This is a conversation between three German-American siblings about the most German of Germans.
Undeniably a Great, I’m not aware of Mann being particularly fashionable at the moment, though his writing is a creative benchmark for anyone who enjoys his language. I only just learned a little about his life in exile, and his journey from Germanic monarchist to passionate democrat. Which seems timely to consider.
Thomas Mann made much of how good art had to be aloof. He was adamant it could have no political agenda, couldn’t be moralizing or “school teacherly”. Even beyond that, he seemed obsessed by the artist’s predicament of detachment - how having any skin in the game was antithetical to the ruthless eye required to observe, and the perfect pitch needed to create.
But when the time came he took a stand, at real personal cost. In 1933, he might have imagined his reputation and privilege would cushion him personally against Nazi persecution, had he spoken out less. And yet he persevered, and exiled himself from the “Fatherland” with which he was so deeply identified. He was completely clear, and scathing in his opposition to the regime. He never hedged his bets.
With thanks to my brothers, whose love of Mann has been a touch point of connection between us for two decades.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit carrie802897.substack.com