
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


“Such is the condition of humanity, and so uncertain is men’s judgment, that they cannot determine even death itself.” - Pliny the Elder
In the 18th and 19th centuries, a specter haunted the minds of the living—it lingered in limbo, where darkness weighs heavy, and the air is thin.
If found in its confines, no course of action nor thrash of panic could save you. You were as good as dead.
How morbid it must be to realize the very reason you’re trapped in this nightmare at all is because everyone you know already believes you to be dead— entombed in a world where the line between life and the grave is weaker than your last gasp of breath.
Your fate echoes above the tolling of the church bells or the screams of the undead. You’ve just been buried alive.
I’m Kate Naglieri. Welcome to The Bygone Society Show.
Death is Uncertain - Proverb
Legal death was once a murky concept. It was not based on the certainties of modern medicine but on practices that often…faltered.
You have to remember, Traditional Western Medicine of the 18th century gave way to the tentative strides of Early Modern Medicine in the 19th century, but both were built on the bones of stolen bodies – thanks to the common practice of grave-robbing – as well as morally-questionable experimentation, and rudimentary practices.
Coupled with frequent epidemics like cholera, smallpox and influenza, and a thick sense of superstition, mortality stalked the populace like a silent and ever-present predator.
The fear of being buried alive gripped the collective consciousness, as science struggled to distinguish life versus its dark twin – where anyone, regardless of age or gender or standing, could be found in its cold resting place.
The Universal Terror of Premature Burial
Taphophobia, or the fear of being buried alive because of incorrectly being pronounced dead, was a common fear, even among the historically famous.
First President of the United States George Washington was so fearful of being prematurely buried that he instructed his secretary Tobias Lear while on his deathbed, saying: “Have me decently buried; and do not let my body be put into the Vault in less than three days after I am dead.”
Washington wasn’t alone in his fears. Edgar Allan Poe, the Master of Macabre, feared premature burial so much, he wrote the Gothic short story, The Premature Burial.
I love a no-frills title.
Here’s a passage that vividly illustrates Poe’s imagined experience of being buried alive:
“It may be asserted, without hesitation, that no event is so terribly well adapted to inspire the supremeness of bodily and of mental distress, as is burial before death. The unendurable oppression of the lungs -- the stifling fumes from the damp earth -- the clinging to the death garments -- the rigid embrace of the narrow house -- the blackness of the absolute Night -- the silence like a sea that overwhelms -- the unseen but palpable presence of the Conqueror Worm.”
Frequent references to premature burial in literary works embedded the concept deeply into societal consciousness, turning it into a naturalized element of Gothic culture and conversation.
For example, Washington Irving’s “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow,” features the Headless Horseman, a ghost of a Hessian soldier who was buried alive.
Or take the Tale of Enoch Crosby, a spy for the Continental Army during the American Revolutionary War, who was captured and buried alive by the British. According to legend, he managed to escape his grave and continued to serve as a spy.
And then there’s the true story of Margorie McCall, a woman from Lurgan, Ireland. She fell ill with a fever and was declared dead in the late 17th century. She was buried swiftly to prevent the spread of disease, and was interred wearing a valuable ring that grave robbers set out to steal.
When the robbers attempted to remove the ring by cutting off Margorie’s finger, she awoke from her cataleptic state, terrifying the robbers and causing them to flee. Margorie then climbed out of her coffin and returned home, shocking her grieving husband and children. She lived for many years after, and even had another child.
Her final resting place famously reads, "Lived Once, Buried Twice."
The Great 'Dead' Watch: When Legends and Laws Intertwined
Stories and legends hold a great deal of power and are often used to shape new policies.
As the fear of premature burial came to a cultural crescendo, early activism emerged to prevent accidental, and sometimes careless, tragedies.
A mid-18th century thesis, written by Danish-born French anatomist Jacob Winslow and translated and augmented by French physician Jean-Jacques Bruhier, describes 181 cases of people presumed to be dead who rose from “their Shrowds, their Coffins, and even from their Graves.”
Bruhier and Winslow’s dissertation alerted the public, carrying the strong and odorous message that putrefaction was the only sure sign of death.
Which takes us, dear listener, inside the dim and somber walls of the deadhouse.
Designed to ensure bodies showed no signs of life, deadhouses were a type of waiting room that addressed the fear of premature burial by waiting and watching dead bodies for up to 72 hours as they decomposed.
These large rooms featured functional furniture, good ventilation, and sometimes alarm systems, allowing family members or hired personnel to keep vigil. The decor was often dark and muted, providing privacy and comfort for those observing the deceased.
Deadhouses could be found all over the world. Take, for instance, the Leichenhaus in Germany, also known as “asylums for doubtful life,” which surfaced between 1800 and the 1830s.
Travel due west to Paris or due east to Vienna and you would have found “waiting mortuaries.”
At one time, the Morgue de Paris, could accommodate up to 180 bodies visible through glass windows. What was intended to ensure death and assist family members in identifying lost loved ones, the Morgue de Paris soon became a popular morbid spectacle, attracting hordes of onlookers of all ages; men, women, the elderly, even children pressed their faces to the glass that separated them from the deceased laid out in various states of repose.
The morgue soon transformed into a grim and unsettling interrogation room, where confronting one's victims unfolded like a chilling scene from your favorite crime show. However, in the mid-19th century, this drama could be witnessed live.
Authorities frequently escorted suspected murderers to the crowded morgue to stand face-to-face with their victims, hoping the sight would elicit confessions. By 1888, they had electric lights installed in the morgue to heighten the impact on perpetrators facing their handiwork. The intense glow intensified these harrowing confrontations, compelling the guilty to reckon with their deadly deeds.
Saved by the Bell: And Other Methods to Prevent Premature Burial
In contrast to the dramatic displays at the morgue, Victorian doctors approached their work with a methodical and increasingly scientific approach. Equipped with sparse but essential medical instruments, these physicians relied on observations and tests to determine the cause and time of death.
Victorian doctors employed instruments like the stethoscope, thermometer, and ophthalmoscope to gather clinical evidence. The stethoscope enabled them to listen for vital signs, the thermometer to measure body temperature, and the ophthalmoscope to examine the retina for telltale signs of decomposition. For more detailed investigations, a hypodermic syringe was used to test for responses such as inflammation to ammonia injections, while a magnesium lamp aided in detecting signs of circulation in the extremities.
But no one test or si…
When you take a look at our longstanding history, mankind can point to endless examples of our march towards progress and daring endeavors.
We’ve risen from the ashes like a Phoenix, emerged from the depths of oppression, and brought in new dawns upon vast empires. The rise of great people and civilizations makes for an uplifting and even ego-affirming tale.
But what of their inevitable downfall?
On the flip side of our ancient coin, we see just as many examples of when humankind couldn’t hack it, for lack of a better term. It’s curious that our retellings of our own declines are distilled into one metaphorical reasoning.
Whether stabbed in the back by a friend, or wiped out by foreign diseases, it would seem that every civilization, every community and every person has their own achilles heel.
Including one of America’s oldest colonies.
The colony of Roanoke, which predates the English settlement at Jamestown, Virginia in 1607, took root on an island off the eastern seaboard of North America, in modern day North Carolina.
This settlement would have become the inaugural English colony in the New World. But it never did.
‘Why?’ You ask. ‘What led them to their end?’
Well, that’s the thing. We don’t know.
I’m Kate Naglieri. Welcome to The Bygone Society Show.
In the misty, rolling hills and deep hollows of Appalachia, is a land steeped in rich tradition and enduring tales.
But make no mistake; these are not mere stories; they are the lifeblood of this place, a deep-rooted connection that transcends time, binding its people to the land and the secrets it holds.
The significance of these age-old tales lies in their power to reflect the hopes, fears, and resilience of a people.
Through storytelling, they've preserved their history, struggles, and dreams. And at times, even their worst nightmares.
I’m Kate Naglieri, welcome to The Bygone Society Show
Picture this…
You’re in a dimly lit room. There’s a hushed gathering of mourners.
The air is heavy with the scent of tears and smoldering incense, its tendrils of gray smoke curling like a restless spirit.
At the center of the room is a solitary figure, he’s cloaked in tattered garments and kneeling beside a crude wooden table.
On it, is a woman, recently deceased. She’s holding a plate of crusty bread upon her chest.
The cloaked, and kneeling man reaches for the bread and eats it. He then reaches for a glass of wine beside him, and drinks it.
In this solemn communion, the man has just absorbed the sins of the departed, taking on her transgressions as his own.
The woman’s soul was set free. But the man remained as he always had— called upon only when the world craved absolution, and then promptly shunned… for being a sin eater.
According to Brewer’s Dictionary of Phrase & Fable, sin eaters were poor people hired at funerals in olden days to eat beside the corpse, taking on the sins of the deceased, so that the soul might be delivered from Purgatory.
Commonly practiced in the British Isles in the 17th, 18th and 19th-century, it might be difficult for us to believe there was ever a time where the town pariah could absolve you of all your wrongdoings.
Perhaps even more difficult to believe knowing that 54% of Americans between the ages of 13-38 years old dream of becoming a social media influencer.
But dig a bit deeper, and take a closer look…you’ll find many a modern-day, unsung hero – be it sanitation workers, caregivers, or call center operators – toiling away.
You see, both groups perform gritty and underappreciated tasks for the greater good. Just like sin-eaters of yore, today’s essential workers valiantly navigate irate customers, grueling hours, and chronic stress for very little in return.
It's a painful parallel – the realization that the more things change, the more they stay the same.
Join us as we unravel the tales of sin-eaters, and discover the rituals, beliefs, and profound impact they had on the communities they served.
I’m Kate Naglieri. Welcome to The Bygone Society Show, episode 10: The Bearer of Burdens.
There are certain places that emerge as profound markers in history, anchoring the narratives of generations past and of those yet to come.
These places are more than just geographical coordinates on a map; they’re repositories of memory, vessels of experience, and a type of conduit for the stories of humanity.
Today’s profound marker in history lies in the heart of New York City; The Bowery is not just a well-known thoroughfare; it's a living tome that holds the heartbreak and hope of countless souls.
From ancient ruins to bustling city streets…from serene landscapes to battlegrounds of conflict, places…like The Bowery…beckon us to explore the past.
And when we do, we gain a lot!
We preserve our collective memory, respect identities and cultures, avoid past mistakes, appreciate how far we’ve come and realize that bygone eras rarely stay in the past.
I’m Kate Naglieri…welcome to The Bygone Society Show.
The sea is a captivating and unpredictable force. It offers abundant resources, sustenance, and trade routes to countless civilizations throughout history, fostering prosperity, cultural exchange and reprieve.
But it also demands respect. The sea’s duality serves as a reminder of nature’s power, and the delicate balance between human dependence on its bounty and the need to approach it with humility and reverence.
The two stories I have to share with you today exemplify the age-old saying: The sea giveth and the sea taketh away.
I’m Kate Naglieri. Welcome to The Bygone Society Show.
Women and water. What is it about “women and water” that holds such power over the whole of society?
There’s a mystique that has fascinated us…petrified us…drawn us in.
Water as a traditional symbol of femininity is an ancient theme that dominates literature and the arts in nearly every corner of the earth.
From the Japanese swan maidens to Disney’s lagoon-loving mermaids, tales of women and water abound.
There are three main tropes you’re sure to find if you crack open enough books or watch enough movies:
The first is the tale of the drowning girl. For me, the 2002 American psychological horror film, The Ring, based on Koji Suzuki’s 1991 novel by the same name, comes to mind.
The second trope is woman as a wild and powerful force born from nature. One example is Mera, queen of Atlantis, from DC Comics.
And finally, the alluring and aquatic spirit. I think of The Birth of Venus, an iconic Italian Renaissance painting by Sandro Boticelli, which depicts the beautiful goddess emerging from a half shell, much like a pearl.
She is but one alluring creature to emerge from Earth’s underwater world, a place that holds and hides many of our world’s greatest mysteries.
I’m Kate Naglieri. Welcome to The Bygone Society Show.
In part one of Radium Girls, we found out that U.S. Radium Corporation in New Jersey commissioned an independent study to test the effects of chronic radium exposure, only after hundreds of young women working as dial painters fell ill and died.
The study’s results were clear: The workers were suffering and dying from radium poisoning. But U.S. Radium refused the findings, hiding the results from the public eye, and more importantly, from their own employees.
Instead, they conducted additional studies that ensured different, false findings that claimed radium was safe. They even went as far as to hire a Columbia University industrial toxicologist to pose as a physician and falsify the womens’ medical examinations, formally declaring they were experiencing an outbreak of syphilis.
There was little public and financial support for community health control programs when it came to treating venereal diseases. In America, syphilis was the scarlet letter of the early 1900s, much like AIDS in the ‘80s and ‘90s.
The scheme was meant to shame the women into silence.
But thanks to the tenacity of Grace Fryer and Catherine Donahue, these women eventually found their fighting voice.
I'm Kate Naglieri. Welcome to The Bygone Society Show.
There was a time, exactly 100 years ago, when the naturally occurring radioactive metal — radium — was thought to be a medical marvel that promised restored health, the eradication of cancer and a youthful glow to boot.
Its safety was tested by scientists, its use cases vouched and recommended by doctors. And yet nothing could have been further from the truth.
Today’s story is a cautionary tale against “the end-all and be-all cure.” It shines a light on corporate greed, and exposes the dangers in blind trust.
It’s a tale as old as time. And yet, we still find ourselves trusting, believing. Maybe because it’s easier to believe stories that make you feel safe.
This is not that story.
I’m Kate Naglieri. Welcome to The Bygone Society Show.
Show notes:
The Radium Girls: And Illinois Tragedy
https://www.nprillinois.org/equity-justice/2018-01-25/the-radium-girls-an-illinois-tragedy
Brittanica (radium chemical element)
https://www.britannica.com/science/radium
The Radium Girls: A Tale of Workplace Safety
https://sites.law.duq.edu/juris/2019/12/01/the-radium-girls-a-tale-of-workplace-safety/
The National Bureau of Standards and the Radium Dial Painters
https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/jres/126/jres.126.051.pdf
Mae Keane, One of the Last Radium 'Radium Girls' Dies at 107
https://www.npr.org/2014/12/28/373510029/saved-by-a-bad-taste-one-of-the-last-radium-girls-dies-at-107
Radium City documentary (available on Vimeo)
Washington State Department of Health – Office of Radiation Protection - Radium-226 (Ra-226) Fact Sheet
The Hartford Republican news clipping (1926)
https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn86069313/1920-10-22/ed-1/seq-3/#words=Radium%2B%2Bradium%2B%2Bradium%2B
On May 8, 1902, Mont Pelée, an active volcano that formed the north end of the island of Martinique, erupted, engulfing the city of Saint-Pierre in superheated gas, ash and rock in just three minutes.
The swift and sudden explosion would turn out to be the deadliest in the twentieth century.
To quote Dr. Ian Malcolm (played by actor and certified genius Jeff Goldblum in Jurassic Park): "Life finds a way," even in the harshest conditions, and when all seems lost. Today's story demonstrates that theory, even if how we survive is a little absurd.