Hunter and Brent finally watch The O.C. but not before discussing John Mayer, Bon Iver, and Grateful Dead. Then, by divine intervention, the boys watch The O.C. 

Hunter and Brent talk about misheard lyrics and Miley Cyrus. Inspired and energized, Hunter makes an executive decision to not pull from the hat. After some back and forth, Hunter gets his way and the boys watch then discuss the Hannah Montana Christmas episode, "It's the End of Jake as We Know It." 

Hunter and Brent discuss accents, parking meters, and lament the absence of Brent's roommate, Andrew. Then they discuss the Parenthood Christmas episode, "What to My Wondering Eyes" which has everything you want in a Christmas episode: cancer, family, and Bob Dylan. 

In this episode, Brent and Hunter discuss Labor Day, what's canceled, and NAMM. Then the boys watch Hey Arnold's surprisingly political and emotional Christmas episode, "Arnold's Christmas." We close things up with a round of Who Are You and drop some hints about the future of the podcast.