The Bulwark

The Bulwark

By The Bulwark
Download on the App Store
  • Favorites

    126

    Followers

  • Latest release

    Today

  • Typical duration

    12 min

    per episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

All The Bulwark episodes

  • Jessica Tarlov Explains Why Your Arguments With MAGA Never Go Anywhere

    Thanksgiving is here, and some of your aunts and uncles may have softened their stances since last year. So, should you engage when politics comes up? And if so, how? Jessica Tarlov, co-host of Raging Moderates and Fox News’s The Five returns to the show to offer some tips for handling Thanksgiving (and the rest of the year), discusses her new book, and she and Sarah listen to some voters talk about how political divisions have affected their lives…and what those voters (Democrats and MAGAs alike) think of people in their lives who think differently.

    Show links:

    Raging Moderates with Scott Galloway and Jessica Tarlov on Apple, Substack and YouTube

    Jessica’s book, I Disagree: Winning Arguments Without Losing Friends

    The Bulwark is growing! This Sunday, we’re launching a new show featuring investigative journalist Michael Weiss and former CIA officer Marc Polymeropoulos called Reporter and the Spy. You can watch the trailer here.

    Be sure you’re following this new show on Apple Podcasts, on Spotify, on YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.

    Leave a comment

    Read more

    0 min
  • Jamie Raskin Has Howard Lutnick in His Crosshairs

    Rep. Jamie Raskin joins Catherine Rampell to discuss the growing investigation into Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s financial ties to NVIDIA, his family’s business dealings, and whether the Trump administration has compromised national security for private profit. Raskin also reveals that whistleblowers are already coming forward with allegations of corruption and criminality, and explains why Trump’s presidential pardons may not protect his allies from the investigations ahead.

    Leave a comment

    Read more

    8 min
  • Fight the Future

    Sarah and JVL talk:

    • Pinball!

    • Income inequality.

    • Trump’s three-way with Putin and Xi.

    • The House Democrats’ reluctance to fight against funding for the Iran war.

    • Elon Musk denying he even knows what MAGA means.

    • Thanksgiving traditions.

    And the big one: Why The Bulwark isn’t for sale.

    Leave a comment

    The Secret Podcast with JVL and Sarah is exclusively for members of Bulwark+. Upgrade now to watch (or listen) to this episode and join the Secret community in the comments. New shows drop each Friday. Ride with us!

    Read more

    23 min
  • In New ‘Hunger Games,’ Truth Is Fascism’s First Victim
    Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. (Courtesy Lionsgate)

    IT’S A GAME WHERE AMORALITY RULES THE DAY—but only if you want it to. Choices must be made and those choices have consequences: The game makers will send new challenges to those who act poorly or try to upset the balance. An entire nation’s GDP is on the line as young people line up to do battle while others simply watch the stream, taking it all in.

    I speak not of Grand Theft Auto VI, but of The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, the latest prequel in the long-running YA series that keeps churning like a well-oiled machine of casual death. Set between the 2023 prequel, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, and our initial introduction to the series and its hero, Katniss Everdeen (Jennifer Lawrence), Sunrise on the Reaping is a member-berry-laden prequel that spends much of its runtime introducing us to younger versions of some of the characters we knew and loved (or hated) from the original series.

    It’s first and foremost an origin story for Haymitch Abernathy, played in the original by Woody Harrelson and by Joseph Zada as a teenager here. Haymitch was the second victor from District 12—one of fourteen distinct regions (thirteen districts plus the Capitol) in a post-apocalyptic North America—in the competition’s history, and now we see how he became the drunken, sad-sack mess he was by the time Katniss rolled around. He was an accidental tribute, called in when one of the two boys chosen for this second “Quarter Quell” (25th anniversary) made a break for it rather than choose to fight to the death for the entertainment of the Capitol.

    We also meet the younger version of the calculating Plutarch Heavensbee, played by Philip Seymour Hoffman in the original films and Jesse Plemons here. Plemons has big shoes to fill—this was one of Hoffman’s final roles before dying from a drug overdose in 2014—and I think he does an admirable job of bringing Heavensbee’s inner turmoil and quiet scheming to life without ever feeling like he’s doing an impression of Hoffman. Plutarch is, arguably, even more important to the film than Haymitch, at least thematically, as the script by Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie drives home the importance of narratives and the danger faced by a society where truth is manipulated to serve the ends of those who wish to remain in power. In a fascist autocracy, truth is one of the first victims of the new regime.

    Heavensbee has the ear of President Snow, played initially by Donald Sutherland and here by Ralph Fiennes, and it’s the perfect sort of role for Fiennes, who has become one of our premier big-screen fascists. He’s played Nazis of all stripes: Nazi post-apocalyptic presidents hellbent on killing kids for the entertainment of the masses; Nazi noseless warlocks hellbent on killing magical kids for the purity of magical bloodlines; and Nazi Nazis hellbent on killing Jews of all ages. He shifts wildly but cleanly between quiet menace, as in Sunrise on the Reaping, and overt theatricality, as in the Harry Potter films or In Bruges, where he plays a vicious family-man gangster who, perhaps ironically given the litany above, has moral qualms about killing kids.

    Ralph Fiennes as Coriolanus Snow in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. (Courtesy Lionsgate)

    And of course there’s Effie Trinket, played originally by Elizabeth Banks and here by Elle Fanning. The attempted rehabilitation of Effie in Sunrise gets to the heart of the big problem with these prequels: She shows up in the new film as a last-minute helper for the District 12 tributes, who have been poorly outfitted by a useless stylist. She is thoughtful and caring and works hard for them, coming to see them as real people rather than props to be used by the Capitol in their sick games. But this is roughly the arc Effie goes through in the original films set a quarter-century later, when she begins as a thoughtless joke of the upper crust and evolves into a supporter of the revolution fought by Katniss and the rebels from District 13. It’s repetitive in miniature form, an unnecessary redux of something we’ve seen before.

    But then, repetition in miniature feels like so much of what people want. What are the big entertainment stories from the last few weeks? Hey, a new James Bond. Look at this, a fresh Godzilla movie set in the post-war era. Ah, finally, a second prequel to a movie series based on books that began in Dubya’s second term. At least Grand Theft Auto VI—the fifth (or, depending on how you count, seventh) sequel to a franchise that began in primitive form in 1997—feels like a remake in maxi-ture. I keep reading critics who spent 100, 150, 170, 200 hours playing the game before release, more hours than I’ve spent, cumulatively, on gaming in the last four years.

    The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is entertaining enough for fans of the series, and I’d be lying if I said it didn’t occasionally tug on the heartstrings. It is, also, an important reminder that those who control the message control the world and that small acts of defiance add up to greater resistance in the long run: One stands athwart history yelling stop even when those who need to hear it can’t—or refuse to listen. (Of course, actions usually speak louder than words.) That said, it’s a pretty straightforward replay of everything the franchise has done before, just in double time.

    Join now

    Watch for the launch this weekend of our new Bulwark show, Reporter and the Spy. Journalist Michael Weiss and former CIA officer Marc Polymeropoulos discuss covert operations, global conflicts, and secret information, unpacking what’s happening behind the scenes.

    Want to learn more? Check out the trailer for Reporter and the Spy here.

    Don’t miss it: Follow the show on Apple Podcasts, on Spotify, on YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.

    The Biggest Cultural Event in a DecadeJason and Lucia, chillin’. (Courtesy Rockstar Games)

    Speaking of Grand Theft Auto VI, that’s the subject of this week’s The Bulwark Goes to Hollywood. The game is going to do something like $3 billion of business in the first few days of its existence. It’s just a huge phenomenon on many levels, and Gene Park of the Washington Post joined me to talk about what it means for America and the entertainment world more broadly. The biggest question I had: Should Tim Miller have a podcast station on the next iteration of the game? I think the answer to that one is clearly yes.

    My Weekend With the White Nationalists

    And speaking of Tim, I talked to him about last week’s white nationalist conference in Irving, Texas. You can read all about my three days with the New Christian Right here and watch me discuss it with Tim below:

    Share

    Assigned Viewing: TenetRobert Pattinson in Tenet. (Courtesy Warner Bros. Pictures)

    THERE IS A TEMPTATION in certain quarters to dismiss Robert Pattinson—who was, this week, revealed to be the new James Bond—as a pretty boy, a lightweight, the sparkly vampire of Twilight fame. This is understandable, I suppose, but it’s woefully out of date as a way of mentally categorizing his work. Pattinson has spent the last decade-plus turning in really interesting performances in a variety of movies, oftentimes doing so in exceptionally odd ways.

    There just aren’t that many young actors who, high off the success of something like Twilight, would work with someone as daring as David Cronenberg. But he did so in Maps to the Stars and Cosmopolis, a pair of films that wrestle, in different ways, with success and failure and the psychological toll of both on those who experience them. He’s frequently playing weird little guys making weird little choices, as in Good Time, a Safdie Brothers film that is somehow even more unnerving than Uncut Gems, at times. Or The Rover, a sort of lo-fi Mad Max, in which Pattinson plays a . . . well, let’s just say “slow” person trying to survive in a post-apocalyptic wasteland.

    The Lighthouse is not my cup of tea—while I like director Robert Eggers a great deal and consider The Witch and Nosferatu to be genuinely unnerving works of historical horror, The Lighthouse is a little too odd for me—but you have to admire anyone who can go toe-to-toe with Willem Dafoe and, potentially, outweird him. And it’s indicative of Pattinson’s complete disregard for his status as a teen heartthrob that he’d make this movie, one in which he’s yelling about the smell of farts or, ah, enjoying himself to the imagined visage of a mermaid.

    And just this year he has had fantastic and fantastically different performances in The Drama and Primetime and The Odyssey. In The Drama he is the avatar of millennial neuroses, unsure of how to navigate a world in which condemnation is the coin of the realm. In Primetime he plays a near-messianic Chris Hansen, a man so consumed with his own sense of righteousness that he doesn’t care whom he destroys. And in Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey, he’s the loathsome Antinous, the foremost suitor pressuring Odysseus’s wife; his unctuousness gives us license to cheer for Odysseus’s slaughter of the suitors. There’s a decent chance Pattinson gets an Oscar nomination for that turn, though who knows what his work in next month’s Dune: Part Three will bring.

    But it’s Tenet, Nolan’s twisty 2020 thriller, that serves as proof of concept for what Pattinson could do as James Bond. It’s not just that Tenet is, functionally, a Bond film, a globe-hopping action-adventure movie about spies trying to save the world from annihilation. It’s that Pattinson’s Neil does, well, everything you could want a Bond to do, more or less. He’s smooth, he’s suave, he can handle himself with a gun, he can rappel and scale a wall, he can do 100 on the highway, probably backwards if needed.

    So look, I understand the trepidation. But it’s misplaced! Pattinson’s a fine choice for James Bond and he’ll do fine work as the representative of His Majesty’s Secret Service.

    To hop in the comments, join Bulwark+

    0 min
  • Anne Applebaum: All the Corruption, All the Time

    Launching Sunday: Reporter and the Spy with investigative journalist (and friend of this show) Michael Weiss and former CIA officer Marc Polymeropoulus. From covert operations and tradecraft to Russia, Ukraine, the Middle East, and the global conflicts shaping our future, Michael and Marc will unpack what’s happening behind the scenes and what it looks like to the people who have actually lived it. New shows each Sunday.
    Follow this new Bulwark show on Apple Podcasts, on Spotify, on YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.

    To much fanfare, Trump had a summit that was essentially about nothing. Kushner plays peace negotiator even though he’s heavily invested in defense contractors making weapons for conflicts he’s supposedly trying to end. And foreign regimes keep plying the White House with bribes. Democrats are going to be very busy untangling all the corruption over the next two years. Plus: Europe is already moving away from using Elon’s Starlink, Putin gave Trump another order, the mystery of Hegseth’s Venezuela trip, and more selections from the Applebaum book club.

    Anne Applebaum joins Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    Leave a comment

    show notes:

    • Anne's podcast, "Autocracy in America"

    • Anne’s piece, “Trump’s Embarrassing, Inconsequential Summit”

    • Anne on what the US is up to in Venezuela

    • Tim and JVL on the Trump press conference

    • Book Club additions: “Profiles in Cowardice” and “Endling”

    • The Atlantic on Kushner’s war profiteering

    • The Bulwark store

    • Closing Song: Orville Peck - “It’s the End of the World”

    As always: Watch, listen, hit the like button or leave a comment. We want to hear from you.

    Premium, ad-free editions of The Bulwark Daily are available exclusively for Bulwark+ members.

    Tim Miller’s Bulwark Daily is available wherever you get podcasts and on YouTube. New shows drop each weekday afternoon. If you like the show, leave a comment and ⭐⭐⭐⭐ wherever you listen. Add The Bulwark Daily to your player of choice, here.

    Watch and listen how you want, when you want—upgrade to Bulwark+ today. Enjoy every Bulwark show—ad free—on the site, the Bulwark App or the Substack mobile and TV apps. Members can also set up their personal member-only show feeds on their podcast player of choice.

    Join now

    Read more

    17 min
  • BREAKING: JD Vance Just Gave Trump the Answer He Didn’t Want to Hear on the Iran War

    Full transparency: this was not a good press conference from the president. For the true sickos among you, upgrade to a Bulwark membership to watch Tim and JVL suffer through Trump’s endless remarks, complete with jump scares from some of the most loathsome figures in his administration. We endured nearly two hours of this. The least you can do is watch with us.

    Join now

    Tim Miller and JVL react live to Trump’s marathon White House press conference following his summit with Putin and Xi. From Trump’s fawning praise of the two dictators to JD Vance’s refusal to say whether the Iran war was worth losing the Senate, the spectacle takes some unexpected turns—including a possible 2028 audition from Stephen Miller. Plus, the bizarre claims, endless tangents, and increasingly exhausted reactions from Tim and JVL.

    Leave a comment

    Read more

    21 min
  • Trump Insider Jason Miller Is Making a Staggering Amount of Money

    From a Trump insider’s $15 million windfall exposed by a child support lawsuit to the administration’s efforts to dismantle government oversight, Catherine Rampell and Sam Stein examine the growing business of profiting from Trump’s presidency. Plus, the financial risks lurking beneath the AI boom, Nvidia’s mounting troubles, Trump’s China summit, and the collapse of his meme coin.

    Leave a comment

    Read more

    41 min
  • America Is Part of the Axis of Evil
    (Photo illustration by Sarah Rogers/The Bulwark | Photos: Getty, Shutterstock)1. We’ll Do It Live

    Short Triad today because Tim and I are going live at noon to watch Trump’s post-throuple press conference. I hope he cleaned himself up.

    Come hang with us on Substack or on YouTube.

    2. Surprise!

    After meeting with Vladimir Putin, President Trump hopped onto Air Force One and while he was in the air decided to call in to a meeting in Berlin of the Coalition of the Willing, a British- and French-led group of more than thirty countries formed to coordinate support for Ukraine.

    From what I can tell of the reporting, Trump’s call to the meeting was a surprise. Kind of like when he dials up Fox & Friends sometimes to announce the end of American aid to Israel.

    Here’s Politico’s account of what Trump said to the coalition:

    In a call from Air Force One on his way home from meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin, Trump lamented what he characterized as the waste of billions to provide Ukraine with weapons and cash for a conflict that is killing so many people, according to three of the European officials, who were granted anonymity to describe a private meeting.

    Hours after concluding his encounters with the Russian leader and Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, China, Trump had one message for the leaders gathered in Berlin: Putin is serious about negotiating a peace deal with Ukraine. . . .

    Some of the officials familiar with the call described Trump’s tone as strongly critical of Europe’s ongoing support for Kyiv, while others said he was just communicating in his usual forthright style.

    We have reached a new low in American history. At the 2018 Helsinki meeting with Putin, Trump merely took sides with Russia against American intelligence agencies. This time, Trump took dictation from Putin and before the day was out took sides against Ukraine and its coalition allies, including almost the entirety of NATO.

    There were other meetings about Ukraine this week. Defense Under Secretary Elbridge Colby was at NATO headquarters in Brussels for talks with the Ukraine Defence Contact Group, an alliance that includes all of NATO plus two dozen other countries. Colby’s contributions, in the meeting and in remarks afterwards, were:

    • He told European countries that it was unacceptable for them to rely on homegrown defense industries and that they must continue buying weapons from America. The American policy, evidently, is that we will not defend Europe. We may even threaten to invade Europe. Europe must defend itself, but must do so while supporting U.S. defense companies.

    • He criticized Ukraine for striking targets inside Russia and said it should stick to defending the front lines.

    • He walked out of the meeting after giving his statement, skipping the classified briefing delivered by Ukraine’s defense minister.

    Stop asking “Whose side are we on?”

    We are on Russia’s side.

    Leave a comment

    3. Yalta II

    Anne Applebaum has more:

    The original Yalta summit took place in a rickety czarist palace on the Crimean Peninsula in February of 1945. Adolf Hitler’s troops were already in retreat when President Franklin D. Roosevelt, Prime Minister Winston Churchill, and the Soviet dictator Joseph Stalin met in cold, drafty rooms to discuss the end of the war. Senior generals and presidential aides slept on mattresses stuffed with bedbugs. Churchill complained that Yalta was good for nothing except the “typhus and deadly lice which thrive in those parts.” Afterward, he asked for his clothes to be fumigated.

    Eight decades later, the Yalta summit is remembered mostly not for building peace, but for consigning Eastern Europeans, whose leaders were not in the room, to Soviet occupation and repression for the subsequent half century. In the name of ending a war against fascist totalitarianism, in other words, Yalta promoted the spread of communist totalitarianism and planted the seeds of the Cold War.

    The inconsequential Trump-Putin-Xi summit in Shenzhen, pumped up by the gullible as a “Yalta 2.0,” was an event more suited for our sillier times. No serious agreements were signed. No country’s borders were redrawn on the edge of a paper napkin. No one was infected by lice or bitten by bedbugs. Instead, the meeting was brief, almost substance-free, and carefully choreographed for the maximum benefit of the Chinese hosts. Its true purpose was not to end any wars—and certainly not to end Russia’s bloody invasion of Ukraine—but to produce propaganda photographs and video clips that each of the three leaders will now use to mask their political failures.

    Certainly this was President Trump’s main goal. Before the three leaders met, he actually told Fox News that the most significant moment was already over: “the greeting yesterday, which in the history of China has never happened.” Xi Jinping, aware of how easy it is to manipulate the American president, had met Trump at his airplane, on the tarmac. “This is a highly respected, this is a great president, one of the great presidents of China—and he’s never gone to the airport to meet somebody,” Trump blustered. He also spoke of “the fanfare, the beauty, the pageantry, the thousands of people, the young children, the soldiers, the whole thing,” adding, “That’s a big win for us. It’s a big win for China too.”

    Read the whole thing.

    Anne Applebaum is Tim’s guest today on The Bulwark Daily. The show will be out this afternoon. Don’t. Miss. It.

    Follow The Bulwark Daily on Apple, Spotify, or YouTube. Or join Bulwark+ to watch or listen to premium editions—ad free—on the Bulwark App or on Substack.

    Join now

    0 min
  • Meet the Influencer Who Pissed Off Everyone in the Immigration Movement
    (Photo illustration by Sarah Rogers/The Bulwark | Photos: Getty, Shutterstock)

    HEAR ME OUT: What if we actually did have second-class citizens? That, more or less, is what many people thought Carlos Eduardo Espina, the influencer darling of prominent Democrats with a following more than 24 million strong, proposed when Donald Trump briefly teased his openness to an immigration deal.

    Espina, 27, is a self-described millionaire, and he often pays bills for people from the Latino and immigrant communities who reach out to him. His generosity and large audience give him some weight in Democratic politics. But that doesn’t mean everyone likes it when he throws that weight around on policy issues.

    Espina’s post floating a pathway to legal status for undocumented immigrants premised on denying the full rights of citizenship through a permanent bar on voting sparked a firestorm that engulfed much of the immigration-focused commentariat. He’s hardly the first person to float the idea of legalizing undocumented immigrants without providing a path to full citizenship. Yet coming from Espina—even as a thought experiment—this proposal caused an uproar.

    The conflagration provides an illustration of the great challenge that immigration leaders and the larger Democratic coalition face as they move from broadly opposing Trump’s extreme policies to determining what they should positively and specifically advocate for to replace them.

    Espina’s post departs from the customary approach immigration leaders take to policy advocacy, which involves a lot of coming together to hash out differences within a coalition before presenting the public with a consensus position. And many who favor this method of operating were quick to let Espina know what they thought of his freelancing.

    In response to Espina’s post, the Congressional Black Caucus questioned if immigrant-rights groups were now dropping voting as a key demand, a source with knowledge of these conversations told me.

    “We must ask for a path to residency and citizenship,” wrote Ade Ferro, a Democratic organizer and activist in South Florida. “Nothing less. We are not creating second-class citizens.”

    Erika Andiola, a well-known Dreamer activist and a veteran of the immigration policy wars dating back to the Obama years, also criticized Espina’s hypothetical compromise.

    “Come on, Carlos. Are you serious?? Can we take your right away from voting or running for office for the rest of your life and then we can do it for millions of other people? It makes me so sad to see this,” she wrote in a now-deleted thread of replies. “Why would you start publicly advocating for such an awful negotiation right now? What is the point of this post?”

    Journalist Arturo Dominguez offered a cutting summary of Espina’s proposal: “denizenship.” Such a status has ugly historical precedents, he argued.

    “More times than not they maintain a scapegoat status,” Dominguez told me. “When you have immigrants contributing, paying taxes, and assimilating but they don’t have a voice in electoral politics, that makes them very vulnerable.” It’s like “going back to the Jim Crow era.”

    Share

    FOR HIS PART, Espina has not been deterred by the blowback. Trump was president when he was in high school, he reminded me; coming up in a time defined by openly hostile, even belligerent politics means that fighting back comes naturally to him. That’s especially the case when he feels he’s speaking up for undocumented immigrants. He tells me that many from across the country, from Florida to Texas to California, see his proposal as something worth considering.

    “This post made a lot of ‘immigrant rights activist’ upset, but what’s interesting is that I posed the same question on Facebook to the immigrants who would be affected by this, and after 20 hours, the post has 2.3 million views, 36k likes, and almost 6k comments overwhelmingly supporting the proposed policy,” he wrote. “I guess it shows how out of touch a lot of activists are with the communities they pretend to care about and represent. Maybe that’s why nothing ever gets done!”

    Thomas Kennedy, a Florida-based immigration activist who has worked with the families of men detained in places like “Alligator Alcatraz” and the Krome detention center, offered a terse reply to Espina’s post: “Good job creating division and trying to weaken negotiations before they even start.”

    Kennedy was himself undocumented for fifteen years. His anger was palpable when I spoke to him.

    “[Espina’s] demeanor is so arrogant, the lack of assuming best intentions, lack of ability to have a mature dialogue, the likes and comments have gone to his head,” Kennedy told me. “The way he dismisses undocumented people and activists, like ‘I’m the authority here, it’s my way or the highway.’”

    Share

    THE CONTRETEMPS OVER Espina’s post isn’t just about disagreements among immigration advocates about the best way forward on policy. It’s also about who gets to lead an immigration movement that, notwithstanding a few individual successes—the creation of DACA, some TPS renewals—has undergone repeated bitter disappointments.

    Many who spoke up to criticize Espina’s plan told me the influencer had committed a cardinal sin against the movement.

    “You never talk about denying voting rights; the entire history of social justice is about expanding voting rights,” a prominent activist with a national profile told me, asking for anonymity in exchange for candor. “It’s ignorant and frankly stupid to say ‘Deny voting rights to nonwhite people’ when any social justice cause is about expanding voting rights for nonwhite people.”

    An added wrinkle: Espina has acknowledged that earlier in the year he was paid for some posts by Tom Steyer’s California gubernatorial campaign, and some activists who spoke with me suggested that someone may have paid for his recent post, too.

    Espina told me the payola accusations are nonsense, and he characterized the tradeoff he suggested as better meeting the immediate needs of the sorts of people who follow him—the ones who come up to him in hotels, emerge from restaurant kitchens to shake his hand, and share stories with him of their families under assault by the Trump administration.

    “People say I’m willing to give up the right to vote, but I’m not giving up anything because they don’t have that either way,” he told me. “They say, ‘You would create second-class citizens’—well, it’s been forty years since the last amnesty; people are already living that way.”

    Instead of waiting patiently for a possible Democratic trifecta to arrive in 2028 before pushing for large-scale immigration reform, as some have privately counseled him to do, Espina said he just wants immigrants to find some measure of relief now.

    “I get that it’s not ideal, but ultimately that’s politics,” he said. “I do fear that historically the idea of citizenship-or-nothing has resulted in nothing since I’ve been alive.”

    The sense of urgency is something Espina shares with many who work in Democratic politics and immigration advocacy. Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.), the presumptive incoming speaker of the House, caught flack for leaving immigration off a list of priorities he announced last week. On Tuesday, Jeffries made a follow-up announcement that the American Dream and Promise Act—a bill that would give protections to undocumented people who came to the United States as kids, known as Dreamers, as well as some TPS recipients—will be voted on “early in the next Congress.”

    Meanwhile, Democrats who want to see reforms to the immigration system stress the importance of showing a united front.

    “This isn’t a time for us to be divided. . . . Our community is still being attacked by ICE every day,” Andiola wrote to me, explaining why she deleted her critical replies to Espina.

    “We’ve had this debate before,” she said. “In 2012, when citizenship wasn’t politically possible, many of us in the undocumented youth movement fought for DACA to win immediate protection. I know firsthand the frustration of pleading for immediate relief only to be told to wait for a path to citizenship.”

    Share

    Espina at the White House?

    Despite the talk of a united front, the underlying disagreements within the coalition are not going away. When Espina mentioned to me that he has been criticized for saying he would go to the White House to speak to Trump about immigration if the president invited him, I prodded him to consider the outcome of such a meeting. One possibility is that Trump and Stephen Miller would ask him to support a policy package that includes tradeoffs many advocates would consider nonstarters.

    I sketched out one such package: Would he support a deal that granted permanent amnesty in exchange for greater funding and provisions for border security, requirements for immigrants to pay status-related fines and learn English, a foreclosure of any pathway to full citizenship (and therefore also to voting), and a requirement that immigrants submit all personal information, including extensive biometrics, for inclusion in a government database?

    Espina listened as I rattled off these provisions, and when I was done, he said the hypothetical package sounded good to him, which I knew would be controversial, particularly the last one.

    “People act like adhering to some of those things makes you a MAGA person,” he said. He told me his early social media posts were about citizenship classes and helping immigrants learn English. “People would willingly enroll in a database if it was about getting legal status,” he added. Of course, people living in fear of a masked police force that can break up their families and physically harm them with impunity would do many things to remove the immediate threat.

    Kennedy became apoplectic when I described to him these other tradeoffs Espina claimed he would be willing to entertain to improve the lives and prospects of immigrants.

    “First thing, who the fuck are you to speak for so many people?” he said. “I’m not saying I’m the guy, but there needs to be a whole lot of people in that room. If not, then you get things like this fucking idiot [who] might surrender a ton of people’s info to the surveillance state to get dragged off the street like fucking animals.

    “It’s beyond shocking. This is a dangerous person,” he said.

    Espina told me he has never voted for Trump, but he likes Abdul El-Sayed’s recent approach to policymaking: Let Trump take all the credit he wants if doing so might make it possible for Democrats to pass a major health care law. It doesn’t matter if Trump and Miller get to do victory laps on immigration, Espina said, so long as people get helped.

    Kennedy did not find this admission encouraging. “He does a lot of good, but you gotta worry about these messianic-minded leaders. Sometimes, they take it too far.”

    Leave a comment

    0 min
  • The MAGA Crackup Around the Corner

    Hey, look: The Senate passed the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act last night, a badly needed piece of energy-infrastructure permitting reform. We’ll see how it does in the House, but the affordability agenda is off to a good start. Happy Friday.

    (Photo illustration by Sarah Rogers/The Bulwark | Photos: Getty, Shutterstock)The Worst Is Yet to Come

    by Andrew Egger

    When Trump first swept into office last year, bringing a rogues’ gallery of wacky and alarming nominees with him, the Republican Senate barely put up a fight. Pete Hegseth, Kash Patel, Kristi Noem, Tulsi Gabbard, Pam Bondi, Robert F. Kennedy Jr.: Yeah, sure, fine, okay, whatever, if you insist.

    But today, a Trump nominee is liable to flame out without warning. This week, the Senate effectively killed the nomination of administration lawyer T. Elliott Gaiser to a judgeship in Texas thanks to opposition from outgoing Texas Sen. John Cornyn, who seemed upset that Trump hadn’t nominated a Texas prosecutor he would have preferred.1 And last night, Politico reported that outgoing North Carolina Sen. Thom Tillis will block Tump’s nomination of White House staffer Eric Ueland to lead the Government Accountability Office.

    With just weeks left of the Republican trifecta, any nominee who goes down now is unlikely to see a replacement before the lame-duck Congress leaves office—which means each failure hands more future confirmation power to incoming Senate Democrats. It’s a powerful illustration of how the various tensions and cracks in the GOP are already costing the party real power.

    And these coalition splinters are only going to get worse.

    Earlier this week, we briefly mentioned Dr. Heidi Overton, whom Trump nominated for commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration back in August. Trump withdrew Overton’s nomination this week, acknowledging that there was seemingly no path to confirming her and apparently resigning himself to finishing his second term without a Senate-confirmed appointee in the crucial position.

    Trump will eventually go, but our troubles will remain. Join our pro-democracy community, because we’re not going anywhere.

    Last year, it was rare to see a figure like Overton go down without even a vote. Her MAGA credentials are strong: She’s a longtime Trump health-policy official who worked on health care issues at the America First Policy Institute during the president’s interregnum and has spent the last two years in a key role on the White House Domestic Policy Council. As tensions between MAGA and MAHA grew over the last year, Overton was as much of an internal peacemaker as any—crucial in mediating fights between HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins, the Atlantic reported over the summer.

    If Trump’s coalition were still basically holding together, someone like Overton—with one foot on both sides of a key internal divide—would be well positioned to thrive. But as fault lines broaden, trying to straddle them becomes more dangerous. In the end, rather than uniting warring constituencies, Overton was pulled apart by them: The MAHA faithful mistrusted her as “controlled opposition” who would work to neuter RFK Jr.’s agenda from the inside, while MAHA skeptics like Sen. Bill Cassidy worried she would work to further Kennedy’s plans to disrupt childhood vaccines.

    And Overton was also caught up in another serious internal divide that hasn’t been talked about much—but which is liable to explode into yet another coalition-shaking controversy for Trump in 2027: how the FDA will handle a crucial decision on abortion policy.

    During his first term, Trump saw anti-abortion activists as a key political constituency and worked hard to earn their support, appointing the judges who would overturn Roe v. Wade and embracing the label of “the most pro-life president in history.” Since his 2024 campaign, however, Trump has swerved hard to the center on the issue. He outflanked Ron DeSantis to the left during the 2024 primary, attacking Florida’s abortion laws as too restrictive. And he has pursued an essentially abortion-agnostic policy program since retaking office.

    Pro-lifers have grudgingly put up with this for a few reasons. In part it’s because they remain grateful to Trump for bringing about the end of Roe. In part it’s because they recognize that the hard, broad turn of public opinion in favor of abortion access has weakened their position in the GOP coalition. And in part it’s because they are waiting to see what Trump’s FDA will do about the sale of the abortion drug mifepristone by mail, which has become one of the most salient policy issues within the larger abortion battle over the last few years. This would not require legislation: Trump’s FDA could dramatically reduce American women’s access to telehealth mifepristone by a change in regulations alone.

    Back in 2024, Trump told Time Magazine it was “very unlikely” he would move to restrict the abortion drug. But as president, he’s tried to maintain a posture of maximum ambiguity, with his administration insisting it can’t rule one way or the other until the FDA completes an ongoing safety reassessment of mifepristone. Now the act is getting old. Pro-lifers are tired of waiting: Cassidy suggested that pro-life senators had been holding out on Overton’s nomination because they are demanding assurances that the next FDA commissioner will move forward quickly on this issue.

    Whichever way the FDA rules spells further danger for Trump and his coalition. After two cycles where abortion politics proved highly favorable for Democrats, the issue all but dropped out of voters’ minds in 2026. But a crackdown on mifepristone would bring it back into the spotlight—while a failure to crack down could prove the final straw for a diminished but highly loyal faction of single-issue Trump voters. Overton lost her nomination fight in part because of this undodgeable dilemma. She won’t be its last casualty.

    AROUND THE BULWARK
    • The Dirty Bomb’s Real Power Is Fear… Recent reporting suggests Iran might be planning an attack with a “weapon of mass disruption” writes MARK HERTLING.

    • We Have to Keep the New Electoral Map… PATRICK GASPARD joins TIM MILLER on The Bulwark Daily to discuss why Democrats need to embrace candidates with the engagement gene if they want to lock in their geographic gains.

    • Hegseth’s Venezuela Visit Was Hidden From American Media… ANDREW EGGER and BEN PARKER give their takes on Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s surprise trip to Venezuela, where he announced a new security agreement with the government of Delcy Rodríguez.

    • Bulwark Book Club for December… T: The Story of Testosterone with CAROLE HOOVEN joining MONA CHAREN. Send in your questions now!

    • John Fetterman’s Days Seem Numbered—and He Knows It… The cantankerous Democrat is now irrelevant. His colleagues think that’s all the more reason to kick him out, reports JOE PERTICONE in Press Pass.

    QUICK HITS

    ADMITTING DEFEAT: While Donald Trump keeps impotently whining about the supposedly rigged election, the official 2026 Stop the Steal effort is dying a speedy death. Yesterday, the Trump administration dropped its legal attempt to block Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory in the Alaska Senate race, which had been predicated on the presence of two men named “Dan Sullivan” on the ballot: one the incumbent Republican senator, the other a man whom Peltola’s campaign reportedly helped recruit to siphon votes away from the other.

    Administration attorneys had asked a federal court in Alaska to segregate out the sliver of ballots cast for Fake Dan during the counting process—presumably so they could be matched to voters who could then be asked whether they had intended to vote for their current senator. The court denied this request, and counting proceeded as normal. Later, the court threw out the suit altogether for lack of standing. In a filing yesterday, the administration argued that it thus had become impossible to determine whether voters had been confused enough to affect the outcome of the election, and that a higher judge should thus rule the case moot.

    It had become moot for another reason too: Peltola ended up with an absolute majority of the four-candidate vote, meaning that even taking Fake Dan’s entire reservoir of votes and depositing it in Real Dan’s account wouldn’t have been enough to carry the incumbent to victory. Because the real objective for Trump was always to stop Peltola’s victory rather than to bring to light some nefarious corruption, the lawsuit became meaningless at that juncture.

    GET USED TO IT: Why is all our tech suddenly going offline? Politico dives into what’s looking unfortunately like our “new normal”:

    Artificial intelligence is making it easier to find software flaws that leave critical systems exposed—leading security experts to warn that mass outages will soon become standard.

    “We are just at the beginning of this moment,” said Helmut Reisinger, European chief executive of cybersecurity company Palo Alto Networks, referring to the accelerating pace of vulnerability discoveries and the resulting outages as the “new norm.”

    The good news is that we haven’t seen any face-meltingly awful security breaches amid this maelstrom of update chaos, at least not yet. Still, plenty of systems are still limping along below full capacity—the National Security Agency, for instance, is still staggering arrival times at its Maryland headquarters to reduce the strain on its classified communications networks—and we’re still only at the dawn of this insane new era.

    MONEY MONEY MONEY: The best thing to be in today’s economy is the president’s son, but being his former body man isn’t a half-bad way to make a living either. The Washington Post reports that longtime Trump aide Jason Miller made a remarkable $15 million in fiscal year 2026: “In that time, Miller was a registered foreign agent for the governments of India and Romania and was in talks to join Trump’s White House as an unpaid adviser and began appearing there regularly this summer.”

    Even more remarkably, none of that money ever appeared in public disclosures. We know about it only because Miller’s finances were subpoenaed in a child-support fight with another former Trump aide, A.J. Delgado, with whom he had an affair in 2017.

    Since Trump retook office, WaPo reports, Miller has inhabited a very lucrative halfway space in the administration:

    Had Miller become a special government employee, he would have been exempt from federal limits on outside income and employment that apply to most White House staff, according to the Office of Government Ethics. But conflict-of-interest law would have barred him from working on government matters affecting his own financial interests or those of his clients, unless he received a waiver, said Kathleen Clark, a law professor at Washington University in St. Louis who studies government ethics.

    She said his lack of official status meant he could operate without committing to follow rules. “What you are describing is someone who has not sworn allegiance to this country, who doesn’t even purport to act in the interest in the public and is allowed to go running roughshod around the White House,” she said.

    Read the whole thing.

    Join now

    CHEAP SHOTS

    Join now

    1

    In a remarkable shouting match with Sen. Ted Cruz on the Senate floor yesterday, loud enough to be partially overheard by reporters half a room away, Cornyn added that “I’m mad at you” and at someone else—presumably Trump—“for ending my career.”

    0 min