It is amazing the length that some people go to in their minds to justify a clearly false idea. This is the basis of troubling ideology. An ideology is a set of beliefs that are so ingrained in a person or a group that no one can counter those beliefs. This is a dangerous place to be in a religion or a culture.
We find here the Sadducees now posing a question to Jesus with the hopes of entrapping him in a religious quandary. But I think also the Sadducees do this in hopes of elevating themselves in the eyes of the public and in their own self-glorification. Their hermeneutical error was an ideology … a belief in the Mosaic Law that could never be challenged. Their hermeneutic developed a doctrine that interpreted the Pentateuch with a materialistic worldview.
The problem with man’s own philosophy is that we develop a worldview through logic alone and avoid Divine Wisdom altogether. The problem with the marriage dilemma posed by the Sadducees is that they were mistaken about what Moses actually decreed about marriage. They were mistaken about what Moses taught about resurrection. I find it ironic that the Sadducees, who were so smart, failed to see that they questioned the ONE who knew Moses the best. Jesus is the WORD after all so he would understand most of all what God spoke through Moses in the LAW.
The doctrine of the Sadducees argued against resurrection whereas the Pharisees did argue for resurrection. The doctrine of resurrection involves the eschatology of judgment. An end-time event where the ungodly are delivered over to judgment and the godly receive eternal life. The challenge by these Sadducees to Jesus over the question of resurrection no doubt came partly because Jesus had a reputation for miraculous resuscitation of recently deceased persons.
Yet resuscitation from the dead is not the same as resurrection from the dead. Those whom Jesus restored to life from the dead would die again someday. Jesus himself is the only man who ever was raised from the dead and never died again.
God’s faithfulness to HIS covenant with Abraham demanded that resurrection be real.
If God is their God after death, death is not the finality for them as the Sadducees taught.
This phrase from Ex. 3:6 “I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob” was a common Jewish prayer reciting God’s faithfulness to the patriarchs as evidence of God’s faithfulness to the Jews in their time.
Notice at the end of verse 32b
“He is not God of the dead, but of the living.”
Another way to think of this statement is that God is not the God of corpses but of living and active bodies. Therefore, HIS created, will not remain corpses. HIS created will exist in living bodies, both now and after the resurrection.
This phrase drives home Jesus’ answer to the ludicrous question from the Sadducees.