The Bulwark

The Bulwark

By The Bulwark
Download on the App Store
  • Favorites

    126

    Followers

  • Latest release

    Today

  • Typical duration

    12 min

    per episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

All The Bulwark episodes

  • Republicans Lost So Badly They’re Now Fighting Over Who to Blame

    The election is over, but the reveling is not. Tim, Sarah, and JVL are back together to discuss the fallout from the election, including the ascension of Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan to White House Chief of Staff and House Minority Leader. Plus: did Sarah like how Ross Douthat handled his interview with Trump Then: Axios is saying that the system held, so we shouldn’t have been so worried about Donald Trump meddling with the election. And JVLs quite mad. Plus: what really drove the Democratic wave?

    Then: Josh Hawley is fasting for America…for only one hour. Plus, why the GOP’s culture war messaging completely implosded on election day. Then, they discuss a very strange Will Sommer newsletter about a Neo-Nazi streamer in a compromising position.

    Then, behind the paywall: Tim has a rant about how we all need to be a little happier with this election. Then, the gang takes listener questions: It’s career advice, life advice, Tim and Sarah’s favorite gay media, why none of the gang are going to run for office, and some other assorted political pundit questions.

    Show links:
    Read JVL’s Triad
    Read Will Sommer’s False Flag newsletter about the Neo-Nazi

    Leave a comment

    Watch, listen, and leave a comment..

    This premium ad-free version of The Next Level is exclusively for Bulwark+ members.

    Read more

    1 hr
  • Dropkick Murphys Frontman Says MAGA Fans Are Finally Turning on Trump (w/ Ken Casey)

    Sarah Longwell sits down with Dropkick Murphys frontman Ken Casey to talk about the election, the working-class voters turning away from Trump, and why Democrats can’t afford to waste this moment. After helping rally musicians and artists to speak out against Trump, Casey says the fight is far from over. He wants Democrats to investigate Trump’s corruption, hold his administration accountable, get money out of politics, and deliver on the economic promises that brought voters back. He also has a warning for Democrats: if they fail to follow through, he’ll be just as loud calling them out as he has been fighting MAGA.

    Leave a comment

    Read more

    6 min
  • How Trump’s Top Tech Ally Got Caught in a Honey Trap

    We guarantee you won’t find a conversation about spycraft quite like this one. Marc spent 26 years in the CIA and has firsthand—and almost hands-on—experience with honey traps, while Michael has spent years investigating Russian intelligence and the people who run these operations. If you like hearing from people who know what they’re talking about, with a few stories they probably couldn’t tell you in a more respectable setting, consider becoming a Bulwark member. Your support makes work like this possible.

    Join now

    Michael Weiss and Marc Polymeropoulos examine the explosive allegations that a Chinese intelligence operative used a honey trap to get close to Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, potentially exposing some of America’s most sensitive AI technology. Marc explains how honey traps work, how foreign intelligence services use sex and blackmail to recruit targets, and why this alleged operation could have serious national security consequences. But the biggest questions may be about the Trump administration: U.S. intelligence reportedly uncovered the relationship, Marco Rubio allegedly warned the White House, and Trump still appears unwilling to take the threat seriously.

    Plus, why the scandal raises fresh questions about Jared Kushner, Steve Witkoff, and the administration’s willingness to confront foreign espionage. And a look at some of the most notorious honey trap operations in intelligence history.

    Leave a comment

    Read more

    13 min
  • Stephen Miller Is a Problem
    (Photo illustration by Bill Kuchman/The Bulwark | Photos: Getty, Shutterstock)Run this town

    As I was finishing this newsletter, word came from House Republicans that they settled on Rep. Jim Jordan of Ohio to be their new leader as they move into the minority in January. With Speaker Mike Johnson saying he didn’t want the job, the choice came down to Jordan, the in-your-face chairman of the Judiciary Committee and Freedom Caucus cofounder, and the widely liked and relatively milder-mannered Steve Scalise, who has spent nearly four years as majority leader after about a decade as the Republican whip. Jordan and Scalise previously faced off in 2023, clashing over who would succeed Speaker Kevin McCarthy; ultimately, neither had enough support, and the job went instead to Johnson.

    I just shot a quick video on this:

    Empire state of mind

    Donald Trump’s decision last week to name Stephen Miller as his new White House chief of staff gives the impression that instead of learning from and correcting the policy mistakes of the past two years, the president intends to double down on them. Miller has been unapologetically racist, and his prejudices and hatreds have fueled much of the Trump administration’s nativist agenda, especially in the area of immigration enforcement. He will now hold even more power over the administration’s policy direction.

    Naturally I wanted to ask Republican senators, newly returned to Capitol Hill on their first day back in session, for their thoughts on Miller’s promotion.

    First, I sought out two of the Republicans leaving Congress at the end of the term. I hoped they would offer some unvarnished honesty, and they did not disappoint.

    “I think it’s the worst possible thing that could have happened this week,” Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) told me. “Look, this guy was deputy White House chief of staff and senior policy advisor and homeland security advisor. Tell me, what in Homeland Security before Markwayne Mullin got there was going well for this administration?”

    “So, for a year, this guy is helping advise on homeland security where we lost the immigration reform and border security issue, right? And then you take a look at some of the missteps with Greenland and a number of other things,” Tillis added. “[Miller is] the last person who should be trying to settle things down.”

    Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) was only slightly more circumspect. When I asked him whether last week’s election results, a Republican calamity, warranted some reflection on the past two years of GOP policy—with Miller a leading voice developing it—Cornyn jokingly pointed at Tim Scott (R-S.C.) and said, “I’m gonna talk to the expert here and find out.” Scott, the National Republican Senatorial Committee chairman, has received a drubbing over the party’s extraordinary losses in the upper chamber.

    Get Press Pass in your inbox every Tuesday and Thursday

    What sort of White House will Miller manage? Based on the man’s character, rhetorical habits, and political priorities, it’s reasonable to assume he will lead in a combative and unapologetic direction, and in ways that may even surpass the already belligerent stance of the first two years of Trump’s second term. Miller has called critics of Trump’s tariffs “economically illiterate, historically illiterate, and probably functionally illiterate.” He has encouraged Fox News to fire its pollster, who showed that Trump’s tariffs were unpopular—and he did so during an appearance on Fox News. He has said Republicans should ignore the “panicans” who were worried about the Iran war. He has called Democrats the “jihad party.” And he called one senator’s criticisms of ICE’s brutality “unimaginably stupid,” all while proclaiming that the world is governed only by power.

    Encouraged by the departing lawmakers’ honesty about Miller’s appointment, I also asked Republicans whose Senate careers are still in the safe category if they were comfortable with the man Trump was placing at the wheel. The answers they gave me varied: Some seemed to be in denial, some refused to see the appointment as their concern, and others defended Miller’s character and record, even to a point of outright sycophancy.

    Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.), who just secured another six years in the Senate, told me bluntly, “The president decides who he wants as his chief of staff, and he does not ask us for permission.”

    Sen. James Lankford (R-Okla.) coauthored a bipartisan immigration reform bill in 2024 that Miller harshly condemned as a secret vehicle for “amnesty”; Lankford’s Republican colleagues ultimately tanked the legislation at Trump’s urging. Even so, the senior senator from Oklahoma dismissed the idea that Miller’s xenophobia presents a full picture of his personality and policy priorities, telling me, “Stephen is smart and tough, and he has the trust of the president.”

    “I think people should sit down and talk to him,” Lankford added. “Quite frankly, I find a lot of people unwilling to actually have a conversation with him. And people that can sit down and have a conversation with him will find a very different person.”

    Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-Ohio), who’s made a name for himself as an unshakeable Trump loyalist, said Miller’s appointment is a signal that the administration is ready for war.

    “It is definitely a period of reflection,” Moreno said. “We got our asses kicked. There’s no question about that, and there’s no candy-coating that. None of us should try to dance around that very fact.”

    “The president appointing Stephen Miller is pretty straightforward. It’s I think what Senator [John] Thune said today, which is if Democrats want to actually advance an affordability agenda and actually get things going for the American people and help the lives of working Americans and grow our middle class, I think Republicans are all in to help that,” Moreno added. “And if they wanna be idiots and put some of these crazy, socialist mantras in place and go back to Biden-era ridiculousness, then we need to go into the arena like gladiators. And that’s where Stephen Miller comes in.”

    Miller has steadily climbed the Trump ladder over the past decade while many of his fellow travelers have fallen into the political abyss from positions several rungs above him. His influence with the president has grown to a point that he has successfully pushed for multiple policies that have directly damaged the economy and sent Trump’s approval ratings through the floor. He’s now in a better position than ever to keep pushing.

    Share

    99 problems

    About a decade after it was founded, the Problem Solvers Caucus is on life support. The bipartisan centrist group’s Republican members suffered such devastating losses in the midterm elections that it is not clear how it will continue to function in the next Congress without a heavy recruiting push.

    Prior to the elections, the group’s roster boasted 43 members, with roughly equal proportions of Republicans and Democrats. After the once-in-a-generation Democratic wave crashed across the country last week, a dozen of the caucus’s Republican members have lost or are on track to lose when the final totals are announced. That means that just seven Republicans in the Problem Solvers Caucus will retain their seats in the 120th Congress, compared to nineteen Democrats.1 (Democratic exits from the caucus were purely the result of retirements; each Democratic caucus member who ran for re-election won.)

    “There’s churn on both sides, but certainly a lot more churn on the Republican side right now,” problem-solving Rep. Josh Harder (D-Calif.) told me Monday evening. “But as you know, in a divided government, there’s always members that are willing to work together, and I think there’s especially going to be an incentive for folks that are currently—or going to be—in the minority to find opportunities to build some bridges.”

    Unfortunately, the Problem Solvers will not be in a position to solve any problems until they figure out how to make up their losses heading into the new year. Any path forward for the caucus will need to include both a recruitment drive and a new strategic vision for how they might actually influence the House agenda.

    Harder noted, “I think there’s going to be a good recruiting push for sure on Problem Solvers and for those of us on [the Build America Caucus],2 as well.”

    “Time will tell, but I think we have to reconstitute,” Rep. Salud Carbajal (D-Calif.) told me. “A number of Republicans have to see the Problem Solvers as having value—as something that they wanna participate with and commit to because the mission of the Problem Solvers is something that they have to understand and commit to.”

    “Certainly, I think there’s hope,” the Democratic problem-solver added. “It’s just a matter of reconstituting and seeing how it plays out.”

    “That’s kind of the way that works, right?” said Rep. Blake Moore (R-Utah), one of the few Republicans in the caucus to survive the midterm elections with his career intact. “I mean, when the Dems lose the majority, they lose members of that committee, as well. It’s not unexpected.”

    Moore sounded a bit more defeated than his Democratic counterparts in the group, hinting that there will be little enthusiasm for their work from the GOP side.

    The Problem Solvers Caucus took its current form in 2017, growing out of earlier negotiations and organizing by the centrist organization No Labels.3 The caucus gains power to help steer the congressional agenda when partisan squabbling reaches critical levels, especially in the context of small margins between the majority and minority parties. But when House Democrats assume power in January, the size of their majority—they will have something like eighty-five more seats than Republicans—means they will have few incentives to reach across the aisle to join hands with their diminished and defeated opponents, whether problem solvers or not.

    Leave a comment

    Young forever

    On Monday, Senator-elect Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) celebrated his 74th birthday. He spent the day in freshman orientation alongside the several other Democrats who triumphed in last Tuesday’s wave elections.

    Brown was a bit out of place during these proceedings. He has either run for public office or held it during every election cycle since 1974, when Gerald Ford was in office. That’s a fifty-two-year career in politics, almost two decades of which he has spent as a senator. Perhaps the facilitators threw in some special tips and tricks to help enliven his orientation for the familiar role.

    I found the whole situation very amusing. I even posted that Brown must be feeling a bit like Billy Madison:

    When I caught up with the new-old senator later in the day on Monday, he told me that people kept sending him my post. As for what it’s like to be the big kid in class, Brown joked, “It’s kinda cool.”

    1

    I have included in the Republican tally a likely (but still uncalled) win by caucus member Maria Salazar (R-Fla.); she was leading at the time of writing.

    2

    The Build America Caucus is a newer group with a similar orientation to that of the Problem Solvers; it is also composed of centrist members of both parties. The midterm elections resulted in cuts to its Republican side, too.

    3

    No Labels is best known for its controversial and ultimately abortive campaign to recruit and run a third-party candidate for president in the 2024 election.

    0 min
  • Susan Glasser: POTUS’s Desperate Fight to Regain Leverage

    Trump’s loyalist foot soldiers in Congress are still sticking by him but the power of the presidency is ebbing away from him. He’s lost not only the leverage to broker a peace between Russia and Ukraine, the Iranians also saw the results of the midterms—which significantly undercuts Trump’s ability to negotiate a deal favorable to the US. Plus: Vance’s political future is evaporating before our eyes, Thune has been the weakest majority leader in decades, and Trump was clearly living in a delusionary bubble before the midterms (with the help of his giggling assistant).

    Susan Glasser joins Tim Miller.

    Leave a comment

    show notes:

    • Susan's column on the election results

    • The New Yorker’s ‘Political Scene’ podcast

    • The Bulwark store

    As always: Watch, listen, hit the like button or leave a comment. We want to hear from you.

    Ad-free editions of The Bulwark Daily are available exclusively for Bulwark+ members.

    Tim Miller’s Bulwark Daily is available wherever you get podcasts and on YouTube. New shows drop each weekday afternoon. If you like the show, leave a comment and ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ wherever you listen.

    Share

    Add The Bulwark Daily to your player of choice, here.

    Read more

    15 min
  • Watch the Moment a Math Teacher’s Former Students Realize He Won (w/ Jake Johnson)

    A high school math teacher just pulled off one of the most remarkable upsets of the midterms. Tim Miller talks with Minnesota Congressman-elect Jake Johnson, who ran a campaign staffed largely by his former students and flipped a district Republicans won by 17 points just two years ago. Johnson recounts the nail-biting election night, explains how his working-class upbringing shaped his politics, and lays out his plans to take on Trump’s tariffs, ICE, and Washington corruption.

    Video of the Jake Johnson victory party courtesy Brian Arola at MinnPost: https://www.facebook.com/reel/2127181301231774

    Leave a comment

    Read more

    0 min
  • The Dark Lesson From the Midterms
    (Photo illustration by Sarah Rogers/The Bulwark | Photos: Getty, Shutterstock)

    I waited a full week. You’re welcome. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    1. Normies

    Last Friday Jim VandeHei and Mike Allen—the CEO and executive editor of Axios, prominent journalists considered “thought leaders” in D.C. and beyond—had a message for America: Chill the eff out. We good!

    Voters were unambiguous on Tuesday: Don’t B.S. us. Don’t say you’ll lower prices and end wars and corruption, then do the opposite. It’s really that simple.

    • This isn’t so different from when Americans told Democrats not to B.S. them about Joe Biden’s health, or about the words they should use, or social behaviors they should adopt.

    Why it matters: Most Americans agree broadly on most things, most of the time. They want competent politicians to focus on issues that meaningfully impact their lives.

    • Like clockwork, every two years, Americans feel the party in power fails to deliver this — so they punish the incumbents at the polls.

    Politicians and some journalists tend to treat the American people as dopes and dupes who don’t get what’s happening in front of their faces. . . .

    In an age when people trust institutions less all the time, our institutions held. Courts restrained executive-branch excess. The press kept doing its job. Voters did theirs.

    • But for all the hand-wringing that America is crumbling, that democracy is fading, or elections are eroding, the system worked. Remember: most Americans are normal and resilient.

    • We should celebrate that. Despite it all, America works.

    Imagine getting drunk, driving your car off a cliff, crawling out of the burning wreckage missing your left arm, and saying,

    “I didn’t die? Well shit, Maynard! Let’s celebrate!”

    You can read the whole stupid thing if you want to—it’s only 600 words.1 But it’s nonsense designed to convince us that the last ten years were normal, that nothing dangerous took place, that nothing important has been broken, and that the people who spent the last decade fighting against Trump’s authoritarian attempt were overwrought alarmists.

    I’m seeing a lot of this sentiment out there from normie elites. So let’s take this Pollyanna bullshit apart, brick by brick. Because left unchallenged, it offers a dangerous, poisonous lesson.

    Read more

    0 min
  • Desperate Hegseth Lashes Out Amid Impeachment Efforts | Command Post

    Pete Hegseth is facing impeachment, and his response is to blame the media, attack Congress, and hide behind American troops. Ben Parker and Lt. Gen. Mark Hertling dissect Hegseth’s combative Pentagon press conference, his defense of controversial military operations, and his refusal to take responsibility for civilian casualties and questionable orders. They also examine how Hegseth has turned the job of Secretary of Defense into a partisan political operation, why he has failed to grow into the role, and what an impeachment fight could mean for the Pentagon.

    Leave a comment

    Read more

    23 min
  • The Wannabe Fascist Has Lost His Fastball

    As we were writing this newsletter, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth was on stage at the Pentagon, defending himself angrily against the “farce” and the “sabotage” of the impeachment effort against him. Too bad we can’t get it all in here—but that’s what Command Post is for. Lt. Gen. Mark Hertling and Ben Parker1 will be breaking it all down on Substack and YouTube momentarily at 9:30 a.m. EST—should be a fun time. Happy Tuesday.

    (Photo illustration by Sarah Rogers/The Bulwark | Photos: Getty)You Go to War, Stephen. I’m Busy Today.

    by Andrew Egger

    How much fight does Donald Trump have left in him? When the president elevated wartime consigliere Stephen Miller as his new chief of staff this weekend, it seemed he might be ready to snap out of his post-midterms doldrums, quit wandering around the White House grounds talking to nobody in particular about ballroom chandeliers, and go back to war on the left.

    But I’m not so sure. Trump may have given Miller the conn, but he showed zero indication yesterday that he’s ready to lock back in himself. Instead, he kept right on with his bizarre post-election hit parade with another sequence of wacky, dissociative distractions.

    First there was his election post. After a full week of glumly agreeing to accept the results of last week’s blue tsunami, Trump suddenly swerved back into full-on election denial yesterday: “Does anybody really believe that this ‘Election’ was honest. How could the Polls be so wrong???” he wrote on Truth Social. “Some early voting ‘dumps’ were so large that it was impossible to win, no matter how many people went to vote. It’s all about the machines, which are far more important than the voter!”

    This is sad stuff, even by Trump’s own election-posting standards. Back in 2020, the stolen-election claims were built on a mountain of supposed evidence, even if it was all fabricated and conspiratorial.2 Today, he’s got nada—no eyewitness testimony, no grainy video footage, not even a theory of how Democrats might possibly have stolen elections right out from under the watchful eye of the Republican governments of Kansas, South Carolina, Texas, Mississippi, and so on.3 He isn’t even mobilizing his government to try to do anything about it. He’s just complaining online.

    You can do more than just complain online. You can join our pro-democracy community today!

    Trump is bringing this new, toothless energy everywhere these days. Yesterday afternoon, he called an impromptu press conference in the White House briefing room—where he was joined, surreally, by UFC CEO Dana White, a guy he is unsuccessfully lobbying to make his press secretary. White took questions from several of the goofball MAGA ringers Trump has sprinkled through the White House press pool, including Lindell TV’s Cara Castronuova, who asked whether Trump or Joe Biden would win in a UFC Octagon showdown. To his credit, White seemed faintly embarrassed by the question.

    Over the weekend, Trump had posted a fever-dream AI-generated clip of a cartoon White in the briefing room, ordering his UFC fighters to clobber the snot out of pencilneck lib reporters. He returned to this theme at the briefing: “Dana is really very unique,” Trump said, smiling. “The only problem is he’ll talk for a little while and then he’s going to beat the hell out of you.”

    The joke (can we call it that?) was in keeping with his decade of dangerous enemy-of-the-people rhetoric about the press. But here, too, the tone was bizarre: He played it as a laugh line, and got some bewildered laughs in the room.

    And the awkward laughs kept coming. Last night, Trump gave a surprise interview on—of all places—Washington Journal, CSPAN’s low-budget political call-in show. The show had no advance warning; Trump just showed up on the call-in line. As CSPAN’s bewildered anchor brought him on, the first thing you could hear was a woman (Natalie Harp? Stephen Miller?) giggling loudly on Trump’s line. Then he was off and running on his normal litany of campaign-trail grievances—all seemingly delivered, not with anger or frustration, but with a strange cheery calm.

    Actually, the word that springs to mind watching Trump do anything these days—even the ostensibly alarming stuff, like calling for elections to be overturned or joking about violence against the press—is “nostalgia.” The president seems, for the moment, to have given up on actually making stuff happen. Instead, he’s going on a personally relaxing trip down memory lane. Remember when we did stop the steal? Remember when I used to go to war against the press? Remember all those times on the campaign trail I talked about other countries emptying their prisons and asylums and sending us their inmates? Boy, those were the days, weren’t they? We had fun, huh?

    At any point, one still assumes, Trump could still snap out of this fugue and pick up his weapons again. Whether or not he does, we’ve still got Stephen Miller to contend with. Unlike Trump, Miller has gotten right to work consolidating power in the building: His wife, Katie Miller, has spent the last few days ending her various business entanglements that had, until last week, led Miller to recuse himself from specific policy issues.

    But even Miller is less dangerous so long as Trump remains in this strange, punch-drunk state. All these pointless press conferences and unexpected call-ins—all snap spur-of-the-moment decisions from the president himself—point to a White House that simply isn’t functioning right now. The opposition just won a massive victory and is mobilizing quickly around it, while Republicans wait uneasily for their leader to emerge from his cocoon of nostalgia and give them marching orders. What choice do they have? They’ve long since forgotten how to function without him.

    Nvidious

    by William Kristol

    It’s not just a sex scandal. It’s a spy scandal.

    In fact, it’s not just a spy scandal. It’s a national security scandal, one that directly involves the president of the United States.

    One of the many striking features of the big New York Times report over the weekend on Jensen Huang, Nvidia, and Donald Trump, was the amount of information the Times was able to get from well-informed sources in or near the government. They were presumably shocked or horrified at the behavior of this administration and president. And as the scandal has exploded, we’ve already had important additional reporting and lots of helpful analysis online by individuals knowledgeable about intelligence matters, export controls, the tech world, U.S.–China relations, and much else.

    But here’s the core of what we know:

    Donald Trump’s national security council, drawing on information produced by our intelligence community, produced a classified memo this past spring warning that the chief executive of the huge chip maker Nvidia, Jensen Huang, was in a close relationship with a Chinese spy, Alice Huang (no relation to Jensen), a Chinese citizen who had been recruited by China’s Ministry of State Security. Jensen Huang has been a major donor to Trump, an adviser to Trump on AI policy, and an opponent of attempts to limit the sale of advanced chips to China.

    The memo warning of Huang’s relationship with a Chinese spy was circulated at the highest levels of the administration. Presumably because of concerns about Huang’s connection to the spy, he was initially not invited to join his fellow top tech executives on the president’s trip to China in May. The media noticed the omission of Huang at the time, and so did the president, who personally intervened to invite Huang to join the trip, which he did at Air Force One’s stopover in Alaska. Trump wrote on social media that it was an honor to have “the Great Jensen Huang” joining other executives on the trip.

    So at this point Trump had been briefed about the electronic surveillance of Alice Huang, about her relationship with Jensen Huang; about the fact that her company, Megaspeed, was helping smuggle restricted advanced Nvidia chips into China; and about the fact that she was working for China’s intelligence services. He nonetheless invited Jensen Huang on the trip, and has since continued to host him to the White House for functions both public and private. Trump apparently continues to solicit his advice, and often to follow it.

    As the Times put it,

    Few executives have had as much sway over Mr. Trump’s approach to A.I. and China as Mr. Huang. Last year, Mr. Huang persuaded the president to roll back a ban on chip sales to China. The two later struck a deal letting Nvidia sell its second-most powerful chip there, with the U.S. government taking a 25 percent cut. Nvidia has donated at least $20 million to Mr. Trump’s ballroom fund.

    We also learn from the Times that a major Commerce Department investigation into Alice Huang’s company, Megaspeed, was derailed at the order of a senior Trump political appointee who reports directly to Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, Trump’s good friend and partner in so many business enterprises.

    There are many further angles to this story, and many threads to pull. But it’s already clear that this is not merely a story of cronyism or favoritism or even corruption. The president knew our national security was being compromised. He chose to do nothing. Indeed, he chose to do worse than nothing. He chose to stay in close contact with the individual who was at the center of the scandal, engaging in conversations that were presumably reported back to the Chinese government, and taking advice from someone who was compromised by a hostile foreign power.

    President Trump is scheduled to meet in a few days with Chinese President Xi Jinping. At this moment one can have no confidence that the president will be putting America’s national security interests ahead of his personal financial interests—or ahead of China’s interests.

    Surely it has to be a top priority for Congress to investigate this matter. And this can’t be something that waits for the new Democratic Congress. The good news is that it does look as if there will be at least the beginning of scrutiny in the current lame-duck session of the 119th Congress. We’ve seen demands for private briefings from the administration and Nvidia. We’ve also seen, for example, a joint statement from Sens. Jim Banks (R.-Ind.) and Elizabeth Warren (D.-Mass.) calling attention to the “urgent” national security concerns and “important” questions about Nvidia and China, and calling for Congress to take “decisive” legislative action now.

    This is the moment for Congress, the media, and others with the ability to investigate to step up. This is the moment for patriots in or near the government and in or near Nvidia to come forward. Because we really do need to know the facts.

    We need to know about the roles of various senior administration officials in this scandal. We need to know what they knew, when they knew it, and what they did or didn’t do.

    But above all, of course, we need to know what the president knew, when he knew it, and why he ignored what he knew. Why did Trump do nothing? Did he not believe the findings of his intelligence community and his national security council? Was he inattentive to those findings? Did he simply not care? Or did he intend to be helpful to Xi and the government of communist China, at the expense of the United States?

    AROUND THE BULWARK
    • A Republic, If We Can Fix It… It’s a new day. Trump’s defeat deserves celebration. But the institutions that enabled him still need fixing, argues MONA CHAREN.

    • Trump’s Electoral Fraud Claims Are Now Evidence-Proof… He’s got a story for any scenario, from lies about early votes to prevarication about polls, observes WILL SALETAN.

    • Pete Hegseth’s Failure to Learn… Even members of his own party have become dissatisfied with his performance, writes MARK HERTLING.

    • Can Democrats Finish Off MAGA for Good? NEERA TANDEN thinks so and makes her case to CATHERINE RAMPELL on Receipts. Plus, billionaire investor JOHN ARNOLD joins to explain why Trump’s attacks on clean energy are driving up costs.

    • This Is the Trump Flailing Phase… BILL KRISTOL joins TIM MILLER on The Bulwark Daily to review his pre-election hopium levels and discuss how Trump’s trying to respond to the electoral shellacking.

    QUICK HITS

    HERDING CATS: Three years ago, a basically unknown member of House GOP leadership named Mike Johnson became speaker of the House almost by default after Republicans—who had tried and failed to elect three other senior Republicans to the post—united around him out of sheer exhaustion. Now, Johnson is shuffling off the scene, and the grumpy, bedraggled klatch of GOP lawmakers who remain after last week’s drubbing will pick their new slate of leaders. “Somebody’s got to get fired,” Rep. Marlin Stutzman told Politico, “because we got our butts handed to us.”

    Once again, it’s shaping up to be an inside-outside sort of fight. Rep. Jim Jordan, a conservative favorite who has never served in House leadership, is running against Rep. Steve Scalise, who has been the No. 2 or 3 Republican in the House since 2014—but never the top dog. And the fight is breaking down along the same old lines as usual: Jordan arguing that a truly conservative House GOP has never been tried, Scalise arguing that he’s a battle-tested leader who brings strong fundraising chops to the table.

    We won’t see a repeat of 2023’s torture chamber: While elections for speaker require a majority of the entire House, the Jordan–Scalise faceoff will require only a majority of the Republican conference. Still, it will be an interesting indication of which direction the GOP winds are blowing.

    TRUMP BACKS PETE: It’s funny how these things go: Pete Hegseth is under the gun because of his stewardship of the disastrous Iran war, but it may turn out that getting impeached in an effort led by Rep. Thomas Massie ended up the best thing that ever happened to him. That’s because, however unhappy Trump is with how the war has gone, he still seems angrier at Massie’s Epstein Files betrayal. “Yes, I’ll stand by [Hegseth],” Trump told reporters at yesterday’s press conference. Why? Because Massie is “a stone cold loser” with “a lot of hatred in his heart.”

    “I don’t want to waste my time watching him,” Trump went on. “We won two wars, and we’ve made the world a lot safer place, and then we’re supposed to be impeached?”

    Trump then headed to Truth Social to reiterate the point: “Pete Hegseth gets an “A” PLUS, PLUS, PLUS for his defense against a disgruntled, angry, defeated, former Congressman, Thomas Massie, a TOTAL LOSER!”

    Join now

    CHEAP SHOTS

    The Bulwark brings you the reporting you just won’t see elsewhere:

    Join now

    1

    Correction (10:45 a.m. EST Nov. 10 2026): Deputy Managing Editor Ben Parker’s name was misspelled as “Ben Parler” in the topper for this morning's newsletter. Ben edits Morning Shots, so we find this particularly amusing.

    2

    Villainous NGOs “muling” absentee ballots to drop boxes! It was fishy overnight “ballot dumps” in Detroit! Poll workers secretly swapping in bags of phony ballots in Atlanta!

    3

    Imagine the conspiracy:

    Chuck Schumer: “Hey, Gov. Abbott, I’m going to need you to have Ken Paxton lose this race. Oh, but you’ve got to lose, too—otherwise it’ll seem too suspicious.”

    Greg Abbott: “Makes total sense, Chuck. Happy to take one for the team.”

    0 min
  • A Republic, If We Can Fix It
    (Photo by Gary Hershorn/Getty Images)

    THOUGH LAST TUESDAY’S smashing Democratic victory was unlike anything we’ve seen in our lifetimes, perhaps the most striking thing is that on the morning after, it all felt so reassuringly normal. The election went forward at tens of thousands of polling places. Hundreds of thousands of election workers and volunteers did their jobs. Citizens did theirs. No ICE goons loitered menacingly at polling places. There was no declaration of a state of emergency. There were no significant claims of cheating, illegal immigrants voting, or late-night ballot dumps. The speaker of the House didn’t contrive a way to avoid certifying the victors. No major lawsuits were filed. The polls seemed to be more or less correct.

    The victory speeches, at least the ones I saw, were gracious, and the concessions rapid and unambiguous. As the Noah-level flood engulfed Republicans, Trump was asked whether he would accept the results. He said yes. (Though he has, more recently, begun to suggest otherwise.)

    This is not the America we’ve been forced to live in for the past decade. It more resembles the country we feared we had lost just two years ago. For me, the most moving scenes Tuesday night were the temporary memorials to Alex Pretti and Renée Good festooned with “I Voted” stickers. The movement to preserve American democracy has martyrs now—and it has millions of adherents. Or does it? We’ll come back to that.

    Share

    First, though, we deserve some joy along with the relief, and the electorate provided that in spades. The voters freed this country from what has felt, for many years now, like a doom loop. We seemed permanently polarized, trapped in a never-ending cycle of close elections decided by a few swing states, gerrymandered up the wazoo, consuming different news, seemingly living in different realities, and goaded by demagogues into senseless hatred. The 2026 election shattered that hamster wheel. True reform is now possible. And some of the worst political actors got what they had coming.

    Vivek Ramaswamy, who managed something that no other Republican (despite some valiant efforts) has been able to achieve—namely, to go lower than Trump—was defeated by 8 points in the Ohio gubernatorial race. Elon Musk, who moved to Texas to savor its MAGA musk and spent almost $190 million attempting to elect the election-denying philanderer Ken Paxton, was handed his hat (the politest formulation).

    Trump’s handpicked candidate in South Carolina was defeated by the physician Annie Andrews after a campaign in which MAGA coined the oh-so-witty nickname “Tranny Annie.” Bo French, the GOP candidate for the influential Texas Railroad Commission, had the sort of bigoted history that has become table stakes in the Republican party. In 2023, he posted an online poll asking who was a bigger threat to America, “Muslims or Jews?” In March, he declared that the United States should deport a hundred million people. In September, he followed up with an image of cheering UT football fans who had a bit too much melanin for his taste. “Americans have been displaced by foreigners,” French whined. He was “displaced” by Democrat Jon Rosenthal, who won the commission role with the support of Republicans Karl Rove, Fort Worth Mayor Mattie Parker, and George W. Bush (who somehow woke up from a decade’s snooze). Also in Texas, Brandon Herrera, a YouTube something-or-other who showed off an original copy of Mein Kampf and bragged about membership in the Sons of Confederate Veterans, was defeated for Congress by Katy Padilla Stout.

    You could go on all day—Greg Abbott is gone, along with Scott Perry (one of the architects of the January 6th attempted putsch). Lauren Boebert has been shown the door. And for poetic justice, it’s hard to beat Scott Colom’s story. A successful Mississippi prosecutor, Colom was nominated for a federal judgeship by President Joe Biden. One of Mississippi’s senators, Roger Wicker, raised no objection (by tradition, senators can block nominees from their states). But the other, Cindy Hyde-Smith, refused to issue the required blue slip, and thereby blocked Colom’s nomination. If his current lead in the vote count holds, then come next year it’s Colom who will be handling the blue slips, thank you very much.

    Join now

    IT’S A NEW DAY, but let’s think about whether the results represent a total rejection of Trumpism. As much as I’d like to believe that, I’m afraid we’ve seen too much in the past ten years to conclude that with confidence. Americans re-elected Trump despite his 2022 call to “terminate” the Constitution to return him to office; despite January 6th and his approval of the mob that attempted to murder his vice president; despite his cordial meeting with a neo-Nazi; despite his theft of highly classified documents; despite his tragic mismanagement of the pandemic that included idiotic musings about injecting disinfectant; despite his embrace of QAnon cranks; despite his corruption; despite his admiration for Vladimir Putin; and despite his promise of mass deportations.

    Americans were okay with all of it until it pinched their pocketbooks. Since the start of Trump’s second term, I have rooted for the tariffs to be implemented fully because I figured that that was the only way to make a large majority regret what they’d done in 2024. Voters needed to touch the stove, as they say. I didn’t anticipate the Iran debacle, which taught the same lesson.

    IT’S A NEW DAY, but Trump’s actions and statements in the immediate aftermath of the election should not be misinterpreted as signals of any sort of mellowing. Stalin hid in his dacha for a while after Hitler invaded Russia. Sometimes autocrats need time to lick their wounds. Now, Trump can soothe his eggshell ego by rationalizing that Republicans can’t win without his golden name—a claim he made on Tuesday night—despite declaring for the previous four weeks that he was on the ballot. Still, he won’t lead a mob to the Capitol on behalf of his party. That would be extending himself for others. He doesn’t do that.

    Share The Bulwark

    IT’S A NEW DAY, but we’ve learned in the past ten years that key segments of American society do not uphold the law or even basic decency. Trump 2.0 could not have taken the dark turn that it did had key institutions in American society not enabled it. Yes, tens of millions of Americans did reject MAGA and all its ugly works, but they were not a majority in 2024.

    Are they now? Probably not. The majority sent a message that it hates the high prices, hates the poorly conceived and arguably illegally waged war in Iran, hates the overreach on immigration enforcement (while liking the closed border), and hates the corruption.

    Democrats seem to have gotten that message loud and clear, but without the White House, their capacity to make policy is limited—at least for now. Much of what they accomplish before 2028 will be signals of the direction a Democratic government would go. One hopes that most will join Senator-elect Adam Hamilton in supporting the repeal of most of Trump’s tariffs, though that will require some Democrats to abandon an earlier hostility to free trade. They should jump at it. Reducing tariffs is one of the only ways to bring down prices without a recession. And Trump has done Democrats the favor of convincing more than 60 percent of voters that tariffs are bad. In January, Congress can pass legislation repealing the president’s broad tariff authority.

    Ending the war on immigrants is not only the right policy morally; it’s also practical. Home prices have risen in part because undocumented immigrants represent a significant share of homebuilders. Meatpackers have also been decimated by ICE raids. Trump promised to deport the worst of the worst but instead hounded the hard-working and law-abiding. The result was shameful human suffering and scarcer, pricier new homes combined with higher food prices. Once again, Trump has set the table for Democrats by convincing voters that mass deportation is both a moral stain and a practical disaster. Another layup for Democrats (provided they keep the border under control).

    Now the challenge will be to solidify the anti-Trump backlash into permanent reforms that will insulate us from a return to strongman rule.

    Fortunately, the Democrats’ majority is large enough that we can entertain serious reforms like amending the Constitution to limit the president’s power. One place to start is the limitless pardon power, which permits a lawless president to order subordinates to do illegal acts. Another is a constitutional amendment overriding the presidential immunity decision Trump v. United States. Impeachment turned out to be a failure. Constitutional amendment, perhaps?

    But above all, we must remind ourselves, perhaps with better civics classes and more focused attention in the culture, of the preciousness of the rule of law, federalism, and accountability. November 3 was a great day for the Democrats. It can yet be a turning point in stabilizing our 250-year-old nation.

    To comment, join Bulwark+

    0 min