
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


What convinced me that Jesus is truly present in the Eucharist? One of the final pieces came from a note about the Bread of the Presence in a study Bible. It helped me see the Eucharist within the story God was already telling Israel.
In Episode 7 of The Apologetic Funnel, I follow that story through Passover, manna, the Bread of the Presence, John 6, and the Last Supper. Drawing on Brant Pitre’s Jesus and the Jewish Roots of the Eucharist and Scott Hahn’s The Fourth Cup, I explore how the supper and Calvary belong together, why the early Christians confessed the Real Presence, and how these connections brought me to a Catholic altar.
I also include an argument from Joe Heschmeyer of Shameless Popery, discuss reported Eucharistic events in Buenos Aires and Legnica, and turn to the Prayer of Humble Access and Divine Worship to hear this faith expressed in prayer.
Once I believed He was there, I wanted to belong to the Church in whose life I could receive Him.
Read John 6 alongside the Last Supper and 1 Corinthians 10–11. Visit a Catholic Mass, experience Divine Worship where available, and listen to what the Church actually prays.
Next in The Apologetic Funnel: the history and authority of the Church that handed on this gift.
Listen on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/033V4EW6He8Lec9swewuly
Books discussed:
Brant Pitre — Jesus and the Jewish Roots of the Eucharist
https://ignatius.com/jesus-and-the-jewish-roots-of-the-eucharist-jjrep/
Scott Hahn — The Fourth Cup
https://stpaulcenter.com/store/the-fourth-cup-unveiling-the-mystery-of-the-last-supper-and-the-cross
The Complete Jewish Study Bible
St. Gregory’s Prayer Book
Scripture and other references:
Exodus 12; Exodus 16; Leviticus 24:5–9; John 6; the Last Supper accounts; John 19; 1 Corinthians 10–11; Catechism of the Catholic Church 2837; St. Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Smyrnaeans 7; St. Justin Martyr, First Apology 66–67; Divine Worship and the Prayer of Humble Access.
#Eucharist #Catholic #AnglicanPapalist
Cancer has made the question of death a lot less theoretical for me. After battling one cancer and now facing another, the question is not just whether Christianity is comforting.
The question is whether it is true.
So what actually happened after the Crucifixion?
In Episode 6 of The Apologetics Funnel, I walk through the historical case for the Resurrection by looking at the empty tomb, the earliest Christian testimony, the transformation of the disciples, Saint Paul’s conversion, and the competing explanations for what happened.
And then there’s the Shroud of Turin.
This part gets personal.
I have actually told my own brother that if he can prove the Shroud is fake, I’ll stop being a Christian. Instead, digging into the Shroud has only made him more curious about the Faith.
Because the deeper you go into the Shroud—the image, the wounds, the blood, the disputed carbon dating, and the fact that the blood was there before the body image formed—the stranger it gets.
And that leads directly into the next episode, because the blood on the Shroud starts overlapping with another subject: Eucharistic miracles.
The question throughout this series stays the same:
If Christianity is true, how far does the evidence actually take us?
The Apologetics Funnel — Episode 6
The Weight of the Empty Tomb
Next Episode: The Jewish Roots of the Eucharist
Listen to The Anglican Papalist on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/033V4EW6He8Lec9swewuly
Could Jesus have survived the cross? Before we ask whether he rose from the dead, there’s a question we need to settle: did he actually die?In Series 2, Episode 5 of the Apologetic Funnel Series, the Anglican Papalist follows the evidence through Roman history, archaeology, the Gospel accounts, and medical discussions of crucifixion. Lee Strobel’s The Case for Christ helps open the investigation, but the question takes us beyond a single book.What does a nail through an ancient heel tell us? Why does Pilate ask the centurion about Jesus’s death? And if Jesus only fainted, what was supposed to keep him alive in the tomb?There’s no trauma team waiting there. Having spent enough time around hospital care himself, the Anglican Papalist considers what that absence means—and why the words “He suffered and was buried” deserve our attention.The Anglican Papalist is a Catholic audio podcast exploring Anglican patrimony, faith, prayer, and life in full communion with the Catholic Church. This is Part 5 of the nine-part Apologetic Funnel Series. You can begin here even if you haven’t heard the earlier episodes.Listen and followSpotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/033V4EW6He8Lec9swewulySubscribe or follow to continue the series.Sources discussedLee Strobel, The Case for Christ, including the interview with Alexander Metherell.Josh and Sean McDowell, Evidence That Demands a Verdict, mentioned in connection with Episode 3.Tacitus, Annals 15.44.The remains of Yehohanan and the reassessment by Joseph Zias and Eliezer Sekeles.W. D. Edwards, W. J. Gabel, and F. E. Hosmer, “On the Physical Death of Jesus Christ,” JAMA (1986): https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3512867/Matthew W. Maslen and Piers D. Mitchell, “Medical Theories on the Cause of Death in Crucifixion,” Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine (2006): https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1420788/Mark 15:21–47; John 19:1–42.David Friedrich Strauss’s objection to a barely surviving Jesus inspiring belief in victory over death.Next in the seriesIf Jesus was dead and buried, what happened at the tomb? Next, we turn to the Resurrection and the claim that his followers saw him alive.Which part of the survival explanation do you think is hardest to account for? Leave your question or objection in the comments.#Crucifixion #CatholicApologetics #TheAnglicanPapalist
Was Jesus merely a great moral teacher—or do his own words and actions force a much sharper choice?
In Episode 4 of the nine-part Apologetic Funnel Series, I revisit C.S. Lewis’s challenge from Mere Christianity, Book II, Chapter 3, “The Shocking Alternative.” But the famous liar, lunatic, or Lord argument is not a substitute for history. Before it carries any force, we must ask whether Jesus made the claims attributed to him, how the Jewish Scriptures frame those claims, and why the first Christians worshiped him within a movement rooted in Jewish monotheism.
From Jesus forgiving sins in Mark 2 and Thomas confessing “My Lord and my God” in John 20, to Philippians 2 and the Nicene Creed’s “very God from very God,” this episode follows the evidence behind the Catholic confession that Jesus Christ is true God and true man.
C.S. Lewis makes the dilemma memorable. Brant Pitre, St. Thomas Aquinas, Larry Hurtado, Pope Benedict XVI, the Fathers, and the councils help us investigate it more carefully.
The question is not whether Jesus offered useful moral advice. It is whether the Gospel Jesus can honestly be reduced to a safe, inspirational teacher—or whether his identity demands worship, obedience, and allegiance.
This episode also addresses the strongest alternative: that Jesus’s followers later attributed divine claims to a merely human teacher. The trilemma cannot answer that objection by itself, which is why the historical record and early Christian worship matter.
This is The Anglican Papalist, a Catholic audio podcast with Michael Bonanno III, rooted in the Anglican patrimony of the Ordinariate.
LISTEN AND FOLLOW
Subscribe on YouTube and follow the Apologetic Funnel Series to continue the argument.
NEXT IN THE SERIES
What happened to Jesus on the cross medically—and why does the reality of his death matter? Episode 5 examines the forensic weight of the Crucifixion.
JOIN THE CONVERSATION
Does the “great moral teacher” option survive the evidence? Where do you think the strongest alternative lies: mistaken claims, later attribution, or Lord?
#JesusChrist #CatholicApologetics #TheAnglicanPapalist
Has the Bible been corrupted by centuries of copying and translation? Can we trust the Gospels—or are we hearing the end of a two-thousand-year telephone game?
The Apologetics Funnel goes deeper as the Anglican Papalist investigates biblical reliability, New Testament manuscripts, Gospel authorship, and the transmission of eyewitness testimony. What can the evidence establish—and where do the harder questions begin?
Drawing on Josh and Sean McDowell’s Evidence That Demands a Verdict and Brant Pitre’s The Case for Jesus, this episode brings textual criticism, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and ancient writers such as Tacitus and Josephus into the conversation. Even a Spider-Man misprint makes an appearance.
Before asking what the record says about Jesus, we need to ask whether we can trust the record itself.
Series 2, Episode 3: The Reliability of the Record
The Anglican Papalist — a Catholic audio podcast rooted in the Anglican patrimony of the Ordinariate.
Listen to The Anglican Papalist on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/033V4EW6He8Lec9swewuly
What is your strongest objection to the reliability of the Bible? Leave it in the comments, and subscribe to follow the investigation.
Science can explain how the universe develops—but why does anything exist at all?
In Episode 2 of the nine-part Apologetic Funnel Series, I explore the Big Bang, Thomas Aquinas, and the question “Who created God?” We examine why the Christian doctrine of creation reaches beyond physical beginnings—and why faith should welcome scientific discovery.
Topics include Georges Lemaître, the argument from contingency, fine-tuning, the multiverse, and the limits of “God of the gaps” apologetics. I also reflect on my experience of chemotherapy and the relationship between medicine and divine providence.
🎧 Listen on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/033V4EW6He8Lec9swewuly
The Apologetic Funnel • Episode 2 of 9
The Creator and the Cosmos
The Anglican Papalist is a Catholic audio podcast with Michael Bonanno III, rooted in the Anglican patrimony of the Ordinariate.
Next episode: Can the Christian record be trusted? We examine manuscripts, testimony, and the Church that carried them.
Does explaining how the universe works also explain why it exists? Share your thoughts in the comments, and subscribe to continue the series.
Truth is easy to praise until it tells us something we do not want to hear.
In the opening installment of The Apologetics Funnel, the Anglican Papalist asks the question beneath every argument for Christianity: Is truth something we discover, or something we create?
Beginning with Amos’s image of the plumb line and the unavoidable clarity of a hospital room, this episode confronts the language of “my truth” and “your truth.” What happens when reality refuses to bend—and what might it ask of us?
Series 2, Episode 1 of The Anglican Papalist. The Apologetics Funnel begins here.
What do you love most about being Catholic?
In this special interlude, Michael sits down with Eyram Klu—writer, speaker, lay Franciscan, and creator of The Afrociscan—to geek out about the truth, beauty, and hope of the Catholic faith.
Recorded at the Catholic Creator Conference, their conversation explores the Real Presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist, conversion, the universality and endurance of the Church, the Sacraments, the papacy, and the way every Mass unites the faithful across time and space. They also discuss the urgent need for Catholics to proclaim and live the Gospel, passing the faith to generations not yet born.
Along the way, Michael reflects on facing cancer without surrendering to cynicism and on the peace he has found since returning to the Catholic Church. Because ultimately, the reason to build one’s life around Catholicism is wonderfully simple: it is true—and that truth changes everything.
Please note: This conversation was recorded in May, and the original audio suffered some distortion. It has been restored as much as possible, though a few moments may remain difficult to hear. The conversation was simply too joyful and important not to share.
This is the Finale of Series 1 of the Anglican Papalist. We close out with Dom Gregory Dix and the formation of the Personal Ordinariates
This is the Third part of a 4 part history of the Anglican Patrimony in the Catholic Church
From the publisher's feed