Today, we pull out a classic episode where we sit down with Zachary Wagner to discuss his book Non-Toxic Masculinity: Recovering Healthy Male Sexuality. Zachary was ordained for gospel ministry in 2022 and has over a decade of nonprofit leadership experience. He lives just outside Chicago in an intentional community with his wife, three kids, and two additional housemates. He also serves as the editorial director of the Center for Pastor Theologians, where he co-hosts the CPT Podcast. 

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Rarely does a conversation cut this deeply into one of modern society's most ignored crises. Joe Bartosch and Robert Jessel join Dr. Ryan Willert and Pastor Mike Wrigglesworth to discuss their book Pornocracy, a term they use to describe a system quietly reshaping beliefs about self-image, gender, and relationships in ways most people never stop to examine.

The numbers and patterns they describe are genuinely unsettling. Increased cosmetic surgery among young women, declining birth rates, and children exposed to extreme content by their early teens point to something larger than individual choices. The authors introduce the concept of "limbic capitalism," explaining how platforms deliberately exploit the brain's reward system, serving progressively extreme content as people become desensitized. Proteins like Delta-FosB physically harden neural pathways (which means these patterns become genuinely difficult to reverse over time).

What does it mean when society stops stigmatizing things that cause real harm? That question sits at the heart of everything Bartosch and Jessel are arguing. They also address the manosphere, school sex education, the consent debate, and OnlyFans, connecting these threads into a broader cultural picture.

Honestly, this conversation covers ground that most people avoid covering entirely. Tune in to hear the full discussion.

CHAPTERS:

00:00:02 - Introducing Pornocracy: A Critical Conversation

00:01:54 - Pornography's Impact on Society and Relationships

00:08:39 - Porn Platforms Use Addiction Tactics Like Social Media

00:12:24 - Pornography's Neurochemical Effects on the Brain

00:16:42 - Social Media Insecurity and Self-Commodification in Youth

00:19:21 - Pornography's Impact on Children and Parental Strategies

00:22:37 - Protecting Children from Digital Devices

00:26:50 - Patriarchy, Pornography, and Male Objectification

00:30:28 - Humanity, Vulnerability, and Education System Concerns

00:33:51 - The Problem With Sex Education in Schools

00:36:33 - Consent Culture and Porn Industry Exploitation

00:40:30 - Consent Alone Isn't Sufficient

00:44:13 - Pornography's Power: Institutional Blindness and Complicity

00:47:25 - Trading Joy for Pleasure: Porn's Impact

00:51:02 - Money vs Power: The Dark Truth Behind Online Exploitation

00:53:11 - Rebuilding Community Through Honest Conversations

00:57:09 - Reconceptualizing Pornography as Public Health Crisis

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Dr. Matthew Lynch, author of "Flood and Fury," joins Ryan and Mike to discuss one of the most contested topics in scripture--the flood and war texts in the Old Testament.

Lynch explains how violent biblical narratives—from the flood to Joshua's conquest of Jericho—are often stripped of their fuller context.

The discussion delves into how both conservative and critical readers tend to oversimplify these texts. 

Through careful literary and historical analysis, Lynch demonstrates how the Old Testament reveals God's mercy while acknowledging persistent mysteries we must sit with rather than resolve neatly.

Tune in for this honest conversation about reconciling biblical violence with faith.

Learn more about Dr. Matthew Lynch here: https://www.regent-college.edu/faculty/lynch-matthew/

CHAPTERS: 

00:00:00 - Cold Open: Understanding Violence in Biblical Stories

00:04:32 - Coffee Talk and Canadian Gas Prices

00:06:55 - Coffee Chat and Faith Journey Begins

00:09:03 - Faith, Bible, and Critical Questions

00:13:05 - From Academic Study to Lay Audience

00:15:36 - Understanding Violence and Complexity in Biblical Texts

00:20:11 - Understanding Biblical Context Through Hebrew Worldview

00:22:12 - Chronological Snobbery and Biblical Violence

00:26:34 - The Hidden Costs of Solving Problems

00:30:40 - Wrestling with Violence in Biblical Texts

00:33:30 - Understanding God's Justice and Mercy in Scripture

00:38:09 - God's Mercy Outweighs His Justice

00:41:41 - Judicial Equivalence and Proportional Justice

00:43:14 - Teaching Faith Through Unresolved Questions

00:46:22 - Understanding Old Testament Violence Through Historical Context

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

What happens when culture misrepresents Christ—and we don’t even notice?

In this episode of The Caffeinated Christian, we dive into two viral cultural moments that reveal a deeper spiritual confusion. From Donald Trump being portrayed as Jesus in a recent post to Tucker Carlson’s comments about Christ that sparked widespread conversation, we ask a critical question: Do we actually understand who Jesus is?

But we don’t stop there.

These cultural moments open the door to a deeper and often overlooked conversation: the meaning of the cross—and how it radically differs between Christianity and Islam.

What does the Quran teach about Jesus and the crucifixion?

Did Jesus actually die on the cross according to Islam?

And why does this difference matter more than most people realize?

This episode moves beyond surface-level reactions and into a thoughtful, biblical, and historically grounded exploration of truth, worldview, and the person of Jesus Christ.

If you’ve ever wrestled with cultural confusion, interfaith questions, or the centrality of the cross, this conversation will challenge you to think deeply and respond faithfully.

Quran & The Cross Packet

CHAPTERS: 

00:00:02 - Welcome to the Caffeinated Christian Podcast

00:03:25 - AI Jesus Image Sparks Religious Controversy

00:04:55 - The Problem With Making Jesus Political

00:12:52 - Controversial Religious Imagery and Public Backlash

00:15:20 - Jesus in Islam vs Christianity: The Crucifixion Debate

00:20:25 - Understanding Jesus's Crucifixion in the Quran

00:22:30 - Quranic Denial and Affirmative Verses on Jesus

00:27:13 - Ambiguity in the Quranic Crucifixion Narrative

00:35:06 - Earliest Islamic Commentary on Jesus's Denial

00:37:35 - Contradictory Islamic Interpretations of Jesus's Crucifixion

00:45:36 - Islamic Eschatology and Jesus's Physical Return

00:49:20 - Historical Evidence for Jesus's Crucifixion

00:53:51 - The Quran's Claims About Jesus Examined

00:56:04 - Jesus in Islam vs Christianity

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Send us Fan Mail

Today we pull out another message from the archives with an episode that remains all the more relevant now. It seems impossible to avoid politics these days, and that's all the more reason we, as Christians, should know how to navigate and engage in those types of conversations. We have a great guest to help us with that. Dan Trippie currently resides in Florida, but is a native of Buffalo, NY. He holds a Ph.D. in ethics from Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary and an M.Div. from The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. Dan’s focus of study is in public theology with a special emphasis on religious freedom.  Dan seeks to integrate theology into the public square dialogue. Dan  recently founded the Center for Christian Thought & Ethics. 

You can find more from Dan at dantrippie.com or thinkchristian.com/

Support the show

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Send us Fan Mail

What does it look like to follow Jesus with your finances… in a world that feels economically unstable?

In this episode of The Caffeinated Christian, we sit down with Christian economist and former Wall Street strategist Peter Grandich for a wide-ranging conversation on faith, money, and the future of the economy.

With over 40 years of experience in finance, Peter brings a unique perspective—one shaped not just by markets and data, but by a deep commitment to Christ. From his time on Wall Street to walking away from major income streams for the sake of his convictions, his story alone is worth the listen.

We dive into some big (and at times technical) topics, including:

•  The reality of U.S. national debt and why it matters 
•  Global economic shifts and the future of the dollar 
•  Inflation, gold, and financial instability 
•  The hidden dangers of debt in our personal lives 

But this episode isn’t just about economics.

It’s about stewardship.

It’s about trust.

And ultimately—it’s about how followers of Jesus can live wisely, generously, and faithfully in uncertain times. Peter offers incredibly practical, biblical wisdom on budgeting, giving, debt, and how to anchor your hope in Christ, no matter what happens in the economy. If you’ve ever felt overwhelmed by money, confused about the future, or unsure how your faith connects to your finances—this conversation is for you.

Follow Peter's work here

CHAPTERS:

0:00 – Cold Open: The Real Financial Threat No One Talks About
1:30 – Intro & Why This Conversation Matters
3:00 – Meet Peter Grandich (Wall Street to Faith Journey)
6:30 – Walking Away from Money for Conviction
9:00 – What Is the U.S. National Debt (And Why It Matters)
13:30 – Why Most Americans Don’t Understand the Debt Crisis
17:00 – The Coming Consequences: Taxes, Services, and the Middle Class
21:00 – The Retirement Crisis No One Is Talking About
25:00 – Global Shifts: Is the U.S. Losing Economic Power?
28:30 – De-Dollarization, BRICS, and the Future of Currency
32:00 – Gold vs. Crypto: Where Is Smart Money Going?
36:00 – Hidden Risks: Corporate Bonds & Private Credit
40:30 – Why Most People Are Financially Unprepared
43:30 – Biblical Stewardship: Less Is More
46:00 – The Power of Budgeting & Living Within Your Means
48:30 – Tithing as a Spiritual Discipline
51:00 – Debt Culture: “Can We Afford It?” vs. “Can We Make the Payment?”
53:00 – Final Thoughts: Truth, Trust, and Hope in Uncertain Times 

Support the show

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Send us Fan Mail

Today, we are pulling out a special episode from the classic vault where we sat down with Pastor Scott Lackey. Scott is the lead pastor of New Story Church, which he planted in 2020. New Story exists so that people can discover the New Story that Christ has for them. In January 2021 Scott released his first book, “Journey into a Greater Concern.” Scott and his wife Kim, have two boys, Clark and Bruce, and they love having the opportunity to be a part of what God is doing here in Western New York. Today, the guys and Scott are talking about Pastoral Authority and what do pastor have authority to speak on and what they do not have the authority to speak on.

Support the show

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Send us Fan Mail

In this episode of The Caffeinated Christian, we tackle two conversations that are exposing deeper cracks in the modern Church.

First, we break down the recent interaction between Mike Winger and Sean Feucht—including the now-viral accusation involving a message Feucht allegedly sent to himself and used to implicate Winger and journalist Julie Roys. But this isn’t just about online drama. It raises serious questions about accountability, truthfulness, and how Christian leaders respond to critique in the age of platforms.

Then, we zoom out to examine a Mainline Christian Denomination's recent statement supporting access to gender-affirming care for minors. What does this reveal about the shifting theological landscape? Where is the line between compassion and compromise? And who ultimately has the authority to define human identity—culture or Scripture?

These two stories may seem unrelated, but they’re deeply connected.

This episode explores the tension between truth and tone, conviction and compassion, boldness and humility—and why the future credibility of the Church depends on getting this right.

If you care about biblical faithfulness, cultural clarity, and the integrity of Christian witness, this is a conversation you don’t want to miss.

Read "What Is It Like to Be a Bat?" by Thomas Nagel: https://www.sas.upenn.edu/~cavitch/pdf-library/Nagel_Bat.pdf

Topics Covered:

Accountability in Christian leadership
The rise of platform-driven ministry
Discernment in the charismatic movement
Gender identity and theological anthropology
The authority of Scripture in a shifting culture

CHAPTERS: 

00:00:02 - Welcome to the Caffeinated Christian Podcast
00:04:29 - Testing Spiritual Claims and Accountability
00:08:09 - Sean's Self-Sent Message and Reputation Damage
00:11:29 - AI-Generated Prayers in Church Services
00:13:45 - Written vs. Spontaneous Prayer in Services
00:15:16 - Leadership Accountability and Scriptural Authority in Churches
00:18:51 - Methodist Bishop on Transgender Rights and Creation
00:21:21 - Nuance in Gender Healthcare Policy Debate
00:23:34 - Body Integrity and Medical Interventions for Minors
00:26:01 - Biblical Perspective on Gender and Identity
00:31:03 - Truth and Compassion on Gender Identity
00:34:42 - Gender Identity and Physical Transformation Logic
00:37:37 - Parenting Faith in a Changing World 

Read "What is it Like to be a Bat?" by Thomas Nagel

Support the show

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Send us Fan Mail

Are Christians being led astray by extreme teachings—and not even realizing it?

In this episode of The Caffeinated Christian, we break down two very different—but equally dangerous—misuses of Scripture:

Claims of “heavenly portals” and supernatural access on demand
A rising political voice using Jesus and Scripture out of context

At first glance, they seem unrelated. But they share the same root issue:
👉 Taking the Bible out of context to support a pre-existing agenda.

We tackle questions like:

Does the Bible teach we can access the supernatural realm at will?
What does Scripture actually say about visions and angels?
Did Mary give “consent” in the birth of Jesus—or is that a modern reinterpretation?
How do we spot when someone is using Jesus instead of following Him?

⚠️ The danger isn’t just bad theology—it’s being shaped by it without realizing it.

Don’t reshape Jesus to fit your ideology. Let Him reshape you.

TIME STAMPS

00:00:00

Detecting Theological Extremes in Bible Reading

00:02:19

Examining Viral Trends in Christian Culture

00:03:51

Patricia King and Charismatic Christianity

00:05:53

Opening Heavenly Portals: Seminary Skepticism

00:08:03

Supernatural Encounters Aren't the Christian Focus

00:09:07

Belief in the Unseen Realm Without Always Seeing It

00:10:55

Testing True Prophets Through Scripture

00:12:19

Spiritual Deception and Redefining Apostolic Authority

00:14:14

Patricia King's Moral Failures and Accountability

00:17:23

Texas Politician's Christian Facade Examined

00:18:53

Selective Scripture Use in Political Rhetoric

00:21:20

Gabriel Never Asked Mary's Permission

00:23:11

The Immaculate Conception Misconception Explained

00:25:31

Mary's Submission vs. Modern Political Interpretation

00:27:10

Reshaping Jesus to Fit Our Ideology

Support the show

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Send us Fan Mail

In today's episode, Mike and Ryan explore how religious leaders—from Muhammad in 7th-century Medina to modern figures like Ravi Zacharias—have sometimes received "convenient" divine revelations that suspiciously align with their personal desires. They examine Islamic abrogation, hadith sources, and the troubling pattern of extraordinary claims made without supporting evidence.

But here's where it gets uncomfortably relevant: How easily do we accept claims in our AI-saturated world without demanding rigorous proof?

The conversation takes a sharp turn toward epistemology, examining how deepfakes and social media have fundamentally undermined our ability to verify truth. The hosts reference Brett McCracken's "The Wisdom Pyramid," noting that we've inverted wisdom sources—placing smartphones at the foundation rather than God's word. They emphasize limiting trusted information sources, demanding multiple independent verifications, and prioritizing analog relationships over digital ones.

With Christianity fragmenting and technology accelerating divisiveness, this episode challenges listeners to rebuild their evidentiary standards from the ground up.

Listen to discover why your screen might be lying to you—and what ancient theological debates reveal about modern misinformation.

Support the show

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.