How to build passive Income and long-term wealth in real estate through REITs, crowdfunding and fractional ownership?
Join host Kevin Vandenboss in The Lazy Landlord podcast as he discusses p
... moreBy Benzinga
How to build passive Income and long-term wealth in real estate through REITs, crowdfunding and fractional ownership?
Join host Kevin Vandenboss in The Lazy Landlord podcast as he discusses p
... moreThe podcast currently has 7 episodes available.
In this episode of The Real Estate Podcast, Kevin Vandenboss speaks with Nitin Chexal, CEO of Palladius Capital Management
Kevin Vandenboss
Real Estate Expert at Benzinga
Twitter: https://twitter.com/KevinVandenboss
Sign Up to Benzinga Pro today to receive most exclusive interviews, news and stock picks fast!
https://pro.benzinga.com/
Disclaimer: All of the information, material, and/or content contained in this program is for informational purposes only. Investing in stocks, options, and futures is risky and not suitable for all investors. Please consult your own independent financial adviser before making any investment decisions.
In this episode of The Real Estate Podcast, Kevin Vandenboss speaks with Mike Logozzo, CFOO of reAlpha
Kevin Vandenboss
Real Estate Expert at Benzinga
Twitter: https://twitter.com/KevinVandenboss
Sign Up to Benzinga Pro today to receive most exclusive interviews, news and stock picks fast!
https://pro.benzinga.com/
Disclaimer: All of the information, material, and/or content contained in this program is for informational purposes only. Investing in stocks, options, and futures is risky and not suitable for all investors. Please consult your own independent financial adviser before making any investment decisions.
In this episode of The Real Estate Podcast, Kevin Vandenboss speaks with Andrew Crebar, CEO of HoneyBricks
Kevin Vandenboss
Real Estate Expert at Benzinga
Twitter: https://twitter.com/KevinVandenboss
Sign Up to Benzinga Pro today to receive most exclusive interviews, news and stock picks fast!
https://pro.benzinga.com/
Disclaimer: All of the information, material, and/or content contained in this program is for informational purposes only. Investing in stocks, options, and futures is risky and not suitable for all investors. Please consult your own independent financial adviser before making any investment decisions.
Transcription:
Welcome back to Benzinga’s Real Estate podcast. Today we have Andrew Crebar who is the CEO of HoneyBricks
HoneyBricks is a real estate investment platform but it's quite unique compared to some of the others we've talked about before.
Kevin Vandenboss: Andy I would love to hear about how you got into the real estate space and then if you can just go into what HoneyBricks and try to give our listeners just a general overview of what this platform does and what's so unique about it.
Andrew Crebar: Sure. And thanks so much for having me on today Kevin huge fan of your work and what your team does at Benzinga.
So I'm Andy I'm from Australia and I moved to the US in 2015. My real estate journey really started probably in my childhood. My dad was an architect who got me involved in real estate at a very young age. Used to take me around to building sites and taught me how real estate's both wonderful and important wonderful and it's spaces where people live work and play and important in that we're surrounded by it every day.
Every person interacts with it. And it's the main driver of our quality of life. He was very influential and helped me buy my first apartment. And I've been investing consistently in real estate since then and really seeing how powerful it is as a platform for wealth creation. Things really came together for me in recent years as new blockchain technology started to make its way into the mainstream bringing new efficiency access transparency and other benefits to a lot of different asset classes and real estate's really no different.
And my co-founder and I were talking about how can we give more people access to this great asset class of real estate with new technology that's being developed. So we got started earlier this year and have built a great team focused on really unlocking the potential of real estate.
So as far as your second question Kevin what is HoneyBricks? We help people invest in real estate with blockchain. And we do that through a two-sided marketplace for people that want to invest in real estate. And secondly for real estate companies or operators that want to fund their projects or tokenize their existin assets.
So for investors they get institutional quality real estate access through new modern technology. And for real estate operators they get access to new and diverse capital pool and all the benefits of tokenization.
Kevin Vandenboss:Why bring that to real estate? To be honest is it just a like a gimmick to attract new audience?Or is there a real benefit to this?
Andrew Crebar: We're just starting with tokenization. So tokenization it's the process of creating digital securities. So when something is tokenized the tokens represent the fractional ownership of that underlying asset. So the tokens really become tangible and more liquid representations of ownership.
Now tokenization is done through blockchain technology which is another word that can get thrown around in recent years. The blockchain's basically a shared ledger for recording transactions.. The big benefit of blockchain which is the same technology that powers cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum is really two things. One is trustless transactions and secondly is instantaneous settlement. And that's outside of just real estate that's really the benefit of what blockchain technology brings. When we think about blockchain's technologies application to real estate as an asset class I like to think about it in what's similar to traditional crowd funding.
And then secondly what's different or better enabled by tokenization. So when we think about what's similar to traditional crowd funding it improves capital formation allows smaller investors to pull capital and invest in larger projects. And also enables real estate operators and sponsors to raise capital from a larger investor base which is very similar to traditional crowd funding.
When we think about the advantages of tokenization. We like to think about it in three ways. The first one is unlocking value through improved liquidity. So when we think about the liquidity discount that affects many assets tokenization really enables a better secondary market transactions and liquidity.
So investors get all the same benefits of a traditional syndicated investment while avoiding the lengthy lockup periods of 5 ,10 years. The second big benefit is around increasing the pooled investors that can actually invest in these securities.
So there's this big underserved market which has high demand for the unique characteristics. Real estate can bring stability cash flow diversification and it's really an enthusiastic investor base that. Wants low cost access to this great asset class of real estate which they don't have today.
I'd say the last benefit of tokenization is really around just improving the flexibility of ownership. So bringing assets on the chain and those two benefits of the blockchain spoken about previously they can really convert private placements into a financial product. So it means these tokens can.
Kevin Vandenboss: So you reference that these are digital securities. Could you explain that a little bit?
Andrew Crebar: So these tokens are securities of understanding. The regulation is key and similar to other securities security tokens come under the SEC's attention. So some key things to aware of is they're very similar to private placements. Although they're not exactly regulated like stocks or bonds they're still treated the same way as a traditional investment in a private placement which means in the US there's accredited investor limitations they need to be launched under either S EC or SEC exemptions.
A huge attraction of applying blockchain to real estate is that a lot of this compliance and regulation can actually be embedded in the underlying smart contract that governs this tokenization.
The value of the HoneyBricks tokens is based on the underlying asset. Now at HoneyBricks today we focus on commercial real estate.We are focused on multifamily assets at the moment. So if we take a $10 million multifamily asset with let's assume $5 million equity and 5000 tokens minted each token would be worth an implied value of $1000.
Now as that equity of the project grows. So too does the token value. The key thing to know is that's the implied value of the token and similar to any secondary market. Normally there's a liquidity discount or sometimes premium of those tokens. So there's the implied value of the token. There's also the actual value of the token that may appear in a secondary market in a perfect world those two would be identically aligned but sometimes they're not.
Kevin Vandenboss:One of the big benefits at least to me in this type of investment is the income from it the cash flow. How is how is that handled in this case?
Andrew Crebar: So it's handled in the exact same way that it's handled in traditional syndicated investments in that.based on the distribution schedule of the underlying investment. That's when distributions would go out to whoever's involved in that asset. Now what's different to that is the new let's call it financial highway of cryptocurrencies which is a very broad term. And there is a lot of speculation and volatility in in cryptocurrencies like any emerging technologies and potential misuse.
But the underlying principles of cryptocurrency and stable coins is very powerful. What that means is as far as these distributions that are coming from tokenized assets generally they're using the new financial highway of cryptocurrencies whether that's stable coins or whether that's using other cryptocurrencies, so as far as those distributions the key thing that would be different is instead of being a checkout to the recipients or a wire transfer. Generally they're getting stent the distribution straight to that same cryptocurrency wallet or sorry same digital wallet. That's holding those tokens is receiving the income directly as well.
So you'd have your digital wallet which would hold your tokens. The distribution for the investment comes through and you'd receive that.
Kevin Vandenboss:So are the deals are these like direct deals where there's you be a specific property or is it HoneyBricks building a portfolio?
Andrew Crebar: That's a good question. And many crowdfunding market participants do offer both in a deal by deal basis or funds. Today we're just focused on deal by deal basis. And that can either be new acquisitions that can be recapitalization or that could be existing asset owners just wanting to tokenize their investments.
As you said we are focused on multi-family assets today so the way we go about finding these investments is we have our in-house real estate team. We then identified and focus on target growth markets. We then identify and partner with local sponsors in those markets. Real
Estate's very much a local game, we'll then review and diligence specific assets with them. And then if the asset meets our investment criteria will then tokenize it and bring it to the HoneyBricks platform.
Kevin Vandenboss: So for anybody that wants to learn more about this where should they go?
Andrew Crebar: People can learn about us at honeybricks.com. We've been working hard the last six months building out an incredible team getting aligned in our strategy and tokenizing our first handful of assets.
We're gonna be ramping up our marketing and publicity in Q3 2022. So lots of exciting news coming up and you can expect to see more of us and hear more of us in the community.
In this episode of The Real Estate Podcast, Kevin Vandenboss speaks with Marc Minor, CEO of Higharc
Guest:
Marc Minor CEO of Higharc
See Higharc DEMO here to see how you can use itHost:
Kevin Vandenboss
Real Estate Expert at Benzinga
Twitter: https://twitter.com/KevinVandenboss
Sign Up to Benzinga Pro today to receive most exclusive interviews, news and stock picks fast!
https://pro.benzinga.com/
Disclaimer: All of the information, material, and/or content contained in this program is for informational purposes only. Investing in stocks, options, and futures is risky and not suitable for all investors. Please consult your own independent financial adviser before making any investment decisions.
Transcription:
In this episode of The Real Estate Podcast, Kevin Vandenboss speaks with Marc Minor, CEO of Higharc
Kevin Vandenboss: Tell us a little bit about your company and what exactly you do.
Marc Minor: Thank you. So Higharc is a web platform for home builders. We automate a whole lot of different parts of the process of building and bringing home to market so that builders can offer better homes to home buyers.
Affordability is a really hard problem with new home construction because of the sheer amount of waste. That's hard to wrap your hands around. In the process. So there's something like 5% of every house. Um, in terms of its sales price, that's lost to avoidable waste. And that comes in the form of materials that you didn't need to order, or that were wasted on site as well as process delays.
So our software automates lots and lots for home builders across the whole cycle of building a house. And in doing that, we help them tighten up the operation and deliver better.
Kevin Vandenboss: what got you into this space? what's your background?
Marc Minor: Actually I came at it like a lot of folks who start technology companies out of personal experience and frustration.
So I was actually building a house and like most folks who experienced these, I was pretty frustrated with the lack of clarity.
lt’s very difficult to know what you're going to get before you get it, how much it's gonna cost. So I realized that a lot of the work I was doing in 3D printing in terms of the digitization of manufacturing actually could apply really nicely to home building.
Kevin Vandenboss: How have the adaptions been like?
Marc Minor: You probably know our industry is one of the least sort of advanced in terms of its adoption of technology.
Spends less than 1% on R&D compared to 3% to 5% in other industries that are similar. And it's not for lack of trying though. So most of the technology that's out there is 30 to 50 years old. We're one of the first platforms to come along that kind of delivers on the promise.
So we've seen actually a pretty significant interest across the board, not just from kind of the obvious, real large builders but also from very small mom and pop builders who are struggling to manage growth across the United States.
So it's been really encouraging for all of us to see the interest in the industry in digitization, obviously housing prices skyrocketed and all of a sudden things are slowing way down.
Kevin Vandenboss:What is the market going to look like in the next 3, 5, 10 years?
Marc Minor:The average time it takes to build a new house has gone up significantly over the last 2 years.
A lot of builders when they're doing well, they're looking at 90 to 120 days for a new home. My home, which is a custom home, took nearly 2 years. So, and there's a lot of reasons for that, but we're really focused on automation using technology, especially the web to replace paper and kind of manual tasks that gum up the gears of the entire process.
Home building's kind of death by a thousand cuts, buyers experience that too. There's not a silver bullet solution. It has to be a kind of holistic effort to clean up how you do business. And so that's where we step in on the process. And the technology side is by helping home builders to kind of cut out a lot of that kind of stuff.
Obviously, there are other important tools that the industry needs to take advantage of, those include mechanization of labor where it makes sense, as you probably know, we've got a huge labor problem and they also include new ways of thinking about financing and the build- to- rent phenomenon.
We've had everyone from the sort of usual suspects around the United States approach us. And then some surprise potential customers come out of places like France, the UK, Australia, Japan. So while we're not going global right now, there's a global demand for what we're doing.
We've really focused on some of the highest growth markets in the US. So we really love Texas and Florida. And obviously the Southeast more broadly is a real strong growth market.Pacific Northwest is pretty awesome market in terms of the homes that are built. California's one that has a lot of development. It's the one that we've kind of avoided at the moment, just because of some of the regulatory hurdles. Otherwise we're open for business pretty much anywhere that builders.
A lot of our customers are small businesses. You can be doing 50 to a 100 homes a year right now, and you're going to get a lot of value out of the kind of automation that we provide. You can get tools that allow you to not only compete with the nationals, but often offer a better experience without having to bring on a huge amount of people onto your team.
And that's kind of the power of using automation to operate your business.
Kevin Vandenboss: IIs there any way for me to utilize this or do I have to find a builder that's already doing it, or can I say I'm building a house, I'm gonna hire my contractors and this is what you're going to use to kinda manage the process?
Marc Minor: We started the business focused on providing tools. Someone in your position and today, if you wanted to use Higharc as a home buyer, you would encounter it on a builder's website or in a sales center on a big touch screen.
If you have ever configured a car on the web that's the kind of experience you would get from us today if you're working with a builder. So, we automatically produce these car light configurators for homes, and what's so incredible about them is they are actually the real home that's gonna be built with all of its various possibilities. It's not just like a representation, which is usually wrong. It's the real thing. And that's because the same data that we use to generate that experience for you, we actually generate the B. Automatically as well. So the same thing that gets built is the thing that you're shopping for.
And that's a, typically a very big disconnect. What buyers see is very different than what they end up getting, less than 2% of all homes are led by architects. It's an unfortunate statistic, and there are many reasons for it. Obviously, economics is a big one. One of the main reasons we started the business was to extend the reach of that kind of consideration design thoughtfulness to regular people. And over time, it's gonna empower folks like your audience who are out developing their own, their own assets to be able to operate without having to become a full-scale builder. For example, there are a lot of other opportunities when you can use the software. To automatically produce things like blueprints and sales materials and online experiences.
The opportunity for digitization of home building is the same opportunity that every other major industry has already taken advantage of. If you look at manufacturing and the way that product development companies have been able to improve their products, and their offerings, because of the way they simplify how they manage data.
That same opportunity is available for home building, whether it's you're building a single one off home, or whether you're building like 10,000 homes a year, the cost of building a home versus purchasing one.
Kevin Vandenboss:What is that comparison right now?
Marc Minor: So when you think about cyclicality in our market certainly there is some cyclicality for the most part, though we are in this place where supply is pretty under.
We need something like 25 million new homes per year, just to keep up with overall growth in the world. Costs in construction generally are a function of demand, more so than it is a function of the input. and it usually commands about a 20% premium, something like that on what you would for an existing home.
I think the opportunity for builders is to comp is to compete more with existing homes by being able to reduce their own costs so they can keep their margins the same, but have a lower entry point for the home. It's one of the reasons why entry-level homes have been such a big category over the last 5 to 10 years.
Kevin Vandenboss: Where can our audience find some more information?
Marc Minor: Sure. Go to Higharc -and reach out to us in the, get in touch section.
In this episode of The Real Estate Podcast, Kevin Vandenboss speaks with Ryan Frazier, CEO of Arrived
Kevin and Ryan talk about:
Guest:
Ryan Frazier CEO of Arrived
Host:
Kevin Vandenboss
Real Estate Expert at Benzinga
Twitter: https://twitter.com/KevinVandenboss
Sign Up to Benzinga Pro today to receive most exclusive interviews, news and stock picks fast!
https://pro.benzinga.com/
Disclaimer: All of the information, material, and/or content contained in this program is for informational purposes only. Investing in stocks, options, and futures is risky and not suitable for all investors. Please consult your own independent financial adviser before making any investment decisions.
Transcription:
Welcome to the Lazy Landlord podcast here on Benzinga today, we have Ryan Frazier, who's the CEO of the real estate investment platform Arrived.
Listen to this episode of The Lazy Landlord on Benzinga.
Kevin Vandenboss: So what is Arrived essentially?
Ryan Frazier: It's a platform that makes it easy for anyone to invest in rental properties. And the way that it works is that individuals can buy shares of individual homes starting from $100 to $10,000 or more, however much you want to invest in that property. And then Arrived, takes care of all the work of managing the property. So all of the, dealing with the property management or the rental operations for the asset. And the impact is that, investors can still pick and choose how they wanna build their portfolio of individual rental properties. They can invest, nearly any amount of capital that they'd like to and diversify across properties.
And then it becomes passive a investment from there with Arrived, taking care of the management.
Kevin Vandenboss: What has been the demand been for investors that invest in these specific rental properties?
Ryan Frazier: I think that's been something that's been a surprise to us is just how remarkable the interest has been where we've had nearly 100k people sign up to invest in properties and buy shares of individual homes.
And I think we thought it might take longer for people to understand the concept of buying a share of a rental property. But I think because investing in fractional shares of stocks and other assets has become a bit more commonplace and more popular, I think people just have a place in their minds where they could understand.
They say “Ok, I can own a share of this property. I will get the proportional returns, cash flow from rental income or any property value growth based on the number of shares I own. And that gives me more control of how much I'm investing and being able to diversify.”
For myself and Arrived co-founders really our personal experience with wanting to invest in property has been the main driver.Through my mid-twenties to thirties, I really was just moving around.We were just never in the same place, long enough, where it made sense to, invest for 5, 10+ years, which is really what's required in real estate to overcome the kind of hurdle of the transaction costs to get any type of material returns. And so I had been questioning that for a while.
Why does it have to be so binary that, you save up for multiple years for these down payments that are often six figures nowadays, and then you're committed to that city or that property forever or really for the long run.
And so that is the idea for Arrived. How do we look at these barriers that prevent people from getting started today in owning real estate? The capital, the time commitments, and the expertise required, and how do we lower the barrier to entry? So that, if you have time and expertise, but maybe not the amount of capital to diversify in as many properties as you want, Arrived can facilitate that for you.
You don't have time to invest in new markets and build up a presence there and you wanna be able to diversify. Arrived can step in that scenario as well. So it's really about taking those three kinds of major rocks that keep people out of investing capital time and expertise and making it just very convenient to get started.
Kevin Vandenboss: How are you able to offer these investments to non-accredited investors?
Ryan Frazier: That was a very important part of Arrived.The mission for Arrived is to make sure that these investments are accessible to anyone that wants to invest in rental properties. Only 7% of people in this country own property investments outside of their primary residence.
That's a huge gap in terms of the number of people who have been able to invest.
Part of that was, working through that on a product experience basis. So the ability to buy shares involved Arrived taking on more of the labor side of managing the investments so that more people would be comfortable investing.
But the other part was making sure that non-accredited investors can invest, meaning people that don't have a net worth of more than a $1M or an annual income of higher than $200k or $300k. And to do that meant working with the SEC for nearly a year and adopting this model Under the regulation A+ which basically created this process of IPO’ing an individual house. The Arrived platform today is a platform for operating these individual house IPOs. And we went through a process under regulation A+ where the SEC reviewed and qualified our offerings so that we can make them available.
Anytime you're making investments available to non-accredited investors, there's a much higher bar for disclosure. And so we have a lot of disclosures that are available on our website for every property. Things like the risk factors, the financials, we, as a result also provide annual audited financial statements for our properties that get reviewed by the SEC as well.
So we really spent the time to go through that process, to make sure that this was broadly accessible.Having these offerings structured this way provides some options for liquidity where people can get access to liquidity on their investments over time if they'd like to as well.
Really those two things, supporting non-accredited investors and supporting some of the future liquidity options that we're in the process of building now, were really why went down that regulation A+ path when we were designing the product and working with the SEC.
Kevin Vandenboss: Why would somebody want to get into this market now? Do you have concerns that the housing market could crash?
Ryan Frazier: I think it's certainly been an interesting time in the market over the last 18 months or so as we went through the COVID pandemic and we've seen that there's been, a lot of impacts to the housing market from that we've seen that people have moved out of these city hubs where they're, valuing more space they're valuing having are moving a little bit outside of the, a core and they're either willing to, spend to, to buy a home or they're looking for quality.
Homes to rent that offer more space that are different from, these apartment buildings that they were living in before at the same time, the fed was changing interest rates to, to all time lows, to, zero on the fed funds rate. But we saw that mortgage rates were dipping below 3% and those kind of two things among other factors have really caused the housing market to accelerate, in price appreciation.
We've seen, price appreciation that probably is not sustainable long term where you're gonna see, 15%- 20%+ price appreciation per year. That's just not what we've looked at in the housing market or in single family historically it's averaged, more like 4% price appreciation per year, historically.
And we think in the market today, as some of these kinds of trends and changes have started to settle out that we'll probably see ourselves go back to more of that historical average. We've seen the FED now increasing interest rates to try to offset what we're seeing in terms of inflation. And I think that, makes the borrowing cost look a lot higher than it was, 12 months ago. But I think the reality is, that we're still well below what we were a decade ago. And so I think that the market's still pricing in, what does that mean for housing affordability and how will the market respond.
From our perspective, we're still very, excited about investing in the single-family space. I think there's a lot of tailwinds for the asset where you have, institutional investors that have now moved into the space, you have some things that are making it really hard to add more supply, the high cost of labor, the high cost of materials.
You have folks that over the last couple of years have locked in these historically low-interest rates. So you now have this kind of interest rate lock-in that will keep more supply from entering the market. People are less willing to give up their home and the mortgage rates that are attached to that.
So we think that there's, still great resilience in the housing market. We don't expect, in our opinion that we'll see a major housing crash, but we do anticipate that the rapid price appreciation will move back to a normal kind of baseline. In general, when we think about Arrived products, investing in shares of homes versus buying a whole home on your own, we really light that it provides access to dollar cost averaging, which is the ability to add investment dollars gradually on a monthly, quarterly, or yearly basis which has never really been possible before in direct ownership of real estate when you're buying whole homes. And, each home is such a massive financial decision. You can really spread that out.
And I think that takes a little bit of the importance off of trying to time the market, because I think that's always very hard and allows you to dollar cost aver in over time and diversify in different cities and times, and different types of properties, which altogether, help lower some of your risks.
Kevin Vandenboss: Along with the prices of home prices, we've obviously seen rent increase at a higher rate in some areas. Where do you see that going?
Ryan Frazier: I think that you do find that rent tends to follow inflation assuming that, the inflation is related to more economic activity. I think some of the inflation that we're seeing is more related to some of the supply chain issues, which I think is part of what's making the current economic environment challenging. But in general, we do think that rents probably follow that.
The other thing to keep in mind is that if interest rates continue to go up or even remain at the point that they're at, that changes the kind of relative affordability of a monthly mortgage payment or of ownership of a property that you live in versus rent. And often times those things kind of work in some sort of equilibrium point. So I was seeing an article last week that as interest rates had gone up, that increases the cost of owning, a primary residence. And as it does that, that causes more people decide to rent because they're making that trade-off of affordability. “Do I want to pay an extra $700 per month for this home that I want to live in or would I rather rent for another year or two and save some money?”
And so I think those types of things also dictate where the rental markets move. But it does seem like the rental markets have gone up a little bit.
Kevin Vandenboss: Are there any particular markets that you're seeing is, especially attractive right now?
I think when we look at markets, we're looking at, where is there growth at a simple level where we're looking at the population data\ are we seeing an increase in people moving to that city? Are these desirable places to live, where they have great and sufficient infrastructure to support that? And we're looking at, some of the top 100 cities today, we're in 19. And we're continuing to add more cities quickly. I think we'll probably be at 40 by the end of the year. And then just calling out some of the ones that, we'd like maybe some of the ones that people wouldn’t think about naturally, because I think there are some cities that we're in let's say Nashville that has just seen, such population growth and a lot of cultural interest in that market.
But then there's other markets that are more slightly the kind of up and coming cities that are seeing rapid population growth, but maybe they're near more the top 100 city versus the top 25. We look at Northwest Arkansas Fayetteville, Bentonville, where there's just such strong economic growth being driven by Walmart being headquartered there.
And then all of the corporate partners for Walmart that have offices there. And they're doing a ton of investment in the region. And as a result, we've seen a strong demand for properties for rentals. And so I think that's an interesting market. A few others that we look at are Indianapolis has had a strong, fundamental economy and I think there's some migratory patterns from Chicago that are driving a little bit of that, but it's been a market that we've followed closely and started to invest. And then Chattanooga in Tennessee where it's become a nice remote work, a whole hub in that region has the fastest internet in the country as a fun fact so great for those remote workers that are moving to that area. But I think you're seeing a few of these. Slightly smaller, but up and coming cities that have great potential for growth that we've been excited to start adding a few assets in and make available for investors.
Kevin Vandenboss: What goes into choosing which homes you're going to be investing in?
Ryan Frazier: Folks that kind of come to the website will notice they're often newer homes and high quality kind of properties and rentals. In our view, those are going to provide stronger cash flow opportunities during the whole period, just because they have less of a need for maintenance. Most of our properties are newer than 2010. No deferred maintenance or anything like that. And if we're buying a older home, we're typically doing any kind of major fixture improvement or renovation before we, we make them available on the platform.
And again, that's really to try to provide these strong and sustainable cash flows. A huge draw of rental properties is having that consistent access to cash flow in our case it's dividends. So we pay out these dividends on a quarterly basis. For our properties, we're paying out, on average, probably between 3% to 7% on an annualized basis. And that just depends on the market and maybe how much leverage is on the property.
People are really desiring a great place to live, whether they rent or not. And for whatever reason, I think it's been more the trend to defer maintenance. So I think that makes us a unique asset when we're, sharing the properties that we have with potential renters in these markets.
Over time, Arrived can support any type of asset. We really believe in this segment of single family and we're really focused on adding cities to allow people to diversify, but in the future we will add new asset types.
Kevin Vandenboss: What is next for Arrived Homes?
Ryan Frazier: We've got a ton in store. I think one of the things that we're most excited about making available for investors is access to short term rentals like Airbnbs.
So many people have been able to experience, Airbnb and VRBO and the short term rental experience. But very few, even fewer than long term rentals on the ownership side have been able to participate in the ownership side of these economies as a host and access the economics that can come from being a host of these c.
We think that we can solve for the ongoing, time commitments, which are even higher than long term invest rentals for investors so that they can access, this short-term rental economy. So that's what we have coming here on the on the near term probably end of this summer.
Kevin Vandenboss: What's the best way for investors to make sure they can get access to these new properties once they're available on the platform?
Ryan Frazier: The best way is to sign up and create an account with Arrived and you can do that just through our website on https://arrivedhomes.com/
And once you do, you get notified of new properties that are coming new assets and you can decide when's the right time or what are the right properties to invest in.
Real estate has continued to do what it does, which is in general historically has, offers the stable cash flow, stable property value, growth over time, a nice inflation hedge. And if you can enter the asset with a long term view, a multi-year view then those things will sustain.
Even if we do see a decline in property values,you still have great cash flow coming that help, provide some resilience to the overall returns. And so I think because of those things and just the attributes of real estate it's a lot of people have been interested in adding more to their real estate portfolio during the last couple of months.
And we've really been trying to make sure that we're making enough assets available for people to invest in. As I mentioned, we've had nearly a 100k people come and sign up and start to create accounts and start investing in properties. And we've probably funded over 20 million of rental properties just in the last two months. And we're making several new properties available each week to, to keep up with investors. And in the meantime, we're staying really selective on what we buy with the cities we're in today, we underwrite something like 50,000 properties per month and we make offers on less than 1% of them. And then, the ones that we win are the properties that we make available to folks.
In this episode of The Real Estate Podcast, Kevin Vandenboss speaks with Adam Kaufman, COO of ArborCrowd
Kevin and Adam talk about:
Guest:
Adam Kaufman, COO of ArborCrowd
Host:
Kevin Vandenboss
Real Estate Expert at Benzinga
Twitter: https://twitter.com/KevinVandenboss
Sign Up to Benzinga Pro today to receive most exclusive interviews, news and stock picks fast!
https://pro.benzinga.com/
Disclaimer: All of the information, material, and/or content contained in this program is for informational purposes only. Investing in stocks, options, and futures is risky and not suitable for all investors. Please consult your own independent financial adviser before making any investment decisions.
Welcome to the Lazy Landlord podcast here on Benzinga today, we have Adam Kaufman, who's the co-founder and COO of the real estate crowdfunding platform ArborCrowd.
Kevin Vandenboss: I would love to hear a little bit about that and how that turned into actually starting ArborCrowd.
Adam Kaufman: Thank you for having me here today, Kevin I'm I'm excited to be here.
I have been around real estate, my entire life. Some could argue that it's in my blood. My father, he's a serial entrepreneur in the commercial real estate space. He is the chairman and CEO of a publicly-traded real estate investment trust our Realty Trust. They offer financing solutions, and mortgage solutions for sponsors and borrowers in the multi-family space.
In particular, my family members work in real-estate. It was always talked about around the dinner table almost every night growing up. So it was just a part of me.
Kevin Vandenboss: What really inspired you to get ArborCrowd going?
Adam Kaufman: I think it's really the entrepreneurial nature that I grew up in and around that, that my father has been really exhibiting.
Something called the jobs act was passed in 2012 and 2013 that jumpstarted the business startups act, and it had a lot of different effects on the world. But what it did for real estate and crowdfunding in general, was eliminate the prohibition of general solicitation to invest in opportunities.
So prior to that, you had to have somebody in your role at X before you could reach out to them to solicit investment. For the first time now you did not, you could go more broadly online and through the access of technology and the reach of technology you could actually solicit people to make investors.
At that time, I was, watching this very closely as it was happening. I was actually working in DC at the time and was very aware of it. And our entrepreneurial background led to the understanding that all of a sudden, there was going to be a whole new investor class that was going to come online to access real estate investment opportunities.
And we wanted to take advantage of that and provide that opportunity. Knowing that we have so much experience in the market and so much access and partnership.
Kevin Vandenboss: What makes ArborCrowd stand out from others?
Adam Kaufman: Firstly, I think it's important to note that anybody could be a commercial real estate crowdfunding platform. What does that mean? You can create an investment, and create a website to find the investment and post it online. It's really as simple as that. And at the end of the day, I think that the environment in which we operate and live in needs a lot more structure and regulation.
And that's something that I've been talking about since the inception, but more specifically to your question, there are a lot of different models out there. There are a lot of more serious players out there. But with that said, we all operate very differently. One of the things that we do first and foremost is identifying ourselves as a real estate company, not a technology company. We have expertise in single family real estate.
We believe the underlying product is real estate. You have to exhibit and have the expertise in the product before you can offer that to the crowd or offer investments up on your platform.
And there are a lot of platforms out there offering a lot of different asset classes, and deal types to investors. And with our experience, we understand how difficult it is to be an expert in so many verticals, so many asset classes, especially when you're not even identifying as a real estate company, you're a technology company.
So it's important that investors really look and analyze the platforms that they're investing in. The underlying expertise and the underlying business plans of the individual properties.We focus so much on quality. We front the equity.We write the check upfront, which is great for the sponsors, because it de-risks the deal from the investment standpoint and because the deal is closed so we can present all the materials finalized to invest in. We're in it, we're taking that risk and that's an important nuance.
Kevin Vandenboss: The offerings that you guys have: Are these like direct deals where somebody investing in multifamily property or are they funds where you invest in several properties across a portfolio?
Adam Kaufman: You ask a great question, because there are three types of models that you can invest in: there are marketplaces, which just present other people's deals and act as the middleman. There are companies that offer funds where they raise the money in advance and then identify the deals that they want to invest in. Then there's our model, which we call the direct real estate investment model, which we've identified the deal, we have closed on it, we've written the check and you have the opportunity to choose which individual deal you would like to own.
And the fund model is something that sounds appealing.I inherently think that there's a tremendous amount of risk in that model when you're dealing with a retail investor or somebody who has not invested in real estate or invested in frankly, anything before, right? Some of these platforms have minimums of $500, $1000 dollars. If you were to go to their investors and ask them and say, Hey, what other types of investments do you make? They might say, I own some Nike stock, or I was gifted some Apple stock, right? That's a scary concept that they're reading a tear sheet saying, "Hey, broad investment strategy: retail, Northeast" that's it, no properties identified. If things go wrong, that's exactly who the SEC comes in and targets.
So I think there's a lot of risks there and that's why we don't offer that model. We also think that our model offers people to truly diversify in their port.folio and pick what they want to invest in.
We definitely have a lot of local investors who say, "this is in my backyard.I love this. I get to drive by seeing how the project is doing and be a part of it"
And that being a part of it is such an instrumental drive in the crowdfunding space.
Kevin Vandenboss: Why the big bet on single-family rentals right now?
Adam Kaufman: It's been my belief for about a year now. And I've been talking about it very actively in the market that you're seeing a rise in housing prices because of where the interest rate environment exists existed, exists today.
And is the amount of money that was printed and put into the economy by the government through stimulus really dates back to 2008, 2009. We've just been on an upward trajectory. I think that more specifically you have the institutional play coming in and that is contributing as well.
I think it's not as major as some of the other factors, but it is there. When you drill down on it. And what's important to note is there's a difference between single-family rentals, scattered-site communities that are being bought up by institutions. And what we're doing, which is build to rent communities. We are finding land and we are looking at the environment and we are building new homes for rental, from scratch. That's adding housing supply. That's helping, that's feeling a demand. We have a shortage of housing. There's a problem with affordability across the board. People want to rent,they want the amenities of what a home offers but they can't afford it. They're being priced out. They want to rent. We provide that for them.
The scattered-site concept that institutions are buying is dangerous. They are affecting the market while be it, most of the market more than 75% is still owned by mom&pops around the country but they are having a big play in it. And more specifically, this asset class has only 5% of the overall multifamily market. So it's important to also know the specifics there, but it is having a play.
And at the end of the day, the way that I look at it for investors, these larger institutions come in and when they buy these homes and they establish these funds and they go out there and they buy these portfolios. They're relying on a couple of different things, they're relying on increasing rents, but they're also relying on appreciation and the market that we exist in today, appreciation may no longer be there.
So these funds will take a hit. But with that said the immediate effect right now is affordability and homeownership. And we're in a bad place.
Kevin Vandenboss:These this build to rent communities: Are they valued on, each individual home and what that might be worth collectively?
Adam Kaufman: They're valued like a multifamily property in that they are the aggregate. You could always break down and we do in our analysis, what each home could sell for. We never have it in our business plan to individually flip a home or sell it. We are solely out there to do build for rent. They're looked at really as a multifamily asset and, we're looking at the local markets and what are the desires of people and what will they pay? So we're analyzing, we're looking at our square footage for each building and what we're offering, and the rents. And obviously, we put a lot of work into making sure that the fundamentals are supported by that local market.
Kevin Vandenboss: Are people renting because they can't afford to own or are they renting because there are a lot of benefits to renting instead of owning a home, especially in a community with amenities or, is it a mix of the two?
Adam Kaufman: It's a pretty good mix. You had, COVID accelerate a lot of trends, right? With millennials, you had people moving from urban areas into suburban areas who couldn't afford the down payment of homes. And weren't sure where they also wanted to end up permanently.
People want more space to work from home. All of those factors contributed greatly to the rise in the demand for this specific asset class. A lot of those trends are here to stay for the long-term and people are getting used to space and people are okay now living in the major urban areas anymore, just outside them to trade that off because even look at the millennial population, they're a huge population that's coming of age, family formations happening.
COVID accelerated their demand or their shift into housing out of the urban areas. This is the perfect product for them, and we're seeing a lot of that across.
Kevin Vandenboss: A lot of our, our listeners here are actually new to real estate and, they're starting to look for things outside of stocks or crypto that they can start investing in.
I'd really love to hear from you, what your reason is for investing in real estate, and what it is about this asset class that, that has attracted you and that you still love?
Adam Kaufman: It's a tangible asset. And specifically, what we focus on is the bread and butter of housing, right? It's workforce communities, and multifamily communities the demand for that will never change. It might go rent might go up and down, but there will always be a demand.
In fact, there's a shortage across the board. I really like the fact that it's tangible. I like the fact that it's always in demand, so it's more safe and more secure. It traditionally acts as a hedge against inflation. You have the ability to move around rents, which is a really big deal. And you're not tied to the public markets.
So sort of diversification for investors is huge. Those are all the factors that I've always liked. I think that they're incredibly and strongly supported Right now the investment interest in multifamily has only grown from that. And with everything going on in the world today, I think that'll continue to happen.
Kevin Vandenboss: Any final piece of advice you want to give investors in terms of navigating the market right now?
Adam Kaufman: My advice would be: know who you're partnering with, know their experience.Look at where they're projecting to exit. Is it realistically in line with where the market is heading right now? It's important to do your diligence, take a lot of things into consideration and ask questions. If you don't get answers to those questions, then there is a problem.
Kevin Vandenboss: Thank you so much, Adam. It was great speaking with you.
In this episode of The Real Estate Podcast, Kevin Vandenboss speaks with Edward Pitoniak, CEO of VICI Properties
Kevin and Edward talk about:
Guest:
Edward Pitoniak, CEO of VICI Properties
Host:
Kevin Vandenboss
Real Estate Expert at Benzinga
Twitter: https://twitter.com/KevinVandenboss
Sign Up to Benzinga Pro today to receive most exclusive interviews, news and stock picks fast!
https://pro.benzinga.com/
Disclaimer: All of the information, material, and/or content contained in this program is for informational purposes only. Investing in stocks, options, and futures is risky and not suitable for all investors. Please consult your own independent financial adviser before making any investment decisions.
We have Edward Pitoniak CEO of VICI Properties.VICI is a real estate investment trust that owns the real estate that some of the largest and most well-known casinos in the country operate out of, including several along the Las Vegas strip.
Kevin Vandenboss: Now you guys have. Really exploded over the past year and you just acquired the Venetian in Las Vegas and even more recently MGM Grand properties. With the market in so much chaos and so much uncertainty, what can you be certain of?
Edward Pitoniak: Owning dividend-paying stocks in times of utter turmoil, is assuming the dividends stream is secure well secured, and funded at least, you're going to get something. I don't think that has resonated as much with the retail community. Cause I think to the retail community dividend-paying stock that is boring.
And I think at a time like this, one of the questions to ask. Maybe it wouldn't kill me to actually be a little bit bored right now because the alternative is hyperventilating.
Kevin Vandenboss: Why do you think the market has been slow to figure Gaming Real Estate Investment out?
Edward Pitoniak: There are some general issues. Kevin, that can help explain that. And then there are some issues specific to VICI the general explanation for VICI what's taking place is that we are still a very new asset class in investment terms in American commercial real estate investment terms.
It was up to us VICI when we announced our first acquisition in December of 2017, to use the term cap rate to put our acquisitions in the context of other real estate investments that have been made in America over the preceding 2 years at that point.
So what we were determined to drive was the institutionalization of our category. As a retail investor, you always want to be thinking about where are the big institutions in terms of their adoption of this asset class that I, as a retail investor am considering investing in.
One of the things that really smart retail investors who do their homework, and who are far-sighted can benefit from is what I call cognitive arbitrage. Learning about a given asset class, learning about the companies in that asset class at a faster rate than the big institutions do.
Now, the good news for VICI is it institutions have come up the learning curve quickly on VICI
In fact, if you look through December, 31st 2021, we had posted a total return over the first 4 years of 87%. That outperformed the REIT Index by, I think about 20 or 30 points. It was just right there with the S&P 500 for total return over that period.
So the return has been there.It just doesn't have the velocity we might like, but I will point out a key thing. And that is that in a case like VICI, and this is generally true of REITs, but especially a VICI given our dividend yield, the good news is you get paid to wait. We have a dividend yield that as of yesterday was probably just below 5%.
And if you have faith, over time the market will truly begin to appreciate our value. You have the chance to match that dividend was maybe 4 to 5% with capital appreciation of the stock that could be around 5%. And if that adds up to 10% total return year after year you get to take advantage of the rule of 72, which I'm sure you and your audience are well aware of. And that's simply dividing that growth rate into 72 in order to learn how quickly you're going to double your money.
Needless to say, if you divide 10% into 72, you're going to double your money in 7 years. Does that sound like a rocket ship to the moon? No, but I tell you, based on what we're living through right now in the markets, you really ought to think about having in your portfolio some stocks that can enable you to double your money over a 5 to 7 year period even if everything else gets a little upside down.
It pays to remember that the NASDAQ peaked in 2000. And what did it take to get back to that 2000 peak? Didn't it take 12 or 13 years, right?
So this is the value of owning income-producing real estate, especially through a publicly-traded REIT where you have full transparency and integrity of the financials as an owner of the business is: it can be there in all kinds of weather for.
Make sure you're picking a REIT that has a good, solid dividend that gets paid through thick and thin. We grew our dividend during COVID. We grew at 11% in 2020. We grew at 9% in 2021. If we may not be able to deliver that kind of dividend growth year in and year out, but we will grow the dividend. And you should think about the degree to which that buffers you against riskier investments.
In the particular case of VICI, we have made it difficult for investors and sell-side analysts to quite understand what we would look like when we grew up, because our acquisition activity of 2021, which was $21 billion, it did require an enormous amount of equity raising. We raised $5.5 billion of equity last year. It did create a whole kind of miasma of moving parts that enabled that led a bunch of people to say, I can't quite nail down exactly what beef is going to look like when all this closes and all this gets funded. You know what, I'm just going to sit back and wait.
Kevin Vandenboss: How many acres do you have on the Las Vegas strip?
Edward Pitoniak: Right now, 660. And now granted not all of it, would we be valued at this kind of price, but there's been a recent trade in Vegas where I think it was Tilman Fertitta who paid 30 million an acre.
So the land value of VICI is 660 * $30 million an acre: you end up with a whole big part of our value without giving any effect to the buildings that we own across the country. And obviously the other land we own across the country as well.
One thing I want to just make sure we don't lose track of Kevin is the value of dividends when re-invested as a dollar-cost averaging tool.
If you are an investor who invests in stocks that pay dividends. And if you have a practice, whether through a drip, a dividend reinvestment program, or some other means you're constantly using those dividends to buy more of the stock times, and times like these are the best times of all, because you're automatically buying the stock when it's cheap.
When a stock you want to own is cheap, you really ought to buy more. And the great thing about dividend re-investment is that you automatically buy more. You're not left with the incremental decision. It just happens. And you benefit by virtue of doing so.
Gaming revenue March 202, as you said, was 35% ahead of March, 2019. Occupancy for Caesars and MGM are two big tenants on the strip are >90%. I believe it was same, was true at the Venetian. We really believe there's runway here next 10, 20 years aging, the baby boom, they're going to want to travel experiences, wellness experiences, recreation experiences, life enhancement experiences.
Millennials are starting into family formation. You're going to see family travel. Your family experiences that we want to make sure we're investing in.
When we started out 4.5 years ago, with this conviction that gaming real estate could be the next great institutionalization story in American commercial real estate investing.
We accepted it as absolute gospel. Institutionalization requires institutions to invest in the sector. They can either do so by buying the equity of public companies like VICI or they can invest directly and we expected this to happen. We wanted it to happen.
The assets you own as a real estate company increase in value to the extent that bidding activity for assets, like what you own establishes higher and higher values. If nobody wants to buy the assets that are like the ones you own, the ones you own aren't worth as much. So it really began in the fall of 2019 when Blackstone came in and bought the real estate of Bellagio on the Las Vegas strip. And that was obviously validating that continued into early 2020 when Blackstone went into a joint venture with MGP on ownership of the real estate of MGM Grand and Mandalay Bay. Now we are part of that joint venture by virtue of having taken over MGP. So we own 51% of MGM Grand and Mandalay Bay and Blackstone owns the other 49%.
You're starting to see other entrances and I believe you're going to continue to see real estate investment capital, whether through publicly traded REITs or through private equity funds, increasingly act on the realization that this is some of the best real estate in America, especially when you look at secular trends and how those secular trends are impacting so many other real estate asset classes.
They're really significant challenges facing office real estate. There's really significant challenges facing certain categories of retail. There are not secular challenges facing our assets. The secular demand trends for our assets are very positive. And with the triple net structures, we offer a transparency and integrity of economics that you don't find in every other asset class. So I think you can continue to expect, again, both public and private market equity to want to own these assets.
Kevin Vandenboss: How do you handle the CPI? How does that work into that? What kind of protections do you have there?
Edward Pitoniak: Yeah. And just for those of your listeners who don't know exactly what triple net means, what is basically means is that the occupant of the building pays for everything. They pay rent to VICI. They bear the cost of the real estate taxes on the asset. They bear the costs of maintaining the asset. They obviously pay the insurance. They pay all the utilities that they pay for everything.
Kevin Vandenboss: So you're not getting calls about backed up toilets?
Edward Pitoniak: Nope. It's a very clean and transparent model versus so many other asset classes where tenants and landlords are constantly getting into fights over who's going to pay for what. Our model's blazingly simple: tenant pays for everything. And I think there's a growing recognition that this is a really good model.
When it comes to inflation protection, it depends entirely on what's written into the leases. We're quite fortunate, especially compared to other triple net REITs is that 42% of our rent coming from Caesars is uncapped CPI. The measurement period for that takes place July, August, September. You look at that 3 month period versus the prior year, 3 month period of July, August, September, and the inflation year over year is what ends up kicking out the rent increase for the following year.
So if in July, August, September of 2022, we ended up with 5% year over year inflation, our rent will grow 5%, that's for the Caesar's leases. Our other leases generally have CPI components. Some of them don't kick in for a few years. But most of those are the higher of 2% or CPI up to a cap of 3%. So again, we do have inflation protection. It's not absolute, and it's not dollar for dollar or point for point. But it does definitely help our investors, navigate a period like this of inflation when it comes to ensuring the dividend grows at a rate close to, or even ideally in excess of the rate of inflation.
Kevin Vandenboss: What's that barrier to entry for anybody to come into the Las Vegas market right now?
Edward Pitoniak: Just in the last year that a very successful Asian gaming company called Genting opened a new property on the North end of the strip called Resorts World. They got the asset opened. There's a lot of aspects to it that are spectacular. Their a focus on entertainment is very strong.
Just a little further up the strip from there is a project that was originally known as the Fontainebleau developed by the developer and operator who brought the Fontainebleau in Miami beach back to the forefront.It is once again being called the Fontainebleau. And that I think is targeted for an opening probably in 2024.
And what's interesting is Koch Industries, home of the famous Koch brothers have put capital into that project. So there will be a new project there as well, very sizeable, one.
Above and beyond that, I think what you're going to, you're going to see is quite a bit of activity Tilman Fertitta just closed on that land that we spoke of at the intersection of Harmon and Las Vegas Boulevard. He will be developing, I believe a high-end hotel there, modeled after the beautiful hotel he built in Houston called the Post Oak. You're going to see other infilled projects along the way. You're going to see other projects expand other properties, expand.
We're very excited about the fact that our partner HardRock, we will be helping them by funding a $1.5 billion development of a new guitar-shaped tower that will be very much like the one they built in Hollywood, Florida at their marquee property down there, which is just spectacular.
So it'll be a blend of some new properties, Kevin, but it'll also be, I think infill because. The land is getting somewhat scarcer. We do benefit from owning a few dozen acres of undeveloped land which we'll realize the value out of at some point here.
Kevin Vandenboss: This will definitely all be exciting to see come together. Do you have any parting words of wisdom for our listeners on how they can navigate the market right now?
Edward Pitoniak: Make sure you own some stocks that are going to pay you to own them no matter what happens. Here in the coming weeks and months, it is the blessing benefit of dividend stocks that they just keep paying you based upon economics that can whether thick and thin.
The podcast currently has 7 episodes available.