In this episode of Gangland Wire, retired Kansas City Intelligence Unit detective Gary Jenkins sits down with author Jay Baer to explore the hidden, human side of organized crime’s biggest names — Al Capone, Meyer Lansky, John Gotti, and Paul Castellano.
Jay’s book, Mob Life: The Private World of Capone, Lansky, Gotti, and Castellano, takes a unique look beyond the murders, rackets, and headlines to reveal how these mobsters actually lived — what they ate, how they dressed, their relationships with religion, and how they handled immense power and wealth.
Listeners will hear:
How Al Capone’s family sold his spaghetti sauce recipe to Ragu — their first commercial product.
Why Meyer Lansky, the most devout of the four, was denied the right to die in Israel by Prime Minister Golda Meir.
The lavish lifestyle and fatal missteps of Paul Castellano, the “Howard Hughes of the Mafia.” The contrast between Gotti’s flamboyance and Lansky’s low profile — and how each approach shaped their downfall.
The staggering fortunes these men built — and how, in the end, they all lost it.
Jay also shares his own lifelong fascination with organized crime, his career outside writing, and his upcoming project, How to Live Like a Gangster — No Prison Required, a look at mob values like loyalty, respect, and power through a modern lens.
Gary and Jay swap mob history from New York to Kansas City, including a discussion of the real story behind scenes from Casino and Kansas City’s own underworld power struggles.
ON AMAZON Wayne said
5.0 out of 5 stars Great Facts on the Mob
Reviewed in the United States on October 3, 2021Format: Kindle
If your looking for a good fast interesting read on the Mafia, this is the book for you. Full of information on mob types that most have no clue about.
You can't lose with this book I believe.
🎧 Listen now to uncover the side of the mob you’ve never heard before.
📘 Get the book: Mob Life: The Private World of Capone, Lansky, Gotti, and Castellano by Jay Robert Baer on Amazon
00:00 – Intro: Gary Jenkins welcomes Jay Baer 01:00 – Why Jay wrote Mob Life and his lifelong fascination with gangsters
03:30 – From detailing cars to writing true crime books
05:30 – Gary and Jay’s early mob reading influences
07:00 – Researching Al Capone’s private life
08:00 – Capone’s secret spaghetti sauce recipe sold to Ragu
09:00 – John Gotti’s love for Cracker Barrel and biscuits & gravy
10:00 – Meyer Lansky’s religious life and denied burial in Israel
12:00 – Castellano’s wealth, arrogance, and fall 14:00 – Jay’s next book: How to Live Like a Gangster — No Prison Required
15:00 – Loyalty and respect in the mob vs. business life
16:00 – How Castellano’s aloofness led to his murder
18:00 – The real Joe Watts story — the German who made millions
20:00 – Gary shares Kansas City mob stories and Casino connections
23:00 – The failed car bombing of underboss Tuffy DeLuna
25:00 – The Mob Museum and modern mob myths
26:00 – Jay shows his book Mob Life and shares fun mob trivia 28:00 – How much money mob bosses really made — and lost
30:00 – Why law enforcement didn’t chase mob money before the drug era
31:00 – Joe Massino’s $10 million cash and gold surrender
32:00 – Final thoughts: The mob’s empire always ends the same way
Listen now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, or your favorite podcast app.
Hit me up on Venmo for a cup of coffee or a shot and a beer @ganglandwire
Click here to "buy me a cup of coffee"
To go to the store or make a donation or rent Ballot Theft: Burglary, Murder, Coverup, click here
To rent 'Brothers against Brothers' or 'Gangland Wire,' the documentaries click here.
To purchase one of my books, click here.
Transcript
Gary Jenkins: Well, hey, all you wire tappers. Good to be back here in the studio of Gangland Wire. This is Gary Jenkins. You know, I'm a retired Kansas City police intelligence unit detective and I am now a mob historian and with the podcast and a few other things, some books and stuff out there.
Gary Jenkins: And I interview other mob authors as well as research stories. And today I have an author named Jay Bear. He has written a book about the mob, a really good, solid, historical, factually true book as kind of a basis for a novel he wants to write. So Jay, welcome.
Jay Baer: Oh, thank you. I'm, I'm happy to be here.
Jay Baer: This is really great. So I'm looking forward to this interview.
Gary Jenkins: All right, Jay. Well, you know, we, we like the mob here and we like the the facts about the mob. When I read about your book, that's, that's when I got hold of you. I thought, well, this is so interesting. It is Mob life, the private world of [00:01:00] Capone, Lansky, Gotti, and Castellano.
Gary Jenkins: And what did Al Capone wear? How much did it cost? Where did he buy it? You know, what, what kind of Italian, right? What kind of, what kind of food did Gotti like besides Italian and, and that kind of a thing. So I, that, that was really interesting, those esoteric little details that we don't really know usually.
Jay Baer: What I wanted to do is I wanted to tell a different story. Everybody writes books about their crimes and law enforcement's effort to put them away. We've heard all that. So this was like something I wanted to do for years. Let me just tell a different story. And I did, and the book is filled with, you know what?
Jay Baer: How much money they made, what they, how they dressed religious views really. Which there wasn't very much in religious views except for May Lansky. The rest of them were, even, even Paul Castellano, the the bishop did not wanna bury him in a Catholic, in, in a Catholic cemetery. And they fought him on it and they got him to do it.
Jay Baer: [00:02:00] But yeah, none of 'em had really any religious views except for, may Lansky.
Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.
Jay Baer: He went to synagogue on a regular basis. He belonged, he did a lot of stuff, you know, during the war to help you know, catch the Nazis.
Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.
Jay Baer: In fact, there's a book out there, an older book with called Luciano's Luck and it's about their, what they did and how they got involved in the, you know, world War ii.
Gary Jenkins: Interesting. Yeah, I had heard that. I've never really, I talked to one guy, an author that had a book really about the, more about the Navy guy that approached Luciano in prison and then worked with this guy named Sox Sox Lanza, who had the Fulton Street Fish market in, in trying to gather information about any possible Nazi saboteurs.
Gary Jenkins: But I've never really got into that. Mayor Lansky area. So Jay, tell us a little bit about where you come from. You're not, you're not a career author. Sometimes I have guys that that's all they ever done. They've been newspaper reporters and written books and stuff. Tell us a little [00:03:00] bit about yourself.
Jay Baer: Well, I'm from New York based, you know, originally you can probably tell with my voice, you know, forget about it and all that stuff. I knew you were from north of me. Where are you? Kansas, Missouri. Oh, okay. So. My father moved us down here to Florida, like, oh my God. 1972, and I've been here ever since. So, but I, I de, I started detailing cars when I was 28, and I've been doing that ever since and it's, you know, brought me, right now I'm kind of like, I only work in the mornings, you know, I'm almost 70, so I'm kind of like maybe semi-retired.
Jay Baer: Yeah. But I'm never gonna retire because, I gotta find something to do all the time. So I write, and right now, you know, I wrote this book, mob Life and I wrote a book before that called Angels of Death. It's about two girls who are on the run for murder and they become killers for hire and realize they're in love with each other.
Jay Baer: And I also wrote a nonfiction book about public speaking 'cause I [00:04:00] used to teach public speaking. I'm a distinguished Toastmaster. I did a lot of speaking over the years. I taught hundreds of people how to overcome their fear of speaking. So I wrote, I, I took my course and I put it into a book.
Speaker 3: Mm-hmm.
Jay Baer: It was only a very short book.
Jay Baer: 'cause you know, people don't need a lot. I don't think people need a lot of information to be successful, but I've always been interested in gangsters ever since I was a kid. You know, my, my friends were listening to The Beatles. I was reading books about. Capone and May Lansky. So there's something about them that always intrigued me, their power, the women, the way that they just controlled so much, you know, they're very powerful men.
Jay Baer: And it's just something I've kept, kept on for, oh my God, since 35 years. No, 55 years. Ever since I was a kid, 15 years old, I've been interested in gangsters. So, and I decided, hey, it's time to write about 'em. [00:05:00]
Gary Jenkins: Interesting. You know what just outta teens in my teens, I first read my first. True Crime book, which was in Cold Blood by Truman Capote.
Gary Jenkins: And man, that book, I was hooked then in that true crime. And so I was, I was in junior college right outta high school and, and I found green was it Greenfeld Jungle? By Ova DeMars. It was all about the mob in Las Vegas. It was. Thick, real dense book, but, but I bought into it, man, I, I love that book. I devoured that book.
Gary Jenkins: I, I read one by a guy named Ken, a New York City detective named I think it was Joe Erno or Tony Tony Erno, I can't remember his erno and read that. And he really. You know, made these gangsters come alive in that book back then. And I remember even, even back then, I thought, boy, that veto genovese, that was a bad, that's a bad dude.
Gary Jenkins: So they I understand. I got hooked on it early myself.
Jay Baer: Oh, that was a nonfiction book.
Gary Jenkins: Yeah. Right. Oh, okay.
Jay Baer: Yeah. You know, there's a,