownpodcast

TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@foodabouttown

The That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:

That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. 

Copyright & Credits:

This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. This particular episode also features Chris Lindstrom, the Lunchador Podcast Network and reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and creators of both entities.

That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site.

Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.

Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:

https://soundcloud.com/

Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com 

Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use. 

#Paranormal #GhostStories #supernatural

Nick and Jess unravel tales of a cursed tree tied to mysterious deaths and ghostly encounters on Civil War battlefields. They discuss the strange bluish glow from soldiers' wounds and a historical tour that becomes a little too real for some tourists.We Need Your Terrifying TalesShare your terrifying tales with us so that you or your stories can possibly be featured on the show at [email protected] That Sounds Terrifying Podcast:That Sounds Terrifying is a podcast for people interested in the paranormal. Whether it’s hearing scary stories, sharing odd happenings, or even hearing different ideologies on such things. Join Jess and Nick as they discuss how the world is much stranger than it seems and explore the unknown which can be, well… terrifying. Copyright & Credits:This podcast includes the original works and interviews by Nick and Jess and is considered the property of That Sounds Terrific Productions, LLC. Reposts and use of this content in whole or part must be credited to the hosts and That Sounds Terrifying Podcast.That Sounds Terrifying A Podcast with Nick and Jess Art Cover created and designed by Molly Lonigan,  mollylonigan.wixsite.com/my-site.Soundbeds and effects were created originally by the hosts, and all audio bites are believed to be from free public domain sites, and/or otherwise covered by a Creative Commons CC License.Soundcloud Royalty Free Music:https://soundcloud.com/Individual Sound effects Used  or special effects were found in the public domain and/or downloaded at https://freesound.org/ and www.101soundboards.com Stories are accounts from personal experiences written by hosts, generated by ChatGpT and found on websites that were deemed free use or Creative Commons use.