
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Retired Intelligence Detective Gary Jenkins brings you the best in mob history with his unique perception of the mafia. In this episode, author Michael Wolraich and Gary discuss his book, The Bishop and the Buterfly. This is about the murder of Vivian Gordon, a prostitute connected to wealthy men, and Prohibition-era organized crime figures like Arnold Rothstein, Legs Diamond, Dutch Schultz, and others. The author explains the corruption within the government and political system, highlighting the investigation’s challenges and media coverage. We learned the investigators uncovered a collection of diaries with incriminating information about gangsters, leading to demands for an anti-corruption investigation. The climax occurs during a meeting between Mayor Jimmy Walker, investigator Samuel Seabury, and Franklin D. Roosevelt. We also touch on the history of New York City and Mayor LaGuardia’s efforts to clean up the city.
Click here to find Michael Wolraich’s author page.
Hit me up on Venmo for a cup of coffee or a shot and a beer @ganglandwire
Click here to “buy me a cup of coffee”
To go to the store or make a donation or rent Ballot Theft: Burglary, Murder, Coverup, click here
To rent Brothers against Brothers, the documentary, click here.
To rent Gangland Wire, the documentary, click here
To buy my Kindle book, Leaving Vegas: The True Story of How FBI Wiretaps Ended Mob Domination of Las Vegas Casinos.
To subscribe on iTunes click here. Please give me a review and help others find the podcast.
[1:25] Well, she was much more than a prostitute. That’s what she was originally convicted for in 1923, although that conviction is a little dubious.
[2:36] Interesting. So like the famous story, Lucky Luciano was convicted of receiving money from a prostitution ring.
[2:58] And so how did she navigate that?
[3:01] Yeah. So she knew some of those guys. She was living in the Park Central Hotel on 7th Avenue, when you just south of the park there near where what’s now billionaires row but it was famous for gangsters in the time that’s where Arnold Rothstein was shot and killed and she was living there i don’t know she was living there at the time he was murdered but she knew him through there and also allegedly knew and hung out with legs diamond but she was closer with another gangster an irish mobster named vanny higgins who was running bootlegging out of Brooklyn.
[3:42] Liquor from Canada and smuggled in.
[4:25] Oh, yeah. So Vanny Higgins was sought by the police after one of the shootings at a hotel in off Central Park in the Upper West Side.
[5:45] Yeah, exactly. So, I mean, just adding to that context of the time, I mean, the city was run by the political machine, Tammany Hall, which is famous in New York history and gangs in New York talk a lot about Tammany Hall.
[7:03] So Arnold Rothstein was particularly well known for being connected with these politicians, and he would use those connections to help protect the rum runners and the gangsters who were were running these operations and they would basically pay Rothstein for protection, not, necessarily muscle, but his connections with the police and politicians.
[7:39] A lot of people believe that they purposely did not try to find the killer because they were trying to bury that murder and bury any connection to Arnold Rothstein.
[8:40] This was big news. And the reason it was big news was because that letter came from an anti-corruption commission that was a state commission that had been set up by the governor at the time, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, set up to investigate some bribery by judges in New York.
[9:25] To frame innocent women for prostitution and it was basically it was a shakedown the cops would arrest the women on flimsy or fabricated evidence and so the women’s court was in the west village and it’s still it’s a library now on sixth avenue beautiful they had a whole separate court called women just for women it was a women’s court exactly and it was of course mostly prostitutes at that time and it was a big spectacle it was a scene as a form of entertainment men new Yorkers would come sit in the galleries just to hold the prostitutes at their hearings oh my god sick sick, but it’s a beautiful landmark building on 6th avenue and 10th street the courthouse is still there there was a jail there’s a woman’s jail right next to it that is no longer but the courthouse is still there it’s now a library and what was the woman’s court is now the children’s reading room.
[10:22] Yeah i’ll have to be doing a reading there in February interesting so this is where this game was going on this plot was going on the lawyers offices were right across the street yeah and the police would bring down these women they arrested they deliver them to the bondsman the bondsman would charge them a high fee and then deliver them to the defense attorneys and the defense attorneys would say look you can pay my fee and i’ll get you off if they did then And the attorneys would give kickbacks to the cops and the bondsmen, and the cop would not show up at the hearing. And that woman would get off.
[11:44] So everyone’s thinking cops bumped her off to shut her up so then how did they get any kind of investigation done on her murder since the cops are the ones that investigate did this commission start have their own investigators that started looking into the murder and calling witnesses about that, So, yes, the investigation was led by a former judge named Samuel Seabury.
[12:23] And he’s people called him oftentimes the bishop because both because of his ancestor and because he was this real imperious moralizing guy a lot of integrity but top down to people spoke perfectly never cursed yeah yeah he was a true straight arrow so he’s the bishop in the title of my book the bishop i’ve seen they said butterflies vivian all right i was gonna ask I was going to ask you how you got that title. Thanks for explaining that.
[13:01] Yeah. So Seabury, he started interviewing witnesses to see what Vivian Gordon knew, trying to figure out why she’d been killed, interviewed some of her friends at the time.
[13:16] That’s where the murder was. But the cops knew right away this was a big deal.
[13:54] Yeah, I’ve seen those pictures. Those old crime scene photos where there’s cameramen and reporters looking through stuff and taking pictures.
[14:05] It was crazy. Yeah, that doesn’t work that way now. At that time, they gave the journalists a lot of access.
[14:25] So Mr. Mulrooney, he was diligently looking into this.
[15:39] But they didn’t have anything to go on and so they were interviewing everyone after After weeks of turning up nothing, the district attorney even hired the Pinkerton, the private to assist with the case because they wanted to show some progress because everyone, of course, is assuming, well, they’re just not solving the case because the cops don’t want to solve it. Yeah, I bet.
[16:02] So that’s a pretty good overview there as we get into it.
[17:25] So, you know, Radulov, the attorney who was a boyfriend, had connected her with this scheme to basically she had money and he had these friends who had this connection in Oslo that they’d met in prison.
[18:15] Not clear what. what? Some interrupted the scheme.
[18:35] Exactly. So she’s pissed. She’s counting these guys to try to get her money back. And she’s writing about that in the diary, but the police cannot figure out who these people are.
[19:32] So as this case is getting all this attention and more and more scandals are coming out, New Yorkers, which had been kind of complacent about Tammany Hall, especially during the Roaring Twenties, everybody was rich.
[21:00] And they started to get angry. And then when these scandals started coming out, they got even angrier.
[22:27] So it was getting bigger and bigger. People were, they were getting dirt on, they were finding these corruption scandals.
[22:36] Totaled about a million dollars. Wow, in 1930s. Yeah. That’s a lot of money. A lot of money.
[23:50] Yes yeah i you know get into politics but there are some analogies i mean yeah i’ll play this mayor eric adams likes to call himself the nightlife mayor, so nightmare nightmare interesting new york city has always been colorful no matter what it’s always been colorful yes, That’s part of the charm. That’s half or three quarters of the charm of New York City. I don’t know how anybody lives there, but it is colorful.
[24:19] And then really, this was just a moment in New York. This is such a New York City moment with Seabury and Walker going at each other. And that wasn’t even the end of it.
[25:32] Yeah, absolutely. I mean, New York was probably the worst. I mean, others after Chicago was really bad, but New York in the 1930s, there was a lot of dirt there.
[26:44] And the chapters will go back and forth. As you’re hearing about the murder investigation, you’re seeing the city investigation develop.
[26:51] And I found them just both fascinating historical developments, one in kind of a small personal crime scale and the other, this epic historical scale.
[28:15] He said they were the ones that helped FDR get nominated. And he talks about this Seabury investigation.
[29:06] I really appreciate you coming on, Michael. Michael, you’ve done a couple of other books.
[29:48] Thanks so much for having me, Gary. I really enjoyed talking to you and I really appreciate you inviting me in.
By Gary Jenkins: Mafia Detective4.6
596596 ratings
Retired Intelligence Detective Gary Jenkins brings you the best in mob history with his unique perception of the mafia. In this episode, author Michael Wolraich and Gary discuss his book, The Bishop and the Buterfly. This is about the murder of Vivian Gordon, a prostitute connected to wealthy men, and Prohibition-era organized crime figures like Arnold Rothstein, Legs Diamond, Dutch Schultz, and others. The author explains the corruption within the government and political system, highlighting the investigation’s challenges and media coverage. We learned the investigators uncovered a collection of diaries with incriminating information about gangsters, leading to demands for an anti-corruption investigation. The climax occurs during a meeting between Mayor Jimmy Walker, investigator Samuel Seabury, and Franklin D. Roosevelt. We also touch on the history of New York City and Mayor LaGuardia’s efforts to clean up the city.
Click here to find Michael Wolraich’s author page.
Hit me up on Venmo for a cup of coffee or a shot and a beer @ganglandwire
Click here to “buy me a cup of coffee”
To go to the store or make a donation or rent Ballot Theft: Burglary, Murder, Coverup, click here
To rent Brothers against Brothers, the documentary, click here.
To rent Gangland Wire, the documentary, click here
To buy my Kindle book, Leaving Vegas: The True Story of How FBI Wiretaps Ended Mob Domination of Las Vegas Casinos.
To subscribe on iTunes click here. Please give me a review and help others find the podcast.
[1:25] Well, she was much more than a prostitute. That’s what she was originally convicted for in 1923, although that conviction is a little dubious.
[2:36] Interesting. So like the famous story, Lucky Luciano was convicted of receiving money from a prostitution ring.
[2:58] And so how did she navigate that?
[3:01] Yeah. So she knew some of those guys. She was living in the Park Central Hotel on 7th Avenue, when you just south of the park there near where what’s now billionaires row but it was famous for gangsters in the time that’s where Arnold Rothstein was shot and killed and she was living there i don’t know she was living there at the time he was murdered but she knew him through there and also allegedly knew and hung out with legs diamond but she was closer with another gangster an irish mobster named vanny higgins who was running bootlegging out of Brooklyn.
[3:42] Liquor from Canada and smuggled in.
[4:25] Oh, yeah. So Vanny Higgins was sought by the police after one of the shootings at a hotel in off Central Park in the Upper West Side.
[5:45] Yeah, exactly. So, I mean, just adding to that context of the time, I mean, the city was run by the political machine, Tammany Hall, which is famous in New York history and gangs in New York talk a lot about Tammany Hall.
[7:03] So Arnold Rothstein was particularly well known for being connected with these politicians, and he would use those connections to help protect the rum runners and the gangsters who were were running these operations and they would basically pay Rothstein for protection, not, necessarily muscle, but his connections with the police and politicians.
[7:39] A lot of people believe that they purposely did not try to find the killer because they were trying to bury that murder and bury any connection to Arnold Rothstein.
[8:40] This was big news. And the reason it was big news was because that letter came from an anti-corruption commission that was a state commission that had been set up by the governor at the time, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, set up to investigate some bribery by judges in New York.
[9:25] To frame innocent women for prostitution and it was basically it was a shakedown the cops would arrest the women on flimsy or fabricated evidence and so the women’s court was in the west village and it’s still it’s a library now on sixth avenue beautiful they had a whole separate court called women just for women it was a women’s court exactly and it was of course mostly prostitutes at that time and it was a big spectacle it was a scene as a form of entertainment men new Yorkers would come sit in the galleries just to hold the prostitutes at their hearings oh my god sick sick, but it’s a beautiful landmark building on 6th avenue and 10th street the courthouse is still there there was a jail there’s a woman’s jail right next to it that is no longer but the courthouse is still there it’s now a library and what was the woman’s court is now the children’s reading room.
[10:22] Yeah i’ll have to be doing a reading there in February interesting so this is where this game was going on this plot was going on the lawyers offices were right across the street yeah and the police would bring down these women they arrested they deliver them to the bondsman the bondsman would charge them a high fee and then deliver them to the defense attorneys and the defense attorneys would say look you can pay my fee and i’ll get you off if they did then And the attorneys would give kickbacks to the cops and the bondsmen, and the cop would not show up at the hearing. And that woman would get off.
[11:44] So everyone’s thinking cops bumped her off to shut her up so then how did they get any kind of investigation done on her murder since the cops are the ones that investigate did this commission start have their own investigators that started looking into the murder and calling witnesses about that, So, yes, the investigation was led by a former judge named Samuel Seabury.
[12:23] And he’s people called him oftentimes the bishop because both because of his ancestor and because he was this real imperious moralizing guy a lot of integrity but top down to people spoke perfectly never cursed yeah yeah he was a true straight arrow so he’s the bishop in the title of my book the bishop i’ve seen they said butterflies vivian all right i was gonna ask I was going to ask you how you got that title. Thanks for explaining that.
[13:01] Yeah. So Seabury, he started interviewing witnesses to see what Vivian Gordon knew, trying to figure out why she’d been killed, interviewed some of her friends at the time.
[13:16] That’s where the murder was. But the cops knew right away this was a big deal.
[13:54] Yeah, I’ve seen those pictures. Those old crime scene photos where there’s cameramen and reporters looking through stuff and taking pictures.
[14:05] It was crazy. Yeah, that doesn’t work that way now. At that time, they gave the journalists a lot of access.
[14:25] So Mr. Mulrooney, he was diligently looking into this.
[15:39] But they didn’t have anything to go on and so they were interviewing everyone after After weeks of turning up nothing, the district attorney even hired the Pinkerton, the private to assist with the case because they wanted to show some progress because everyone, of course, is assuming, well, they’re just not solving the case because the cops don’t want to solve it. Yeah, I bet.
[16:02] So that’s a pretty good overview there as we get into it.
[17:25] So, you know, Radulov, the attorney who was a boyfriend, had connected her with this scheme to basically she had money and he had these friends who had this connection in Oslo that they’d met in prison.
[18:15] Not clear what. what? Some interrupted the scheme.
[18:35] Exactly. So she’s pissed. She’s counting these guys to try to get her money back. And she’s writing about that in the diary, but the police cannot figure out who these people are.
[19:32] So as this case is getting all this attention and more and more scandals are coming out, New Yorkers, which had been kind of complacent about Tammany Hall, especially during the Roaring Twenties, everybody was rich.
[21:00] And they started to get angry. And then when these scandals started coming out, they got even angrier.
[22:27] So it was getting bigger and bigger. People were, they were getting dirt on, they were finding these corruption scandals.
[22:36] Totaled about a million dollars. Wow, in 1930s. Yeah. That’s a lot of money. A lot of money.
[23:50] Yes yeah i you know get into politics but there are some analogies i mean yeah i’ll play this mayor eric adams likes to call himself the nightlife mayor, so nightmare nightmare interesting new york city has always been colorful no matter what it’s always been colorful yes, That’s part of the charm. That’s half or three quarters of the charm of New York City. I don’t know how anybody lives there, but it is colorful.
[24:19] And then really, this was just a moment in New York. This is such a New York City moment with Seabury and Walker going at each other. And that wasn’t even the end of it.
[25:32] Yeah, absolutely. I mean, New York was probably the worst. I mean, others after Chicago was really bad, but New York in the 1930s, there was a lot of dirt there.
[26:44] And the chapters will go back and forth. As you’re hearing about the murder investigation, you’re seeing the city investigation develop.
[26:51] And I found them just both fascinating historical developments, one in kind of a small personal crime scale and the other, this epic historical scale.
[28:15] He said they were the ones that helped FDR get nominated. And he talks about this Seabury investigation.
[29:06] I really appreciate you coming on, Michael. Michael, you’ve done a couple of other books.
[29:48] Thanks so much for having me, Gary. I really enjoyed talking to you and I really appreciate you inviting me in.

2,177 Listeners

2,794 Listeners

2,766 Listeners

2,947 Listeners

673 Listeners

46,358 Listeners

824 Listeners

1,515 Listeners

432 Listeners

571 Listeners

775 Listeners

125 Listeners

265 Listeners

78 Listeners

117 Listeners