Let’s get that straight from the start. The lie of professionalism is not about standards. It is about control. It is about making you smaller, quieter, less visible, less real. Professionalism, as it’s sold to us, is composure, neutrality, self-control. Being palatable to the greatest number of people.
In practice, it’s a weapon. It punishes emotion, vulnerability, and individuality. It rewards performative detachment and punishes realness, especially for those of us who feel things visibly. Crying, shaking, even smiling too much. If you show anything unguarded, you are marked as a problem.
I know this because I have lived it. I was kicked out of not one but two graduate counseling programs for showing emotion when the conversation was about me. Not for being out of control. Not for crossing boundaries. But for letting tears fall when I was unfairly judged. I stood my ground. I said, “This isn’t weakness. This isn’t a lack of control. This is me being human.” But to them, my tears were proof that I was unfit. They felt vindicated, as if my humanity was a flaw in their system.
This is where we have lost the plot. There is a version of being out of control that is dangerous. When you cannot separate yourself from your work. When you lose your grip on reality. When you violate boundaries. But simply tearing up, showing emotion, is not that. There is no reason for it to be seen as a loss of control.
And yet, how many of us have been told we are unprofessional for being sensitive, for being excited, for being sad? For smiling too widely. For crying when we are hurt. For showing up as ourselves. To them, it looks unhinged because it does not fit their image of a “professional.” Cold, heartless, calculated, beige.
Professionalism dehumanizes everyone. It takes our humanity, strips it away, and says, “This should not be part of you.” It forces sameness in a world full of different nervous systems, different emotional expressions, different ways of being present and real.
Maybe some people do not want a counselor who tears up when they feel judged. Fine. But I would have loved it. I know others who would have too. Someone whose eyes glint with excitement. Who shows happiness when they are happy for you. Who does not sit there with a half-smile and nothing else. This is not Freud’s era anymore. We do not need to be distant, clinical statues. And yet, I was gatekept from managing clients because I was too real.
Now, as a therapist and coach, I get to work with people who want someone genuine, emotional, human. If you want a milquetoast, unfeeling professional, go ahead. The world is full of them. But how did we get to a place where having a personality is unprofessional? How are we in 2025 and still having this conversation? The world is crumbling, and we are worried about whether a tear falls down in a meeting where I am being accused of something I did not do. What does that say about us?
Here’s the harsh truth. Standing your ground, telling the truth, being yourself — it will not make you the star. You will be pushed out. This is not a TV show where the quirky main character teaches everyone a lesson and is finally accepted. Hollywood writes those stories because we wish they were real. In reality, the system doubles down. You say, “This is who I am,” and they say, “No, you are too much.” They will never admit it, but they want you to be less yourself. They will lie to your face, say they are sensitive and supportive, but the moment you show real emotion, you are out.
Professionalism confuses safety with sterility. Different people need different counselors, different doctors, different bosses. There is no neutral human. The cost of dehumanization is connection, trust, the chance to be seen. The very things every people-centered field should be about.
So what should professionalism mean? Not less humanity. More capacity. Real professionalism is flexibility. It is holding space for different ways of being, different emotional styles, different human realities. It is knowing how to stay with someone who is real, not policing them into numbness.
If someone tells you to be less yourself to be more professional, they do not know what professionalism is. Who decided that being professional means being less yourself? Show me where it says that. It does not exist.
Every time I asked, “Are you saying I should change who I am?” they would say, “No, heavens no.” But that is exactly what they mean. They will never admit it. They have made their decision and they are standing behind it.
If the system were not built to fear or punish sensitivity, professionalism could look like whatever fits the person. Maybe I am not for everyone. Maybe some people are alarmed by a counselor who tears up. Fine. There are different types of professionalism because there are different types of people. When you work with people, you need to meet them as people.
That is what we all want. Someone who gets us. Someone who is right for us. And yet, we are still told to stay inside the lines. Inside the box.
So f**k professionalism. Not in the sense of reckless rebellion. But in the sense of refusing to shrink. I am not saying you will win if you fight. I lost. But something is deeply wrong when we punish humans for being human. For showing light, ordinary emotions.
I had to explain to them, “I have trauma. I am asking you to explain what I did wrong so I can do better.” And they said, “You are just too much.” And they kicked me out. I was an amazing student. Others were literally getting high during class. But I was the problem because I had tears in my eyes when accused of a misunderstanding, while dealing with my father’s ALS diagnosis. They treated my humanity as an excuse.
Why do we use so little of our humanity when professionalism comes into play? How is being human against being professional? What have we done to ourselves?
It is time to reclaim humanity as the real standard. Enough with the beige. Enough with the numb. Enough with the cold. Enough with shrinking to fit someone else’s idea of “right.” The world needs more realness, not less. The world needs you, not your mask.
Do not let them convince you otherwise.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit embrain.substack.com
