Does the Amityville Horror live on? Greg and Dana discuss a haunted plank of wood in the Newkirk Museum of the Paranormal: an actual piece of 112 Ocean Avenue. In this episode we stan Jodie the Demonic Pig, argue about spooky ghost children, and reveal surprising, brand-new information from an eye-witness source who claims that the world's most infamous haunted house held a deep, dark secret that other paranormal investigators have missed. Drink your Pepto Bismol, because everyone is getting diarrhea.

How would we have investigated The Amityville Horror differently? What was Jodie the Demonic Pig really up to? Did anything weird actually happen in that house or was it just one big hoax? You'll find the answers to all these questions and more in the all new Haunted Objects Podcast!

Join the Museum: https://patreon.com/paramuseum
Watch Haunted Objects on YouTube: https://youtube.com/planetweird
 

00:00 - Everyone Gets Diarrhea

05:20 - Object Intro - The Amityville Plank

09:20 - Would You Live in the Amityville House?

12:39 - BTW Kids, It’s a Murder House

14:56 - The Priest Has a Really Bad Time

16:15 - Jodie the Haunted (Possibly Demonic) Pig, AKA Best Babysitter EVER

23:21 - Amityville Inspires Ghostbusters

25:30: - THE Amityville Horror Book

27:00 - Amityville in Space & Amityville Karen

30:05 - Dueling Psychics

33:13 - Amityville Ghost Boy Photo

37:57 - Let's Get Skeptical

47:13 - Jodie the… Neighbor’s Persian Cat?

55:55 - New Information: A Phone Call Changes Everything

1:06:43 -  Was It The House or Was It George?

1:12:28 - The Lingering Horrors of the Amityville Plank

1:18:05 - How Would Greg & Dana Investigate The Amityville Horror?

1:28:10 - Summoning Jodie

Follow Greg Newkirk
Twitter: https://twitter.com/nuekerk
Instagram: https://instagram.com/nuekerk
Website: https://gregorynewkirk.com

Follow Dana Newkirk
Twitter: https://twitter.com/weird_dana
Instagram: https://instagram.com/weird_dana

Follow Connor J. Randall
Twitter: https://twitter.com/connorjrandall
Instagram: https://instagram.com/connorjrandall

Show Notes:

Purchase Jay Anson’s The Amityville Horror: https://amzn.to/3znWEi0

Watch the 1979 Amityville Horror film: https://amzn.to/3Fqjucm

Channel 4's The Real Amityville Horror doc:  https://youtu.be/fZAm8yOS0LM

Watch the Amityville Horror remake featuring Ryan Reynolds: https://amzn.to/3U5jTVY

Watch My Amityville Horror  doc featuring Daniel Lutz: https://amzn.to/3DJgDtU

The  infamous “ghost boy” photo:  https://tinyurl.com/2p832ne5

The alleged hoax concocted by William Weber and the Lutz’s: https://tinyurl.com/45xzb4hd

1979 People Magazine Article claiming a hoax: https://tinyurl.com/2xzsfxsh

3D scanning the Amityville Plank (Patreon exclusive): https://tinyurl.com/yu5he843

The "ghost girl" Amityville Plank photo: https://tinyurl.com/27dpjb8k

Christopher (Lutz) Quaratino shares his perspective with The Seattle Times: https://tinyurl.com/yys2jzr4
 

Credits: 

Copyright 2022 Planet Weird

Hosted by Greg and Dana Newkirk

Produced by Connor J Randall

Photography by Karl Pfeiffer

Art by Dustin Williams

Theme Music by Adam Hayman

"The Disembodied Voice" by Chuck Fresh

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices