Betsy Ross made the first American flag. George Washington visited her shop, she suggested five-pointed stars, and the rest is history.

Except the evidence gets weird fast.

Kyle and Rae dig into what we actually know about Ross, Congress’s hilariously vague 1777 flag instructions, Francis Hopkinson’s competing claim—and unpaid bill—for designing the flag, and the fact that the famous Betsy Ross story wasn’t publicly told until roughly a century later.

So did Betsy Ross really create America’s first flag, or did a family story, a famous painting, and some excellent 19th-century marketing create the legend instead?

“Give me liberty or give me death!”

Patrick Henry said it.

Probably... Maybe...

Okay, we actually have no idea.

Welcome to Everything You Know Is Wrong, a new detour from The Buck Starts Here where Kyle and Rae take the historical facts everybody learned in school and start questioning everything.

First up: Patrick Henry.

The version most of us remember is pretty straightforward. Fiery Virginia patriot. Brilliant natural orator. Gives one of the most famous speeches in American history, drops “Give me liberty or give me death,” everybody loses their minds, Revolution happens.

The actual story is considerably messier.

Henry failed repeatedly in business before becoming a lawyer. Thomas Jefferson later portrayed him as an almost comically uneducated country lawyer who barely studied before getting his license... but Henry’s surviving fee book shows him handling roughly 1,200 lawsuits in just his first few years of practice.

Then there’s the speech.

Henry absolutely gave a powerful speech in Richmond in March 1775. We know it helped convince Virginia to prepare for armed conflict.

What we do not have is a transcript.

The famous version of the speech (including “Give me liberty or give me death”) was first published in William Wirt’s biography of Henry in 1817, forty-two years after the speech and eighteen years after Henry died.

A loyalist writing just two weeks after the actual event remembered Henry calling the king a tyrant, a fool, a puppet, and a tool of the ministry.

But no liberty. No death.

So did Patrick Henry actually say the most famous thing Patrick Henry ever said?

Listen now to find out!

John Paul Jones has reached British waters, and the enemy is about to become extremely distressed.

Unfortunately, so are his sailors, his commanding officers, the Continental Congress, several European governments, and nearly everyone required to work with him.

In Part 2 of our voyage through the life of America’s Pirate, Jones takes the Revolutionary War directly to Britain. He attempts to burn an English harbor, loses control of another crew, tries to kidnap an earl, steals the family tea service instead, and writes an apology letter that somehow becomes flirtatious, self-promotional, and suitable for publication.

Then he gets serious.

Jones captures HMS Drake, takes command of the increasingly questionable Bonhomme Richard, and sails into one of the most famous naval battles of the American Revolution.

His ship is blasted apart.

His crew is surrounded by fire, smoke, flooding, and British cannon.

The enemy suggests surrender.

Jones responds by locking his dying ship to HMS Serapis, sending in the Marines, and taking the British vessel while his own sinks beneath him.

His ship sank, so he stole theirs... That is an aggressive upgrade.

We also get into the Whitehaven raid, the Selkirk tea-service heist, the improvised Serapis flag, France celebrating Jones while confiscating his prizes, Congress rewarding its most dangerous naval commander with paperwork, his service under Catherine the Great, the scandal that ended his Russian career, his lonely death in Paris, his alcohol-filled coffin, and Theodore Roosevelt’s eventual campaign to bring him home.

John Paul Jones was vain, abrasive, theatrical, politically disastrous, and apparently incapable of having a normal professional relationship.

But when America needed someone to distress the enemy, it found the correct man.

Before John Paul Jones became the father of the United States Navy, he was just John Paul: a thirteen-year-old Scottish sailor with ambition, a talent for navigation, and an alarming habit of finding himself in the middle of mutinies.

In Part I of our John Paul Jones deep dive, Kyle and Rae follow America’s pirate from a gardener’s estate in Scotland to the decks of the fledgling Continental Navy.

The résumé gets chaotic quickly.

He quits the slave trade after condemning it as an “abominable trade,” takes command of a ship after yellow fever kills the only two men who know how to navigate, gets accused of beating a mutineer to death, runs another sailor through with a cutlass, flees to America, adds “Jones” to his name, and spends several years sleeping on a tavern floor.

And that’s before the Revolution gives him cannons.

We cover:

• His Scottish childhood and merchant-marine apprenticeship
• The slave trade and the voyage that changed his career
• The Mungo Maxwell mutiny and murder accusation
• The second mutiny that forced him to abandon Britain
• Why “John Paul” suddenly became “John Paul Jones”
• His friendship with poet Phillis Wheatley
• The chaotic creation of the Continental Navy
• The early Continental Marines raiding New Providence
• His command of the Providence and Ranger
• British warships attempting maritime catfishing
• A six-week campaign that captured sixteen vessels
• The congressional ranking that rewarded all of this by placing thirteen newcomers ahead of him
• And the stolen British uniforms that later appeared at Valley Forge

Jones was brave, brilliant, self-promoting, thin-skinned, difficult to command, and apparently incapable of encountering a British ship without considering whether he could steal it or set it on fire.

In other words:

Exactly the sort of emotionally stable professional you want launching a navy from scratch.

This episode is sponsored by TJ Koivisto at Fairway Home Mortgage.

Every president made choices. Some aged well. Some did not.

Getting a second mortgage quote is generally one of the better ones.

Email: [email protected]

Call or text: 612-417-7767

TJ Koivisto, NMLS #2836158

Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation doing business as Fairway Home Mortgage. NMLS#2289. 4750 S. Biltmore Lane, Madison, WI, 537181-866-912-4800. Restrictions and limitations may apply. All rights reserved. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Every friend group has one.

You've got the charismatic troublemaker. That's Ben Franklin.

You've got the dramatic overachiever. That's Alexander Hamilton.

You've got the guy sneaking out of French windows after midnight. That's Gouverneur Morris.

And then you've got John Jay.

The man standing in the corner holding a treaty, wondering why nobody is following the agreement they already signed.

In this episode of The Buck Starts Here, Kyle and Rae dive into the life of America's first Chief Justice, co-author of The Federalist Papers, diplomat, governor, treaty negotiator, and professional manager of other people's nonsense.

We cover:

• John Jay's Huguenot roots and elite New York upbringing
• The New York–New Jersey border dispute that somehow lasted for years
• His role in the Continental Congress
• The collapse of Continental currency
• Secret committees and Revolutionary War intelligence operations
• The disastrous diplomatic mission to Spain
• The Treaty of Paris
• Why the states kept violating the Treaty of Paris almost immediately
• The Federalist Papers
• America's first Supreme Court
• The Election of 1800
• The Doctors' Riot of 1788
• And why John Jay spent most of his career trying to explain that rules only work if people actually follow them

Along the way, we discover something surprising:

John Jay may not have been the flashiest Founding Father.

He wasn't inventing bifocals.

He wasn't writing spicy pamphlets.

He wasn't getting into duels.

He was doing something much harder:

Trying to convince Americans to stop acting like thirteen separate countries.

And honestly?

That may have been the tougher job.

Music: Military March Drums by KimyF. from Pixabay

Some Founding Fathers wrote constitutions.

Some fought wars.

Gouverneur Morris somehow found time to do both while carrying on romantic affairs across two continents with the confidence of a man who had clearly never considered the phrase “maybe don’t.”

In this episode of The Buck Starts Here, Kyle and Rae dive into the wildly entertaining life of the man who wrote the preamble to the Constitution, helped design New York City’s grid system, fiercely condemned slavery at the Constitutional Convention…

…and developed a legendary reputation for loving women almost as much as he loved liberty.

We cover:

• The carriage accident that cost Morris his leg• The jealous husband rumors• John Jay openly gossiping about him in letters• His anti-slavery speeches at the Constitutional Convention• “We the People” and the writing of the Constitution• His years in revolutionary France• Attempts to save the French monarchy• Aristocratic affairs across Europe• The New York City grid system• Hamilton’s deathbed• And the deeply bizarre whalebone incident that ended his life

But somewhere underneath all the scandal, gossip, and “celebratory liaisons,” the episode takes an unexpected turn.

Because Gouverneur Morris also turns out to be:

• intellectually serious
• fiercely anti-slavery
• unusually supportive of women for his era

and one of the more forward-thinking political minds of the Founding generation.

Which is deeply inconvenient for anyone hoping he was just a horny chaos goblin with a peg leg.

Unfortunately for history textbooks, he was both.

Music: Military March Drums by KimyF. from Pixabay

“Remember the ladies.”

That was Abigail Adams writing to her husband John in 1776,gently suggesting that maybe creating a brand-new republic while treating women like politically decorative livestock wasn’t the strongest governing philosophy long term.

John Adams, naturally, thought this was hilarious.

And then America spent the next 250 years proving Abigail absolutely correct.

In this episode of The Buck Starts Here, Kyle is joined by Rae to dive into the women of the American Revolution: the spies, fighters, writers, organizers, smugglers, business owners, and complete chaos goblins who helped keep the colonies functioning while the men were off inventing the phrase “we’ll deal with that later.”

We cover:

• Sybil Ludington’s 40-mile midnight ride
• Deborah Sampson disguising herself as a man to fight in the Continental Army
• Nancy Hart holding Loyalists hostage in her own house because apparently frontier Georgia produced action movie protagonists
• Women running farms, businesses, and supply chains during the war
• Female spy networks the British kept accidentally briefing because they fundamentally underestimated women
• The Betsy Ross myth
• Republican motherhood
• And the deeply inconvenient reality that many Founding Fathers depended heavily on highly educated wives they still refused to treat as political equals.

We also get into correspondence culture, women disappearing from the historical record after the war, and why so much of this history survives only because somebody saved a box of letters instead of throwing it in a fireplace.

Because the American Revolution was never just a bunch of guys in wigs arguing about taxes.

Somebody still had to:

• make the clothes
• run the farms
• smuggle the intelligence
• manufacture the ammunition
• and occasionally blow up their own house before the British could seize the gunpowder

You know.

Founding stuff.

Music: Military March Drums by KimyF. from Pixabay

Jean and Pierre Lafitte are usually remembered as pirates.

Which is technically true… and wildly misleading.

Because what they actually built wasn’t chaos, it was a business.

A very good one.

Operating out of the Gulf of Mexico, the Lafitte brothers ran a full-scale black-market supply chain: intercepting ships, moving goods through hidden bayou routes, warehousing inventory, and selling it right back into legitimate markets.

Efficient. Scalable. Profitable.

Also illegal.

In this episode of The Buck Starts Here, we break down how U.S. tariffs, embargoes, and weak enforcement created the perfect conditions for that operation to thrive, and how it eventually pulled Lafitte straight into the War of 1812.

We cover:

• Piracy vs privateering (and why governments loved it… until they didn’t)
• The Barataria smuggling network
• How policy created a black market
• The British attempt to recruit Lafitte
• The deal he cut with the United States
• The Battle of New Orleans
• And how a multi-million-dollar operation disappears into history

Was he a patriot?

No.

He was a businessman who picked the winning side.

Which is a lot less inspiring… and a lot more useful.

Music: Military March Drums by KimyF. from Pixabay

What do Hustler, Afroman, and the legal system have in common?

More than you’d think.

In this episode, we take a detour into the strange intersection of free speech, lawsuits, and the fine line between expression and consequences, featuring everything from landmark legal battles involving Hustler Magazine to modern-day chaos involving viral moments and unexpected courtroom drama.

Because as it turns out, “FAFO” isn’t just internet slang.

It’s also… occasionally a legal strategy.

We break down:

• How free speech protections actually work (and where they don’t)
• The legal chaos surrounding Afroman and recent headlines
• Why some lawsuits backfire spectacularly
• And what happens when the courts get dragged into cultural moments they definitely didn’t ask for

Is this a normal episode?

Not exactly.

Is it a perfect example of how law, media, and culture collide?

Absolutely.

Music: Military March Drums by KimyF. from Pixabay

Normally The Buck Starts Here is a history podcast about U.S. presidents, American politics, and the decisions that shaped the country.

This week… the tangents won.

With schedules blown up by real life, we opened the archives and stitched together a supercut of conversations that were too weird, too nerdy, or too wildly off-topic to survive a normal episode.

Inside this historical fever dream:

• Andrew Jackson doing a Boston accent

• The eternal 747-on-a-treadmill debate

• Economics explained with medieval farmers

• Why American universities dominate the world

• Presidential libraries and museum heckling

• And a very aggressive explanation of how America opened trade with Japan

Is it a normal episode?

Not even a little.

Is there still history in it?

Somewhat.

Mostly it’s an example of what happens when the guardrails disappear.

Music: Military March Drums by KimyF. from Pixabay