
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Are Michelin stars and James Beard Awards actually worth pursuing? Amanda Polick reveals the uncomfortable politics behind best-of and awards lists—and what they really mean for your career.
In this episode, you'll discover:
→ Why restaurant awards are often more about PR relationships than food quality—and what happened when Amanda's Oakland restaurant picks got killed for "not fitting our demographic"
→ The truth about the Michelin Guide's Southern expansion and why Top Chef's Gail Simmons says she "hates that cities judge themselves by awards"
→ How awards impact cookbook deals and platform building (critical intel if you're pursuing a book deal)
→ How to build your food career and define "best" on your own terms, with or without institutional validation
Perfect for: Chefs, food writers, cookbook authors, restaurant owners, and anyone building a career in the food industry
Amanda Polick is a cookbook and food memoir coach who helps food professionals land book deals. She brings insider knowledge from years in food editorial and publishing.
Resources: Show notes & full blog post: amandapolick.com/blog-best-of-episode Newsletter: Weekly insights on food writing and creativity
Connect: Instagram: @amandapolick Website: amandapolick.com
By Amanda Polick5
44 ratings
Are Michelin stars and James Beard Awards actually worth pursuing? Amanda Polick reveals the uncomfortable politics behind best-of and awards lists—and what they really mean for your career.
In this episode, you'll discover:
→ Why restaurant awards are often more about PR relationships than food quality—and what happened when Amanda's Oakland restaurant picks got killed for "not fitting our demographic"
→ The truth about the Michelin Guide's Southern expansion and why Top Chef's Gail Simmons says she "hates that cities judge themselves by awards"
→ How awards impact cookbook deals and platform building (critical intel if you're pursuing a book deal)
→ How to build your food career and define "best" on your own terms, with or without institutional validation
Perfect for: Chefs, food writers, cookbook authors, restaurant owners, and anyone building a career in the food industry
Amanda Polick is a cookbook and food memoir coach who helps food professionals land book deals. She brings insider knowledge from years in food editorial and publishing.
Resources: Show notes & full blog post: amandapolick.com/blog-best-of-episode Newsletter: Weekly insights on food writing and creativity
Connect: Instagram: @amandapolick Website: amandapolick.com