The Communication Solution

The Communication Solution

By The IFIOC-Casey JacksonEducationSelf-Improvement
Download on the App Store

The Communication Solution episodes

  • Open Ended Questions
    About This Episode

    Welcome to today’s communication solution podcast. We love talking about motivational interviewing, and about improving outcomes for individuals, organizations, and the communities that they serve. We have an interesting topic to talk about today: Open Ended Questions and the quality and complexity of what’s being talked about. 

    About This Episode
    • Open ended questions vs close ended questions
    • How do you ask open-ended questions?
    • Reflective listening and empathy
    • Motivations and the quality of curiosity
    • Learning curves
    • Mindset
    • Perspectives
    • Connections and values
    • Real life examples of differences in questions
    • Skill building
    • And so much more!
    • To Watch Our Video Podcast – Join MI PLUS
      Join MI PLUS+
      Transcript of Show – View Below

      The Communication Solution – Open Ended Question

      Tammy: Hello, and welcome to the communication solution podcast today. We’ve got Casey Jackson on the line, John Gilbert, and I’m Tammy here at IFIOC. We love to talk communication. We love to talk motivational interviewing, and we love talking about improving outcomes for individuals, organizations, and the communities that they serve.

      Welcome to the conversation.

      John: All right. Welcome back everyone. We have interesting topic to talk about today. At least for me, maybe not for everyone, but we’ll see how it goes. I know that Tammy, you had particularly wanted to talk about this topic and subject because you were thinking of a situation that just starting at the basics we can talk about. But then I was like, well, we can go deep into this with multiple layers. So, I’m looking to hopefully do that with you Casey and Daniel. Today and just see how far we can get in a shorter podcast we have today. So, Tammy, what was the original kind of thinking you had for this topic? What is it, you were thinking?

      Tammy: The original topic was open ended questions, 101. And the reason why is because I think some people get stuck into. A lack of curiosity sometimes because we don’t really know what to talk about. And then there’s a difference between open ended questions versus close ended questions. You closed ended questions are. Yes, no, you expect a certain specific answer. Open questions, allow for the person to openly share their thoughts and ideas. Opinions could go so many different ways. The more that we can create open ended questions, the more we can hear people’s thoughts, ideas, beliefs, all that type of stuff. So that’s kind of where my mind was at when I was like, let’s do open ended questions.

      Casey: Well, what’s so funny to me is. I feel myself having a natural bias and a natural writing reflex this topic which I shouldn’t it’s so weird. And I think because so many people I’ve heard so much more lately that people are talking about, well, yeah, I went to a motivational interviewing training and it’s like, how you ask open ended questions? It’s like, oh my gosh, we’re drifting so far away from empathy and accurate, reflective listening, but. I know it’s my bias because I know I over correct on leaning so heavy into teaching people. What is high, accurate empathy? And the reality is that smart, strategic, evocative eliciting open ended questions are critical.

       Skill set to master in motivational interviewing. And I know I overcorrect towards teaching reflective listen. And so, so I’m getting over my bias and listening to that, cause it’s just like, oh, I don’t want people to think that it’s open-ended questions, you can’t do motivational without really smart, strategic open-ended questions.

      Tammy: Yes. It’s part of the equation. And I think that’s a really good point, Casey, because reflective listening is critical to motivational interviewing, but there are those times where you need to elicit and draw out from people. Their thoughts, ideas or beliefs too.

      Casey: Well, it, just, when you say that, I even think of the MICA, you know, the motivation incompetency assessment. And I think when we’re writing a thing about evoking in the intentions, we, measure open ended questions. We measure, evoking and, you know, I always share this and if you’ve heard other podcasts, me talking about evocation, but it just is so profound about how important open-ended questions. when I share that example of, in the cloudy cup, there’s pearls in a cloudy cup, we tend to want to throw our pearls of wisdom when people are confused when their brains are overwhelmed and again, in. The era of COVID people are under profound stress. And when they’re under profound stress, you know, they’ve got lots of pearls of wisdom. They get covered up by the trauma and stress response. And so, we can reflect that. But part of moving people from that trauma response up into their executive functioning is how do we draw out their thoughts and their ideas? Because just reflecting in circles or reflecting what’s going on inside. Doesn’t necessarily open the pathway to get them up into their executive function in the prefrontal cortex. It is the quality of a great open-ended question that, has that curiosity that evokes or elicits their thoughts and their ideas. And you see their brain work through the cloudiness to get to those pearls of wisdom inside of themselves. So, it just, even as we’re starting this topic, it’s like it’s making my brain kind of go back around with that. What we’re really talking about with, with open ended question.

      John: Well, and I’d like to speak to the learning curve here, just working with so many different people and my own learning curve and still working on empathy myself, and that there’s a certain degree of. Who are we interacting with and where are they at with their degree of expression of empathy? Because there seems to be this crossover of like, if you can go deep, complex, rich reflections that are very provoking of the person to speak more. There’s something there that when you can guide that conversation, standing shoulder John: to shoulder, that someone like yourself seemingly Casey, that’s not just you. It’s about the skill I realize, but. Has this tendency, this ability to go there in ways that are worth training to, and it’s just hard to go there for various people. And so, in the learning curve of this, how do we help people transition from something that you weren’t necessarily saying at the beginning of this Tammy, but that we talked about offline before, which is out of that, fix it mode into a curious mode and just that alone is a shift. Empathy is a shift at a fix it mode, but even myself as Casey, you’re being transparent about your writing reflex. I’m having the writing reflex of what like Terry Moyers and some of these other researchers have found in recent history, which is that open verse, closing into questions matters significantly less than the quality of your curiosity. It’s less about. Do you think this, or what do you think about this? Versus I know that the quality of my curiosity is I’m asking them what they make of this situation to engage them, to get oriented to their reality, to engage and be engaged with them. I know that it doesn’t have a lot of direction to it. But I know that right now, this is going to be engaging for them. And then I can come in with the demonstration of I get you versus I don’t get you, which is the thing we’re kind of alluding to here, Casey, that you trained me in is questions, communicate. I don’t quite understand. And the person then has to, and microseconds go, what do I want to share with this authority figure usually? And then instead the empathy gets at that information maybe in a different angle. But if you are going to ask a question of, I don’t understand, I don’t get you versus demonstrating. You understand? What are you trying to understand? Are you trying to understand a sense of their reality more generally, which is a part of empathy, but it’s more demonstrating is what we focus on, but it’s seeking to understand, are you just trying to understand their reality more general? Are you trying to gather information, because that’s a part of your job and assess their situation. That’s a different curiosity. Are you focused on the problem and trying to problem solve with them? There’s a place for that. And motivational Interviewing we tend to jump to that pretty quick with the premature planning trap. but that’s different asking is different than telling. At least we got that down. That’s a different quality of curiosity. And then even different than that, that seems to come later for people. But the whole term of motivational Interviewing means to interview someone about their motivations and the quality of curiosity, to just be curious. Why do you do what you do? Or why would you even want to change to see something different? Or what does it matter if things change and why does that matter? And just the curiosity of motivation is one of those key things in motivational Interviewing that can get lost in the fray of all these acronyms and all these other things.

       John: And it’s so much to why I’m grateful to Casey talking about the physics of this, the mindset and the intentionality of this versus the technique components of it. Because if I’m not aware of where I am putting my curiosity. I’m not necessarily being as mindful as I could be to guide this conversation. And I am getting paid most of the time in the helper role to guide this conversation. So, it’s that quality of curiosity, spectrum that I was lit up to talk about with all this. And I have a lot of different examples we could get through, but I’m just wondering if that resonates or any thoughts that any of you have on any of that?

      Casey: Yeah, I, I think that’s why my natural tendency is to over correct. Away from questions is because it’s to pull people away from what we’ve been trained to do, because questions, the nature tends to be more self-centered I’m asking a question, because I’m curious and I want to find something out. And when you’re, when you run it through a healthcare or behavioral health lens or any of the other lenses that use motivational interviewing it’s because we’re gathering data or we’re gathering demographics, we’re gathering information most of the time that we never use, but we gather all of this stuff from people, but it’s for our own purposes. Motivational Interviewing being is so other person centered. And so, I think everything you’re articulating John is the nature of what open ended questions are in motivational interviewing, but I think that we are so trained, and I think it’s just natural instinct out of curiosity, but the curiosity tends to be about us and how these people relate to us or how their information relates to us or how their lives relate to us. Because we may ask the question, oh, what do you do for work? But mostly we ask the question to listen so we can bring it around to ourselves. I mean, it’s just, it tends to have that quality to it. But what you’re articulating is that is not the quality. Of curiosity. It is curiosity about how the person’s brain works in relationship to their life. What are their ideas in relationship to their life? And that is just substantively different than asking kind of the traditional closed ended questions. Or we need to gather data to, to come up with a plan or an intervention here, or we need to assess their life and their health and their safety. We need to assess all these things so we can come up with an intervention that tends to be the questions we ask. And like you said, the more we ask questions and the more data we get, the more opinions we have on somebody else’s life. And so, then we ask more questions and the more opinions we get, which is again, more of a self-centered process. So, I think delineating this and distinguishing what we’re talking about with this quality of evocation eliciting. Is I think is really value added.

      John: Well, there’s so many thoughts I go through with that too Casey, because one of them is this place of it depends, so much of the context and what work environment, when I think of a healthcare situation you’re trained to, call it the medical model, assess. Assess because we are the people that know. And if someone’s ready to go and willing to do all the work, the information that comes from that, or if you’ve been in a car accident, if you, as you’ve talked about in trainings or something like that, where it’s acute short term, that information to inform the intervention really, really matters. It’s that when we’re talking about motivational interviewing context with this particular technique, it’s that there seems to be something to people coming to their own sense of a oh crap or an aha or a lit up something in their brain when you can guide that process. And that can happen through reflections. Or questions or ideally a combo of both with more reflections than questions. But when we’re trying to get to the heart of it, it’s getting less self-centered to me, Casey’s what you’re speaking to that we were just talking about in another podcast of compassion that I care more about you and your outcome, and you aligning with your values than you aligning with my values or me talking about my reality versus you talking about your reality. Danielle, you were alluding to this as us, as egocentric being us talking from our perspective. It’s just easier. I enjoy it. You enjoy it. We come across authentic and genuine with each other. It’s fun. We get a sense of connection. So, for me to shift that and now go, oh, let me stand shoulder to shoulder from your perspective and say something from your perspective. That can be a hard shift.  So, for me to just go, I am curious about your perspective is one shift into getting. Ideally less focused on us. And then as you shift that deeper, ideally, you’re going to get oriented and you can give voice to their perspective, give voice to what’s going on for them, regardless of what you think. And as you do that, you’re going to get more likely expansion and information and get more curious about a particular something. Well, what that could be you paying attention to their motivations or their change talk, or them doing something about something different in their life? Well, if your curiosity shifts to that all about them and their values and how much they’re aligned with that, or not, at least you’re making this less self-centered approach more of your approach. And Casey, to your point, I think to get really less self-centered you would have more statements about what’s going on for them than questions. That’s what the motivational Interviewing would point to with two to one ratio or three to one ratio of. Reflections to questions. And that is something that when people hear that have even been through in my trainings, they’re like, wow, I don’t think I ever heard. I didn’t realize how much

      John:  reflection and reflective listening is a part of this, but there is a point to not just open-ended questions. When you do ask a question that as you’ve taught me, Casey, you’re teeing up the question with reflections. Yes. You’re getting more information. What their reality is what’s accurate or not so that you can ask it for their brain and their mind as much as we possibly can. But I do want to bring it back to, there is a place for assessment questions. For orienting to someone’s reality. If they’ve had trauma or not had trauma, if they have gone through this thing or that thing with an autoimmune issue, there is information to be on the table. So, I don’t want. Negate that’s a part of, of being a professional to help someone is assessing information to get oriented to their reality. It’s just that that’s less a behavior change conversation. Casey, as you’ve talked about, it’s assessed. So that this can be fixed. It’s not let’s get into your reality and help you align your behaviors with your values. So that’s so much of what I think you just spoke to is, is really critical. Making it as much about them aligned with their values or not is what the motivational Interviewing curiosity is trying to be about.

      Danielle: I was just going to say I sat in, on one of your trainings, Casey, and the, the biggest takeaway many, but was about the quality of curiosity, because I had not realized how important reflections were to take that guess of how that person might be looking at the world. And it, you had mentioned something about it’s the quality with which you make. That statement, that reflection. Yes. That will allow that person to respond. Even if you got it wrong. That’s okay. because you just got information now, but you did it with that quality of curiosity that did not make them defensive.

      Casey: That’s it? And, you know, as we’re talking about this and I think this is going to be a whole separate podcast, it just strikes me is. When you’re talking about the side by side, and that curiosity, what that requires is a brain that’s not under its own stress or trauma, the amount of energy and, chemical reaction in your cortex and prefrontal cortex that has to exist. And your mirror neurons, the amount of energy that, that takes to leave your experience and enter someone else’s experience accurately is not going happen when people under stress and it’s not going happen when you’re traumatized because your brain science is set up to keep you surviving. like your default is going to be survival. So, when people under stress and pressure and there, productivity’s dropping and their, child has COVID again and, now we’re getting more pressures and now our funding streams have shifted and, now I’m supposed to be empathetic. And now I’m supposed to be shoulder to shoulder in somebody else’s reality. Damn, I can barely manage my own reality. Like I think, putting Casey:  that in that context, and I think that’s going be a whole separate podcast that just struck me because There’s so much more complex than thinking about open ended questions, affirmations, reflections, and summary statements. That’s all accurate, but the depth and the quality and complexity of what’s being talked about when you’re talking about the complexity of the human brain and human behavior is just mind blowing to me. and the example that I tend to use and that we can use it with open ended questions. is you can, give a first-year resident a scalpel and have them kind of remove sutures using a scalpel. And they’re fine with that. But given that same scalpel and have them go in and try to do advanced surgery on the heart. They’re not as adept at that. It’s the same scalpel. It’s just how. Skilled are you ailing it for what things? I mean to, to snip a couple of sutures is not difficult, but to get in there and actually navigate around human organs is way more complex. And I know I overstate this, but I genuinely believe the work you do. If you’re genuinely working on behavior, change is as complex or more complex than heart surgery or brain surgery. These are moving pieces of human beings whose thoughts and feelings are adjusting. Moment to moment and day to day, the human heart has some basic structures that aren’t going change. The human brain has some basic structures that people know how to navigate, and even that’s a new horizon, I don’t think it’s overselling it for people to understand when we’re talking about the quality of empathy and accurate empathy, which is usually leans into things like reflective statements and validation in these, you know, these techniques. It’s the same thing. I guess when we’re looking at open ended questions that it’s not about a question it’s like, John, you’re talking about that Moyers at all are writing about that. It’s just the quality of curiosity and the authenticity that you’re bringing to that on what opens people up to their own thought process. And that is extremely complex. It’s beyond a worksheet it’s beyond, you know, a recording of, did you use questions or reflections? Did you use open questions or close questions? There’s so much more, mindset and intention behind that.

      John: That will be helpful in, I think, a future podcast as we do looking at time that I’ll be wrapping for this one here, but I do want to mention that the less time you have, the more, it’s important to be aware of. What is the quality of your curiosity? What is the quality of your [00:18:00] empathy and the depth of it? Because the less time you have. The more precise you need to be.  So, when I think of brief MOTIVATIONAL INTERVIEWING or doctors or people in healthcare that have that less time, and then Tammy’s saying, well, now they’re going open up about everything. Well, it’s like, oh my gosh, I don’t want them to open up about everything. I’m curious about this particular thing for it to serve them for their change. And so, I just wanted to end with that sense of it’s functional, it’s effective. It’s efficient that we’re talking about. Not just feel good, but Tammy go.

      Tammy: Perfect. I just wanted to end with like three real life examples so people can distinctly see kind of the differences. So, we’re, we’re talking about a lot of people start with close ended questions, which are like have, have you had any thoughts about this topic? Yes or no. And then people start to evolve their skillset and do more open-end questions. Like what are your thoughts about this topic? And that starts to get people to talk. What their thoughts are, but the next level, which is what we’re talking about, how reflective listening can sometimes replace open ended questions is doing a statement like, yeah. And you’ve had a lot of thoughts around this already. and that can come sometimes lead people to then share what some of those thoughts are. So, I just wanted to give a distinct example of the show, like close ended and open ended and a reflective statement. You can get to the same ending point or outcome with an open-end question versus a reflective statement. But the reflective statement is much more of that empathetic place where you’re coming.

      John: So that’s and we, we, we go over that even in some skill building stuff in our trainings, if people are interested in going through that from questions to reflections, we’ve got different handouts or different professionals. So just a, a heads up with that, that can be a very helpful skill building. Also, that I’ll be putting together something I’m working with this expert group, or we’re working with some expert group people right now. And the reason I was saying I is because I’m putting together this list of different types of questions, of engaging, focusing. Pursuing and planning. And so, with that we’ll have some stuff posted on our motivational Interviewing plus or anyone that is interested in that for some more resources, some more skill building that you can find on our motivational Interviewing plus membership as well. So that I point people in that direction. But for now, that’s all I have unless anyone else has anything else for wrapping it up?

      Casey: Sounds good. Thanks everyone.

      John: Everyone was helpful. See you next. All right.

      Tammy: Thank you for listening to the communication solution podcast as always. This podcast is all about you. So, if you have questions, thoughts, topic, suggestions, ideas, please send them our way at [email protected]. That’s [email protected]. For more resources, feel free to check out. IFIOC.com. We also have a public Facebook group called motivational interviewing every day. We have an amazing blog and we have lots of communication tips on our website. In addition to all these amazing resources we do offer online public courses. On our website on motivational interviewing and effective communication strategies. Thanks for listening to the communication solution by IFIOC.

      23 min
    • Landscape of Motivational Interviewing
      About This Episode

      Welcome to today’s communication solution podcast. We love talking about motivational interviewing, and improving outcomes for individuals, organizations, and the communities that they serve. Today we are talking about the larger picture of the landscape of motivational interviewing, some of the things that are going on in its world, and the future landscape of motivational interviewing. We will also be transitioning some team members. 

      For those who are new to this podcast, the MICA is the motivational interviewing competency assessment.

      In this podcast we discuss:
      • The larger picture and landscape of motivational interviewing
      • The field of motivational interviewing has grown or spilled into
      • Motivational interviewing is a method of communicating
      • Cultural Bias
      • Dr. William Miller and his book, “Lovingkindness: Realizing And Practicing Your True Self”
      • Measurement and motivational interviewing
      • The components of how language works
      • Mindset 
      • Responsibility and choice
      • The Western medical perspective
      • Dr. Theresa Moyers and her new book, “Effective Psychotherapy”
      • And so much more!
      • You don’t want to miss this one! Make sure to rate us or share this podcast. It would mean so much to us!

        Thank you for listening to the communication solution. This podcast is all about you. If you have questions, thoughts, topic suggestions, or ideas, please send them our way at [email protected]. For more resources, feel free to check out ifioc.com.

        Want to see the video podcast?- Join MI PLUS
        Join MI PLUS+
        Transcript of Show – View Below

        John: Hello everyone. And welcome back. We have some special podcasts here as we’re going to be talking about this larger picture here of the landscape of motivational interviewing and some of the things that are going on in the world of motivational interviewing. If you’re interested in that more generally, we also are going to be having a transition of some team members that you might be seeing if you’re seeing this, but you’ll be hearing here soon. So, I know Casey, you were going to give some words to that with Tammy and.

        Casey: Well, mostly I’m crying internally cause I’m losing Tammy. She, and I’ve been buddies for years and years and years. Actually, Tammy was. Integral to me transitioning and doing some work in senior living which wouldn’t have happened with her role touch mark and just now makes me a little emotional, because there’s this chip little face who would run around high, high energy, usually that a little bag of M&Ms with peanuts in it. And I could get people to do almost anything. Like she was the biggest. Cheerleader not only for training but just for motivational interviewing, just so it’s actually a little hard for me to see her kill a little face right there. To know that we’re going to be transitioning and she’s going on to wonderful things with her family as it continues to grow, in her belly right now. Yeah. And the good news is we’re bringing on Danielle Cantin. Who’s just a. A force to be reckoned with. So just, it it’s an exciting transition. And so, we’re going to hear some of that transition over the next few podcasts as, as Tammy’s, you know moving on to, to other things. And Danielle’s jumping onto the I team. So, it’s exciting, exciting times and a little bit of grieving going on at the same time. so, anything either of you would like to jump in and say, Tammy

        Tammy: no. Except I do want to make sure that we cover the actual topic of

        Danielle: the podcast at some point

        Tammy: I’d like, sorry, the name. So, people know what the name, what we’re focused

        Danielle: on today.

        John: Yeah. The landscape of motivational interviewing, for sure. Yeah. Yes.

        Casey: Sounds good. And Danielle, any thoughts as you’re jumping on?

        Danielle: Yes. I’m just so thrilled to be here. And what I think is really interesting is how you and Tammy connected is how we connected is in the senior living space. So, there’s something really interesting about what you’re bringing to the world with this work. And I, I just. Really interesting about the senior living piece and learning everything that you’re doing is really awesome. Tammy. You’ve been wonderful through this transition, so excited to, to pick up the torch that you’ve been carrying and keep moving it forward.

        Casey: You know, and I think that’s, it’s, it makes so much sense for the topic for this podcast is about just the landscape of motivational interviewing and what fields, you know, has motivational interviewing kind of grown or spilled into. And, you know, for me, my, my background, most people know my background is in, you know, substance use treatment, chemical dependency, and mental health. Motivation one was born out of the, the addiction world. Dr. Miller, Dr. William Miller. It was his area of expertise as a clinician and as a psychologist, as a researcher and, and. But when data’s good and things are effective for behavior change, you know, word spreads and as research pours out and, and people say, hey, this is effective. Then it, you know, in short order it went from the chemical dependency world, you know, and with just the hand and glove with mental health world and as soon as the number started changing and outcomes improved, then you know, healthcare obviously was perking up and going, hey, we need to learn more about this. And then as soon as you say healthcare, then it’s just like, okay, Bing, Bing, Bing. You’ve got, you know physical therapy, occupational therapy, nutrition, you know, dieticians. It just starts to spread pretty rapidly. I, I think the most fascinating. Like jump gaps that have happened that I’ve been lucky enough to be involved in is, you know, when it started to, like, when I was asked to work in employment services or with corrections or law enforcement, and again, then moving to some of the corporate side in terms of senior living and things like that as well, too. So, it’s just, it’s fascinating. And I think. When I step back and I think, how does that happen? First thing I think is obviously data, you know, when people see data and see research and things are improving, we, people are going to

        Casey: dig into that and say, hey, does it relate to us? Can we, can we get those outcomes? How does that happen? I know that’s what John’s fascination when he and I bumped into each other in the beginning was just looking at the data side of it. And wow. There’s a lot of promising practice. In the nutrition world that John works in this looks like a very upcoming promising practice. And hey, I’m fascinated with this, which is where we got so obsessed with fidelity. Like, okay, but we want to do it. Right. And I think that happens with seeing the data, but I’ll say the most profound thing. And I think this is what. Really lean on and take pride in, in IFIOC is that we really do see it as a method of communication. So, I think that still can get taught and I don’t think it’s wrong. But to think of it as a counseling technique. And I think that causes a stutter step. Into moving into other professions, I’m going, Hey, I’m not a therapist, I’m not a clinician. I don’t work people with addiction issues. My job isn’t to do interviewing, I mean, if there’s, if there’s a couple of one-liners, we hear all the time is my job isn’t to do interviewing or how do we motivate them?

        Casey: You know, how can I get them motivated to take their medication or follow through on the doctor’s recommendations or stick with treatment? How do we make them do that? Using motivational interviewing? I think there’s so many misperceptions, but when you step back and think, how did it. You know, evolve and those tendrils just continue to reach out into other professions. I think when you break it down, it’s because people do become aware that I can be more mindful about how I communicate. And as soon as you think of that, then my brain goes to, well, if it’s about communication language, then you can see why it starts to spread into other countries and other languages as well too. And this is my obsession about talking about and learning about the human brain because the human brain is a cross-cultural thing. A human brain is a human brain and language and how it hits our ear and hits our brain. Is pretty profound. So that’s my blah, blah, blah. About kind of just some aspects of when I think of the landscape of motivational interviewing and, and kind of what fields is it in and, and how it’s kind of grown. But John, what are some of your, I mean, you you’ve been around this for over 10 years now, so, I mean, what are, what are some things that strike you as I’m rambling on?

        John: No As you’re talking, it was going through my mind is this. Sense of communication is one thing, but how culturally relevant that communication usually is meaning it’s, it’s in a container of a culture. And so, as I’ve gotten more and more into motivational interviewing and just life in general, learning how biased by our culture we can be and how it’s been very interesting just to learn all the conscious and unconscious and implicit bias that we bring to the table. And trying to get more aware of that and how, if we’re going to influence someone, how are we doing that from our cultural bias? Right. And so that we’ve, we’ve had other podcasts that have gone deeper into this. One of our more recent ones talking about more first nations people and how this really attunes motivational interviewing really attunes to that sense. Respect and openness and really honoring someone in their talking. And then that seems to be, there seems to be something motivational interviewing that really has transcended across cultures really well, be it the basics of just listening with empathy and expressing empathy, but also other parts of the recipe that have expanded into. You and I, for some of the latest numbers it was something like at least 40 countries and at least I want to say 26 different languages.

        John: And so, I remember even seeing or hearing possibly more than that, but the point is that there seems to be something about this method of communicating and the way we’re talking about it as a method, not a T. As a way of seeing a way of being a way of treating that seems to transition to cross cultures. Well, and I think it gives voice also to why Dr. William Miller, one of the creators of motivational interviewing wrote that book, loving kindness of how to treat people humanely from a place of human humane. And so that’s what goes through my mind is just how this seems to be a transcendent way of communicating that isn’t just. specific to one culture, but it seems to resonate with humans more generally for some sort of reason that we’re further discovering, and it’s about change for happier and healthier all at the same time. So, it can be productive, culturally relevant and helpful for people. And there are also times to recognize. Maybe you’re not having a conversation about change, so you’re not going to use all the pieces of motivational interviewing, right. But there’s still a spirit there of supporting choice, curiosity, and equal treatment that really you can bring to the table. No matter the conversation. I think that seems to be getting out of our Western culture and into maybe potentially other cultures as a way of treating people. That’s what was going through my mind.

        Casey: You know, John, when you say that, what, what just stands out to me is. I think of how expansive motivational wing is in terms of the MINT, you know, the international motivational wing network of trainers with IME the international conference on motivational interviewing. Like when you’re talking so many different countries, all these people doing research, you know, fascinated with it. So, I think of the, the breadth of motivational, but then when you just brought up Dr. Miller’s name, you know, I, you and I both have, have met Dr. Miller Spend some time with him. He’s just, he, it’s almost inexplicable how kind and how deep and how thoughtful he is.

        Casey: And so, when you have like a father of a, a modality who continues to write about the, the soul and the spirit and the quantum nature of change and the kindness and the heart and the humanity and has a profound appreciation for metrics and measurement. I, I think that just to have that as the. The charge of, in the growth of motivational wing, because the growth of motivational interviewing, he has turned the reins over to all these amazing people that are just obsessed with, you know, all the aspects of motivational interviewing. So, you know, he still is the figurehead. But the there’s such a fascination when you said his name that I thought, you know, this is what’s incredible though. I remember having a conversation with him when they introduced the construct of compassion and I, as a social worker, I loved it. And as a trainer, I’m like, oh my gosh, we teach empathy. Why are we doing these little nuance things that don’t have an impact on outcome? Like from a measurability perspective, which is weird for me. Cause I like the spirit side of it. And the technique side is really critical as. But I remember him saying, you know, yeah. We spend years and years. I, I know that he and Dr. Moyers and Dr. Ernst, like there’s so many people that worked on, how do we measure empathy in language? Like how do we come up with a metrics to measure that? And that took a long time. Not only did it take a long time to measure empathy, but I remember in the first versions of the mighty the motivation treatment, integrity scale, it was to measure the spirit.

        Casey: Of motivational interviewing. And so, to come up with components to measure the spirit of motivational interviewing, which we know we can’t measure the spirit of anything, but for them to come up with metrics of different components that we could measure. I was thinking about why are we adding compassion to the mix? And I kept looking through a measurable lens. And then when I had a chance to talk to, to, to bill about this, this is what I think I just had this deep appreciation I need to acknowledge it is that he said, you know, yeah, we spent years understanding empathy. He goes, I don’t know if we, I don’t care if we ever learn.

        Casey: To measure compassion, but if it is not an, an aspect of compassion, it’s not motivational interviewing and he goes so, and , as long as I have a say in it, then that’s going to be, I’m going to write about it and say, we need to not lose compassion because I, he said, I don’t want the, the field to over correct. And make it all about technique and measurement, because then you are drifting away. Even if we can measure empathy, you are going to drift away from what is the purpose. And I think that’s, I think like the book that he referenced, John, that he wrote. It’s just about the love. It’s about the humanity. It’s about the kindness. It’s about how we interact in this human family is critical. And I think this is, I know this is my obsession. I don’t think it, I know this is my obsession is it’s the balance between that heart and soul of, of kind of the human family. and it’s measurable, reliable, and valid. Like that to me is just like the holy grail. Like what else could you want then to have something that’s measurable and reliable and valid.

        Casey: And it comes from a heart of a pure desire to help. And I think what’s so fascinating to me is the understanding of the depth and breadth of that is not always, what’s translating into a lot of. It’s still, the translation ends up being into the or skills or these techniques. And so people will balance between teaching techniques and then talking about the spirit. So, I think this is why it’s for me, after you know, 20, more than 20 years, why I’m just. Continually daily obsessed with all the components of how language works and how our brain works and how change works and how stuckness works and how anger works and frustration and politics. And just like, oh my gosh. So, when we’re talking landscape, like there’s not a day, I think everybody, this podcast, like we all know there’s not a day that there’s not a construct for motivational that doesn’t, that couldn’t float through your. Like there’s, you know, whether it’s tension in a relationship or frustration as a parent or, you know, watching CNN or, you know, just anything that happens when you understand the constructs.

        Casey:  It’s like, wow, this is, this is human beings in motion. And can I interface in a way that has some positive impact? And so, I think when you talk about how popular is it, what fields, what parts of the world, when you think about effective communication, it’s like, what corner of the world wouldn’t that touch? Exactly.

        Tammy: I that’s just, what I was going to add in is it’s about communication. It’s not going back to the very beginning. Casey, you talked about counseling methods and all this type of stuff, and people lose fact or lose focus on the point that this is just a type of communication. This is how we communicate. And like you said, Watching CNN relationships, all these different things. You encounter tension, you encounter people struggling with change. You encounter people with ambivalence, which are all things that motivational interviewing can help

        Casey: with. That’s exactly it.

        John: Well, and we’re as we’re going with this with this overarching sense of MIS. reflecting on kind of what you were asking me, Casey, of learning over the years and, and mentorship by you and learning more and more. It’s recognizing this under these underlying intentions and what’s your intention with someone. And that’s why we talk about that with the motivational interviewing competency assessment the MICA, and really focusing on mindset. You could also say heart. And not just technique and technique people. And there seems to be this dilution of dispersion happening with motivational interviewing across the world from the original pro projectors of Dr. Miller and Dr. Steven Rollick because it’s getting so dispersed, it’s losing that original intent of the potency of that from this model and what seems to be playing out in research so far. There’s not one theory, that’s underlying AMI, but there seems to be these ways of treating people. That’s more helpful than not helpful for other things we know right now. For the vast majority of people, it doesn’t mean it works a hundred percent of the time, all the time. There are articles written on that. And if someone’s highly motivated, they might want to be challenged and confronted and all these things. And so the idea though, is for a lot of people, a lot of the time is what the research is pointing to. These ways of treating people that they have concessions to make in life. And that was something I was listening to on a other podcast recently that we always have by spending our time here.

        John:  We’re not spending it here by focusing our thought process here. We’re not focusing it there. And so, we are always making concessions of here versus there of this versus that. And in, so doing. How much am I making an informed choice that this is really going to serve me in the best ways I want. And at a certain point through our culture, through the information that has been biased to us in our culture, we get exposed to certain things, thinking we’re making a certain kind of decision when we may or may not be with our time, our energy, our effort. Right? And so, at a certain point, so much of motivational interviewing seems to be. On this overarching view that I think transcends cultures is embracing someone else’s perspective beyond yours being curious about and not judgmental and getting clear of their motivations and priorities, and then helping them make an informed choice about who they want to be now and into the future, given certain amount of information and last but not least, I think the thing that gets lost in. Is there is a place for information and education and motivational interviewing. Yes. That isn’t necessarily advice, but it, there is something to be said about this cultural humility, but also that as best the helper can tell here is information that I’m going to throw in as neutrally as I can. That seems to help you get in the direction of what you want.

        John:  And I think it’s. Way of being in the way of treating people that is so different than how motivational interviewing gets perceived of. Yes. Let me learn this thing. That’s been shown to be effective because my job is. Paid, or I hope to get you to do what I want you to do because I care. And you know that whole road to hell is paved with good intentions. That’s why we put down intentions and embodying them in a certain kind of a way with AMI, with the MICA, because so many people mean well with their compassion cases is what they should preface the whole thing with. Your compassion made me think of this, that so many people are trying to be compassionate and helpful, but they’re not treating people with this choice that they have concessions to make, and that radical responsibility that self-determination theory and other things would point to is that we have these decisions to make.

        John:  It doesn’t mean that our support network doesn’t matter. It can make those decisions easier or less easier. The equal opportunity that we don’t have in our society also makes it easier or less. But we do have choices to make and treating people that they have concessions and choices to make. And being curious about that empathetic about that, that to me, is a style of compassion, Casey, a way of expressing the compassion that might be different than so many other professionals that think if I can just get them to do what I think is best, that’s compassionate. It’s like, whoa, that’s, that might be a version of your compassion, but that is not what Dr. Miller is. Meaning for compassion and motivational. I.

        Casey: You know, and if you if you peel it back even, oh, go ahead, Tammy.

        Tammy: Real quick. I just want to comment for people that are new or maybe new to this podcast. The MICA is the motivational interviewing competency assessment, and it’s one of the fidelity-based tools to help people measure whether they’re doing motivational interviewing to fidelity to actually receive the evidence-based practices.

        Danielle: There we go.

        John: Yeah.

        Casey: Yeah. That’s it. And, and you know, and when you, as you were talking, John, I. What just struck me is that when you look through a Western medical perspective, which is, you know, we’re Western medical perspective because we’re Western and we’re in healthcare, behavioral health. I mean, that’s the perspective. It is so much transactional based fundamentally because when you think of Western medicine, you think if somebody breaks their arm, you know, you don’t need a lot of compassion. You just need to get their arm. You know if there’s, and we know that there needs to be bedside manner and partly because the research shows you’re going to have lower liability if you’re nicer to people and people tend not to Sue you as much. So that’s one reason that the medical field move towards more compassion is just to avoid litigation. And, but we’re so transactional based even with the attempt to transform. And I think that’s, what’s so fascinating about motivation is of methodology is because it is about the other person almost. And that is not normal in Western because we tend to be so self-centered even our, in our provision of service is what do I get out of it besides the, you know, either the paycheck or I feel good about my job or I feel, I feel, I, you know, we tend to just. Be a little bit more towards self-centered creatures and, and motivation is so profoundly other person centered when you’re doing it with the full intention of the full skillset.

        Casey:  It is another person centered. And when you look at where the world is right now, there’s a. A glaring absence of that. And I think that’s why there’s this underlying gravitation towards a method of communication that people get to feel deeply heard and understood and help them work through. Do I like John, what you were saying, do I want to put my time here? Which means I’m not putting my time here. But to be able to work that in a way that align with your values and have somebody help you navigate that in a brief conversation is pretty profound actually, for some people its pretty life changing. To be able to get out of the chaos of the day to day, you know, race and to be able to just inhale, feel like you have a, a heart-based Chimney cricket inside of you, that’s helping you kind of navigate things in a way that you’re listening to even days that you don’t won’t listen to it. I mean, that, that to me is a pretty profound thing to be able to offer to another human. You know,

        Danielle: it’s, it’s interesting listening to you guys talk about this. John, you brought up culture in the beginning and as I’m listening to the conversation, go back and forth and how you just brought it around to the beauty of how we don’t focus on like almost exclusively the other person to really lift them up and help them. And something I was aware of in the beginning is you were talking John about the culture piece and our biases. What I’ve fallen in love. With Me watching you train people. How much you do look inside and become aware of your own bias or things you weren’t thinking of, but it’s not, you don’t make it about you. It’s like this beautiful way to grow as a human. Yes. But not in that self-centered way. It’s just like, oh, note of that. Holy smokes. I didn’t realize I was doing that and, and it really kind of invites you to step in to being, being a better human, a more compassionate human for somebody.

        Casey: You know, Danielle, when you say that what strikes me so much, like kind of what lights up in my brain is. It’s why I continue to be obsessed with motivational interviewing. I think one of the hardest things to do is surrender the expert role. Because I don’t consider myself an expert on motivational interviewing while other people do, because I just feel so naive to all the dimensions of it. I’ve been studying it for way more than 10,000 hours, but I still don’t feel like I’m an expert in it. And I think part of that is because what you just touched on my obsession every time, I do a training is. When you’re in high empathy, when you’re leaving your reality, when you’re staying in Equal poise, but entering somebody else’s worldview, I always talk about, it’s almost like these mini vacations. I get, I get to travel to other countries, other worlds, even in a training, which means I need to sit on my hands and keep my mouth shut and learn.

        Casey:  How does this person see the world? Which is the way when I travel to foreign countries that I believe I should operate because I don’t want to be an ugly American. So, it’s just like, I’m going to sit on my hands and observe and observe and observe and keep my thoughts to myself until I understand how. Their reality works, how, what this culture functions as, and that is the antithesis of taking on the expert role of stomping in there and saying, Hey, that’s a problem. Look at your blood sugars. Look at your blood pressure. Look at this surgery. You need to change this. And if you don’t want to, okay, we’re going to mark you as non-compliant and maybe there’s some mental health issues going on. It’s just like, that’s kind of an ugly American approach. But it is the way that our kind of our services have evolved over the year from a Western medical perspective. It is fascinating. So, I this, this concept of landscape of motivational interviewing, I think that’s my obsession is that it’s forever changing. it is forever. Every time that new data comes out, that catches attention. When we learn how human beings operate, there’s things that we jettison and go, you know, that wasn’t like, I don’t train. Am I the way that I did 20 years? You know, there’s aspects of it that will always be the same and there’s aspects that are just like, you know, I don’t know if that’s the core of what makes

        Casey:   behavior change when we look at this data it’s more about, this is what makes people change. This is where the brain starts to kick in differently. So, there’s some core constructs that will always be the foundation of motivational interviewing. But part of that evolution is as we learn more, it is a field that grows. And that that’s fascinating because not a lot of techniques or methods do. Mostly it’s, you know, you know, everything old is new again, but I think that’s when people who got trained in motivational interviewing, we, we hear this all the time as trainers, you know, oh, I got trained in motivational interviewing 10 years, so I just need a refresher. And then by the end of the train, they’re like, oh my God, this is not what I learned. this is, this is not what I learned 10 years ago. And I think this is, it helps people understand that this is the landscape is forever growing and changing and evolving. Well,

        John: Also, in relation to this overarching sense too, as we’re coming to more of an end of, of our time today, what was going through my mind earlier, too, of like thinking about over the years, what I’m learning. And how it relates to motivational interviewing it’s it somewhat relates to what Dr. Theresa Moyers is putting in her new book. And her new book is called effective psychotherapy. Motivational interviewing is not a therapy. It is a method of communicating. It was developed as a pre-treatment to engage people in their own change process. The reason I’m saying all this with it being in the book, what I’m referring to is she’s. Really started to study and I’ve listened to her on webinars, and she’s gotten a lot of flak for it, but studying this sense of genuineness and authenticity and these things that are so intangible and so difficult to measure, but she really believes that her and even Dr. Miller and some of these other people. Are believing that there’s, that’s part of why it be cognitive behavioral therapy or other approaches, be it therapies or MI that there’s so much variation of outcome within. Even the same say clinic or set of clinicians, that there seems to be a, something about the human interaction there that goes beyond the language and beyond even just the method that there’s something else.

        John: And the reason I want to give voice to that is I see that as the future of a landscape of motivational interviewing and really looking. This genuineness, this authenticity, this sense of resonance in that way, whatever that is. And it’s ironic, because it, you know, Casey, we know incorporate how there’s some robot or computer studies that show when people feel safe because they’re not speaking with a human it’s almost like they can open up more. But it seems to be that sense of psychological safety at the end of the day, that sense of, I feel safe and open to speak without judgment. And that if a human can do that, my hypothesis is that that’s going to be even more potent. Am I in the future than

        John: the usual? Maybe am I, or the. Now using motivational interviewing with artificial intelligence motivational interviewing. And so, we’ll see how everything shapes up as I’m thinking about that. But I just wanted to highlight that because that seems to be such a critical point to the, you know, yes, 350 plus randomized clinical controlled trials showing that these sorts of things can be very helpful with motivational interviewing, but there seems to be more to tap into. And that’s what I’m really excited for. And. With that kind of future look, I also wanted to reference something that you referenced earlier. Casey, before we wrap up that if anyone’s interested in this overarching landscape of motivational interviewing, I’ll just say Dr. William Miller, getting to speak with him said that he is a very humbled and appreciative of motivational interviewing. And he thinks his, and it’s far beyond him. He thinks he’s a conduit and he’s very humble. But the work beyond motivational interviewing, he believes is in a book called quantum change. And that’s what you were kind of referencing earlier case. I just thought I would mention that as we’re kind of talking about this way of treating people motivational interviewing as an extension of that, and then William Miller, who’s done all this and been a part of catalyzing. All this still doesn’t see this as the bulk of it. He sees the future. As this book you wrote on quantum change. So, I think between the genuineness, the authenticity and the quantum change, that’s the future of motivational interviewing to potentially discover more. So that was my last little bit for the landscape of motivational interviewing, but I’ll wrap it up

        Casey: there. You know, and I think this is why, you know, I have such a deep appreciation for all the people that interface with IFIOC is because our intention is to just continue to grow classes and fill in the gaps. And it’s not about classes and trainings. It really is about. When there’s a new angle, how do we share it with people? You know, there’s ways we share it through the MI plus and, and through the membership side of it, there’s ways we try to share it through for the self-study side. And then there’s through the trainings, how we keep evolving. And now there’s motivation and trauma informed that we do. And the, you know, everything from intro to advanced, to skill building and coaching, and that because of a training, I just did this week. I’m going to start working on a curriculum for motivation being in neuro divergence. And as we’re learning more about the brain and, and I, I just think this is why it’s never ending. And I think this is why, it just feels like, oh my gosh, this can go on forever and ever, and ever, and, and we’re going to keep trying to the best of our ability fill in, you know, as much of the pieces as we can for people that are interested in, in the things that we have to offer. Yeah. And

        John: that it’s not a stigma thing too, because even we have a upcoming class for motivational interviewing with in nutrition and, and health coaches. And the reason I mention that is because with that coming up, it’s like, okay, yes, I’ve been through health coaching. Yes. I’ve been through motivational interviewing before, but. So much of that, I was trying to design around what you were just talking about, Casey, the fidelity of it, the sense of embodying it with those intentions. And I want to just point to that, that it’s easy to think we do something including for myself to think we do something. Versus really be it versus think it, and it’s that practice with feedback that I don’t care if it’s with us, but if you resonate with us great, we’re a resource for you to practice with feedback your motivational interviewing.

        John: And that’s what I would invite you to do no matter what it is, whatever complex skill it is. But practice with feedback is really where it’s at to embody a lot of this stuff. And one way to do that is with the MICA tool that you were talking about earlier and, and had mentioned Tammy, and we really try to focus on that embodiment of intention. And I just wanted to highlight that Casey, for a lot of these classes, working in brain research, working in fidelity research, and really trying to make this more about embodiment rather than about ting people. And hopefully that resonates with a lot of people, but you can of course go to if I c.com, if you’re interested in our stuff, I know we had talked about mention. We also have other resources there’s you can of course go to the mint website, motivational interviewing network of trainers. That’s the international group and they have a lot of resources there. We’ve also posted our trainings on there. They have a lot of great resources, lot of great trainers and a lot of great things there.

        John: We have our website if IFIOC.com and then on ours, we also have a free. Newsletter that you can sign up for and get free resources that way as well with membership that does a lot of various skill building. So hopefully that’s helpful just to know for your own options for where to go from here. And of course you can be involved with us here at the podcast or sending questions for us to resonate and riff off of what you want from us. [email protected] That’s [email protected] and send in anything if you want to be on wonderful. We would love to have you, if you want us to answer questions, get deeper into certain subjects. Please let us know. But that’s all I have unless anyone else had anything else you wanted to add

        Casey: there? Oh, this was a great, this was, this was my brain. Won’t stop working now. So I know it’s a good conversation. My brain’s just going a hundred different directions. So, I just appreciate everybody being on here today. Yes, Have a great day.

        36 min
      • Navigating Resistance

        Navigating Resistance

        About this episode

        In this podcast we discuss:

        • What is your role
        • Informed choice
        • Empowerment vs. Power
        • Fight, Flight or Freeze
        • Culture
        • Righting reflex
        • And so much more!
        • You don’t want to miss this one! Make sure to rate us on apple podcasts or share this podcast, it would mean so much to us!

          Want to see the video podcast? Join MI PLUS+
          Explore MI PLUS+
          Want a transcript? See below!

          Tami Calais: [00:00:00] Hello, and welcome to the communication solution podcast. Here at IFIOC we love to talk communication, we love to talk motivational interviewing, and we love talking about improving outcomes for individuals, organizations, and the communities that they serve. Today, we’ve got Casey Jackson on the line, John Gilbert.

          And I’m Tammy. Welcome to the conversation.

          John Gilbert: Hello and welcome everyone. You are listening to another conversation with us at the team here. Today we have, uh, a topic. I was surprised we haven’t talked about fully yet, but it is gonna be navigating resistance. And so you might have this in a variety of different situations, personal professional, all sorts of different things.

          And so we talk a lot about this in our intro to motivational interviewing course that will reference throughout. And there’s some other, uh, resources like MI minutes setting Casey [00:01:00] can speak to, that will point you towards afterwards, but for now, that’s what we’re gonna be kind of setting the tone with.

          In terms of resistance, one thing that came to mind for me, Casey, is something that years ago you brought up of the whole rubber band analogy and kind of the physics 1 0 1 thing. So I think that could be a place to start if you are both open to that. But at some point I think that would be helpful just to get a sense of defining our terms a little bit, or what are we talking about instead of the maybe stigma that happens when you think.

          Making the label that someone is being resistant. So I don’t know if you’d mind starting there.

          Casey Jackson: Well, I, I think it’s interesting because if we kind of unwind the history a bit of this in the beginning, when I first was learning motivational interviewing and, and getting trained on it and then training on it, resistance was a term we used literally rolling with resistance and then it started falling out of favor.

           And the big shift was towards discord. And I understood the thinking behind it. Because what they were saying is [00:02:00] we don’t wanna label the individual as being resistant. We don’t wanna label the individuals being resistant. You know, what do we contribute to that? You know, so there’s discord, there’s tension between people.

          And it was interesting because I had been training resistance as the energy between two things, because I I’m so a little freakish about semantics. Like I, I, I need to, my brain needs to know what it means. And so I’d researched and, and looked up, you know, the source of it had to. Physics, you know, when you’re looking at human physics or when you’re looking at, you know, just physics and science, that resistance is the energy between two things.

          So that’s when I started using that analogy. Like if you pick up the rubber band, there’s no resistance in the rubber band, you know, it’s when we pull on it and it’s, and then I started talking about, you know, if I pump my fist together and smash my fist together, that’s resistance. What I’d say is that it takes two things.

          So there is no such thing as a resistant individual, by definition, it is the energy between two things. And for me, that really helped my brain start to evolve of [00:03:00] understanding what causes resistance and what reduces resistance, which makes it easier to navigate resistance in dialogue. I think the thing that’s so interesting with different populations that I’ve worked with.

          Is that there’s so many things we do to try to manipulate or control people to bring down their resistance, which just in inadvertently increases resistance. One of the things that I I know is such an interesting challenge, um, when I train law enforcement is one of the most common things they’ll say is, you know, oh, well maybe we could use motivationally after we get them cuffed and in the car.

          And it’s like, oh my gosh, the amount of resistance you’ve generated that you’re gonna have to come over to overcome. That is gonna. A challenge. Um, another way to think about this, if you’re thinking from a kind of an evolving practice or promising practice is what if you eliminate the resistance, so you don’t have to use force or it doesn’t have to escalate, which is, you know, I mean, we’re talking about if there’s not health and safety, if there’s not a minute risk mm-hmm , but the majority of calls officers go [00:04:00] on, there’s not imminent risk.

          You know, and so it’s just like, can we rethink about how do we eliminate that tension instead of creating massive amounts of resistance and then trying to undo it after the fact mm-hmm, just seem almost, I can see from that logical perspective, but it’s counterintuitive. Um, when you look at it from a, you know, a different model too, mm-hmm mm-hmm yeah.

          John Gilbert: It’s, it’s interesting. When you start to. And helpful and, and useful. Uh, more importantly, when you start to put the responsibility, back into the lap of the practitioner contributing or not contributing and there’s, or is something you’ll say, um, at trainings that I’ve will use in trainings of, you know, with everything you say, uh, You either have the potential to increase or decrease that sense of between you and the other person stretching or pushing or something like that.

          And that [00:05:00] mindfulness, there is something to be said about getting in the flow and a practice skill. So I don’t wanna take away from that for counselors therapists, people that are listening, that, that are in that zone, but there is something to be said about the ability to respond. There’s taking responsibility of resistance between you and something else, and it’s just a more powerful place to be.

          And so it brings empowerment back to the officer, back to the counselor, back to the therapist, back to the social worker to recognize back to the child, back to the teacher. Yeah. I mean, you’re right. That’s exactly it. And well, and oh, go ahead.

          Casey Jackson: Well, and, and the thing I think about too is you’re, you’re laying that as you’re talking, John.

          What it comes down to is what is your role and what are you trying to accomplish? I mean, maybe people don’t wanna reduce resistance. Maybe they wanna increase resistance. Maybe they wanna rally people up. So I think this is also why, you know, we’re talking about how do you navigate resistance, but I also think is what is your end goal?

          Or what is the, what’s your intention going into the [00:06:00] conversation, you know of, do you care if you’re generating resistance, if you’re pounding your fist on a table and you’re trying to make a change mm-hmm , um, these people think that, you know, generating that resistance, it gives you a dynamic tension to work with.

          And so it just, it, it just really does come down to what is your ultimate intention in, in reducing that resistance? That thing I always brace against is when people think that when I can see or they talk about that, ultimately the mindset has some. Tone of manipulation to it. And that’s when I get a little itchy, in terms of, yeah, that’s, that’s a different mindset going into, trying to manipulate someone to almost necess like rub the alligators belly.

          So they go to sleep kind of thing. Like if you’re doing that to manipulate them or, or entrance them, that’s a, that’s not what we’re talking about.

          John Gilbert: Yeah. I’d like to bring Tammy in related to that with sales, because where, where my brain goes is very philosophical and I I’ll just throw out. Well, do Casey, to what you’re talking about.

           Do you believe more in the power of fear [00:07:00] or, uh, power of kind of that sort of thing, or do you believe more in the power of love and acceptance and that sort of a thing, and that will really shape, do I want to take this acceptance, motivational Interviewing spirited thing to see if the power of that works. You can always rely on the power of the confrontation, but some people so believe be it through evolutionary psychology or otherwise believe in the power of the, uh, For being more powerful, like we’re seeing with so many things in the world, right. That it’s not even going through their brain to be in the power of huh.

          Versus Ugh. You know, and just that, but that underlying belief conscious or not is really gonna shape how you enter with that intention. I think that’s so powerful what you, you said there, but then there’s also this other thing of being mindful of. Now I’m going to use my skillset to get this person, to see what I want them to see by acting like I understand where they’re coming from and then kind of imbuing my stuff in there.

          And that is definitely not [00:08:00] motivational interviewing, but I think there is a connotation of sales with that. So I was wondering Tammy, if, if you can speak to your experience in the world of business with empathy and what you kind of. Thought it was or what you were introduced to it and just, I don’t know any, any sort of thoughts you have on resistance in sales and, and anything you learned with that?

          Tami Calais: Well, as far as navigating resistance goes, even in a sales role, I was lucky enough to believe in helping people is the first priority. So if you help people get clear about what they really. Then they might choose, you know, your product or whatever, but reducing resistance for me was never about how do I reduce resistance so I can share my product and get them to buy it.

          It was, how do I reduce resistance to help them get clear about who they are and what they want. [00:09:00] And then together we can work towards navigating getting them to their goals, essentially. So. Yeah, that’s my 2 cents on it.

          Casey Jackson: Tammy, for me, what that trigger is that I think is so helpful to think about because it expands the primary concept of informed choice, because we tend to think of informed choice more in my, like a medical model.

          We want people to have informed choice, but I become such a fan of understanding how comprehensive that is, because that’s exactly what you’re talking about from a quote unquote sales perspective is. If they can get a clear idea of who they are, if they can get a clear assessment of their needs. And if they can get a clear assessment of what their opportunities or services or resources on.

          Then the decision becomes there, theirs, as long as they’re clear that, which is not normal in the sales community. I mean, that’s not the that’s, that’s not the predominant way. It’s how do we convert? How do we [00:10:00] convert? How do we convert? How do we convert, um, to a sale and. But the thing that I think is so fascinating when you look at human dynamics, it’s in that absence of resistance that people can make a more informed choice.

          And then I can dive deep into the brain science behind that because mm-hmm, , our logical brain is more engaged when we’re not in a fear based or defensive. Status? Yes. The thing is, is that people depend on how we attached we are to someone else’s outcome depends on how much free will do we want them to have.

          And John, this circles back all the way around your question about power, you know, what kind of power are we looking? Are we looking at empowerment? Are we looking at power? For dominance or power for control or power for the outcomes of which we’re attached to. So I think that’s, mm-hmm, that for me is where it really gets fascinating.

          And when you start to peel back some of those layers.

          John Gilbert: Mm-hmm well, it also, uh, you know, you were alluding to this earlier, Casey, like healthy boundaries at a certain point of health and safety. You’ve been in some extreme situations where you still chose to try to decrease resistance and, you know, [00:11:00] nonviolent communication.

          Marshall Rosenthal. If I got that name right. Would talk about extreme situations where someone will try to, you know, especially express empathy as some of the things we’re, some of the stuff we’re alluding to, but in extreme situations, does it always work? Not necessarily, but there is a certain place where.

          I don’t know that there there’s a decrease in a sense of me fighting you or wanting to attack you. If you understand me more now that is easily could be from a privileged place, not being attacked right now. Not, you know, being a, a male, all these things and not being in a situation as a female out, walking at night.

          Right. There’s so many things that I wanna honor there yet. At the same time, there does seem to be a, there, there to go. This is not okay for myself or someone else. And where is that line for yourself and being a little bit clear, you might need to come up with it in the moment, but up until that line, having the awareness and the skillset [00:12:00] practice of expressing what it must be like for this other person.

          And I, I do think the violent situations are an extreme example. I do think Casey, you mentioning the officer thing is important, but I’m wondering. Kind of situations. Where, where do you see kind of the most danger, but still application for Motivational Interviewing Casey with the officers? If we want to take it to some extreme, I know we show some videos in our training.

          And then where do you think it just could be more. Um, like more basic life day to day resistance. I’m just wondering from both of you kind of to get a spectrum of resistance here of there’s this end of it, where maybe we start to bring in compliance and then there’s this end of it. Just day to day with, you know, kids or partners.

          And so I was just wondering kind of to that discussion.

          Casey Jackson: The thing I immediately think of with day to day is I think of, you know, I mean, I’ve got twin 13 year old, Yeah. You know, and I’m married [00:13:00] and so on any given day. I drive, you know, so, you know, um, so the capacity for resistance on any given day where there’s tension between two things, uh, you know, I watch the news, I go on social media at times.

          And, and so the opportunity on a day to day basis for extreme resistance, uh, sometimes is not even in law enforcement. I think it’s sometimes, I mean, especially with this entrenched, because it’s not these. Touchstone moments, um, like with law enforcement, I mean, this is a, can be a chronic issue with a teenager who just is refusing to do their homework, or no matter what their parents say, they’ll run away before they stop smoking weed, or you can kick me out.

          I mean, that kind of day to day resistance will grind people to a halt. That constant pressure of resistance is it’s taxing on people and can do damage. Those are the things I think of day to day reality.

          Tami Calais: Which is why I think it’s so important to be talking about [00:14:00] navigating it because we all encounter resistance every single day.

          Absolut, whether there’s big resistance or little resistance.

          Casey Jackson: Absolutely. Mm-hmm, tension between two things. I mean, that for me is just always, what I look at is just, yeah, that, that, that capacity is so high. I think when we get into navigating it, then again, for me, it comes back to the intention. What are we trying to do?

          You know, are you, I I’ll just take personal examples. Am I trying to get my daughter to get the homework done? or am I trying to help them develop study habits or do I just want them to graduate or, you know, what is my there’s, you know, and we can wrap it all together, but the more you wrap it together, the harder it is to untangle mm-hmm

          So it, I think it takes an onus on if we’re trying to navigate resistance of what is my attachment to the outcome, what is my end goal? And do I believe using pressure is going to get me the best long-term outcome, because Motivational Interviewing is much more about long-term outcome than short-term outcome mm-hmm

          So is it a compliance thing where’re grounded or is it a behavior change [00:15:00] thing where you have choice and you’re gonna get the benefit or the consequences of your choices? Mm-hmm and it’s, those are two completely different mindset.

          John Gilbert: That really triggered in me this whole thing. We don’t need to go into the, the brain child.

          That is that amazing concept, Casey, that you had come to you, uh, related to resistance in politics, but I do want to allude to, and we can open up as much as that as you would like the sense of when we think of resistance. We think of decreasing resistance, we’ve been alluding to it in our training. We talk a lot about empathy becoming shoulder to shoulders, stepping in their shoes, getting a sense of feeling, what they’re feeling, having a sense to care enough, to feel what they’re feeling and then giving voice to that.

          All these sorts of things are not necessarily an attachment to an outcome other than, giving voice to this experience of this person. As soon as you bring in [00:16:00] that attachment or that direction, or that guidance of where to navigate that view. Now we start getting into, can you remain in equipoise? And we talk about that right?

          In other, other podcasts and getting into that, the thing that, that triggered for me, that you were just getting at is if we’re gonna decrease resistance, one way to do it because I want to talk about other ways of decreasing resistance is empathy and getting out of your perspective into this other person’s perspective.

          And so I just the example you gave with, you know, your, your twin 13 year olds, it’s like. To decrease resistance. One way to do it is just leave your reality completely and empathize. But then at the same time, that can be so triggering as a parent. That can be so triggering in so many ways. It seems like that’s one way to decrease resistance and I want, and we can unravel that more is empathy.

          But then there’s also this like level of your perspective to [00:17:00] bring in and how do you navigate that of not being manipulative, but still decreasing resistance? Um, you know, be it in a parent, in a relationship. And then also my brain goes to. One of the talking points we talked about, which is how do you decrease resistance without necessarily empathy?

          Like, are there ways of decreasing resistance without empathy? So those were just two thoughts I had.

          Casey Jackson: That’s a great question. 15 questions you have there to unpack and then, and then, and then, and then, and then the, the, the biggest thing I think of that went, went through my brain when you were talking about John, and I’ve never even thought about this, you know, analogy before, but my brain just always goes there is I think of a teenager suited up with football pads on ready to hit their parents or their sibling or their teacher.

          And they just keep running into these walls. Like they’re looking for somebody to run into. And what the vision I have is what if they were just on a white piece of paper, you know, with no walls, [00:18:00] nowhere, and they just keep running and running. There’s no walls, there’s nothing to run into. There’s nothing to have an opinion about.

          I can almost see them running until they just get exhausted and drop down and start sobbing. Cuz there’s nothing to fight against. And they’re not sure what to do if we can’t give them something to fight against. This is how you get to the source of where ambivalence resides. As long as there’s things to fight up against, then we have something, we get outta an opinion and get rallied up inside of ourselves around.

          And that’s where our righting reflex comes in. And we just wanna have something to pound against, but , I think of, you know, forest gum running from coast to coast or whatever, it’s just like when there’s just nothing in front of you and just keep going and going. There’s no stop lights. There’s no trees.

          There’s no people, there’s nothing. It’s just open Prairie and you just run and run and run forever. Until you just get exhausted cause you have nothing to bounce up against. And I think there’s something about if I don’t give them something to bounce up against, you’re gonna get to the, the core of their ambivalence.

          And this is why from a brain science. It’s so fascinating to me because we get defensive. [00:19:00] We need something to fight against when we’re in that fight, fight free. We’re in that primal response. And the reason we’ll go there sometimes is if we can’t move up into our executive function, if we can’t solve the problem, if our brain can’t do the metrics around how to get out of this situation.

          Then the converse is we get sucked further and further into our defense mode, especially if we feel pressure from other things. So it’s easier for me to swing at you and be mad at you and be pissed at my, my parents, or be pissed at this person or mad at this person or angry about this and wanting to pick a fight and half the time it’s because we can’t solve the issue ourselves.

          So I’d rather put my energy that I’m so fr that internal frustration of stuckness or frustration with status quo that makes us more edgy or snappy or snippy at other people. That’s just like, Ah, ah, I mean, just it it’s quintessential teenager is what it is. And teenagers are quintessentially in a chronic state of ambivalence.

          you know, because they don’t wanna do what their parents say. There’s part of their brain that knows that, you know, some of the stuff their, their peers may be doing may not be the right thing to do, but I don’t wanna think about it anymore. I just wanna do it. And [00:20:00] my parents are stupid and you’re stupid and that’s stupid.

          And you know, I don’t wanna do my homework and that’s not gonna change anything. And I hate history class. I’m never gonna use it anyway. Like it’s just all of those things to fight against because they really don’t know. And they know that they don’t know, but they don’t wanna give themselves acknowledgement that they don’t know which means you’re gonna have chronic resistance.

          John Gilbert: Hmm. Hmm. There’s this sense about me? That’s like, Well, but isn’t there. So aren’t there so many distractions in life that you can always point to. So you’re always gonna be able to point outside yourself. Absolutely. So there’s always resistance. You’re never gonna be in that white God bless America. Yeah.

          Casey Jackson: The us gives us things to pay attention to 24 7 365. So we don’t have to think about ourselves. We can react everything around us. We don’t have to, we don’t have to engage our executive function in our brain. We let other people do it for us.

          John Gilbert: Yes. Yes. Well, so there’s this. Yeah, damn. Tammy. What resonated for you with that?[00:21:00]

          Tami Calais: Just some personal beliefs, but yes. Yeah. yeah. Oh my gosh. Don’t go.

          Casey Jackson: It is it just, and then we get further and further from who we are and what our values are. And then we let other people dict dictate our values, and then we blame other people. When we get in trouble for decisions we make, you know yes. When it’s like, you’re not taking responsibility for what your values are, what are your values?

          And I know what some people are thinking is what if some people don’t know what their values are or if they came from a family where, you know, they have antisocial values or, I mean, it just, this is when we start to pull on these threads that it starts to unravel.

          Tami Calais: Oh my gosh, that, yeah, that, yeah, that really, yes, people, it’s so easy to get distracted by other people and the noise of what the world is trying to tell you about what you really value that you don’t figure it out yourself.

          Yes. And that can impact so many different things.

          Casey Jackson: Well for me, and what’s so critical about that is when everybody’s making those decisions, it does nothing to develop executive functioning children. This is what [00:22:00] makes me so nervous about technology and not for being an old curmudgeon.

          It’s really from going, wow. When you look at how the brain fires and functions. What are we doing to foster executive functioning development? When the kids just literally, I watch my own children at times, just staring at a screen for an hour. And I’m just like, I can’t like I can literally see that their brain isn’t firing it.

          It, it causes me chills thinking, you know, the matrix I’ve actually talked to the kids about that, of just going, you know, you’re basically a battery for something else because you’re just sitting there absorbing information and drooling and, and your brain is not using its capacity. It’s being anesthetize, which means they’re not developing executive functioning skills.

          Tami Calais: Well, and it’s interesting. So as a new mom, myself, like it’s so interesting how much I am constantly at a fight with myself between compliance and be behavior change with my child. Absolutely. Absolutely. Almost a two year old. He’s gaining more independence, but it’s funny how like quickly I [00:23:00] resort to. No, we’re just doing this.

          Yes. Without, without, like you said, engaging as his executive functioning, which then creates a ton of resistance. Yes. Cause I’m just telling him what to do versus trying to create a little bit more one empathy. Yes. And relating to why he’s upset in that moment. Even though I think it’s so silly that he’s crying.

          You know, to him, it’s a big deal that I took away a lollipop or whatever. Yeah. Or that we didn’t go out to the garage today, whatever it was . But then, then trying to navigate like, well, what do you wanna do about it? And that is a completely different way of communicating that we don’t naturally do.

          Casey Jackson: Like, you know, what’s so fascinating, Tammy is we don’t naturally do it in our, in our culture.

          And because I had this whole string of thoughts, as you were talking. Because of, we live in a culture about mass production and maximizing. Which means we never have enough time, which is delusional because if you go to a different indigenous [00:24:00] culture, that is where you see this depth of wisdom that’s passed on from generation to generation, because there is time.

          There’s not this sense of, well, we gotta get to the store. We’ve gotta get here. We’ve gotta go pick up your dad. We’ve gotta go do this. You’ve gotta get to soccer. We’ve gotta do this. You’ve gotta do this. That that’s our culture. And so we as a team, I mean, all three of us have talked about fundamentally bandwidth.

          We wanna do everything. We wanna do it, right. We wanna be involved in all these things. We wanna maximize our life experience and we wanna get it all done in an eight hour day and not be exhausted. It’s just math. The bandwidth doesn’t exist. And we get all of these shortcuts to having to think and use our own executive functioning.

          So we turn on the news and we have other people tell us how to live our lives. And we turn on social media and have other people tell us how to live our lives because we don’t have the bandwidth to think for ourselves. So it just, it feeds itself. If you don’t get back to what the core, that’s why I go back to an indigenous perspective is, oh my gosh, there’s all the time until I die to teach this lesson to my son, um, you know, every day it’s something that we think about.

          And because it’s not, we don’t [00:25:00] have to get to soccer practice, you know, and then don’t have to get their homework done and they don’t have a, you know, a. The birthday party that they’re getting to. And, you know, it’s just all these chronic pressures socially that we have in our mainstream American culture.

          And I’m gonna try to find some way to bring this back into how to navigate resistance.

          John Gilbert: No, no, no. I got, I was thinking to this, I’ll do that brain soapbox. All of a sudden I can climb up there and just. Preach preach, preach. no Casey where my brain was going. That connects is just something that was talking about earlier, as you brought up the, indigenous populations and culture, um, around that more importantly, the culture and how critical it is to pay attention to culture and, um, equal opportunity and things like this and how the, the situations in which we’re raised really shape a lot of things. We know this is different therapy or cultural socio, um, uh, what am I looking for when, uh, [00:26:00] economic psychology in groups? Oh, sociology. Yeah, all sorts, all sorts of things that, you know, situational will shape how we think or act given the container we’re in.

          And I just really wanted to give voice to that because culture and, you know, Daniel conman and all these people will point to, we think our character would act in one way, but when you control for all these variables through behavioral economics and all these studies. Our container we’re in our culture, how we’re influenced by our parents.

          All these things seem to really matter to influence our belief systems and then the things that we end up doing. And so I wanted to give voice to that because you had mentioned what’s that perception of time and immediate compliance, growing up in a culture like that is going to have a default sense of either.

          You know, immediate fight or flight, like you were thinking, uh, or mentioning earlier, or a sense of there’s time. Like you were just getting out with your son, you know, like, what is that default [00:27:00] sense? Is there a sense with this discord, this lack of harmony that we’re experiencing this resistance we’re experiencing, to what degree is there?

          This sense of embrace over time for long term change of that. And what degree is we need the short term change immediately. And that seems to be a really important default, regardless of, is it through the power of compliance and getting them to do it? Is it through the power of love and acceptance? If we don’t feel we have the bandwidth or we.

          Have more of that culture of immediacy, like you were talking about immediacy. Yes. Then we’re gonna just go to that, even if we believe in this love thing, right? Yes. I just don’t have the time for this love thing. Right? Yeah. Uh, so it’s just a really, really important point and not all families have the same, uh, opportunity.

          There’s a lot of adverse childhood experiences and a lot of right disenfranchised groups that unfortunately. Create that impaired executive functioning that make it harder to have equal opportunity to do that. Uh, so I just think that’s really important to give voice to is [00:28:00] culture and container shaping.

          Absolutely how immediate that is.

          Tami Calais: And I just wanna say that really resonated with me, cuz again, I, I go back to, I literally deal with this every day, trying to reduce resistance with a toddler. And every single day, it tends to be that culture of “rushed-ness”. And like, I’m trying to get places. I’m trying to do things I need to get X, Y, Z done.

          So I need you to do X, Y, Z. Like you said, John, I tried to write it down, but we don’t have time. Oftentimes I don’t feel like I have time to work towards behavior change because I need compliance in that moment for my timeframe. Mm. And I think that’s really important to recognize, because I think a lot of us, I think of leaders, I think of business people, I think of parents, I think of, law enforcement, any of the people that work serving and communicating with people, you often feel like you don’t have enough time to work towards behavior change.

          You don’t have [00:29:00] enough time to be empathetic to put yourself in your shoes to get the guard down. So you can really talk about behavior change and what they’re ultimately looking for. Cause ultimately my toddler, my toddler is not trying to upset me. My toddler is not trying to be difficult. My toddler is not doing any of these things, but it’s my communication method that’s causing it.

          And so again, I am not trying to get my toddler to do what I wanna do, but I am trying to get them to communicate clearly to me. What is it they really want.

          Casey Jackson: Well, and there’s two things that I think of that just hit me so hard is we can’t, you have to put it in the context of understanding the righting reflex.

          Because when I think about, you know, you see your son has climbed into the candy drawer, you know, eight in the morning and your righting reflex is triggered by. Eight of those different behaviors, just because like, what are you doing up this early? What are you doing in there? Why haven’t you, it’s just, there’s so many [00:30:00] righting reflexes, which is going to generate resistance.

          And so it’s not just the righting reflex side of it. It’s also this sense. Like we keep talking about the time or the urgency around it as well, too, our perception of what we’re doing as well. I think of those parenting moments, Tammy. I think it’s not only that, it’s what my perception of my own parenting is and what good parenting is.

          My perception is if somebody else could see me. In my parenting in this moment and all the narratives that you have around that as well too, or your, your perspectives as a spouse or your perspectives as a boss or your perspectives as a law enforcement perspective, as a doctor, a teacher, it just doesn’t matter.

          It’s, what’s, what’s your perception, how other people perceive you, which can generate a lot of resistance to what’s the right thing I should be doing. I mean, and then you get into these whole, how do we navigate that level of resistance? It’s that, that, that deep breath and it’s. Just passive acceptance. I think this ties all the way back to me, what you had said, Tammy, about helping people get to that [00:31:00] place of informed choice so they can just breathe.

          But then it just is gonna come down to how attached I am to their outcome, because if I can just take a breath and breathe and realize it, they really do have some choice here. And how attachment to this specific choice in this specific moment is really facinating. So ways that I think of kind of encapsulating, how do we navigate that?

          Resistance has to do so much with our own righting reflex and our attachment to our perspective, our perspective about ourselves and how we are in this narrative with this person. How important is that? Um, or how much it is really about this other person, their own narrative around themselves. I mean, that right there is almost goes full circle from where we started from, you know, is it the rubber band or is it the two fists pushing together?

          Where, where am I gonna put myself in this equation? Um, So do I need to reduce this resistance? Do I wanna reduce this resistance or do I wanna create a different experience? That’s that’s gonna come to a personal professional choice.

          John Gilbert: Yeah, it seems to be that as we’re, we’re coming to the close of this one, [00:32:00] there is that, that personal, am I being reactive or responsive?

          That those sorts of connotations, how mindful am I being in my response to this sense of tension, this sense of. And the, you know, we could relate that to emotional intelligence and other work that’s out there as well. Uh, we had alluded to empathy throughout, so I just wanted to point people to the podcast that we did on empathy, with the head of the social worker podcast.

          That was a wonderful, um, Deep dive into empathy for some practical ways to potentially decrease resistance. If, anyone would like to listen to that. We didn’t get into lots of other ways than empathy, but we did talk about resistance from so many angles. It was so interesting. And I just wanted to summarize, like the sense of belief in time seemed to be kind of a, key indicator of what’s my response to resistance, my sense of belief in time with my culture. How intense is this situation with safety or not safety? And that sense of psychological safety seem to be really [00:33:00] important as well. What are healthy boundaries or what is my actual boundary here of safety?

          And those seem to be two underlying fundamental things we talked about that will shape, how reactive or how re responsive we are, um, with compliance or trying to decrease resistance.

          Casey Jackson: The one thing I think about John, as you’re talking about that, is it just, it, it just keeps popping into my brain. These are things that if people really are interested in any of these concepts, our intro class covers these things.

          It’s not even about Motivational Interviewing per se. I think it’s startling to some people who take the training, even people at higher risk for these trainings. I think they’re almost startled a bit that it’s not so much teaching technique. It’s teaching these constructs because for me, context matters so much.

          Um, and so I just think if any of these concepts are intriguing, the righting reflex, equipoise, dealing with resistance. I mean, that, that , that is so much just what our intro class is about is for people to understand these dynamics. Because the dynamics are almost more important than the technique behind it.

          Mm-hmm . And [00:34:00] so if there, if you are curious about any of this stuff, I mean, that I’d point people in either more of our podcasts around some of these concepts or, um, some of those MI minutes, but honestly that I, I would just send people back to the intro class and just say, really look at context, because there’s so much, what we teach is about context, about behavior change in this resistance construct.

          Yeah. The emotional side of approaching Motivational Interviewing versus the cognitive side. And there’s a lot we get into in the intro in that that a lot of people find more helpful than, um, potentially other Motivational Interviewing trainings they’ve been in. It’s been a lot of the feedback with that. It’s fun. It’s surprising that we can bring up a concept like resistance.

          We talk about all the time and we can spend 30 minutes talking about it. So I just, I, it’s always fun for me that we get to do these topics that it’s just like, wow, I feel like I could do this topic 15 more times and we wouldn’t even repeat, you know, there’s just so much depth and breath to it. So I appreciate people listening to this.

          John Gilbert: Well, with that, we, um, invite you to check out all the things we got, the intros, of course, uh, probably one of the best bang for bucks of what we talked about today.

          There’s [00:35:00] the Motivational Interviewing minutes as well, if you’re interested in that, on, uh, our YouTube and you have that to, to look to, and, um, any other podcast we have, thank you so much for listening and hopefully this was worthwhile for your time and we’ll see you around for the next one later. Take care. Excellent. Thank you.

          Tami Calais: Thank you for listening to the communication solution podcast.

          As always, this podcast is all about you. So if you have questions, thoughts, topic, suggestions, ideas, please send them our way at [email protected]. That’s [email protected] for more resources, feel free to check outIFIOC.com. We also have a public Facebook group called motivational interviewing every day.

          We have an amazing blog and we have lots of communication tips on our website. In addition to all these amazing resources we do offer online public courses on our website on motivational interviewing, and [00:36:00] effective communication strategies. Thanks for listening to the communication solution by I F I O C.

          37 min
        • Guns, Violence and Motivational Interviewing part 2 with guest Steve Wohl
          About our guest

          Lieutenant Steve Wohl

          • 25 years with the Spokane Police Department
          • Training Director at the Spokane Police Academy
          • BA from Eastern Washington University in Interdisciplinary Studies, minor in Communication and Psychology.
          • Previously supervised the Major Crime (Robbery/Homicide/OIS) unit, Special Victims Unit, Internal Affairs, and Tactical Operations unit.
          • Commander of the Spokane Independent Investigations Regional Response team (SIIR) investigating all critical incidents involving regional law enforcement officers.
          • SWAT and Hostage Negotiation team Commander 2014-2019.
          • About this episode

            We loved having Steve on as a guest so much that we just had to schedule to have him back again to discuss even more about law enforcement and Motivational Interviewing.

            In this podcast we discuss:

            • Compliance vs. Behavior Change
            • Lewis and Clark school shooting
            • New Era of law enforcement
            • Fight, flight or freeze
            • And so much more!
            • Want to see the video podcast? Join MI PLUS+
              Join MI PLUS+
              Want a transcript? See below!

              Hello, and welcome to the communication solution podcast. Here at I F I O C we love to talk communication, we love to talk motivational interviewing, and we love talking about improving outcomes for individuals, organizations, and the communities that they serve. Today, we’ve got Casey Jackson on the line.

              John Gilbert and I’m Tammy. Welcome to the conversation.

              Hello everyone. Welcome back to the MI guys here. We have our team as usual. And this time again, we have our very special guest, Steve Wohl. I’m saying that right? I know sometimes I mess that up. Um, but anyhow, Steve, welcome back and thank you for coming back.

              Steve Wohl: Oh, my, my pleasure. Glad to, join you guys again and, and, love the, the opportunity. So appreciate you guys having me on the team.

              Casey Jackson: Yeah. You know, Steve, what I wanna dive in with this is, [00:01:00] you know, after we wrap last time, the first thing you said is, gosh, we didn’t even get into the active shooter side of this.

              And, I think that is so predominant right now, unfortunately, um, you know, I just know you’ve had multiple experiences and I think even launching this, what I want to really look at and, and kind of lay the foundation for is walking down that path between compliance and behavior change. Because even as we tee this up and we talked about it quite a bit last time, but I just think, I think from my mind, it helps me from a social worker.

              Really bridge that gap that we talked about last time between, you know, that the behavioral side of it, law enforcement side of it, community safety, you know, civilian safety, officer safety, like just, I think it’s just such a complex issue that people try to oversimplify. And if we’re gonna start from a simple place, I just wanna start from that place of kind of compliance versus behavior change and why law enforcement has to put on the paths that they have to just.

              For, [00:02:00] for reasons that most of us don’t even comprehend. Um, and then the way that your brain continues to keep trying to expand, how do we make this as effective as possible with the best possible outcomes for everyone? So I just wanna start from there as we walk down this path, but I just wanna kinda set that tone for, for people listening as well, too, that this is just so wildly complex, and I don’t want to feel like it gets oversimplified.

              So, but, so, so what were some of your thoughts as we were wrapping up and they, the things you were thinking, like, I just wish we could have had a chance to touch on this a bit.

              Steve Wohl: Yeah. You know, I think with Motivational Interviewing Casey, you’re always looking for behavioral change and, looking for the way to get into people who are in crisis. With, active shooters, a lot of times we are called when, the violence is, is going on. And we have got to stop or neutralize that threat, and we don’t always get the opportunity to sit and talkwith the person in crisis to, hopefully end the situation, [00:03:00] the bad situation, in a way that would be beneficial to all involved.

              Um, a lot of times we show up, after the fact, unfortunately, and not always do we get that opportunity? I had mentioned, in previous conversations with you guys, uh, about a shooting, a school shooting we had here in Spokane. Boy, it’s, it’s going on 20 years, probably 18 to 20 years ago at Lewis and Clark high school.

              And so I was a part of a specialty team that, showed up to that, situation. And ultimately we ended up having the opportunity, to sit and engage and, and talk with, a young man who was going through some, some real crisis in his life. And I look back now and I think to myself, had, we had, your training, Casey, could we potentially, have altered or could we have, maybe got those, those hooks, that we needed to, help him, prior to him forcing, a, a shooting. He was, troubled and he, ended up forcing law [00:04:00] enforcement to, shoot him, um, which is, which is devastating for, for everybody involved.

               Not only him, but his family, but the law enforcement as well. Cuz that’s not the outcome that we look for. In a perfect world, we would, utilize the tools that, you have trained us with Casey and, and tools that we’ve, taken through different courses. And we would had a better outcome.

               Not always is that gonna happen? Right. But we’re always looking for that, especially now. Anytime we engage with somebody in a, a negotiation, or a, somebody that’s going through crisis, we’re looking to, end it, in a way that, is mutually beneficial for, for those involved and, and police.

               So I think that’s big is looking at, at how now Motivational Interviewing can change those active shooters where we have a chance to talk with them.

              Casey Jackson: What was the scenario? How’d that play out? I mean, what was the, for as much as you can share about it, I mean, what, how did that situation play with that youth?

              Like what had happened? Was there anybody else that was [00:05:00] harmed in that? Or how did that, how did the situation unfold?

              Steve Wohl: Yeah. So he, going through, definitely mental health issues, and later, diagnosed mental health issues. He had taken a firearm, I believe, it belonged to his father, and had gone to Lewis and Clark high school in the morning.

               Ended up going into a, like a science wing and fired off, some rounds. Um, and kept some, some people in a, in a classroom for a time. They were eventually able to, escape. Police were called a fire alarm was pulled. We responded once we got the call that, um, it actually was an active shooter where we had, a young man with a, gun inside the school.

               And we were able to with, uh, security and everything, we were able to lock him down into one hallway of this, of this science lab. He ended up barricading the room. But after a time we had a couple negotiators from our team. Um, at the time who were able to get a dialogue with him, through a [00:06:00] doorway, he would, he would come and go.

               But he was, uh, definitely in, the pit of despair that day. He just kept wanting, to force and encounter as he wanted to take his life. So truly, I don’t, believe he was there to hurt other people, but wanted to force, a deadly encounter with law enforcement. And so we had an opportunity to, for an extended period of time to talk with him, face to face kind of down the hallway.

               And, he would, he would kind of go through those, times where he’d be up and then he’d come back down and we were able to, to kind of bring him back down, and have him a little bit of rational talk with him. And then he would get very irrational. Ultimately, uh, the negotiations broke down, unfortunately.

              And he ended up, pointing a weapon at officers, to start that, I guess, uh, suicide attempt. He ended up, being shot and, we had medics on our team, on our SWAT team at the time, uh, who, so we were, we were to him able to clear everything out, um, very, very [00:07:00] short amount of time.

              And we were actually able to, save his life. And in the end, he ended up getting some help that he needed. And we actually built a pretty good relationship with him. To the point where he became a part of our, talk that, that our two negotiators did around the nation where wow, we would go in and talk with and come, came back.

               And I’ve met with him since that opportunity or since that time. And, uh, it’s kind of led to a, an opportunity for us to, talk with people and to talk about mental health and about, uh, these situations. And he was, able to, move past that very, that very sad encounter and, and is now doing so much better.

              Casey Jackson: You know, it’s so easy me for, to get caught up in the, just the, the story of that, the narrative of it.

              And then there’s a moment in time. I cuz my, my brain never stops. I think when you were relaying that Steve, the, the part that hit me, was, and you and I have talked about this, we talked about [00:08:00] in the last podcast as well too, is that, that vacillation between trying to get engagement, relationship based or trying to work with their ambivalence internally, you know, there’s that.

              And I think that’s just, I think that’s where we’re starting to find that where it’s gonna be the intersection between some of the expertise in law enforcement and negotiations and expertise in communication from like a Motivational Interviewing perspective, looking at the ambivalence. But what struck me when you’re talking about it.

              I just started thinking about different body cam footage that I’ve looked at, and the difference between active shooters that are looking for suicide by cop and active shooters that are, actively like on the verge of taking their own life with no assistance from officers, you know that they’re not doing that.

              And for me, I think where my MI brain goes and I’m, I’m treading lightly here because I, this is unexplored ground. But the first thing I think about is if they want suicide by cop, my brain is like, I can almost guarantee that the ambivalence exists inside of their brain. They don’t wanna do it. They can’t do it.

              I don’t wanna take my own life, which is all signs [00:09:00] of potential change talk in there. Just, when you were talking about, it’s like, okay, where would my brain have gone in trying to have this conversation find, where is that capacity? I know from law enforcement, it’s where there’s a hook from motivational Interviewing it’s, where is that potential for ambivalence?

              Where can I shine light or reflect something that they can see? There’s two sides of their brain that are firing at the same time. And I think that’s, what’s so fascinating. And I don’t know if that’s true, but that’s the first thing my brain goes to that the difference between wanting to be shot by somebody else versus.

              I’m gonna kill you first, or I’m gonna kill myself. And nobody gets a chance to where I think there’s, it feels like there’s a, a, a smaller sliver of ambivalence in those in instances when it’s an active shooter who wants to be shot. I think that by definition, is there some modicum of ambivalence that has to exist inside of their brain then?

              And I think that’s the part that it’s just, for me, it’s just fascinating to explore the construct in terms of how do you. Go in there. And I think that’s where, where my, what my sense [00:10:00] is is that when we try to go relationship based, that’s not what they want. And that’s where they start going more into, like, I’m not gonna do this game.

              Versus working within their mindset of going, can I tease out both sides of where the ambivalence exists? Um, you know, you’re just done. I think what I, I jumped to is I think of how. Efficient and effective O’Brien was with the individual with mental health addiction issues on the fire escape.

              And they show that video all the time. And that was one by the time he got him in the back of the, of the car, you know, he said, you know, I didn’t wanna take my own. I can’t take my own life. But I want somebody else to do it because I can’t. Um, and I don’t wanna live anymore. And it’s like, I’m like, I mean, literally if you get out of the context of it, that is just the, the core definition of ambivalence of deep, deep ambivalence with an individual is, you know, I want to, I want them to take my life, but I can’t take my own life, but I’m just tired of the bullshit.

              I can’t take it anymore. And so it’s like, oh my gosh, this is where I always want to dive in and go, okay, we’re really on a precipice. [00:11:00] Promising practice of things that from an evidence based practice perspective, can we explore this and really look at this, but then I think the level of , you know, of critical incidents here is just like, you know, how much do we explore?

              But that’s also where promising practice comes from. We’re we’re kind of treading new territory at the same time. So I’m just curious what your thoughts are because you’ve been inside some of those brains before what your thoughts are.

              Steve Wohl: Yeah, I fully agree, Casey, and I think we, have to dissect the difference between, a individual in crisis, who is wanting to hurt himself and not others. And then those who are, true terrorist acts that go into schools and just wanna cause mayhem that don’t exactly, um, have any desire to have. They don’t have the ambivalence because they know this is the outcome. This is why I’m gonna do.

              On top of that. I think there’s a difference between, juveniles and adults when it becomes, um, even suicidal. Cause I think some adults have made the decision and there’s nothing we’re gonna say they’ve made that decision. They, they might not be able to [00:12:00] do it themselves, but they’ve kind of made that decision where we look at some juveniles who, as we know their brains aren’t fully functioned.

              And so they’re not complete. And so they’re, having a hard time with that ambivalence and a lot of times,. I look now at every encounter that we have with, uh, people in crisis and look through that Motivational Interviewing lens of how can we make that connection to get them back to reality versus it’s the despair end, you know?

              And so, but there is a huge difference between, those very criminal, minded. Terrorists. I call him that go into schools and just cause harm because that is what they’re gonna do. Um, and unless we stop that threat, neutralize, that threat, they’re gonna cause as much harm as possible where the Lewis and Clark one, we were able to, to slow down.

              He didn’t wanna hurt anybody else ended up, he wanted to hurt himself, but wanted us to do it for him. I think, I fully agree with you Casey, in, in that. In a true [00:13:00] Lewis and Clark shooting or other situations where I’ve negotiated with people who are suicidal on the side of a bridge.

              Most of the time there’s ambivalence because they, they don’t know a hundred percent, if they want to do it, they know it’s final. And so, yes, if we can delve into that and build those relationships and, and get into that, um, can we, and a lot of times we do pull them back to reality where we can get them the help they need.

              Casey Jackson: You know, this is fascinating to me because I just, and I’m just pulling numbers just anecdotally from my own experience. But when you were talking about that, like the terrorist brain side of it, like this is my last day and the ambivalence has been resolved. There is no active ambivalence in that this today is my last day.

              It’s my last cigarette. It’s my last whatever. And this is, this is a done deal. What my brain went to from my years, working in, uh, corrections in, in federal and state corrections is, I always would tell people in my experience. So this is anecdotal and I’m, I’m just wondering if it’s where it lands with your [00:14:00] experience with it is for everyone in prison who by definition can be diagnosed antisocial personality disorder, right.

              Or they wouldn’t be in prison. I always said about maybe 5% of that population was truly sociopathic with no social conscience. Probably 90 to 95% are people that just didn’t made bad decisions. Horrible things should be imprisoned. There should be consequences, but when they’re laying in bed at night, they’re like, how the hell did I get here?

              Or, you know, and missing things. And God, that was stupid. And, you know, so there’s that the remorse that happens. But I think it was really difficult for me because I always in my social worker’s side is that there’s always that redeemable. There’s something inside that I can find. But for the years that I worked in prison, There was that five to 10%.

              That was like that kind, where you go home and you just don’t feel good in your stomach. Like, it just feels like there’s that kind of evil out there, that there is no social conscience there. It really is, if they’re released, it’s gonna be mayhem and there’s just no [00:15:00] remorse. What’s no, there’s no even semblance of remorse anywhere inside of their experience.

              Um, it’s more of a sense of fulfillment than remorse. Um, and it’s not from a trauma perspective. It’s just from a, a brain perspective from my experience. And I think that’s what I think of. And again, I don’t know the numbers, that’s just what anecdotally I always felt was about 10 to five to 10% was truly sociopathic.

              And I wonder if that’s the same thing with the terrorist, but I don’t know that that mentality, that when they wake up in the morning, last cup of coffee, last cigarette, and I’m gonna do damage before I step out. And nothing, nothing is gonna stop because from a Motivational Interviewing perspective, there is no ambivalence that exists, um, when you’re looking at that.

              And so I think, I think that’s another part of it too. But I don’t know which, and then there’s the social media and the media side of it, even, you know, 20, 30, 40, 50 years ago, then there’s the, how it’s presented to the public. So I don’t know, because it tends to be the worst or the worst are the ones we always get a see splattered on the screen, but it’s those then I keep thinking about where is that percentage of [00:16:00] people where things are reconciled, but either law enforcement doesn’t get credit for it, or it’s just another day at the office for negotiations.

              Where it is just massive ambivalence inside of these individuals. So I’m just, I have to throw all that out there. Cause my brain was running through the Motivational Interviewing lens and thinking about where is that modicum of ambivalence? And when you said that, I know it’s gonna be a terrorist act. My gut automatically went to, oh, there is no ambivalence.

              There, there, they are gonna take as many people as they can take out and they know they’re going to. So what, I’m just gonna throw that out back to you, what your thoughts are and how’d you, you deconstruct.

              Steve Wohl: Yeah. You know, I think your numbers are probably pretty close may, maybe a little high, but I, I do think there’s a continuum of there’s the, and I don’t even, I even hate to say their names because I don’t like to throw to, to publicize ’em, but the John Wayne Caseys, the Bunds that are just criminal they’re, they’re evil, there’s evil people, and had the opportunity to sit down.

              With John Wayne, Casey or whatever, I’m not gonna change what he, what his mind is and what he wants to do and what, where he gets his satisfaction from.

              Casey Jackson: That’s exactly what I do with [00:17:00] mine goes to Hannibal Hector. Yeah. That’s my Hannibal. Hector is just like, I don’t care how smart you are. I don’t care.

              There’s no semblance of ambivalence inside of there. None. Yeah, no, it’s how you get. Yeah, no, totally.

              Steve Wohl: But I do think there are many people that are currently in prison. There are people who, unfortunately will become terrorists of some kind or something that life, um, whether it be social media, whether it be, um, family things, maybe how they grew up, just their environment, some of that plays a role in putting them in a situation that is just the Tinder that sets them off.

              And then they’re down the road going. I can’t believe I did that. I didn’t see myself doing this where the other one. Know good well that yes, that what they’re doing and, and, and how, I mean, they’re just evil is what it comes down to. So I would say that 5%, um, you know, being that, that sociopath, person that you talk about is, is probably a, a pretty legitimate number, just, you know, from just my experience, [00:18:00] 26 years in law enforcement, um, just for the people we deal.

              Casey Jackson: See, and that’s the thing I think that’s so, I mean, cuz we keep peeling back layers and peeling back layers and I think that’s where it gets so fascinating. I think one of the things I wanna say too, knowing this is a podcast and if people are listening to it, I think because we are really looking at a lot of unexplored ground.

              I mean, some of this ground has been explored so many times, but I think the things you and I are talking about are starting to explore things in just a different way. Like you were talking about last time, you can see more convergence than divergence between, you know, the behavioral health side, just with CodeDeploy and law enforcement, where people tend to think that there’s more of a divergence there.

              But I think there’s this piece of it, about what are we trying to get people to understand in terms of how the brain works and this intervention, or how do we communicate in a way to be effective? That what struck me? I remember, I think it was the first series that I did for law enforcement ever. And it was, there [00:19:00] was tension in the room.

              People were listening, but there was tension in the room, but I remember God, he was the nicest guy in the long run. people were pretty. Not as they were just present. Um, but guarded rightly so, but the one I wanted to talk about is I think he was, I don’t know if he was with, uh, I, if he was with internal affairs at the time, but he was doing a lot of the investigations and he said he just became really transparent and just really a nice way.

              Actually, it wasn’t confronted, but he said, you know, I, I guess my biggest concern is I’m gonna see you sitting across from me, um, in a court room,. Testifying how I didn’t do this and it cost somebody their life. He goes that I, I just have to throw that out there cuz that’s part of where my anxiety’s coming from.

              And I, I think I wanna be transparent about that right now too, because we really are talking about things that have never fully been explored. So there’s no expertise around it. So, I don’t want people to think that we’re saying, oh, this is the right way to do it. What [00:20:00] we, what I think we, I, I think what I love this conversation is because we’re kind of piecing together different realities and seeing where can we build a better mouse trap?

              Where can we do something that’s better outcomes for all people? So I just, I feel like a need to say that, cause I don’t want people listening, thinking, well, why isn’t everybody doing this? Or this is what they said, or this is what it shows. And it’s like, this truly is kind of the Dawn of a different way of looking at things.

              Bringing some of the old ways of doing things that we know effective to the table. So I think that’s partly what I wanna say when I move into this is as we start to explore this, nobody can say what was right or wrong. I can, I couldn’t sit in front of somebody and say they should have used Motivational Interviewing this would’ve solved the problem, because I think that’s asinine for me to think that I could know that, but I think what’s so fascinating is, is we continue to explore where is that?

              Modicum ambivalence can make a profound difference in this outcome. Because we know the data is so clear. If we can work through the ambivalence, we know the data around. If you give more oxygen to [00:21:00] change, talk, the person talks more about change. The data is really clear about that. When we, when we use affirmative statements or self-affirming statements, the data’s really clear that the brain starts to go there.

              It wants to have this self affirmation inside. So, and that’s with individual statements that can come out of our mouth. So that’s where I start to peel it back from when you’ve got a brain that we’re saying, where is that modicum of ambivalence inside the brain and how do we get some oxygen in there to see, can we expand on that ambivalence and then utilize that ambivalence to move more towards the change talk side?

              And that’s just a different mindset. It, I think where I get fascinated, I’m gonna throw it back to you, Steve, on this is I think that’s my fascination between like reading the Chris boss stuff, you know, never split the difference, looking at negotiations mindset and there’s some parallels, but there’s almost a fundamental mindset difference between the two.

              I was even thinking about that when I did the training last week, or this week with, with, uh, Kern camps group was that it’s like, okay, you’re looking for that hook. You’re looking for the hook. You’re looking for the hook, you’re looking for the hook. And, [00:22:00] and I think that construct is really similar to where we’re looking for that Motum of ambivalence, but it’s almost like to.

              To get the win and get the safety, which is good. And I’m thinking about where do we get to that resolution of ambivalence? We can set up for longer term change or a warmer handoff to another system or, or service. So, but that’s just my take on it as I deconstructed. So what are, what are your thoughts on it?

              Steve Wohl: Yeah, well, first I want to I’ll address kind of like the part where you said there was a, you know, somebody who would, who was kind of, you know, guarded a little bit guarded at a training. I think the law enforcement world, um, we’re a different animal. As you know, God, I do our, our, our mindset is always like, you know, because everything that they worried that you would do, we get every time with a defense attorney, right?

              They’re gonna break everything we did. And. Here’s the cause of this, you know, there’s, there’s, there’s a correlation between the outcome because of what you did or what you didn’t do. And so a lot of times, every, every event, we’re a part of, we’ve got to have a game plan of, [00:23:00] um, we wanna do everything correctly, but sometimes even if we do everything correctly, something bad could happen.

              Uh, like the, the Lewis and Clark shooting. Right? We did, we, we negotiated, we, we had a good report. Everything was going smooth in the end. um, that young gentleman unfortunately pushed our hands and, and a bad outcome became of it. Right. And so, um, you’re, we’re always kind of playing that, that mindset. So I, I understand where they come from knowing you though.

              Um, as a person, I know I can easily tell ’em, that’s not the case with Casey or with this training. It’s this is truly, um, a wave of the future and how it’s helping, not, not only law enforcement, but, but relationships. With, with family, with everything. Right. And so, um, that piece I felt like I needed to, to touch on.

              Um, but I do. Yeah. I, I do, I do agree with you, Casey. It’s changing in a good way with law enforcement, and the courses , and the mindset and the, um, dealing with people in crisis and, and looking back into, um, what we call the hoaxes, um, you know, in negotiations or somewhere to, to basically, [00:24:00] uh, alter that person’s game plan.

              And ultimately that’s what we want to do, whether it is through, you know, getting a hook into ’em or, or, or getting into that ambivalence and, and getting them to realize that they can. Make make a decision today, step off the ledge with us, the, the, the ledge or, or put down that weapon or, or do whatever.

               It’s changing how, not only law enforcement, but. Many relationships can be impacted by it, through, you know, the, the Motivational Interviewing piece that, that you teach and that you bring to the law enforcement side. Um, and it’s, it’s, it’s a teamwork that we’re, we’re looking at, right? We don’t have all the answers and, and as you have stated, MI is not gonna work in every situation you can, you know, when there’s no ambivalence, right?

              Yes, absolutely. And so, yeah, and so, but in those situations where, where it can work, we need to be proficient and, and, and have the, the skills. To make that hook. Like we talked about, um, with Jan, where, where Jan and I [00:25:00] had that, uh, that situation where I was able to, to, to chat with her, during a mock, crisis, in one of your, your trainings, um, we just need to, we need to continue to build those skills so that when we can do it, and it is , available, and we can make that difference.

              We do. And we don’t lose that person. Um, so yeah, I, I fully agree with you though.

              Casey Jackson: I got so many things going through my brain. The, I, I, it’s fascinating to me with my own ambivalence about. I am such a bleeding hard social worker. I love what I do. And I, I know what a bleeding hard social worker, and then I hear myself.

              not defending law enforcement, but I just wanna, I want people to have perspective. And when you were just talking about what struck me, Steve, is that I think what people don’t fully give credence to is how many people. People won’t allow themselves to have a [00:26:00] camera strapped to their chest and watch people work, have them work all day.

              If there’s things where they could get in trouble, a physician is not gonna do that. A surgeon’s not gonna do that. A social worker won’t even record a session to get feedback on their motivational interviewing skills. Doctors. Won’t do it. Nurses don’t wanna do it. Nobody wants to be monitored and law enforcement doesn’t have a choice.

              And so everything can literally be deconstructed and criticized. And with that, I just want people to understand as professionals, if that’s what your life was, are there times that you’re gonna stutter step in what you do from what you normally do, because you know, people are watching and those microseconds can be life and death microseconds.

              I don’t think people have an appreciation of how complex that is. And then you have. 50 different experts in a courtroom saying why, what you did was wrong when you’re a human being and your brain can only absorb so much data [00:27:00] based on the training that you’ve had. So I think that’s, you know, you’ve all the, all these different things and I’m not going right or wrong, good or bad.

              Any of that. I just want people to understand how perspective, how complex this is. And I said, this last time, I’m gonna say it again. Especially since people are listening to, this are usually more on the Motivational Interviewing side of the world. Most of us. don’t even want our recordings to be listened to, to get feedback on if we’re doing good in motivational interviewing.

              Even if we’re role playing a situation where it’s not life and death, people get nervous about just doing a role play about, should I go back to the gym or not, and submitting that cause they’re afraid to get feedback, like something as benign as that compared to the situ situations we’re talking about with life and death and no choice about this is gonna be recorded.

              So I just, I just feel a profound need to say that again. Like I did last time and. Podcast around this. I want people to have perspective and it’s not. I think cuz if we’re in Motivational Interviewing then there has to be some sense of empathy there. Right. so it’s just like, yeah. So there’s no, I have no sympathy for Steve, um, [00:28:00] but a profound amount of empathy.

              So I think that’s the thing that I think of is just that think of the complexity of what we’re talking about here. And when you hear Steve talk about, you know, a terrorist mindset where the, the intention. Las Vegas, the intention is to do as much death and destruction as possible. Um, and so it’s just like, that’s fairly easy for us to say, yeah, that’s, that’s an, that’s not an MI based situation.

              That is a isolate and, you know, take him out. I mean, that’s just, there’s there. That is. Stop this immediately kind of perspective. It’s just, I think it’s just fascinating. We have the capacity to have these conversations about where, where does that potential for ambivalence exist? And I know some of the, the curiosity from some of the Motivational Interviewing purists are gonna be well, how can you even use this in law enforcement, if there’s not a specific target behavior?

              And what I keep thinking about is. When we get inside that ambivalence, you know, there could be multiple target behaviors, but I just think from a law enforcement perspective is a target [00:29:00] behavior is just that no one gets hurt. You know, that the person gets the help that they need, that that’s, you know, they’re pretty good social target behaviors that we wanna work towards.

              It’s not, are they gonna quit smoking or keep smoking? Um, and I think this, it pushes. The motivation side of the house, I think to really start to expand because we get so target behavior focused on how do we help people resolve ambivalence in a way that gets to a positive outcome, even if we can’t drill it down to one specific target behavior.

              So just, I, I keep, wanna throw out context when I think about the audience and, and the ways that, you know, so many people that are interested in Motivational Interviewing the way their brains can absorb

              Tami Calais: well case as we’re wrapping up and everything too, that. You know, you talked about the target behavior also, you know, we at, IFIOC like to talk about the focus mountain people’s values.

              I also think there’s a little bit of a difference between a target behavior and someone’s values. Sometimes people will not, sometimes [00:30:00] people want to live in alignment with their values. And so you might not necessarily have a target behavior, but you do have opportunity to explore people’s values and the alignment or misalignment that is there.

              Casey Jackson: Well, and when you say that, Tammy, the, the first thing I think of is, and it’s how, when we’re talking about this in this context is how quickly our brains get sucked down into the trees of just the day to day, day to day operations and day-today Ney. And, and the more we just, the more the trees close in on our brain.

              The the further away our brain can see the top of the mountain where our core values are. And I think these are some of the individuals we’re talking about. I, I think the one that the LC one and so just, just how quickly that the trees can close in, or if you’re born in a system like Steve was talking about, if it’s the family of origin or through mental health issues or just, you know, whatever going on with brain chemistry or environment.

              So the way those trees kind of close in on us, as far as what we think are the most important things, we do start to lose perspective. And I think. I don’t even wanna go [00:31:00] too far down this rabbit hole, but then I keep thinking about that same thing from all of the people in the situations, like almost every weekend now, where there’s, where there’s active shooting is that I think with social media, how those trees just close in around our brain.

              And we can’t see the forest through the trees, literally. I mean, there’s just, all these issues are so wrapped around their face, that they lose sight of who they are. And what their ultimate values and goals are. And, and the reason why Tammy, I agree that a hundred percent, I, I remember John and I were at a, the mint, uh, one of the international mint forums, all the Motivational Interviewing network of trainers.

              Um, and it was the first time that I heard, uh, Steve Rollnick say, you know, maybe we emphasize target behavior a little bit too much, and maybe we’re not looking enough at values. And John and I literally, like I made, he looked at each other and said, oh my God, this is, this is what we’ve been teaching for probably six years now.

              Kind of felt like we were outliers because there was so much pressure about no, there has to be a target behavior. It’s not Motivational Interviewing and here’s Steven Rollnick. One of the, you know, joint creators of motivational interviewing saying, you know, I think [00:32:00] target behavior’s really important, but I think we’re missing.

              Where is that deeper motive as well too. And that’s where values. We need to start looking at human values as well, too. And then I, then I translate that all the way back into this conversation with Steve going, we just know there’s a, there, there, you know, we know that there’s things we can continue to grow and evolve and explore and expand in not only our knowledge base, but our skill set on, on trying to work towards all of us, trying to get towards better outcomes for.

              John Gilbert: Yeah, I’ll, I’ll mention too with the training that, uh, we were doing this week as well, that I was conducting for the values piece of it, with the focus mountain that you’re bringing up Tammy, and what you were talking about. Casey being more values based. There’s a lot of resonance around it and it’s a particular skill.

              And, uh, even after we went through these three day, um, components of it and went through activities, it really is one of these things that we get so sucked into the target behavior of this particular thing that it’s, it’s so hard. And I could only imagine [00:33:00] Steve, in, in your situations. Crisis is on the table, um, to not make it about a particular outcome, because I think of, you know, this person is seeking more connection in their life and not feeling so alone or feeling, um, wanting to have some relief and some peace of mind from the constant whatever in their head or abuse they’re facing or whatever’s going on.

              They’re, they’re, they’re seeking something. Uh, if there is that ambivalence in there and there’s motivation in. It’s to then recognize and say things like one way you’re thinking is to take your life. That brings peace of mind. And that’s something that you’ve thought about a lot. And, you know, there are other ways like Casey, you referred to that O’Brien video.

              We show in. The, uh, trainings with being on the bridge, you know, you realize there are other ways to go about your values, or you thought about other ways to go about your values, you know, imparting these in reflections or having questions is just to do [00:34:00] that and then not attach yourself to the particular outcome of.

              Not jumping them, not following through at a certain point, you gotta move to compliance in the situations. It sounds like Steve, you were talking about where all of a sudden, okay, I gotta make a judgment call. That is this something I just gotta come in and, and make the decision. Right. But leading up until that point, can you try to be values based and open.

              Two different ways to get up that mountain, to have their, their values get met. That’s just a very heady conceptual thing. Versus when you’re in the moment being scrutinized with your body cam footage, uh, I just wanna honor that as well, but there seems to be a practical there, there, that seems to be important when, when you get into the communication of it.

              So I don’t know how much Steve. Resonates for you or how much you’ve done that with your own skill set. But I would say that’s something Casey that I have seen people [00:35:00] resonate with a lot are the values.

              Steve Wohl: Yeah. I agree with you, John. Um, and Tammy on the, on the values piece. And I think when, when people are in crisis, whether whether you are a 17 year old guy or gal that can’t see past, you know, very myopic, can’t see past what’s happening today.

              Or you are a, a 50 year old person who’s battling, um, a, a disease and their world is closing in and you can’t see that forest through the trees. They can’t break out of there. Our goal in law enforcement, I think in, in, and especially in the, in your world is to clear those trees, help them find that piece where they can look past this very nearsighted right now, this needs to happen to fix it to, to, to help them maybe clear those trees and weeds out a little bit to say there, there is something to look forward to and to, to kind of.

              Clear that mind. And I think that’s where, um, Motivational Interviewing comes in, cuz it’s teaching us [00:36:00] how to move past that ambivalence and to, to get that hook and to really help them, um, see that there is a future and that it’s not just, uh, the negative right now. And, and you know, I, we see this in people in crisis, um, in, in mental health crisis.

              But we also see it in, in, like we talked about patients who are going through cancer and going through other things, it overwhelms their brains. Yes. And unfortunately we can use this type of, of training and tools in life. It’s not just critical incidences like that. Right.

              Casey Jackson: Excellent. Yes. Well, and, and what you’re talking about when they’re overwhelmed in life, this is where I get into the, the brain science side from a trauma inform side is, and when our brain gets overwhelmed, where does it go?

              It drops down into our reptilian brain, which is what fight flight or freeze, like, I mean, lit what you just articulate is the definition of when people are stressed and overwhelmed, what does the brain do? It goes into survival mode and survival mode is. Usually one of those, you know, fight flight or [00:37:00] freeze, which is exactly hijack, right?

              Steve Wohl: Absolutely. We, we call it hijack for a reason, right? Yes. It’s boom. It’s taken over. We now immediately, you guys, us have to find a way to get that, take that back, that hijack back right. Of that, of that reptilian brain.

              Casey Jackson: And I think this is what’s so interesting or the irony in it is because what we know what the data shows is when people feel deeply, deeply, authentically heard and understood.

              That high level of empathy, high acronym, not sympathy, not, not the compassion, even side of it, but what is deep, accurate communication of empathy, active empathy, accurate empathy. That’s where that brain starts to relax a little bit because it doesn’t have to be on the defense then, uh, when it feels hard and understood.

              And when it’s not on the defense, what is it? When I do it start, it wants to start to explain what the struggle was, which is where the ambivalence exists. And I think that for me, peeling that level back is like that mindset is so different than where’s the hook. Where’s the. and I think this is where we keep kind of pushing a little bit further the ball a little bit further down the field in terms of, yeah.

              That is a different way, [00:38:00] a different mindset with it. Um, yeah. And the last thing I wanna wrap up with that kind of dovetails with this is John. One of the things that you said that really, again, I think it’s where we’re pushing the ball down the, the field a bit more, um, because it is such a, a fascinating concept to deconstruct is.

              When we talked about detachment from the outcome, I literally, I can really, I can remember where captain Cummings was sitting and Dan waters was sitting in the room at, I F I O C when we’re talking about, you know, working on detachment from the outcome and both of ’em said, Casey, we are attached to the outcome.

              We don’t want them to jump . I was like, we are. And I said, I, I, I know that. And I know that that instinct is we are attached to the. But that in some ways can contaminate the situation as well, too, because then you’re more about what you’re trying to get for the outcome versus trying to be that every modicum of energy that you put there, every I iota of energy, you put, there is one less capacity for you to be in that [00:39:00] person’s reality to reduce the resistance piece of it.

              So there’s this almost shadow tension going on of being attached to the outcome. That makes it harder to let go. It’s almost like this rubber band that keeps you from leaning forward and reaching out a little bit further to get inside of their experience when you’re holding onto the outcome, the outcome that you can’t control.

              And again, this is why it’s pushing the ball even further into the darkness a little bit. Cause it’s like, yeah, that’s really easy to say when you’re not sitting in that situation. Um, you know, and I think this goes back to the humanity of what we’re talking about, of how complex these issues really.

              Steve Wohl: Yeah.

              You know, and that’s an interesting point, Casey, in that I think it, it shows it like just doing, I go back to that same training we did with Jan at I F I O C and I was attached to the outcome because I felt, I felt Jan’s pain, even though it was fictitious. Yes, she was. She, it was, it was not, it was, she was not gonna jump off a bridge yet.

              I could feel her pain and struggle and she could feel when I [00:40:00] made a connect. A hundred percent real as that. Right. I mean, so there, there, there’s a, there’s a human piece to that, that having that connection, but you’re exactly right in that sometimes there’s outcomes that we’re not gonna control, but if we can kind of try, start working out that peeling away that.

              That those layers of the ambivalence. Um, that’s where it, it happens, but there’s a human side of it too. Right?

              Casey Jackson: Yeah. And, and, and I think the thing I wanna wrap up, God, now there’s 15 more podcasts I wanna do. Um, but , as soon as you say that, Steve, oh my God. My brain goes straight to that moment is when I can almost guarantee if we had your brain hooked up, is your mirror neurons lit up at that moment in time?

              And I wonder the distance between the mirror neuron. Lighting up, which is where, where accurate empathy comes in. When we know that we can almost step inside the experience of another human being, we have that brain capacity to do that with, with, you know, with, with the way that our brain is structured and how far distant that is from our need to control the situation, which is gonna be probably closer to the own [00:41:00] fight flight freeze reaction of trying to get them off the edge is gonna be hovering between that really smart part of the brain.

              And that f*** something goes wrong here. This is not gonna bode well. And I think that. Uh, because I think that’s where the whole team was at. It was on that precipice of, yeah, we get this empathy, we get this reflective listening, but you’re the one who stepped off into the, I think, into the mirror neuron and just went.

              Whoa, this feels real. And she felt the realness there and it’s like that to me, that’s where the synapses jumped the gap. Um, and the connection happened. And I think that is different than trying to control outcome. The I, to me, I, I not even in law enforcement, I think in behavioral health, healthcare, I think in all of our professions that I think is the new frontier of how do we explore.

              The brain on that level. And how do we maximize that to improve outcomes? And is it, is it born ironically from that depth of empathy, um, to get that connection, to get somebody off the edge. which is different than finding a hook to pull them off the edge. Sure, sure. So, well, this guy can’t even thank you.

              Now. This is my brain hurts now. so [00:42:00] it’s oh my God. This really big. I really do think this be something we do quarterly. Um, just there’s so many things we can talk about, but I think the law enforcement thing is just so prevalent in our world right now. Um, yeah, I, I. A thousand things going on and I know we need to wrap up, so yeah.

              John Gilbert: Yeah. I know we need to wrap up too. So I won’t, uh, continue on, on the, the many thoughts that I could, uh, add in here as well, and, and riff off of with, with you all. So, Steve, I just wanna say thank you so much for coming on and, joining us and yeah, it sounds like we’ll be getting to do this again, if you’d be open to it and, just getting to learn more of your experience and all that you bring to the table.

              Just thank youso much..

              Steve Wohl: I just thank you guys too, for the opportunity to partner with you guys. I mean, not, not just me with you three today, but law enforcement with your rural, right. Because that’s what, ultimately, we want to have the tools to help our people. And so, um, just this relationship, [00:43:00] um, has got to expand and, and, and that’s what we’re doing here at the Spokane police department with I F I O C and, um, and Casey’s group.

              And so we just appreciate the opportunity to continue to, to build upon that relat.

              Casey Jackson: It’s a hundred percent mutual. I can tell you that. Perfect.

              Tami Calais: Steve, if people wanted to connect with you in one way or another, what would be the best way to do that.

              Yeah, through,

              Steve Wohl: our, through our public relations, um, here at the Spokane police department, uh, uh, director, Julie Humphreys is the, uh, is kind of in charge, um, of that.

              But we, we, we deal with, uh, you know, different entities that way. And so by all means. Great. Thanks again, Steve. Yep. My pleasure. All right, take everyone. See, next time.

              Tami Calais: Thank you for listening to the communication solution podcast. As always. This podcast is all about you. So if you have questions, thoughts, topic, suggestions, ideas, please send them our way at [email protected].

              That’s [00:44:00] [email protected] for more resources, feel free to check out. IFIOC.com. We also have a public Facebook group called motivational interviewing every day. We have an amazing blog and we have lots of communication tips on our website. In addition to all these amazing resources we do offer online public courses on our website on motivational interviewing and effective communication strategies. Thanks for listening to the communication solution by

              45 min
            • Ethical Influence and Behavior Change with guest Josh

              Ethical influence and behavior change with guest Josh from Valuegraphics

              About our guest

              Josh is the VP of The Valuegraphics Research Company. Helping global brands like PayPal, lululemon, and Genesys to increase their ROI, reduce their risk and improve ESG by using a research-backed values approach.

              By conducting custom research, The Valuegraphics Research Company is able to provide a unique experience for each of its clients, that uses data to remove the guesswork from their marketing and messaging.

              The demographic models that marketers have used for centuries are no longer effective because people don’t fit the demographic stereotypes of days gone by. Around the world, companies are looking for an alternative that helps them find the intersection between profit and purpose and Valuegraphics is that answer.

              About this episode

              This podcast episode is a must listen! Josh joins us from Value graphics to share his experience on values and the core values found in the U.S. and Canada and around the world, as well as discuss ethical influence.

              In this podcast we discuss:

              • Pre-frontal cortex and how it relates to our values
              • Explaining demographics, psychographics and valuegraphics
              • Values theory
              • Competing values
              • Sales, manipulation and connecting people’s values
              • Recruitment, culture change and employee retention
              • Top 10 values in the whole world
              • If you loved this episode, please rate it on apple podcasts and subscribe to our podcast for more great podcasts!

                Want to watch the video podcast?

                Join MI PLUS!

                Want a transcript? See below!

                [00:00:00] Hello, and welcome to the communication solution podcast. Here at I F I O C we love to talk communication. We love to talk motivational interviewing, and we love talking about improving outcomes for individuals, organizations, and the communities that they serve today. We’ve got Casey Jackson on the line. John Gilbert and I’m Tammy.

                John Gilbert: Welcome to the conversation. Hello again, everyone. We have a guest today that is going to get into something that if anyone has listened to our podcast on values, focus, mountain, all that good stuff. This will be familiar, but. You will also expand your mind in some really cool ways. I’ve got to hear our guest on various podcasts out there.

                I suggest listening to his work. He has a book as well. He can tell us all about himself. It’s Joshua Dittmar and he, is [00:01:00] gonna tell us about value graphics and what that all means and how we can relate Motivational Interviewing to that and how he’s doing a lot of massive change at a large level. He’s the VP of value graphics research company, and he’s helping global brands be it PayPal, Lulu Laman Genesis their he’s using these value graphics to help with increasing.

                ROI, reducing their risk and improve some of their outcomes with a researched, backed values based approach. So we’re gonna talk about that, how to do that with values and get into some aspects of how do we think about ethics in relation to discovering people’s values, how we’re influencing them.

                And just some of the, some of the things around that from an Motivational Interviewing perspective, as well as Josh. Your perspective as well, more generally from everything you’ve learned. So anyhow, welcome Josh. And if you wouldn’t mind, I know you have some information you were thinking of sharing about what does this even mean with value graphics and how could people get attuned to [00:02:00] it?

                Josh Dittmar: Amazing, good day guys. Thanks for having me on. And yeah, really looking forward to having a chat about values and a values driven approach with people who are already living and breathing this stuff. It’s always exciting to talk to like-minded folks. Yeah, this this amazing database that has originally been created by our founder, David Allison, and a team of researchers out of New Zealand has really given us some powerful tools to not just change businesses, but also, you know, change the world potentially and, you know, help us change the way that we look at each other and see each other from, a personal perspective through our values. And instead of just looking and, you know, taking in the world through a, with demographic stereotypes, so lots of fun on the business and profit side, but also being able to make a, you know, social impact as well is, is really helpful. So I’ll start off with a, a little bit of a story which will help to provide some context around this, you know, massive database that we have.

                We’re accurate in 180, out of 185 countries. There’s over 750,000 survey responses that we’ve [00:03:00] collected. All anonymously. And we have 152 different languages that we’re, you know, able to translate into. And we’re super, super accurate, more accurate that you need for a PhD at any university in the world.

                So for all the stats geeks out there like me, that’s We’re accurate to 3.5% with a 95% level of confidence. So that’s just super, super accurate with our research and but this, this whole idea was born out of the thought that every organization on the planet. Wants to engage and motivate a group of people, whether it’s, you know, us on this podcast, we wanna get people to come onto the podcast, whether you’re a Toyota wanting to sell people, cars, whether you’re a, you know, religious organization, you want donations.

                Every organization wants to get a group of people to do a particular thing. And so, you know, we are all walking around with the questioquestion our heads, how do we get people to do things? How do we get people to do what we want to buy our products to, you know, come to our shows, come to our events, listen to our podcasts.

                We always start off this, [00:04:00] this introduction with a story about three friends in an alley at midnight. So if you can imagine Covid’s ending, we haven’t seen our friends for a while. I’m from Australia, living in Canada. You can imagine if I get to see a bunch of Australians come over to Vancouver, Canada.

                We’re gonna go out and we’re gonna have a good time. And we’re at the bar. And, you know, we haven’t seen each other for a long time. There’s a lot of, you know, punching in the shoulders, slapping each other, just really enjoying each other’s company. And it gets to about one or 2:00 AM and we’re like, okay, maybe it’s time we, we take the, you know, take the party elsewhere. The bar’s closing down and we’re gonna walk back to our apartment and you know, it’s you and, and you and two other friends and you start to walk back and you come across a dark ally. And the first person who’s driven by adventure sees this alley and they think, wow, cool.

                Okay, let’s go down this alley. Come on guys. Like, I love you. This will be lots of fun. It’ll be a shortcut. We’ll be able to get there quicker. Super exciting. Second friend, friend, number two, who’s driven by safety is like, this is the worst idea ever. I love you [00:05:00] guys. We’re not going down his alley no matter what, that’s not happening.

                Like I love you. Let’s go back to the bar, get an Uber. . Yeah,

                we’re gonna go back to the bar. Let’s call an Uber. Like let’s go back to the apartment safely. That’s all it matters. Friend. Number three, who’s driven by friendship is like, guys, I don’t care what happens down the alley, back to the, you know, back to the bar, whatever happens as long as I’m with you guys.

                I love you. I’m cool with whatever happens. So there’s three different people. We’re three different responses in an instant. It’s an instinctual response. It’s not like they had to sit their own process. Am I 26 to 35? Am I 35 to 46? Like, you know, you know, the numbers, you know, the, the demographic profiling that we have around everything, nobody sits there and goes am I a six foot, two white male?

                Does that mean that’s okay for me to walk down this D dark alley like that? No, we have an instinctual reaction and the instinctual reaction comes from our values. Our values, determine everything we do. [00:06:00] And, you know, the, the way that we market and message and talk to people is through this demographic lens.

                And it just, it doesn’t really make sense. It’s a little bit, it’s, it’s cracked, it’s broken, you know, it used to work for us in the past when we had to have certain, you know, back in the day, it was important that you fit at a certain role in society and you did a certain thing, but now the world’s changed, you know?

                Institutions are still kind of back in this, this olden day way of looking at things, but people have changed, you know, we can go out and you can literally learn anything off your phone. You can become anything that you want, which is fantastic. And it’s a part of, you know, we’ve, we’ve really gotta start talking to people through this value based lens.

                And so thankfully there’s people out there who, you know, figured this out way before we did, who are a lot smarter than we are. If you think of the science of neuroscience, you think of the prefrontal cortex of your brain. It’s like the CEO of your brain. And it has this filter, which decides, which decides what feels good and what feels bad.

                 I move towards things that feel good. I move away from things that feel bad [00:07:00] and that filter is your values. If we look at things from a psychological perspective, which it sounds like where some of your question comes from an individual basis, it saying, okay, if I have a person. And I can understand their values.

                I can, you know, maybe do a, my Briggs test or, you know, something like that, the engram, or all sorts of there’s all sorts of different ways that you can do it. And you lie on the couch and they’re understanding your values. And they’re going to coach you into getting back in alignment with your values to deliver happier life.

                And then if we look at from a sociological perspective, Which is massive groups of people. Why did this group vote Republican? Why did this group vote Democrat? Why did this group move this way? Why did this group move the other way? They’re looking at the past. So they’re saying, okay, what caused people to do this?

                And those three different, you know, groups of sciences, they don’t agree on too much. They bicker about all sorts of all sorts of things, but they all agree that our values determine everything we do. Our values are the determinant for our behaviors, our actions, and our emotions in our lives. And [00:08:00] so we, you know, we took a little bit from all of these sciences and looking at large groups of people, instead of looking at the past, we’re trying to use it as a predictive tool to determine what people will do in the future.

                And so we’re able to go out and we’re able to survey people. We’re able to look at what drives their lives and use those tools to connect with people and help businesses connect with their customers. Instead of asking the question who are our people, you know, is often a question. We, I think, I think I know, you know, you might get, you might have seen a.

                Sign in the front. You know, when you go into the office building, there’s a massive sign that says our values are safety, respect, and friendship, you know, and it’s like, you can kind of tell that someone sat in a boardroom with a box of donuts and made those three, made those three values up. And they’re like, these are our company values.

                And it doesn’t really have anything to do. Who, how, who decides what that is, you know? And there’s this big. There’s a gap between, okay. We think this is how, you know, the information that we have. We have some demographic information, we have some psychographic information, which is really [00:09:00] useful, but how do we leap, make the leap between here and there to saying that it’s safety, you know, friendship and respect.

                What we’re doing is we’re narrowing the gap so that there’s more information. So you can go, oh, like it’s really, it’s personal growth and it’s friendship. And it’s personal development, let’s say for example. And then once you understand that you can speak to the people in the organization and we we’re removing the guesswork is essentially what we’re doing.

                John Gilbert: So on that real quick, that’s really interesting cuz you brought up psychographics and that’s where I was curious. How is this, how are value graphics different? Because you know, Casey you could chime in here at some point too, of, of how you develop the focus mountain that we train on of that there’s a finite amount of human cross-cultural values based off of values theory, at least.

                And that. It’s harder to, to why a value, like why that, that why fulfillment? Well for quality of life, I guess you could always bring it back. You know, it’s like at [00:10:00] what point do you stop and call something of value versus being more of a psychographic. And I was just wondering how you determine the values and what, what is a value versus what is a preference or a desire?

                 It seems to matter, cuz it seems to define everything. Totally, totally.

                Josh Dittmar: So we think of demographics, psychographics and value graphics as a three-legged stool of audience insight. So demographics is a very simplified oversimplified definitions just to preframe my my next couple of sentences.

                But demographics kind of define what people are. So, you know, certain age bracket, certain income, you know, where do they live? Those sort of things. Like what, what is this person doing? And you know, where are they in their life? Psychographics. We look at it as very simplified, like a record of what people have done in the past.

                So if we, you know think about, I’m wanting to, you know, sell someone some green tea or sell someone red bull, and I know that they drink two cups of [00:11:00] coffee a day. That’s really useful information to know they’re already a caffeine consumer. You know, it’s great. They, they already consume it twice a day, every single day of their lives.

                It’s really, really powerful information to know, but it doesn’t inform me how. Get them to take an action on switching to green tea or switching to the red bull that I’m trying to sell them. And the values are that, that driver behind behind it. So just to, you know, preframe the rest of what I’m gonna say is like we’ve got demographics, what people are psychographics is a record and value graphics is, the motivator or the driver in their lives. So essentially it sounds like what you’re asking is what makes a value, a value? Like how do you determine where we stop with all the other stuff that people talk about? You know, they say I really value work.

                I really value money. And you’re like, well, those are things they’re not really, they’re not really values. So, I mean, part of this came out, you know, we have the, I think it’s the world values index is, is that says that there’s 40 values. And what we have after doing all these surveys all around the world, the research team have actually found [00:12:00] an extra 16.

                So if you’re a stats geek, that’s like finding 16 new pyramids. You’re like, oh my goodness, this is crazy. 16 new ways of how people see and move through the world. And that can change from, you know, country to country or region to region is how they talk about something can be different. It’s not gonna be a very concrete answer for you like the stats it’s because we’ve done so many, so many surveys and people talk about things in the same way.

                They start to group themselves in different ways. And so there’s a 2% margin for, you know, a group, being created or a segment being created in one way versus another. Let’s say for example, we have an audience called the workaholic investors. These people like they work and they work and they work. They self-report working 80 hours a week and they invest all of their money because they really care about status and they really care about building wealth.

                Then we have another group called the life driven workers who work and work and work and they self-report 80 hours a [00:13:00] week, but they’re working for experiences. So one of their highest values is experiences. Now they’re like kind of similar groups. They’re kind of talking about the same thing, but they’re a little bit different.

                There’s different things that drive their lives when they’re talking about. Status it’s to, you know, move up in the ranks and, and invest and you know, all that sort of stuff. It’s like a very work focused, but then the life driven people, they’re like really just working for experiences. So if you’re talking to them about anything in their life, talk to them about experiences rather than about status, you’re gonna talk to this group versus the other.

                So they’re very, very close, but there’s like these slight differences. And so when we are looking at, when we do so many, so many, so many surveys over and over again, and have, you know, thousands and thousands of different codes of what separates people, it starts to bleed itself out. So it’s kind of like a mass like how many people we’ve done allows us to group them in this way.

                It wasn’t as clear at the start and it’s become clearer and clear and clearer. Once we had a hit a mass critical number.

                John Gilbert: So [00:14:00] then that’s to say that you’re, you are able to put ’em into, if you really wanted to overlapping or different, like 56 different values or something like that, that you could label. And then from that place, you have a sense of this bucket with these people, with these values, this bucket for this people, with these values.

                And there might be some overlap in there, but there’s like a VIN diagram differentiation, depending on.

                Josh Dittmar: Perfect. Yeah. We use Vinn diagrams, like all of the time as a perfect example. What’s really cool is when you see people, like exactly what you’re saying , and they’ll talk about something in a different way.

                So like the I’m I’m family driven, I’m working for my family, or I’m working for status. There are 56 values, which, you know, is fantastic that we have this finite number of values makes it a lot simpler, but everyone talks about them in different ways. But the cool thing is, is we see the same types of people show up in different parts of the world.

                John Gilbert: So where I’d be curious to transition is into [00:15:00] the influence part of it. But before we do, I just wanna highlight, like we get into especially in our advanced training for motivational interviewing that we do, we get into values based activities of trying to understand and discover someone’s values beyond the behavior such as drug use or something that someone might see as negative or antisocial and find the value the driver like you’re talking about behind it, or the, the other happier, healthier value.

                That they want to be different in their life and reconnecting with their family or something, but the value being that sense of connection or contribution. So in that way, we get into that in our advanced training to help identify values and then help people align. And that’s where there seems to be an overlap here with us.

                It’s helping people. We’re influencing people to help them align with their values. Now there is as Terry Moyers, Dr. Terry Moyers and other people would say, there’s an aspiration there that we’re trying to help them do something right. [00:16:00] It seems like maybe there could be something different, at least how I was interpreting what you were talking about that I’ve heard other people talk about.

                We’re always in sales, we’re always trying to get people to do something we want. It does seem that there could be a difference of influence in that in Motivational Interviewing we’re trying to, as ethically unbiasedly as possible, help them get to where they want to go in the cultural context of, you know, compliance if it’s antisocial and their sociopath or psychopath, but we’re trying to help them align their behaviors with their values is the, the desire versus get them to do this particular kind of a thing.

                And so I’m wondering your thoughts when you’re thinking about values and helping them align their behaviors with their values. How have you thought about it in your own? That, okay. I’m being ethical about what I’m doing in the world, and I’m helping these companies do this in a way that might lead to these sales things.

                But I know that for me, I’ve figured [00:17:00] out a way to, to navigate this ethically for myself and for how I’m helping people. I’m just wondering your thoughts on that.

                Josh Dittmar: Yeah, totally great. Great question, man. And I think that it is an important question that we talk about all the time. And since we very first started like David and our head researcher, this is a thing for good, this isn’t, you know, because it can be used for bad.

                If, once you understand people’s drivers, you can influence them to do things. You know, if you can spin a message in a way that, you know, influences them. for example, Cambridge Analytica, which also took people’s information. You know, I started talking about how we do things anonymously. Like we have no information about anybody that’s answered the surveys.

                So we, you know, we have their demographics and we always get the right audiences and we have the right amount of people, but we don’t know where they live, what their contact details are or anything like that, which is, which is very important on for one part of it. But also just working with good companies, you know, we’ve been approached by a couple of companies that, and [00:18:00] government organizations and said, that’s not what we do.

                We, we don’t dip into politics or anything like that. And it was important for us to sort of set the groundwork of how the business is gonna move forward. Cuz as far as we know, this is the first that has ever been created the first, you know, massive Library of people’s values around the world, which can be used as a tool for good, you know, amazing lots of, you know, finding the intersection between profit and purpose for businesses, which impacts people, you know, from inside the organization and outside, but also having a fine, a very firm line of these are the companies we don’t work with and staying outta politics was a good.

                Tami Calais: I know, I didn’t even think politics. That’s such a good point. Not, not that yeah. I wanna share any opinions or anything, but yeah, that is such a good point that it could even be used for politics.

                Josh Dittmar: And the, and the dream state would be, I mean, imagine, you know, we have the values for the United States and Canada and Australia, and it’s like, what if our politicians were [00:19:00] held to the standard of our country’s values?

                And not by other things, you know, would be, would be amazing. And you know, what, if we were moving towards the things that cuz these things matter to us, you know, like, like belonging in the states is value number one, whereas family is value number one in Canada and belonging is second. And so, and you can kind of see there’s there’s like there slight differences is like belonging, belonging being in American is like really, really important.

                And it’s like less so in Canada, it’s like, we’re like, yeah, everyone up here is like, yeah, family. And like way more, there’s, there’s a different feel to the country, you know? And as they, as they filter down, like those are just the top two example examples. But as they filter down, you can see the differences.

                In the, in the countries. And you can see the differences in, you know, China, Afghanistan, France, Australia.

                John Gilbert: Well, and, and this is interesting too, cuz when went through my mind is this paper that I came across when I was researching some stuff for partner, we were working [00:20:00] with that related to, kind of like some things that Casey you’ll talk about of like, if someone has 0.0 ambivalence Motivational Interviewing is not indicated it can’t work.

                If there’s like 0.0 ambivalence, right. About whatever the topic is to inform that related to values is something called cultural constructivism. And so there’s a paper that talks about cultural, constructivism and motivational interviewing and how you can help people align with, with certain things.

                If they come from a certain culture and it’s more easy to talk about like certain cultures that might be less prosocial, so that are more violent or something like that to then say, oh, well, if we help them in these ways, we might, be helping them perpetuate a certain belief system about, you know, sexism, racism, whatever it’s going to be.

                So how does cultural constructivism fit in, you know, to that? And so I guess where I’m, I’m going with this for you, is that [00:21:00] at a certain point. Let’s say we have that ideal of, we have these value graphics and politicians are holding back on using that, to manipulate the masses in this hypothetical utopia we’re talking about.

                And, and in that process, we’re gonna have some, again, VIN diagram overlaps and not. So I’m wondering is the, is the goal of this with companies and, and working with someone with friends to like focus on the strengths, overlap like a strengths finder or something where. Focus on the overlap. If you were gonna work with someone that doesn’t have the same values, you know, I’m thinking about it on an individual level too.

                If you’re having a lot of triggers, as we call righting reflexes, where do you focus? If you’re noticing like values are different. But we share some of these. Do you focus on these or do you do anything with the separation of values and have discussion around that? It’s just some, some thoughts that I was thinking as you were talking about the different cultures.

                Josh Dittmar: Yeah. Love it. I mean, you’re totally on our, on our [00:22:00] page. Like something that we do, one of the most common projects that we’ll do with a company is like, what do our people care about? What do our competitors care about? And what do the prospects care about? And then looking at what are the, you know, to be able to, at the same time as solidifying our own base, how do we steal market share from the competitors?

                And also how do we get people who don’t know who aren’t using either? And then, like you said, you got this ven diagram piece in the middle. They’re the values that you talk to. And if you just wanted to do a program about prospects who don’t use either you or the competitors, then these are the values that make them unique.

                The ones that are outside of the, the center of the VIN diagram, and this can be done from we did a, you know, massive survey on high performing call center workers versus low performing call center workers. And so we looked at this was a global study we did for Genesis. Every call, call center software, you can imagine gets, gets used by basically any company in the planet is like through Genesis.

                So these guys are gigantic [00:23:00] and they wanted to do this like surveys. Like how do we talk to the high performers and how do we get more of them when we are doing hiring and recruitment and how do we engage them more? And we’re able to see the low performers, the average performers and the high performers.

                What are the things that make them similar. And then what are the things that make the high performers different and how do we talk to them? So we can now change the culture subtly to engage those people more and get them, you know, and encourage more, to come on and stay longer and recruitment and all that sort of stuff.

                So that three, you know, that VIN diagram image that you were thinking of can be split in so many different ways. And you can, you can look at it, like you said, from a central perspective, what makes them similar? How do we talk to everyone? and what makes them different? How do we just talk to this particular audience?

                Hmm. You know, I started my career in sales and so as I learned about sales, it was a question that I was like, what am I doing here? You know, you’d read sales books and, you know, do all these course and stuff like that. There’s really [00:24:00] beautiful book by a guy called Chris Vos. It’s called never split the difference.

                Oh man, that guy. Incredible. Just amazing. But he talks about like, he talks about it as like, people want to be spoken to like this. He’s like, when I get spoke, when I get like, when someone sells to me like this, not a pushy way, not a pressury way. Like he talks in this way, that makes you feel like you’re important.

                And then you buy the product and you feel good about it. I used to teach, sales, and I used to say the only difference between a good sale and a bad sale or a good purchase and a bad purchase is how you feel about it. I might buy an amazing product like my, my new iPhone and my, you know, obviously this is a very, like, sometimes you buy a bad product.

                That’s bad for you. It’s like, that’s a bad sale, but, you know, from a, from a very simplified perspective. I go and buy an iPhone that I buy every single year, cuz I’m getting an upgrade and it’s basically the same phone is like if I have a good experience with the person [00:25:00] at the checkout, I’m like, wow, I love it.

                It sticks with me. I remember the phone. I remember the experience if I have a bad experience, even if the phone’s a little bit better, I’m like, man, screw these guys. Like I, I didn’t enjoy that experience. I didn’t have a good time and I wasn’t like I wasn’t in my sold well, and so. It’s a fine line. You know, maybe I was manipulated, maybe I was sold well, but it really comes down.

                I think, you know, good product versus bad product. Are you doing good in the world or bad in the world? And there’s also like a line of being like, are you forcing something, you know, doing a classic, you know, stereotypical car salesman, salesman, manipulation tech tactic to sell someone a car, or are you selling them a car that they need in their lives?

                It’s it’s, it’s a tricky question to answer. And I think it’s, it’s a, it’s a good moral discussion that we could talk about for like hours. I think with examples and I love the discussion. Cause I went through that same process, you know, as I got older and as I went further and further in sales, I was like, [00:26:00] what am I doing the right thing?

                Like, what if I use you get taught a line, you know, to use? And you’re like, ah, it didn’t feel very good. Like I felt a bit greasy and. But what’s the outcome. Like, you know, sometimes I have my own biases when I’m being sold something but I want someone to overcome it. I don’t know how to overcome that myself and a good salesperson will overcome that and they’ll get the product in my hands and it will be for my benefit.

                John Gilbert: So, wow. There’s, that’s really interesting for me, Josh, because it makes me think of therapy or counselors or people that learn Motivational Interviewing, like we will. And then all of a sudden they learn that people are using active listening and the awareness comes up. And then if you have a therapist, you now can understand some of what your therapist is doing and you can break it down.

                And then it almost like that bias, like puts up a wall almost rather than makes it easier. So if they can overcome that with a sense of genuine, authentic, whatever, You wanna call that mm-hmm , there’s something there to break past bias. And I think it’s breaking past the [00:27:00] bias. We all have unconscious biases, implicit biases.

                I have ’em right now. All that is happening, but how can you try to. Speak, I don’t know, to some sort of truth in the other person, you know, with trying to take your bias, your conflict of interest out of it, as much as possible. That’s to me, some sort of guiding light in there that be it a therapist and knowing another therapist is using therapy with them or a salesperson and another person that is selling to them.

                How do you get through to the human underneath it?

                Josh Dittmar: Mm-hmm totally. Yeah. I, I think like it’s, that’s a part of life. Is like, are we going, you know, doing good or, or doing bad and figuring out what that means from a, you know, these things are fashioned onto us from a cultural perspective. And if we move to a different culture, someone might say, what we’re doing that we think is good is bad.

                And so it’s like really just trying to. It is, it’s really fun, moral conversation, isn’t it like I’ve, [00:28:00] you know, really feel like we could sit here for a long time and, and flesh it out because there’d be things that inside of each of us, as individuals we think is the right thing and the wrong thing. And I think that, yeah, yeah, I think that, you know, if we’re moving forward, generally, In a better, you know, people with less pain, happier people, you know, businesses are more aligned with people rather than just being profit focused.

                You know, I talked about the, you know, businesses are trying to look for this place between the intersection between profit and purpose. And there seems to be this idea that you can only have one and not the other. And what we think is. The intersection between the two is a values driven path. And when we’re able to impact businesses, we’re able to impact cuz businesses influence everybody.

                They impact everybody. You know, whether it’s the stuff we buy our Amazon, the computers in front of us, like we’re all purchasing. Everything was thought up by somebody in a room somewhere for it to be a particular way, you know, like [00:29:00] someone designed the microphone and the headphones. And I think if that.

                If we change the thinking at that level to be more about what are the people care about that we’re building this for? I think that generally we are, we’re building a better world.

                Tami Calais: This is interesting, it is such a challenging balance. But to your point, Josh, like I’m, I’m thinking about like one of our big Motivational Interviewing people that that is engaged with us is law enforcement. So there’s, people that are trying to make a really good difference out there and a really good impact. And so, like I was thinking of David, who is one of our main people in our MI plus membership that is engaged with us.

                 He likes to, he uses motivational interviewing to help people understand hearing mm-hmm and how they can hear literally physically hear better. But people typically struggle with getting, for instance, hearing aids so they can hear conversations. Right. So, I mean, like again, value graphics in that sense, [00:30:00] like, oh my gosh, you, you were helping people be more engaged in the world by being able to hear better.

                So. It is tricky navigating this because yeah, that would, I’d say that would be an ethical influence. That would be really good to help people be able to hear better mm-hmm or get the medical needs that they need.

                Josh Dittmar: Yeah, it’s really, it’s really fascinating. Like in, in never split the difference. Chris Vos talks about this example of where This doctor was like, he would just have patients like leave and they, he they’re like, this is he’s like, this is your last chance.

                Like, you basically have cancer, you’re gonna die. If you don’t change your lifestyle. And then they go out and they’re like, yo, here you, oh my God, I’m gonna change my lifestyle. And they go out and they don’t change their lifestyle. And it’s like, there’s him in his way is being like, there is, is explaining essentially when they’re saying this, they’re not talking, to what matters for the patient. They just say the same stuff. And the patient’s like, yeah, absolutely. I’ll change my life. This is so scary, but they’re not talking about what drives their life, you know? And so it’s like from an individual perspective, like you were talking about with the [00:31:00] hearing aid example, it’s like, how do we influence people to go and, you know, make these changes?

                Cause sometimes it can be a do or situation and they don’t do it, you know? We’re not getting to the core of what matters and drives their lives.

                John Gilbert: This, Josh was something that I wanted to bring of before we wrap up with our time. And I know we’re coming closer to the end of it, but is this sense of competing values?

                And I’m wondering if you’ve dug into this at the massive scale you have. I know for ways that we have talked about it in our training, it could be like a value like Tammy brought up of my independence and, and having my sense of independence and not being dependent on some sort of device or something external, or could be a medication.

                In the case of, you know, the, the physician type example or healthcare example. I don’t wanna be dependent on this thing. I’m independent, right? A very Western, especially American. Focus like value in this way. And so [00:32:00] then that can compete with this sense of, you could say more transcendently quality of life or Tammy, you were saying engagement or connection with others.

                And so there are these competing values of independence, maybe there sense of connection, and they’re now competing. To make a decision just like we all do, especially with the example you gave of consuming a toxin of alcohol and lubricating and having a good time socially, you know, but it not being healthy, but we make those, those negotiations of life and absolutely, you know, different people have to make different ones depending on your socioeconomic status and the opportunities that aren’t equal all everyone’s making these negotiations of sorts of values.

                So I was just wondering about how much, you’ve focused on that. Your, your just thoughts on that, on, on how people have competing values and maybe all you’re doing is just identifying them. I shouldn’t say just, maybe you’re identifying them and that’s it. Or then what do you do if you are gonna do something with competing values, from the [00:33:00] values graphics perspective when you’re helping people?

                Josh Dittmar: That that is such a good question. I I’ll talk from a personal ex experience, and then I’ll, I’ll share a little bit from a larger scale. So I belong to. A segment or an audience called the personal growth junkies, which is like, we’ve got different names for all the different segments and audiences that come up when you do my value graphics profile.

                Like I’m like personal growth and experiences at the top of my list. Everything else is like personal growth experiences, health and wellbeing. And there’s, there’s environmentalism and some stuff, you know, just below that. But those two things just drive everything in my life. And so. Sometimes I’ll be having a moral conversation with David about being like, man, like what about the planet?

                You know? Cause I, I do like organized cleanups on our local mountains and all this sort of stuff. And I’m like, but this doesn’t seem to like be making the biggest difference. I’m like, am I, should I be just focusing a hundred percent of my energy on value graphics because we can actually change the world, but then there’s trash on my local mountain and I need to go and do this thing.

                And so there’s two [00:34:00] values that are just like. Just crashing together. I’m like, okay. Do I just, and they both give me personal growth. They both give me an experience. And so I’m wrestling and what, you know, David has done is he just talks with me about it and he manages to sell me essentially or explain in a way and help me understand my own.

                Which one is going to meet my values the most, essentially, because in that moment, I don’t have an understanding of what’s gonna make the biggest difference. I’m like, is it the environment and this thing in the moment, or is it the investment? And, you know, I feel like I’m giving up on one of my experiences.

                So I’m wrestling between these two values. And a part of that from a larger scale is if we see two values, like experiences and personal growth at the top, how do we talk to both of those values at the same time with a message, because we all probably have those moments in our lives where we’re like, do I go left?

                Do I go right? Oh my God. They [00:35:00] both feel so good, but they both, like, I’m gonna feel like I’m missing out. If I go one way and not the other. And it, it seems to come down to. How we’re, how it’s explained and how we perceive it. And sometimes that can take some time.

                Casey Jackson: What you just articulated there is what motivational Interviewing is.

                Is to help people work through those, to dilemma that, that right there is. I mean that if we just took that exert and you put it on a wall for people that are trained in motivational interviewing, they’re like, oh yeah, that’s what we do in motivational interviewing is help people work through that. Yeah.

                Because there’s not a right or a wrong, it really is. How do you help people? They resolve their ambivalence based on their own value set. And that’s where they’re gonna find the sense of peace or settlement from that.

                Josh Dittmar: Yeah. Yeah. And going and going back to that, you know, person who leaves the hospital and, takes an action or doesn’t is like, how did they see that moment? How did they perceive that moment? You know? And that’s like, you’re saying it’s through our values. How are we receiving this information? How is the story being told to us? Cause we’re being told stories every day and we’re telling stories to other people, you know, when [00:36:00] we talk to them and it’s like, are we five out of the six keys match up or only three out of the six?

                And it just didn’t really land. Mm.

                John Gilbert: Yes, we’re, we’re coming to an, in, it reminds me of like a Stanford model of behavior change too. It’s one of the four quadrants. And unfortunately, I can’t remember the researchers or the name of the model, so it’s a bit ridiculous to even mention it in that way. But I remember motivational interviewing sticking in one of the quadrants of this.

                One-on-one kind of like you’re talking about with this physician interaction. and then, you know, Casey that you brought up from years ago, that book that talked about extra therapeutic factors and just how many things outside of that interaction affect change. And so I appreciate what you’re, you’re doing in the world.

                And, and talking to that point of us having these, you know, laptops and these things of that are gonna influence us around, products and things that businesses are going to remain. So how are they influencing us consciously or unconsciously? And I think there’s something important to be aware of in, in [00:37:00] culture and get more and more seen values in companies, in people and in so doing you can, you know, from all the biases I have and what I’ve learned with Casey.

                Digging into this, you can transcend some of the behaviors to see the humanity in what’s going on. And it seems like there’s a, there, there that if we work towards that together, there’s gonna be some disagreements and there’s gonna be some stuff that might be like, I would choose this over that, but if we can keep working towards.

                Something like that. It seems like it would bring us together in some sort of a way. And there’s, there’s, there’s a, there, there that I don’t know, cause it’s gonna be perceived differently by different cultures, but whatever that is, it seems worthwhile. And that’s what I appreciate what that value graphics is doing.

                And then I, of course, in this. Utopia see Motivational Intervieiwng coming in to help people once there is that sense of it. I also see, you know, cultural constructivism and that coming into schools to help inform at a [00:38:00] young age, I see emotional intelligence coming into that picture to help with perception of other emotions. And I see this, this foray of just, all these things coming into like schools mm-hmm and this amazing society that could be values driven that could have this information to make a decision. But it doesn’t mean that we always are gonna make this decision of choosing values, graphics over cleaning your local hill. And that’s where I think that, conflict of interest, we all have to check inside ourselves our own bias to be like, well, I think you should do the values, graphic things cuz of these things, but you’re thinking the things. So how do I sell you and explain this to you in a way to get you, to make the decision I want you to make in this Josh.

                I think that’s what we gotta check. As we move forward with all this. And that’s what we, you know, call the righting reflex in motivational interviewing, getting out of equal position. You know, we have podcasts that talk about how do you maintain equipoise, but still influence.

                But I think [00:39:00] that’s the key check for me. When I think of the ethics of all this, how do we try to check that, but still work in this future direction together with being value based. So those are just some ending thoughts I have is I don’t know for Josh Casey, Tammy, anything else that you wanted to, to throw in with or add?

                Casey Jackson: When you said that, go ahead, Josh. No, you go, you go for it. What I was thinking about my, my aha moment, it’s fun for me in the podcast to have aha moments. With this is I I’ll admit, I came into this podcast with some, I was braced, I was braced and ready for, I’m not sure where this is gonna go, how much, you know, because I’m so anti manipulation, it’s just, you know, I just don’t like to be played.

                And I don’t like people being played and you know, that’s my social worker side of myself, but the thing that I can deeply appreciate it was my aha moment actually, in working with Tammy’s company, when Tammy wasn’t with us on the sales side of things, is what struck me so profoundly. And I think this is where I, my brain really [00:40:00] understands the potential with value graphics is what I realized from a social worker perspective.

                Looking through a sales lens was that if you have an exceptional product, you really don’t need a sales department. You really need a good marketing depart. If you have an exceptional product. And I think that’s where I see value graphics, like, oh, this makes sense to me because if we just market it, well, we just have people standing by to collect the orders that because good marketing will help them resolve their ambivalence based on their own value set, which is different than cold calling and try to sell stuff to people that they may or may not want.

                And I, think that’s probably too rudimentary and oversimplified. But for me, I think that’s what was helpful through this conversation is it really reinforces my belief that if it’s an exceptional product who wouldn’t want it, like if that fits their values and it fits their lifestyle, I just want, I want exceptional products, but I just don’t wanna be sold anything.

                And I think that’s what helps me in this dialogue. Listening to what [00:41:00] you talked about Josh, is that that helps delineate between the sales side and the marketing side from the, sales perspective when you step back looking from the value side of it’s like, well, you’re helping people that really would find the product, you know, value added in their life, get access to that in a way their brain can, you know, comprehend it in a way that lines up with their own value set.

                So that, that, I just, this, I really appreciate this, cuz it helped make clear about certain things that still were a little fuzzy in my, my brain. Just in the way that I look at how I communicate and talk and about what we do as well too.

                Josh Dittmar: Yeah, totally. Totally. Mm-hmm . If we can change the way like this is bigger than, you know, us, it’s bigger than if we can change the way that we look at each other, instead of we’re programmed to look demographically, we’re programmed to see someone look a certain way on the, in the desert and be like, okay, that person’s gonna kill me.

                I’m gonna run away. And you know, we just don’t, we don’t live in that, in that world very much anymore. We still do to some extent. What we’re [00:42:00] really, what we’re really doing is we’re trying to, you know, we’re not gonna cure racism, homophobia, ageism, and all these things. But if we can turn the dial down from where it’s at right now, what it seems like is an 11 outta 10.

                If we can help to turn the dial down to a seven or an eight, hopefully even lower. I think that that’s, that’s building a better world. You know, if we can start to look at each other through a values, value, graphic lens and say, you know, like these people are more like me than they look. Then we can really start to, you know, create a more cohesive and a better, better world.

                And it comes from changing the way that we look at each other. And that’s, that’s really the core of what, you know, besides better businesses intersection between profit and purpose and all that stuff. Like that’s really what we’re driving for and what we are hoping for. And, and it sounds like you guys are, are doing the same as well.

                So. Hundred percent, a hundred percent.

                Casey Jackson: And that’s, yeah, it’s, it’s fun to listen to other people out there in that charge, you know, with that mission.

                John Gilbert: With the level of massive impact you’re having thank you for what you do and, and [00:43:00] yeah. It’s like obviously leading a lot of helpful things at a massive level.

                We’re gonna, you know, keep as individual and organizational change as our Institute is called. Keep. Keep that going. Mm-hmm and I’ll just point to some degree of motivational Interviewing, being a way to, to help with this, for anyone that hasn’t gone through that I just want to throw that out there for intro advanced training or whatever it would be be it with us or otherwise we have our own resources we provide, but I just wanna mention that because it’s a way of discovering someone it and co discovering things within them. But more importantly, to your point, Josh, I perceive it as a way of seeing and treating another human and in seeing them in a different light. I now can see the humanity and, and transcend the demographics more.

                And the values are one way to do that. And hopefully in that process, given we’re in a capitalistic culture currently, that will relate to more, not [00:44:00] just conscious capitalism, but compassionate capitalism, that yes is values driven with a place of compassion, which I think is what we can all, kind of attune to that, bringing it together from what bill Dr.

                Bill Miller and Steven Rollick put in the, the third edition of motivational interviewing is that place of compassion and coming from that place. So I think as long as we got that as our, our guiding light we’re, we’re gonna end up somewhere. Good. So, Josh, I can’t thank you enough. I know that we had talked beforehand if people are interested in your work or reaching out to you, where can they find you?

                What is some information related to that?

                Josh Dittmar: Yeah. If you just search value graphics we are everywhere possible where you can find value graphics on Google, LinkedIn, Facebook, all the stuff. And then if you, yeah, wanna shoot me a line. It’s just [email protected]. You’ll hear from our assistant Abigail and she can she can guide you wherever you wanna go.

                John Gilbert: Wonderful. Wonderful. Well, is there anything sounds good else that you’d like to add or anything for closing thoughts or anyone else that I’d like to add before we wrap up? Yeah. I just [00:45:00] think like looking at your own life and seeing how different the peopleare, that are in it, you know, and just, just looking at your own life and be like, wow, I’m already living a values driven life because the people around me are around me.

                Not because they look, sound and smell exactly like me they’re around me because we talk about the same things and we care about the same things in our lives. You can look around in your life and appreciate how. I think things sound worse than they are. If we listen to the media and you, you know, if you’re on the social media or, or whatever, like things sound worse than they are.

                And I think that people are really coming together and we are moving forward in a beautiful way that is more conducive to, you know, peace and, togetherness togetherness is, you know, the togetherness values. There’s five of them, family relationships, friendship, community, and love. [00:46:00] And those five values are what, you know, they show up in a different way.

                Everywhere around the world in the top 10. So sometimes it’s community and relationships, sometimes it’s friendship, you know, but they show up at the top 10 everywhere in the world in some different variation. And these are the things that make us human human beings love being together. And if you just look around in your life, you can see that you’re already living in values, driven life.

                Casey Jackson: Love that. Hmm. Thank you for sharing that again. Thanks for being on here. This was, this was wonderful. Hope we get a chance to talk again. Yes. All right.

                John Gilbert: Well, hopefully you all got to enjoy that are listening to this and you know where to find Josh, you know where to find us at IFIOC.com and all sorts of resources.

                If you want to see people from this light, we are one way to do that. And another way is through value graphic. So hopefully it’s been well, Josh powerful closing comments. Thank you. And take care of everyone. See you next time. Thank you for listening to the communication solution podcast as always, this podcast is all [00:47:00] about you.

                So if you have questions, thoughts, topic, suggestions, ideas, please send them our way at [email protected]. That’s [email protected] for more resources, feel free to check out, IFIOC.com. We also have a public Facebook group called motivational interviewing every day. We have an amazing blog. And we have lots of communication tips on our website.

                In addition to all these amazing resources we do offer online public courses on our website on motivational interviewing and effective communication strategies. Thanks for listening to the communication solution by I F I O C.

                48 min
              • Guns, violence and Motivational Interviewing with guest Steve Wohl

                This is part 1 of a 2 part podcast with guest Lieutenant Steve Wohl from the Spokane Police Department.

                About our guest

                Lieutenant Steve Wohl

                • 25 years with the Spokane Police Department
                • Training Director at the Spokane Police Academy
                • BA from Eastern Washington University in Interdisciplinary Studies, minor in Communication and Psychology.
                • Previously supervised the Major Crime (Robbery/Homicide/OIS) unit, Special Victims Unit, Internal Affairs, and Tactical Operations unit.
                • Commander of the Spokane Independent Investigations Regional Response team (SIIR) investigating all critical incidents involving regional law enforcement officers.
                • SWAT and Hostage Negotiation team Commander 2014-2019.
                • About this episode

                  We loved having Steve on as a guest so much that we just had to schedule to have him back again to discuss even more about law enforcement and Motivational Interviewing.

                  In this podcast we discuss:

                  • Real life situations of law enforcement, behavior change, engagement and Motivational Interviewing
                  • The law enforcement brain in microseconds
                  • Hostage Negotiations
                  • When does Motivational Interviewing work and not work
                  • Compliance vs. behavior change
                  • And so much more!
                  • You don’t want to miss this one! Make sure to rate us on apple podcasts or share this podcast, it would mean so much to us!

                    Want to watch the video podcast? Join MI PLUS+
                    Want a transcript? See below!
                    Guns, violence and MI with Steve PDFDownload
                    46 min
                  • Motivational Interviewing and culture and self disclosure

                    In this podcast we have 2 guests join us to ask their questions about infusing Motivational Interviewing and self disclosure. Guests Diana and Michelle join us from Canada as we navigate culture norms, Motivational Interviewing and the impact of self disclosure.

                    Diana and Michelle are from our public Facebook group “Motivational Interviewing Everyday” where we share tips, create discussions and talk about Motivational Interviewing in the real world.

                    In this Podcast we discuss:

                    • How self disclosure impacts communication from a Motivational Interviewing lens
                    • Cultural norms
                    • Relating and self disclosure
                    • And so much more!
                    • Want to watch the video podcast? Join MI PLUS+
                      Want a transcript? See below!
                      Self-disclosure-and-MI-PDFDownload
                      47 min
                    • Motivational Interviewing and Group Communication

                      Question from one of you! Motivational Interviewing and Group communication

                      Want to watch the video podcast? Join MI PLUS+

                      Wow this podcast is full of great information about using Motivational Interviewing with groups or in a group setting. This question came from one of you, our listeners! Kati works in a school setting and was curious how Motivational Interviewing could be used in groups.

                      In this Podcast we discuss:

                      • How to use Motivational Interviewing in groups
                      • Tips: don’t fall into the expert trap, get engagement first, EPE (Elicit, Provide, Elicit)
                      • The spirit of Motivational Interviewing and whats your intention
                      • Refocusing groups
                      • And so much more!
                      • Want a transcript? Read below!

                        [00:00:00] Hello, and welcome to the communication solution podcast. Here at IFIOC, we love to talk communication. We love to talk motivational interviewing, and we love talking about improving outcomes for individuals organizations and the communities that they serve. Today, we’ve got Casey Jackson on the line, John Gilbert, and I’m Tammy.

                        Welcome to the conversation.

                        John Gilbert: Hello everyone. And welcome to another conversation with us here at the communication solution. You know, each one of us from our intro and we today have a really interesting topic that is going to come from a listener that we really appreciate Katie.

                         If you wouldn’t mind, Tammy just orienting us to what Katie had asked us, and then we can go from there with what, to a respond to.

                        Tami Calais: Yes. Sounds good. So Katie actually wrote [00:01:00] in the question she was asking about, can you use Motivational Interviewing as a tool for group communication?

                        She said that her background is in behavior interventions in a public school setting, and she would often end up working with students in small groups. She’s done some reading on synergistic change, talk in a group setting, but I’d love to know if IFIOC has any more information on it. So that is our conversation today, Motivational Interviewing in group settings.

                        Casey Jackson: So I can tell you for me, this is a question that has kind of percolated at times from the beginning. Ever since I started training it, not a common question, but it, it will surface fairly often. And kind of the two names the forefront of Motivational Interviewing and groups is Chris Wagner and Karen Ingersoll who wrote a book on Motivational Interviewing and groups.

                        And John was talking about, there’s a coding tool that [00:02:00] Johnny can reference as well to talk about a bit too, but prior to even knowing the things that had been written about Motivational Interviewing in groups is I was thinking about how, how I was using motivational interviewing in group therapy sessions in family therapy.

                         What I realized in explaining to people is that first of all, you need to really be pretty skilled at Motivational Interviewing individually, because there is a complete different level of complexity that I found in using it in a group setting. The way I started to look at this was like, I remember getting called in asking to work with this group of Youth that were justice involved.

                        And they said, we know we wanted to learn how to use Motivational Interviewing can use Motivational Interviewing with these guys in the group and all these concepts. And so what I was talking to them about is the way that I think of a way to look at Motivational Interviewing, in groups is if you treat the group as a brain with all these little brain cells in it, and there’s going to be ambivalence inside that brain.

                        And so it’s not like you’re talking to them [00:03:00] in mass. I mean, there’s still this level of engagement, but you have a sense of how the majority of them are feeling and that the majority, and probably have mixed feelings about being in that group, especially if it’s a BI classroom or that, you know, a small group from a behavioral classroom.

                        You can think there’s part of it. That’s just like, they don’t want to be separated out. They don’t want to feel that way. They also don’t want to get the negative attention in classrooms, you know? So there’s some basic empathy. When you’re thinking about articulating a reflection and you’re thinking about talking to it as if it’s one brain.

                        The way that I would explain the way I would use it is saying like, this is perfect with both of you, you know, in the podcast with me of saying, you know, Tammy, when you first started, this was something you were completely opposed to. You thought this was a waste of your time and you thought I just don’t even want to be here.

                        You’d sit in the corner, had no intention of changing. And basically that’s what John’s behavior is right now. And, and I can then turn over and say, you know, John, that’s kind of the way you are now. You think this is a bunch of BS. [00:04:00] You don’t even want to be here, Tammy. There was something about you. What shifted for you?

                        Because for the most part, this felt like such a waste of your time. What, what changed for you? And it’s almost like you’re doing a double-sided reflection of one brain, but you’re doing it in the group because they’ve had similar behaviors or similar perspective or similar kind of reaction. So I know that I’m going to get resistance and sustained talk from John.

                        And I know there’s a probability. I’ll get sustain talk one more change, talk from Tammy. And so you can almost use that in a group dynamic because you’re gonna see that ambivalence in a group. If it’s a group that’s fully functioning on track, no resistance, no ambivalence. You wouldn’t be using Motivational Interviewing as a tool or a method of communication anyway, to be what’s the point of the group, unless it’s a process group, which means there’s, points of contention or there’s going to be ambivalence that, that comes up. In those group where there’s such a good respect for boundaries and people are there to learn and listen, and it’s kind of this improvement group perspective. It’s much easier than to grasp it from [00:05:00] that.

                        Tami Calais: So what you’re saying is like in this group setting, whether it’s two people, five people, 10 people.

                        However many people, if you can find a couple of different sides of the ambivalence within that group, that’s what you can help reflect in the double-sided reflection to bring out how most people are feeling.

                        Casey Jackson: Yeah. And, and, and what you’ll see, I, John, I think you were around when I used to do this with Washington state divisional rehab with their orientation, because they just had a struggle with orientation.

                        They said, you know, people wait till the end. And then they ask all these questions and they end up leaving the group after sitting there for two hours, just angry and upset because they shouldn’t even have sat through the two hours. And I said, if, you know why at least 60 or 70% of the people are in there.

                        And you know, that there’s a portion of them that don’t even believe that if they knew what this was about, they would opt out. You can start, you can either do that from an educational perspective, but so many people will hear your [00:06:00] instruction, or let me explain what this group is about and think it doesn’t necessarily relate to them until they get asked their question.

                        So it’s like, yeah, yeah, yeah. I know those are the rules. I know that that’s what it’s for, but I need to ask a specific question, but it’s an orientation. So what I would say is start with high empathy of going, you know, a lot of people, this feels very odd being in a state agency where, you know, especially if you’re looking for public assistance, some you’re comfortable with that.

                        And so we were very uncomfortable with this. Somebody who had a disability from birth. And so you have a newly acquired disability And some people are here just because they heard that DVR would just pay for college. Like if you just showed up and you had a disability, they just they’d pay your tuition.

                        So for those of you that have a disability are looking at long-term employment, This is something that works really well. There’s some people that just show up and think, Hey, if I show up, they’re going to give me a job. And that’s an employment agency. That’s not DVR. So a lot of people show up for orientation and that’s how they feel.

                        And they get really frustrated thinking, my God, I just came in for a job and I’ve been here for six months and I’m still not working. And they get really, really frustrated. You know, some of you are here [00:07:00] for different reasons. And they said when they started using more of that narrative, that felt like everybody’s being talked to, like there was an empathetic aspect to it.

                        There’s people that would get up during orientation. ’cause, it was just like, oh yeah, that’s what I was looking for. That’s not what this is about. And they just get to leave and not wait for two hours and then be really angry about, well, I heard and you said, and they said so it would clean some of that up so that I wouldn’t say that that’s Motivational Interviewing in groups, but there is that thing about if you know, your population like a BI classroom, you know what some of the feelings are, you know, what some of the experiences are coming in there.

                        And so when you float those out there, And say it, you could hear a student say, yeah, it feels like all the teachers are against me because you lead off by saying no there’s days. You feel like all the teachers are against you and there’s days that it feels like the students are against you. And that gets really frustrating.

                        But then there’s days that it’s just like, I want to go to school. I want to learn, but it feels like nobody really helps me do. So I can say that group of six kids in a BI classroom or in a subset, and [00:08:00] somebody is going to respond to that. And you’re going to start to see where is the resistance? Where’s the sustained talk.

                        Where’s the potential for change talk then

                        John Gilbert: One thing is you’re talking Casey, that’s just really, really powerful is it seems to me that there’s these layers of awareness. Ability and skill or knowledge, skill, and ability in groups that Motivational Interviewing can come in to. Help facilitate, like you’re talking about with say there’s a sense of resistance or ambivalence in the room for even being open to Motivational Interviewing or components of whatever’s going on there being voluntold to be there, you know, in department of corrections, I’d get kid with the effort you can teach us all sorts of things like that.

                        And what I want to speak to is there’s a layer of recognizing when to use full on Motivational Interviewing and when to use components of Motivational Interviewing or some, [00:09:00] some level. And I just want to define some level of, again, bringing it back to what are we trying to do with Motivational Interviewing it’s to decrease resistance. Access potential ambivalence. If it exists in there and then help it, if that exists to resolve towards them, aligning their behaviors with what they say they want in this case, probably a, some kind of helping profession or, or stability and security with their job, at least, you know, if they’re doing that.

                        But the whole idea is trying to tap into something. There, if there’s ambivalence and to, to the point you said earlier of if the group is engaged, there’s healthy boundaries, there’s all these things. I just want to throw in there that you’re going to be further along in the spectrum, we talk about, you know, the processes of engaged focus.

                        We’re going to be more in planning and preparing. If you’re going to use components of Motivational Interviewing there are certain tools like elicit provide elicit. You can keep going. There’s a spirit of being [00:10:00] curious of what they make of that or how they see that working. There’s a collaborative component each day of mapping out the agenda for the day.

                        There’s all these sorts of tools. I feel that you can bring in with a highly engaged. Highly motivated group, but you’re not necessarily going to be addressing the ambivalence and resolving ambivalence so much as like you said, with kind of the information and education you’re using an Motivational Interviewing spirited approach with that.

                        So it’s kind of just determining just like we have with our one sheeter, for the Motivational Interviewing approach you match where that group is at. And if that group has a bunch of dynamics, Of different places where they’re at. It’s just that much more challenging because the brain has that much more different brain cells.

                        And one thing I want to highlight that came to mind earlier when you were talking about that is to not go after just the minority of the brain cells as it were. Even though, you know, you could [00:11:00] reach those people in the ways that you were talking about earlier, which was very highly skilled by the way to say, you know, Tammy, you know, you were in this place and John, you, you might be in that place now, like that ability to do that, I have more and more seen is even more extraordinary.

                        So I bow to that. Casey is just incredible. To do that authentically. And to do that in a genuine way, it takes such a level of awareness and skill. And if that’s the minority of people, try to go, you taught me with the majority of where people are at to not need. To drag down the momentum of the group for the sake of a few people and vice versa with the highly motivated people that I tend to attune to too much, and then go too fast.

                        And there’s this balance of where is the whole brain at? Is there ambivalence? How much ambivalence, how authentic can I be in how I, depict empathy like you were doing so authentically with rhetorically, like, [00:12:00] and maybe I’m thinking all of that stuff really matters for a really skilled facilitator, but even at the basic facilitation of Motivational Interviewing 101 , is there resistance?

                        How do I try to deal with the ambivalence? How do I try to use my spirit of curiosity and support choice? And I feel like there’s different layers to take it. At least the way I’m interpreting, you’re talking about it. I’m a bit biased is at a pretty high level of awareness, skill and authenticity all mixed together to really try to do your best with the skillset to bring to the table.

                        Casey Jackson: That’s it, John. And, and that’s why it was important for me to even launch this off by saying you really have to be skilled at motivational interviewing before you start to think by using it in a group setting. Because of what you’re talking about, the layer and the complexity of that, you really do have to have a level of skillset.

                        To be able to understand what’s going on. What, what struck me when you were talking as well, is when you’re talking about, you know, we try not to [00:13:00] overcompensate for the, kind of the most resistant pieces of the group, which is something I used to do when I would train. I get excited about finding where the most resistance is and knowing I can convert that resistance into ambivalence.

                        And I remember you and I have talked about this before, when I, when I started to shift away from that is, that in the moment, what I realized is I’m sacrificing 85 or 90% of the people that want to be in the training who want to learn to get 10% back on track.

                        And I’ve got 90% of the people who are learning by me getting the people on track, but I’m not advancing their learning the way I could with the 90% of the people that are really engaged and want to move forward. So that was just my own reconciliation. The dual universe with that is, oh my gosh. That’s almost what so many people fall into when they’re younger in motivational interviewing with staying too long and empathy and sustain talk..

                        When, even if there’s a motor come of change, talk, we know we want to pour more energy and give that more light nutrition and, and you know, oxygen. So it’s the, it’s so fascinating that [00:14:00] kind of parallel process that as you get higher skilled at motivational interviewing, you can hear change, talk more readily and know based on experience and based on data.

                        You’re going to see more of a profound shift. The more adept you are at cultivating and expanding and exploring deepening and converting change talk just then you are spending way more time in the sustain talk. So it’s this completely like octave level difference between, you know, talking from a person how often we spend too much time in empathy.

                        And now what you’re talking about of, yeah, I would need to be careful because if there’s two or three people in a group that are more on the resistant side, we can’t cater too much to that. For the sake of a larger group. And it’s like, you’re talking again where they’re talking to individual dynamic, we’re talking about collective conscious consciousness.

                        It’s that same reality of based on experience and based on data, we know that the more skilled you get, the more we tend to lean towards change, like because of what it yields.

                        John Gilbert: And what’s so critical here is an [00:15:00] interesting contrast that I’d be curious of your thoughts and reactions to Casey, because there’s a certain level of.

                        If kind of like Dr. Theresa Moyers will talk about if you’re going to err, on the side of not doing harm, err, on the side of empathy. And so could you linger, as we talk about in the Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment tool you could linger could you follow or wander like is under guiding in the Motivational Interviewing competency assessment? Yeah, totally. Now there’s this sense that you instilled in me and that seems to be really important in groups.

                        Make sure you have engagement that their reality is on the table and that it’s attuned to. Even at the expense of covering content at the expense of direction and guidance. So that’s something I’ve really had to attune to. Cause I want to bring up the other end of this ambiguous spectrum here in my mind, which is the other end of the spectrum.

                        Instead of wondering, I guess it’s not ambiguous, but wondering following is, you know, directing as we talk [00:16:00] about in the Motivational Interviewing. Where my mind was going. There is this other spectrum into the spectrum, being that expert trap that we talk about in Motivational Interviewing and how, and I’ve talked about this a lot with Sue one of our colleagues in an organization, mint, a coach that has so many helpful, helpful ideas .

                        She was talking about this balance, cause we’ve talked about this, cause we’ll work together with the coaching with IFIOC and this balance of not falling into the expert trap, but also conveying information and education. And when you’re in a group setting or even certain kinds of coachings, if they’re open to it, how do you do that?

                        But not fall into the expert trap. Right. How do you recognize that people are in that state of openness and interest in asking you questions, but also not always expert trap, expert trap. So I’ve had to learn this sense of how do I balance out empathy and [00:17:00] engagement. Without falling so much into the expert trap with the people that are particularly motivated so that I’m not going so high in direction that I’m losing the majority of the people that aren’t as where those few interested people that are more speaking up and more engaged.

                        So I would be curious of how you have. Become aware of that if at all for yourself, because I know we have different styles and different approaches, but just any thoughts you have on what you’ve seen for people that, you know, I’ve seen this with healthcare people in particular that will take the chain shock and run with it.

                        Right. And so how do you, how do you balance out that sense of not falling in the expert trap, but still conveying information with empathy? Still recognizing people are asking questions and not wanting to parking lot at all the time, but still. Doing it in a way that isn’t slowing down the process, but that isn’t going too fast.

                        What are your thoughts on that?

                        Casey Jackson: Yeah, [00:18:00] again, a couple layers of it. I mean, he bouncing back between the individual and the, and the kind of collective approach to the group approach to motivational interviewing from my vantage point. And one of the first things that struck me, John, you were talking, is it helped my brain get clear about what is your role in the group.

                        If you’re a group leader that’s different than a group facilitator. If you’re a group facilitator, you should be facilitating learning. If you’re a group leader, you know, if you’re the group leader in I was going back to my old days, working in substance use treatment. We had a psycho-education group for parents.

                        You don’t facilitate that because they’re there to learn about. Drugs and the impact on the body and impact on their children impact on family. That’s different than me facilitating a group with parents who have youth that are using substances. Those are two different roles. One is to have an open conversation and share and learn from each other and grow from each other.

                        One is because they’re there to be educated. That’s why [00:19:00] they signed up. By an expert or a professional or somebody is going to lead the group in that process. So, so that’s what I partially think about when you’re putting this example that there is so much of it is defined by what is my role in this group, because it could be a psycho-education group where they, the group is lurking looking to learn something from the leader of the group that is not an Motivational Interviewing based group.

                        This is what your point earlier that is accurate is we can use components of motivational interviewing of active listening, empathetic responses. You don’t capitalize on change soccer. We hear it. But our, our role is not to change behavior in the role of the group leader. The one for the person for Katie her role is to do some of that and facilitate it.

                        So I think that’s, I think what’s helpful as we’re distinguishing things is what is our role when you’re looking at it from an educator perspective, it’s not that you’re necessarily trying to change behavior, but what I want to drill down to for what the example you brought up is when you have these.

                        Some kind of super users in the group who are absorbing and chopping information. And then [00:20:00] another portion of the group that feels left out, or they’re just not the same level of engagement. Again, if we, the first thing my brain started to do is when I run it through the Motivational Interviewing and filter, I go to that example of when people give change, talk, like I want to get healthy.

                        I want to lose weight. I can’t just jump into a perfect, let’s get you in a CrossFit class and you’re going to go protein plant protein based by the end of the week. Just because they said they wanted to get healthy. So just because we get changed talk doesn’t mean we can jump to plan automatically. You have to cultivate more of that.

                        So when I think of that in a group setting, there has to be a preponderance of change brain going on in the group. If you’re gonna move towards plan or experts. So, or it can be just defined by the nature of your role. I could have somebody in the psycho-education group and there’s four parents that feel like they’re forced to be there.

                        And six parents who are, are just hanging on every word. I’m not going to wait for the other four parents who don’t want to be there. To give education. I’m just going to give the education to the six parents that really came there to learn something. [00:21:00] And so the people that feel like they were forced there by the school or somebody.

                        So because it’s not a behavior change based group, it’s an education group. So I think that’s the same thing as educators. We have to think about that, our groups the same way, or when you’re looking from a group perspective, what is my role? What are the objectives? You know, what did they sign up for? And am I orchestrating that to the best of my ability for everyone that signed up that then that’s a different type of you know, a purpose.

                        And that’s why, like we always do that. We run it through that filter of Motivational Interviewing, is it resistance or discord is our ambivalence is our target behavior. They’re working on some groups have a very specific target behavior they’re working on. Some are just process groups that get together. AA is a process group.

                        You know, there’s not there. They’re all focusing on substance use, but the, the point of the group is not to get them into. A different stage of change based on their values. Those are self-motivated.

                        John Gilbert: Yeah, this is, this is really helpful for me and Tim yet. I don’t want to suppress you out of the conversation.

                        So please feel free to jump in here, but I’m just having all sorts of interesting [00:22:00] thoughts come to mind, having, you know, been involved with training now and doing all this for as getting trained by Casey and just all these thoughts. One of those is Casey you’re talking about a particular.

                        It’s subset of people versus the majority. And I just go, well, how would you, you know, know how would, you know, was one concept that went through and you could say, well, it’s changed talk, but then another concept that came through and you were talking, was this sentence. Well, are you focused on helping resolve ambivalence or are you focused on developing some education and a skill set and that delineation of kind of I’ll put those in two sort of categories, resolving ambivalence, being more pure Motivational Interviewing.

                        Education and skillset development. It’s not that there’s not any overlap here. It’s that there is a Venn diagram overlap I’m doing with my hands, but that, it seems like the more you go towards the spectrum of [00:23:00] education and skillset development, the more you’re going to be in that you could use an Motivational Interviewing spirited, evoking, EPE, all these other things that we know can help things stick for people and, and be embodied by people yet.

                        That is also. A bit heavier handed or leaned then helping someone resolve ambivalence is going to be even more particular to their reality without as much, necessarily as much education or skill development. I just thought that’s a helpful way to start thinking about. What’s my role in this moment with this individual or this group of people.

                        And that might shift if it’s small groups. When I was thinking about Katie, depending on the dynamics in that group, if that group is particularly a set of individuals or kids or something that have a particular. Sociological bend towards not doing the activity. That group might be different than this other, you [00:24:00] know, more stigmatized goody two-shoes group that really wants to do the activity.

                        And so just recognizing the attunement like we have in our Motivational Interviewing approach to is the group more in majority pre-contemplation. Or early contemplation, are they more in deep contemplation or preparation in my, more than based off of that, going to be an education and skill facilitation, or am I going to be more in helping empathize and help resolve some ambivalence related to the topic at hand?

                        And I just was, that was going through my mind. That was really helpful. The last thing that was going through my mind that I’m curious of either of your thoughts on, but Casey, you had taught me a while back. What, you know, we were talking about intentions, right? Like in the Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment, what’s your intention.

                        And you would always ask me that what’s the one or two things you want them to walk away with. Maybe you said two or three, depending on the length of it. And I always thought, gosh, that’s so little, right. But it’s so critical. The more I [00:25:00] found in group settings and even individual work that I’ve been up to with people.

                        What’s the one or two, maybe two or three things for them to walk away with. And I was just wondering if you could speak to that a little bit more and then I’ll be quiet. I mean, you can chime in with whatever, but I just was curious where that came from. Was that just experienced or. Giving voice to that for others that are group facilitating for people to walk away, whether that be education and skill development, one or two or three things, or resolve of ambivalence one or two or three things, just giving voice to that and where that came from and how important.

                        Casey Jackson: I think like everything else, just the more expertise and the more exposure you get, the more you learn. And for me with Motivational Interviewing so much more has been experiential than book learning. You know, I got that initial book learning and then it’s just been trained and practice, train, and practice, train, and practice, train, and practice, and then read research on the side and then try to read books on the side and those things.

                        For me, I just, that’s why I’m [00:26:00] obsessed with the practical application, the real world of how Motivational Interviewing works in really complex situations. So in my own evolution from just being a clinician to a trainer and moving through that, you know, supervisor, administrator, those kinds of things, what I’ve developed a, a profound awareness of, and this even came up in a consultation I did today with an organization.

                        What I told them is you have to be crystal clear what your vision and your mission statement is. And for me, this goes to the whole group concept of what’s. Why is the group getting together? If somebody is going to pay for a training, they want an education around it. They may show up a not act like they want it, you know, and we can respond to that.

                        You can have when they’re, when they’re it’s a BI class or behavioral classroom or a subsection of that, they’re not there because they’re, they’re there to make smoothies. You know, there, there be for specific things around academics and behavior that needs to be addressed. So that has to be part of the equation.

                        Is it, is it a self self-help support? Is it a psycho-education group for parents of children with substance [00:27:00] use? Is it you know education for justice involved, individuals who want to find employment? Like, what’s the, why are we getting together? There has to be that clarification and that if you’re not clear about that, then the instructor just goes about, or the facilitator just goes about doing what they think it’s about.

                        But if the collective is not clear about that, by definition, Motivational Interviewing, you don’t have very good focus. Which means you’re gonna have more than one right way, which isn’t wrong. You’re gonna have people ending up at different end points because nobody knows to at the top of the mountain is. So I think that needs to be clear.

                        It’s also why there’s times, you know, you’ve experienced this, I’m sure on your own, but with me as well, and we co-train together. I know I do this often is saying, you know, and the point of this training really is, is you get to decide how much professional development you want. If you really want to affect behavior change.

                        And it may not be something you’re interested in, but that’s the reason why people are here is because we really there’s people that just genuinely want to understand how can I communicate more effectively because I really want to [00:28:00] improve outcomes. And for some of you, it’s just like, I don’t want to sit through another training on zoom, you know?

                        So it just, I think it’s that almost refocusing in the moment. This is something that’s come up. Another main question I get, and it relates to this thing in group, but it was such an individual thing as well is, and you’ve heard this too. Both of you have heard this in trainings of people saying, oh, I wish I would’ve known this with my old clients.

                        I’m not going to use with my current clients, but I’m use with all my new clients. And my response always is there’s never a bad time with anyone to get refocused on why we’re here. I think that in any group or any situation, I think we can get. Nest the size as group facilitators or group leaders in almost assuming that people know why they’re in our group and that can be lackadaisical on our part because that is not how we treated on day one.

                        We very first facilitated our first group. We wanted them to know about us and the process and what the goals were, you know, 200 groups later. And you skip [00:29:00] a lot of that stuff because it’s like, oh, they know. And it’s like, well, it doesn’t mean it’s not the obligation on you as a leader to refocus them.

                        It’s the same thing in an individual thing, as it is in a group session with why are we here? What would be your best case scenario? Some of you’re forced to be here. All of you have volunteered to be here. All of you have paid to be here. I mean, what’s what, why are they doing. You know, so I think did that clarification for me in Motivational Interviewing is that focus.

                        Once you start to get focused, that’s where you can start to assess where is the ambivalence about what the target behavior, the target goal or the objectives of the group are. Once we get clear about that, then we can decide where is the accurate ambivalence existing? Or was it mostly just confusion of why are we here and what do you want from me?

                        And that keeps turning to this lady who keeps saying, you know, you need to pay attention and raise your hand in classrooms. You know, it’s just, so did I get in trouble? There’s other kids that don’t raise their hands. I mean, it just, if they, if they don’t understand, it’s really hard for individuals to stay focused.

                        Once you get clear what the [00:30:00] target is, that’s where you can start to assess does the end, but where does the ambivalence exist about the target behavior and not just a general resistance to being in the group. You had some thoughts earlier.

                        Tami Calais: I think we might have to save that for another podcast, but I will say I liked that summarizing essentially or summarizing, you know, what the focus of the group.

                        In simple terms because it does help them understand why they’re there and it kind of, like you said, gets people refocus. So that was a really good mental moment for me.

                        John Gilbert: And with that, Tammy, that further solidifies, we’re bringing it to the very end of our day and with being at time. I was talking about this with a group this week for an advanced group and getting into that.

                        So for those that are interested in. We do talk about these in our intro and advanced courses of how to view more practically I’ll just give a quick summary voice to what we’ve talked about here. And, and part of that is the intention of the [00:31:00] facilitator being clear. What is your role that Casey was talking about?

                        What’s your role as, as. Psychoeducational is this more a resolving ambivalence as I was framing, but there might be a combination of the two depending on where that group is at or that day or whatever it is. But determining that with what is your rule, what is required of your role and just getting clear on those things.

                        So that at some point there’s a sense of clarity of focus. To what that is so that there’s, you know, what people, some people in, in a group facilitation we’ll call expectation management, it’s a little compliance oriented, but at least there’s a sense of focus, more Motivational Interviewing oriented, and the practical nature of that to the degree that Casey was saying at the beginning and towards the end.

                        Is expressing empathy in some sort of authentic, non robotic, non parroting way that engages people in the group, whether they’re earlier in the spectrum of pre-contemplation or later it engages their perspective. [00:32:00] And then from that place, ideally checks in or somehow brings in change talk. For what is wanted, what’s the point?

                        What are we here for? And that can be a long check-in or that can be a brief check in sometimes check-ins, but somehow having that combination of engagement with empathy authentically like Casey was doing and focusing the conversation, engage , focus, and then movement forward was just something I wanted to bring together for some practical concrete things for group facilitation with each individual small group, if it’s Katie in that situation, or somehow a mix of that in a large group.

                        So I just wanted to bring that together, but anything else before we wrap up.

                        Casey Jackson: Yeah, and this is just, I have to say, just because it’s one of my triggers in talking about Motivational Interviewing, in groups, and it’s just, it’s completely kind of a sidetrack, but it’s just one of these things that I think is I just have a need to say, because it is such a trigger for me.

                        [00:33:00] I do have a significant reaction when people do have groups that are called a group for people in pre-contemplation. And so I just want to put that out there when we’re really thinking about the complexity of motivational interviewing. If you’re using Motivational Interviewing as a tool, that group should only last for maybe 15 to 20 minutes, and that group should not be there anymore because they should be at least been contemplation of using Motivational Interviewing skills.

                        So that’s just my last kind of things we’re looking at Motivational Interviewing in group? It’s just that one particular topic that, that I’ve ran into more often than I would think that, you know, oh, we have a group for people in pre-contemplation. And my response always is, well, I hope that doesn’t last more than a day or a group or two, because they should be in contemplation after that group then if we’re using Motivational Interviewing skills.

                        So again, it’s not about people are in pre-contemplation it’s, you know, what’s the target behavior. So I think it puts that in context as well, too. You’re looking at individual dynamic and group dynamic. And I think that’s what makes this such a fascinating question about how do we use Motivational Interviewing in group communication?

                        John Gilbert: Which could be its own separate podcast. We could go off on. I feel [00:34:00] because there’s so much richness to this. So if you do have. Questions or comments and would like us to add information or opinion or whatever’s helpful from us. You can email [email protected], that’s [email protected] and send those in.

                        And there’s all sorts of things we could get into, even from what Casey just said, which is what target behavior are we focused on? Are we focused on values and motivation or does it have to be just the substance use? Stopping or can it be reducing? There’s so many different things to get into depending on what your setting is and how you’d like to apply it.

                        So if you want to talk more about groups, if you want to talk more about things like presentations and ways of using techniques of Motivational Interviewing and presentations, we could get into that. We were potentially going to talk about that. If you want to talk about. In groups on societal level or politics, we can get into that.

                        So there’s all sorts of ways to think about Motivational Interviewing and approach it with different awarenesses and skillsets. We’re just here to hopefully add to being [00:35:00] a communication solution in your world. And hopefully this has helped you out Tammy or Casey. Anything else before we wrap up today,

                        Tami Calais: I’m just going to say, thank you, Kati for sending him the question.

                        Casey Jackson: And I want to reinforce build on like, you know, Tammy and John just said, We love having, we invited Katie on. If you want to beyond ask the question. If you ask the question, you don’t have to be on the podcast, but if you do ask the question and want to be on the podcast, we love to have people on it’s just more brains are better to get into these fascinating conversations.

                        So you’re more than welcome to. To send those in and just reinforced today was another day where we had the webcast. And so if you’re part of the Motivational Intervieiwng plus membership, we get to have these kinds of conversations once a month on a Friday. So it’s not me, blah, blah, blah. Well, there’s a little bit of me, blah, blah, blah.

                        But it’s mostly because you’re there asking me questions that you want to blah, blah, blah, about too. So it’s almost like a live version of the podcast that would be in, you know, a. Something that’s just one specific topic. So just think about the MI plus+ membership because you get to get in these active dialogues with other people in the Motivational Interviewing [00:36:00] community.

                        They’re just fascinated with all these components. So just, that’s another thing to think about on ways to up your skills and join in. And I’d be remiss to say. Katie was talking about, Motivational Interviewing in education? Casey does trainings in schools on Motivational Interviewing and education. There’s a series of books by multiple authors in the out there in motivational interviewing education.

                        I’m sorry to hold it at hand a little bit there, but I just wanted to give voice to that’s its own podcast. That’s its own training. There are resources that we have available on that. And if you’d like us to go deeper into that in any different age groups, Please let us know [email protected] so thank you all so much.

                        If you have not heard our whole podcast on motivational interviewing and school administration, that would be another resources. Yeah. Excellent. Thank you everyone. Thank you finally. All right. We reached the end and take care of everyone. Bye-bye bye.

                        Tami Calais: Thank you for listening to the communication solution podcast.

                        As [00:37:00] always, this podcast is all about you. So if you have questions, thoughts, topics, suggestions, ideas, please send them our way at [email protected]. That’s [email protected] for more resources, feel free to check out ifioc.com. We also have a public Facebook group called motivational interviewing every day. We have an amazing blog and we have lots of communication tips on our website.

                        In addition to all these amazing resources we do offer online public courses on our website on motivational interviewing. And effective communication strategies. Thanks for listening to the communication solution by IFIOC.

                        38 min
                      • Infusing Motivational Interviewing into Healthcare systems with guest Dr. Amy Burns

                        Motivational Interviewing and Healthcare with Amy Burns

                        Want to watch the video podcast? Join MI PLUS+

                        Wow this podcast is full of great information about operationalizing Motivational Interviewing in a healthcare setting. Whether you work in healthcare, are in leadership in the Healthcare industry or just love Motivational Interviewing, you will love this podcast! Guest Amy shares all about her experience helping her organization and culture shift to Motivational Interviewing.

                        In this Podcast we discuss:

                        • Operationalizing Motivational Interviewing
                        • Changing Culture
                        • Fidelity of Motivational Interviewing
                        • Champions of change and Motivational Interviewing
                        • Coding training (Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment-MICA)
                        • Train the trainer program
                        • And so much more!
                        • Want a transcript? See below!

                          [00:00:00] Hello, and welcome to the communication solution podcast. Here at IFIOC, we love to talk communication. We love to talk motivational interviewing, and we love talking about improving outcomes for individuals, organizations, and the communities that they serve. Today, we’ve got Casey Jackson. John Gilbert and I’m Tammy.

                          Welcome to the conversation.

                          John Gilbert: Welcome back everyone. We are back here for another podcast. Then we have another very special guest. That’s also a director here, uh, and in my eyes quite a big wig. Her name is Dr. Amy Burns. And Amy, if you wouldn’t mind for getting us started, just give us a little bit of sense of your role and anything else you’d like to share of course, but particularly your role.

                          And then [00:01:00] from there, we can get into how you’ve applied, Motivational Interviewing, your thoughts on it and how you’ve applied it in your world.

                          Amy Burns: Yeah, sure. Well, first off, I’m really, um, happy to be here this morning, talking about one of my favorite topics It’s very exciting, with the “MI” Motivational Interviewing guys. Um, so, um, I am an associate program director for a psychiatry residency in Spokane Washington.

                          And, um, I, and my other role that I kind of created for myself, because I felt like it was important and is as the lead for motivational interviewing training for graduate medical education for all of the residency’s Spokane wide. Um, yeah, so, the basically, I first got into motivational interviewing, um, teaching Medical students that were, on a [00:02:00] psych clerkship.

                          And, then it kind of grew from there. In part, because of all the training that I got at IFIOC, that kind of helped me give me the confidence to be able to, to expand what I learned and teach it to other physicians.

                          Casey Jackson: Well, and I’ve got to dive in because just give Tammy and John context as well too, when Amy and I connected, I mean, there was multiple things that, that kind of grew from that one was just fascinating.

                          Because I’d done training for physicians before. And it really was a lot of looking at it at the time, actually looking at pagers and, and waiting to get out of the training and being respectful. But Amy was just questions, questions, questions, questions, questions, because she had such a phenomenal foundation of motivational interviewing.

                          And since we were teaching at less from kind of the acronym side and more of the fidelity. Kind of measurement side. It just, it was just like this kind of perfect meeting of the minds. And, [00:03:00] and for me, the thing that just was, just overwhelming was when, um, she had reached out and wanted to look at training, having actually having her instructors, physician instructors go through Motivational Interviewing training to think about how to train Motivational Interviewing in their classes, not just an Motivational Interviewing class, because that’s pretty traditional..

                          Like they have them go through a section on motivational interviewing. And that was kind of about where they were at. And Amy was lead in that, but in us and you know what, we need to infuse this in every, all of our coursework. Like this needs to be a foundation of how people conceptualize patient care.

                          Um, instead of, oh, they need to go through an Motivational Interviewing class. That’s, that’s where I was introduced to Amy and where we had some conversations and got to do a little bit of work together and, and with some of the, the team that she works with. So that gives you two context about just kind of just that’s.

                          That’s why I thought, oh, it’d be so fascinating if we get Amy to come on and talk about her perspective with this.

                          Tami Calais: Wow. Very forward-thinking to Amy.

                          Amy Burns: Oh [00:04:00] yeah. Yeah. Well, you know, one of the things that, That really influenced the way that I think is when I think about, life expectancy, disparity and behavior changes, health behaviors and how, these health behaviors are there things that are leading to life expectancy changes in our patients, in the medical field and, And a lot of reasons, a lot of ways motivational interviewing could, can result in behavior changes as significant as medications that we prescribe and, um, making sure that we can, have the skills and implement these type.

                          This form of treatment is as important. Pharmacology is for physicians,

                          um, because it can result in that kind of behavior change. And so, that was kind of the inspiration behind wanting to make our physicians that we trained really, really good. And the other thing that I think was [00:05:00] part of our thinking here in the Spokane graduate medical education was around, the, the idea that we pride ourselves on practicing evidence-based medicine.

                           And evidence the evidence base for teaching motivational interviewing, um, really demonstrates that one workshop is not enough to change clinician and client behavior, and that you really have to have the coaching and. Feedback and coding, if you really want to get your patients to change. And so without those things, um, the learners may think they’ve got it and may really like it.

                          They think that they’re doing it, but when you actually code them, maybe not so much, not so much. Yeah. Yeah. So that’s what, um, really inspired our teams to think about. [00:06:00] Um, less about, uh, the medical knowledge acquisition of like the acronyms and the, the theory behind motivational interviewing and focus more of our energy on skill acquisition and attitude, which attitude towards employing it attitude towards what is, what does this mean?

                          Um, valuing it’s important than their practice.

                          Casey Jackson: You know, and it was interesting timing as well, too, because we were working on the Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment and, um, and some of your folks went through a Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment training right in the early stages of us while we were developing it. And when we finally first published the very first version of it, I know we’re at version 3.2 now, but that first version, literally your, your folks were some of the first ones to get exposed to that.

                          Fidelity training. Um, when we’re, when we’re working on the motivational and competency assessment and got a little bit of feedback on that as well, too, in the process of working on it, which was, [00:07:00] it was exciting for us. And I think it was a fun kind of partnership right there in the beginning.

                          Amy Burns: Oh yeah.

                          Yeah. That was amazing. We had, we were able to send, , faculty from three or maybe four different residency programs. So internal medicine, hospitalists and family medicine, outpatient docs, and psychiatrists, we all came together. The faculty. Um, learned how to use the Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment to code. And then we quickly turned that around and implemented it before everybody forgot it and got out of it.

                          That was really critical because then you can lose your confidence really quickly if you don’t start practicing it immediately.

                          Casey Jackson: Well, and I need to ask you this Amy, because you know, I’ve, I said it before, but I’m curious. I mean, motivational Interviewing is not new. It’s been around since 1984. It’s been, you know, swirling around the medical field for years.

                          And I know it’s implemented at a much larger level than it was, you know, [00:08:00] in the beginning, but it was, I guess, in my experience in the “MI” Motivational Interviewing circles that I run into, you know, and, and get exposure to nationally and internationally. In the states, it’s like pockets of, of programs that see value in it.

                          But mostly it’s just kind of this brief exposure, because there are so many things we need to get residents through. And it just like, it’s like dust in the corner, um, is the way I’ve always kind of perceived motivational interviewing. And when I met you, you were one of the first people I’d met in the medical field.

                          That was like, guys, we need to really, really, really pay attention to this. Like, this is, this is significant. Why did your brain. Grab onto why did you gravitate towards motivational Intervieiwng in the way that you did and you’ve stuck? Not only do you stuck with it, you continue to be completely intrigued with it.

                          Amy Burns: Yeah. It’s really hard to know, like why well, parts of it maybe have to do with just that. I really felt like it was a good fit for my temperament and my personal ethos about how I like to [00:09:00] respect my patients and, honor their. Autonomy and, where they’re coming from and what they want to do.

                          And I really experienced it as a way for me to practice medicine with less burnout. I felt less responsible for the, the patients outcomes and. While simultaneously making a bigger impact by practicing motivational interviewing. And so I found like it was a huge part of my own personal physician wellness.

                           I think part of it had to do with the fact that I was working with some really treatment refractory patient populations and, other strategies weren’t effective, medications were effective. And so I really needed to look outside of my normal. Um, psychopharm and so those are some of the dynamics that came together.

                           One of the things that I thought about when you were talking about is how, um, in the medical education [00:10:00] world, that motivational interviewing, you know, it, there’s more and more workshops being taught in medical schools. And then they’ll do another workshop during, um, residency and there’s near universal support for motivational interviewing.

                          It’s incorporation is, is still kind of emerging. And I think it’s starting to grow a little bit on the heels of a growing recognition of the problem. Substance use disorders are causing our society. And so there’s pockets within graduate, graduate medical education, um, that are calling for a motivational interviewing competency to be a requirement.

                          By the governing bodies over seeing I’m graduate medical education or residencies. Yeah. Yeah. So there’s been, um, and that’s probably been in the last five years that there’s been growing editorials and [00:11:00] calls for that. I’m on a task force. That really, um, amongst psychiatry training, um, program directors, that’s recommending motivational interviewing training in psychiatry residencies.

                          And so there is like a, some growing want need for that. And, um, you’ll see some trainings occasionally for graduate medical educators that nothing required.

                          Tami Calais: Tami, Amy, I had a question for you? So you mentioned you wanted to immerse, you know, your culture and motivational interviewing. My question is like, what, what did that systematic change look like for you guys?

                          I know you, you mentioned that everyone went through the Mica and the coding, but was it literally every single person went through, you know, training and then the Mica coding, or did you do like a smaller group that became like coaches to your organization that helped kind of coach other people.[00:12:00]

                          What was that systematic change?

                          Amy Burns: Yeah, well, I think I started myself and probably Dr. Mauer and I’m like what? He’s like motivational interviewing fan boy, number one. Um, and so he, and I would start doing some coding and then we decided we wanted to try to take it up to the next level.

                          Dr. Keeble was really instrumental, instrumental, and a real powerhouse and supportive motivational interviewing. It really helps to have leadership, that’s in support. And so that was a huge part of our success too, is that we had leadership that was really supportive. And then we had a group of, faculty from each program, not every faculty member from each program, but rather a few select champions that got the Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment coding.

                          And then, each of our programs [00:13:00] implemented a series of curriculums that, um, made sure that we trained, every single physician that was coming through our programs, that’s kind of how we started, trying to build the culture.

                          Casey Jackson: Okay. Well, I have to say Tammy, on, as far as the culture goes on the flip side for me, I’ve trained, so many people in the medical field, but what stood out to me so much is that the culture had already started with, with Dr. Mauer and, and, uh, Dr. Burns his perspective because it was the first time I’d trained people in healthcare. Like, especially at the physician level, when they came in, interested to learn.

                           When Amy said they kind of hand selected some of the ones to go through that initial training, like the champions I just was, I always prepare for, I need to present differently to physicians. I just, I prepare for that. Um, because there’s a culture around that and this was the most collegial, [00:14:00] collaborative training. Like I was after day one, I was just blown away because their brains were so interested in learning from an integration perspective. So that cultural, I mean, Amy talks about that’s where it started for me. It’s like, oh, that started way before that with Amy and, and Dr. Mauer, his passion for it.

                          Because that had to have rubbed off for the folks that came into my training, the physicians who came into my training were so intrigued and wanting to learn, like it felt so like sponges who wanted to collaborate and talk about it and let’s look at nuance. And how would we present this to students?

                          And how would we weave this into this type of curriculum? I’m in the level of collaboration and curiosity. Was so far beyond what I expected. And to me, that is part of that culture that exists within their program. That, that didn’t show up because it’s like, Hey, let’s send some people through and then we’ll build culture.

                          That culture. What, for me, I could feel had been cultivated long before. Um, I was able to provide some information and support the initiative.

                          Tami Calais: That’s great. Yeah. I just am always curious because a lot [00:15:00] of agencies do come to IFIOC going, we want to immerse our organization and motivational interviewing. So Amy being a successful organization that has done that, granted Casey, to your point, it’s all because of the mindset people are coming in with.

                          But that’s just great to know.

                          Amy Burns: You know, like looking back on it. I wonder if part of it had to do with, that, We had our faculty champions self-selected and so they, they got to decide themselves that they were wanting to make this change. And, um, we had really pitched it as an evidence-based practice. And, really compared like, are we really training our physicians and evidence-based practice if we’re not giving them this piece of the, of the skillset, um, and really challenged their concept of themselves as a really comprehensive educators. Like, are you really, if you’re not doing [00:16:00] this.

                          Casey Jackson: Well, and, and again, because you know, Kenny and John, you both worked on so many projects.

                          What was interesting too, is like Amy was coding before the Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment as well, too. I mean, that was just part of the expectation of the residents as they were submitting, um, and getting coding and coaching. That was just, that was just standard practice in, in the class. And so. For me, what was just, I still think it’s so progressive is that it was that integration into other classes outside of Motivational Interviewing, that it was really thinking about how do we put this into curriculum?

                          So this is a mindset shift within the context of the service we’re providing of how do we engage patients more effectively? And I think it was, and I even think it was on that parallel process when you’re thinking lifestyle medicine. It’s like, we need to think this way, because this does have profound impact.

                          And it’s not just a method. It really is. Something can have an impact on [00:17:00] behavioral health outcomes. And we need to think about this more comprehensively. I just think at the time when you’re thinking, you know, five years ago, six years ago, seven years ago, that was really innovative. I mean, that’s, that’s just not the exposure I had or what people that were training people in the medical world that I was talking to as other Motivational Interviewing trainers.

                          There just, wasn’t a lot of that going on. That was not the norm by any stretch. Um, so just context for people. I just want them to understand, like this really was innovation. Um, and it, and it wasn’t for the sake of innovation. That’s why I wanted Amy on is because it’s just her brain. Wouldn’t let go of Motivational Interviewing.

                          It’s just like, there’s, there’s a, there, there, and I need to keep looking at this and wow, this is really fascinating. And why have we thought about it this way? And then to have a team that was. Thinking that same level is just, that is outside the norm. It’s outside of the normal of everything I had experienced and, um, all the things from the, my world of other trainers, I talked to, it just wasn’t the norm in the medical.

                          Amy Burns: Wow. It’s so interesting to think about because, um, I didn’t really know that at the [00:18:00] time, I just knew that it was important in that, um, it needed to happen in order to take care of patients. And, you know, it’s been ironic. Like, you know, you have an unintended consequences, there’s been a huge physician wellness.

                          Um, that’s been coming out of this as the physicians feel less and less, uh, Personally responsible and unwell at the end of the day. So it really helps the patient, the patients take more responsibility and help them change, you know, so that the patient, that physician doesn’t have to take at home.

                          John Gilbert: Oh my gosh, Amy, that’s huge.

                          I’ve been trying to. Over the years, see burnout research. And there’s not as much as you would think in motivational interviewing, but there’s a lot of anecdotal reports and that’s, what’s so interesting is what you’re recording is this sense of a sense of not as burnt out and you can call it empathy, fatigue, compassion, fatigue that happens.

                          But for [00:19:00] physicians, there’s a lot of other things you’ve got to navigate as well. Yeah, that’s really interesting. And I’d be curious to do any sort of research around that because that is a right area. But I, I do want to highlight how you have gone about it seems to stem from, uh, an attitude of yourself that you brought to the table of having the champions.

                          Uh, which seems to be across all the organizations we’ve worked with really critical with your early adopters, like you obviously were keyed into, but then also you had an evidence based pitch as well. And that’s really important for, physicians not doing harm with the essence of the credit code, as well as you’re taking it to a level of an evidence-based practice.

                          So all of that seems to stem from your perspective and your attitude and how you’re approaching it. And then what you and Dr. Mauer brought to interact [00:20:00] with Casey. It just was this attitude of openness progression of contribution. And there’s just a lot there, but I want to also get a sense from you too.

                          Um, just with, with where you’ve taken it, you were mentioning to us before we started that you were recently at a conference, uh, presenting with this. And so it was really curious about some of those points you were making and what you felt was most important. Where you’re at now with what you’ve learned with the whole program.

                          Amy Burns: And yeah, it was really, it was really interesting this conference that we took, that we presented at, and I combined forces with, uh, four other training programs that were different parts across the country. Some of them small programs, some of them academic. Powerhouses. And we all came together and presented our motivational interviewing curriculum as kind of a, [00:21:00] of a way of, letting, other teachers kind of see how different programs do it, depending on their size, their bandwidth, the faculty, and so on and so forth. And so, um, at this conference, we talked about the evidence-based for teaching motivational interviewing and what’s known about. Um, how you have to, what you need to do in order to get your learners up to speed.

                          And then we each presented our curriculums, and there’s a huge variety in how and what curriculums look like across the country. Everything from an hour long didactic. With no role-playing at all, all the way to high fidelity coding, um, and tell proficient, you know, you have, you have to keep going until you do it kind of thing.

                           And, and so what, some of the things that, the takeaways from that, is that there’s a variety of different fidelity coding tools,[00:22:00] that the different programs I’ve talked about, you know, there’s the mighty them, which, um, because of the length of time, that of tape that you need to have is a little bit cumbersome for the medical field.

                          And for that reason, that’s part of the reason we really liked the Motivational Interviewing competency Assessment, but the majority, some have created their own tools. Some programs have that are even faster and quicker. Then the Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment. And then I have even learned about some artificial intelligence. One of the things I learned about artificial intelligence, coding, a blizzard.

                          Um, and so I guess, like if a program had more money than time or faculty, you could theoretically think about, you know, purchasing artificial intelligence. I’m coding. I haven’t looked into it too much. Um, but so those are some of the things, um, you know, another thing that I really, um, took away from that conference [00:23:00] was this sense of.

                          I feel like in the medical education, we think of two or three, three different, pillars for training physicians, knowledge skills, and attitudes, knowledge, skills, and attitudes. And those, those are three things that we, try to teach around, for medical physicians. And I feel like as far as motivational interviewing correctly, We’ve been over-reliant we too much time spend on knowledge and these physicians can learn notoriously fast.

                          You don’t need to spend a few minutes, um, and you can let them read something and they can learn faster from reading. A lot of them can. And so we’ve really pivoted away from knowledge to spending almost all of our energy and skill, acquisition, and attitude. You don’t really feel like I know we’ll spend any time.

                          Tom teaching someone about something that they can read off of a piece of paper. So we do [00:24:00] not, even in our seminar, we don’t spend any time with knowledge. We just do skill acquisition. I don’t really care if you can pass a paper test on motivational interviewing. So, um, and the patients don’t care.

                          Casey Jackson: Well, because if they’re in your program, you already know they can pass the paper test.

                          If you give them the book and give them an outline of kind of what the expectations are, you don’t even need to do instruction and they’re going to pass a test.

                          Amy Burns: Oh yeah. I don’t. They, these people can jump through hoops in their sleep. But what is really hard is applying operationalizing the concept.

                          And, being, getting the skill that is the area for improvement. So I spend zero time. I think we do have like a two hour workshop in our first year, but the vast majority is on skills.

                          Casey Jackson: It’s probably not the best analogy, but the analogy I always use, because I actually, literally today I just got a text or an email this morning about people wanting train the trainer training and, and they want to send like their standard trainer for the organization through the training.[00:25:00]

                          And what I tell them is I compare it to brain surgery and I said, if somebody has never performed brain surgery, but they can teach it. That makes me nervous. Because there’s going to be questions and there’s application things that if you’ve never performed. You really don’t know how to instruct it well, so you can read the book and you can smart enough to teach people and tell them how to do brain surgery and talk about the mechanics of it and do a phenomenal job.

                          But if I put you in front of a brain , this is a dynamic process, it’s not a static process. Um, and when we’re talking about language and human behavior, and we’re talking about the brain and the way in communication, Like, it’s not as easy as you think. And, and people still want to reduce it to, well, it’s just a training on motivational interviewing.

                          And for me, the level of complexity, I mean, I’ve been doing this for 20 years, teaching it for 20 years and I’m feel like a novice still. Like it it’s just every time. I unfold new things. And I read the new things about, you know, brain science and trauma and the way the brain works and how language [00:26:00] affects parts of the brain and how our attitude affects parts of the brain.

                          And that affects how we should be speaking more using motivation to affect behavior change. So it’s like, so when I get these calls of people saying, Hey, we want to send somebody through a train the trainer. So our organization candidate, I always get nervous and I don’t want to be. Uh, contractor say, no, you just need to buy more training.

                          Cause that’s not it it’s this, what you’re talking about is there are things that need to be in your structure. If you really want to have this actualized in an attitude and a skill base, it is so beyond knowledge acquisition, like it is definitely beyond otherwise the reputation of Motivational Interviewing is well, we tried it and it didn’t work.

                          But then we measure that and they weren’t doing Motivational Interviewing, they were doing what you’re trained to do, and that isn’t necessarily motivational interviewing. And I think that’s, that’s again, why I think it was so innovative in the way that you conceptualize it. And the way that, you know, Bob was thinking the way, you know, your whole program was really thinking.

                          We need to think about this in a comprehensive way. And I [00:27:00] always believe with motivational interviewing, then the proof is in the pudding. What people find with evidence-based practices is when you practice with fidelity, Things get better. Otherwise it’s not an evidence-based practice. And so when you do get to that level of competency or proficiency and you feel less burned out, then you feel that shift happened.

                          That the one other thing I wanted to comment on what you and John were talking about with the, the shift in, in burnout and, and just, you know, physician wellness and, and, you know, practitioner wellness is I really been talking a lot about in medical model. Western medical model. We have just been forced to be the experts like that is the expectation.

                          You don’t go to school that long, you know, in any of our professions, you don’t go to school that long and get pushed as hard as you get pushed to not be the expert. You need to have the document on the wall. You need to show that you can jump through those hoops. And then when I tell people is, and your patient doesn’t care, They want to know that stuff is there, but they just want, they just care about themselves, [00:28:00] you know?

                          And so it, it forces motivational interviewing, forces a collaboration, but once you get past the, the part that you can surrender, that I have to be the expert. And instead I’m almost this medical consultant and I can sit shoulder to shoulder with them and find out how do you want to use my expertise to better your outcome?

                          And it’s a collaborative process. That’s where you see exponential behavior change happened from that point, but it’s just, that’s just culturally, not Western medical medicine. You come into the doctor, you sit, you explain what’s going on. They tell you what you’re supposed to do. And then we stigmatize patients by saying, yeah, they’re most of them are pretty noncompliant.

                          And it’s like, well, you’ve got to engage your brain in a behavior change process for behavior change to happen. You can’t dictate behavior change or everyone would behealthy. Eating their three square meals a day and exercising and minimum of 20 minutes a day. And as you would just hand them that brochure, you would just the book of health and say, read this book on health and do application.

                          Amy Burns: , Once again, it’s not about [00:29:00] knowledge, it’s about attitudes. It’s like, you can know what the right thing to do is, and not do it like our patients demonstrate.

                          Casey Jackson: Exactly. So that’s, I, that’s why I think for me and I it’s, it’s fascinating for me. That your brain wasn’t looking at how innovative it is. I think because from my vantage, right.

                          And being able to travel across country and around the world a bit and looking up through motivational interviewing that really your mindset was very progressive. Um, from that perspective, I know that when you’re in your own little world, it’s like, well, it just makes sense. So if it makes sense, I’m going to pursue this.

                          And it’s like the you and Bob or Dr. Mauer were just like, no, this is really something we need to look at.

                          Amy Burns: I don’t think we could have done it without the support of IFIOC. I know we couldn’t have done it because you guys were able to give us the background and to show us the evidence base about how you teach people, how people learn and then to be able to train us in the Motivational Interviewing Competency Assessment.

                          I mean, so it’s been a collaboration. I don’t think it’s any surprise [00:30:00] that, uh, the, our proximity toward you, you guys is the reason why we were able to pull this off.

                          Casey Jackson: Yeah, for me, it was the, kind of the, the, the perfect synergy that happened, the timing, the location, um, and just the chemistry, you know, because we, again, it is a, it’s a mutual admiration society with, uh, with yeah, just your whole team and, and, uh, it it’s, it’s just, it’s just always an odd, just feels fun to be shoulder to shoulder in little Spokane, Washington.

                          You know,

                          and to hear these things that are happening now, nationally or internationally, because of the work that, you know, our programs are.

                          Amy Burns: Yeah. You know, one thing that I’m really excited about, that’s kind of our next step forward is we are no to John’s question. We are gathering some data about physician wellness metrics from our learners to understand their experience of how motivational interviewing has changed their, their, um, experience of practicing [00:31:00] medicine in the other direction that we’re also moving in is starting to gather data measurement based.

                          Um, Uh, treatment. So using a metric to, and we’re going to be trying at first, an patients with addiction. So we’re going to be using de-brief addiction measure, um, in measuring how motivational interviewing is impacting our patient’s ability to change and to get better. Because I kind of feel like, that’s the holy grail. Like what’s the use of doing all of this. If the patients aren’t getting better. And so I’m really hoping to close the loop on our curriculum with that being the cherry on the top is if the patients first, we get the learners, um, you know, some tapes where we see they’re practicing high fidelity medicine, and then I want them to have the rewarding.

                          Experience of watching a patients, um, get better as a result of there. [00:32:00] And I feel like that that’ll be the final, like reinforcing loop to get the physicians, to keep doing it.

                          Casey Jackson: That makes so much sense. That that’s, what’s amazing. That’s amazing.

                          Amy Burns: That’s my dream. It’s taking, it’s going to take me years, um, to get it done because it has implications for our electronic medical record and workflows with MAs um, things that things are more complicated, but what else should get in to do.

                          Casey Jackson: Yeah. That’s, that’s why I look at our little corner of the world that it’s just like, it’s just. To hear where your program is now is just it’s so, so exciting. Um, well, if, if people wanted to, to touch base with you or reach out or contact you, what would that look like? Amy? I mean, how could people know.

                          Amy Burns: You can email me [email protected]. If they want to talk to me, I’m happy to share a curriculum. Love, to help other programs that are wanting [00:33:00] to, um, to grow and get better.

                          Casey Jackson: I just appreciate you taking time to do this. I know your time is incredibly valuable and it just, for us, I think for people to hear, um, your, your perspective and your vantage point and what your mindset has been, uh, is just incredible.

                          And I just appreciate you taking time to do.

                          Amy Burns: Oh, it’s my pleasure. Thank you so much. I, we couldn’t have done it without you IFIOC and a fan girl to.

                          Excellent you to admiration society. I love it. Thank you so much for coming on today, Amy. We really, really appreciate it. Yeah. Well, thank you everyone for listening.

                          Tami Calais: Excellent. Thanks. Fine. Thank you for listening to the communication solution podcast as always. This podcast is all about you. So if you have questions, thoughts, topics, suggestions, ideas, please send them our way at [email protected]. That’s [00:34:00] [email protected]. For more resources, feel free to check out ifioc.com.

                          If you haven’t already followed us on social media, please do. You can find us under @theifioc on Facebook and Instagram. You can also find us on YouTube and LinkedIn. We also have a public Facebook group called motivational interviewing every day. In addition to all these amazing resources we do offer online public courses on our website on motivational interviewing. And effective communication strategies. Thanks for listening to the communication solution by IFIOC.

                          Want more?

                          Want to infuse Motivational Interviewing into your organization? Reach out to connect with us!

                          Learn more about the MICA coding program we offer.

                          Want to enhance your skills with skill building worksheets, training videos, micro-courses and more? Join our MI PLUS+ community!

                          35 min
                        • Insecurity and building confidence with guest Matthias

                          Insecurity and building Confidence with guest Matthias J. Barker.

                          Want to watch the video podcast? Join MI PLUS+

                          Join us as we really plunge into a deep discussion about insecurity and building confidence! Guest Matthias J. Barker joins us sharing his expertise in trauma. This rich conversation is well worth a listen as our conversation navigates the challenges with insecurity as well as how can we restore confidence?

                          In this podcast we discuss:

                          • Labels and false summits
                          • Anxiety
                          • Fight or Flight
                          • Values
                          • Blame
                          • Depression
                          • Shame, guilt and personal responsibility
                          • Control
                          • About our guest:

                             Matthias Barker has a Master’s Degree in Clinical Mental Health Counseling and has been formally trained for treating complex trauma, anxiety, and marital issues. He treats a large variety of mental disorders and difficult life circumstances in his clinical practice based in Spokane, Washington. Matthias is the author of two e-books, On Grief and On Avoiding Burnout. In addition, he has released three public workshops focusing on Anxiety, Trauma, and a Couples Workshop.

                            Want a transcript? See below!

                            Tami: [00:00:00] Hello, and welcome to the communication solution podcast. Here at IFIOC, we love to talk communication. We love to talk motivational interviewing, and we love talking about improving outcomes for individuals, organizations, and the communities that they serve today. We’ve got Casey Jackson on the line.

                            John Gilbert and I’m Tammy. Welcome to the conversation.

                            John Gilbert: Hello. Again, everyone. We have yet another guest on our IFIOC podcast today. This is a wonderful human being that I’ve just met. And I’m really looking forward to this conversation because he has some particular questions in mind. Um, his name is Mathias Barker and he will share his contact info and he is quite the.

                            Instagrammer, among many other things out there with his own podcasts that Casey was on. And so, [00:01:00] we will make sure you get some sort of direction or link to that in our notes. We just want to, as you said, play around with some thoughts today, uh, particularly with your expertise in, trauma and some different projects you’re working on.

                            So first I just want to say welcome. And, uh, what would you like to talk about today?

                            Matthias Barker: Thank you. It’s an honor to be here. Yeah, I, I encounter Casey at one of his workshops back when I was in my masters program. And so I’ve kind of been, um, continually gleaning wisdom from afar. And so anytime I get to be in a room with Casey, I just, I just try to get him talking and steal all the secrets.

                            So that’s all I’ve tried to do, but I’m happy to be here. It’s a generous, yeah. Title of the. Trauma expert title. I, I think I’m learning just the same as everyone else. It’s uh, most of my clientele is in complex trauma and in working particularly with sexual trauma, that’s where I’ve done most of my training.

                            Insecurity and trauma

                            And so that’s where a lot of. Um, yeah, a lot of my reading, a lot of my supervision, a lot of my mentorship has been in that [00:02:00] world. So yeah. It’s, it’s an honor to get to hang out. Yeah. I, you know, right before we started recording, I just kinda threw out the idea. I’m like, you know, it would be interesting to discuss, cause I have some thoughts front of mind, but I’d love to get both of your views on it is, is just the dynamic of insecurity as it relates to trauma.

                            And, um, you know, so I’m on social media. I, I make a lot of like Instagram and Tik TOK videos. I have a popular podcast. And so I’m kind of like almost in this like pop psychology field, even though maybe I spend most of my time reading. I don’t know. The academic journals and the literature on different interventions.

                            So it’s confusing. Cause people are like, well, what psychology books would you recommend? And I’m like, you wouldn’t like any of this stuff, I’m reading it. Like, I don’t know. All the stuff I’ve read is like out a way in the weeds. And um, but, but one question I constantly is like, do you have any book recommendations on confidence?

                            How it can increase my confidence. And, and while that’s like a very invoked topic in like the pop psychology world, um, or in like, I dunno the self-help [00:03:00] world. It’s it’s something that isn’t necessarily zeroed in on, in the trauma literature. Maybe it is maybe just in the reading that I’ve done. It’s we conceptualize it perhaps a little bit differently because when we think about self-criticism, we think about like the wounds that are underneath self-critic.

                            When you think about, um, you know, insecurity or me not feeling confident, you know, perhaps in an Motivational Interviewing lens, like maybe this is, this is my theory, confirm or deny this and maybe expand on it as like, through the Motivational Interviewing lens, it would be, you know, looked at through the lens of ambivalence. There’s a part of me that wants to be able to feel really secure and safe and pursuing this thing that matters to me.

                            But there’s a part of me that has this deep fear that it’s going to end in catastrophe, or I’m not really going to put myself out there. I’m going to be vulnerable and it’s not going to work out. And, and so that’s, that’s more the lens, like when I think of how do I conceptualize insecurity in relation to trauma, and then what would be the prescription or what would be perhaps like the arc of boosting one’s confidence thats, I guess that’s [00:04:00] the domain that I’ve been thinking about a lot lately, trying to relate some of my training more in like the theoretical world to this question that’s kind of on the front of everyone’s minds in the pop world of how do I boost my confidence? So what comes to mind for you guys? When that question is….

                            Casey Jackson: I got to tell you.

                            There’s multiple things to go through my brain with this. And I like how you keep things so simple. Uh, let’s keep it as simple and as tight as we possibly can. Let’s not throw 15 different angles in at one time. I mean, this is what I think is why you and I love what we do. It’s just, it’s just, it’s never ending.

                            Motivational Interviewing and insecurity, trauma and confidence

                            Cause it’s so fascinating. There’s two things that struck me when I first, my brain was starting to, you know, as you talk and I’m trying to, you know, look through the Motivational Interviewing lens at this. I think at the importance confidence ruler, I mean, something so simple, so basic, not exclusive to motivational interviewing and, and I was starting to deconstruct it as you talked from when we get into building a plan, use the importance, confidence, ruler, that the thing that we know with that when we use, you know, [00:05:00] how important is it to you?

                            How confident are you in getting there? Importance tends to almost always be high confidence tends to always be low.. Unless you run into like personality disorder, things like that, where it can be inverted, but mostly what you see is people it’s really important for me to do these things, but my confidence is low and in a very so specific and so simple way, it’s just like, well, what would take you from that four to just a four and a half in your confidence and to help people go from this overwhelming thing to a smaller step, but that doesn’t get to the depth of what we’re talking about with the kind of confidence and insecurity that you’re talking about.

                            And what struck me, especially when you’re talking about pop psychology is I think because we are so immersed 24/ 7/365 and other people’s realities, how can you not be anything but insecure? Um, and, and for me, what I equate to is when I developed the focus mountain, just knowing that there’s almost an infinite number of trees we can get lost in and never see the top of the mountain, because we’re so lost. And I [00:06:00] always use that kind of Mount Rainier perspective that, you know, everything we’re talking about with the security and, and looks and productivity and intelligence and all these things where we are comparing ourselves or the self doubt or the insecurity or the trauma we’ve experienced.

                            Gets us further and further lost in, you know, what am I supposed to be? Who am I supposed to be? And then I look over there and there’s a tree over there, and that’s how they look on social media or that’s what that’s supposed to be going on there. And John used to talk about, you know, the, the Buddhist perspective that, you know, that whole thing of that jealousy is kind of the stealer of joy is, you know, we want other people’s things, then we just feel more and more insecure.

                            And for me, where it starts from, and I was thinking about this with the insecurity and with trauma. It is shocking to me. You can take the most insecure person, but the more they start to talk about what their core values are, you start to see some of that restorative process happen. Hmm, because it’s not about what they look like or what they’re supposed to be doing or what their degree is or what their job is, or how much money [00:07:00] do they have, what car do they drive?

                            It’s who are you like, who do you know yourself to be? If everybody’s gonna strip everything away from you, who do you know yourself to be? And you know, this Matthias people we talk to, they will say, I know I’m a good person. Yeah. Um, some people doubt that at times, but, but they’ll get done these basic things.

                            If I know I’m. And, and, and then the way they start to talk about that, you can see, they’re not even convincing themselves. They’re kind of revisiting or they’re refining themselves as far as what, what makes me tick? I just think our culture, our, especially our mainstream American culture, we are distracted from that 24 7 365.

                            I just, especially with social media, it just is, it’s what everybody else is doing. And I have to replicate what everybody else is doing and they did a little bit better than I did. And so I’m going to keep practicing to get better. And just because you get better, it doesn’t mean it has substance to it, but it’s kind of, what’s socially defined a substance.

                            And so we just have all these things. It’s just like eating, you know, cotton candy. [00:08:00] It’s just like, there’s just no substance to, it looks like there’s ballplayer. There’s just no sustenance to it. And I think that’s where for me, from a social insecurity perspective, I can see how that is really hard to get out from underneath.

                            Matthias Barker: I think you’re right where that’s the thing that can organize the conversation. This is what are the values? And I think the analogy of the trees in the mountain top is perfect for that, because it’s so easy to get caught up in the trees. And the thing that was first apparent to me is I’ve been kind of digesting this question of like, okay, how do you boost one’s confidence?

                            Or how do you, how do you, you know, take apart insecurity or something along those lines is, is like, man, there’s so many, um, false summits and there’s so many things. There’s so many labels that we’re trying to live under. There’s so many, uh, wounds that we carry that have a parent fixes. Like, you know, the first thing that jumped to mind for me was like insecurities around body image and, um, one’s weight and, and you could think, oh, I’d just be confident if I lost 20 pounds.

                            Yeah. You know, you could think I would just be confident if I had her hair, if, uh, [00:09:00] if I could lift this much, you know, and, on one level, what we’re doing is, is we’re just, we’re picking kind of like this very static temporal, um, Tangible thing to try to grasp onto because, because that feels doable, but then we almost focus our entire like lens of experience onto that one thing.

                            And we’re not paying attention. For example, we’re not paying attention to okay. What kind of diet my using to drop that 20 pounds, maybe that’s healthy. Maybe that’s not is me losing 20 pounds about long-term health, because that would actually dictate a lot of the strategy that I use to try to lose the 20 pounds.

                            ’cause I could just starve myself and lose 20 pounds, but maybe that’s actually not in line with my values. And then in a clinical setting, what I, what I know to be true is often when you get underneath it, it’s more often the case that people have a conception of what they don’t want more than what they do want.

                            Yeah. You’re just like, I just don’t want to feel disgusting anymore. I just don’t want to feel fat anymore. I just don’t want to feel ugly anymore.. And so [00:10:00] that’s where the strategy has almost like, no, there’s, there’s no, uh, there’s no boundaries around what strategy you can use, because the only thing I’m doing is I’m trying to get away from this feeling.

                            And then you get to the 20 pounds loss and you look in the mirror and like the classic thing is I don’t see anything different. Like, I can’t tell you how many have not even just clients, just my friends, like, you know, we’ll just be chatting and be like, oh, we lost weight. I’ve I, this group of guys, we all go to the gym together and.

                            And we were just chatting the other day and we’ve all lost a good amount of weight. And in one of the guys, it’s just like, I look in the mirror and I see nothing different. Like I’ve hit my goal weight, but I still feel this way. And, and so conceptually, I mean, I’m not therapizing my friends at the gym, but I conceptually I’m thinking, yeah, I guess that’s what happens when you try to run away from something.

                            It doesn’t necessarily give you a good vision for what to run to. If all you’re doing is trying to find the best tree in the forest, like you’re going to be running around the forest, looking and comparing these different trees and some are going to be better than others [00:11:00] in some ways, or it’s almost like there’s too many variables to really hold onto.

                            Um, but when you really know narrow down a dream or another way to say that, like a positively stated goal, it’s not just a negatively stated goal. I just don’t want to feel fat anymore. It’s a positively stated goal of, I want to, I want to have a lifestyle that supports my overall health and creates, you know, ability for me later in life.

                            That that lends me to feel concentrated and present with the things that matter most like my family or my job. I want to feel, um, comfortable going on a walk, you know, through, on a hike and not feeling winded. I want to be able to feel fully present when I’m engaging in nature. When you start to have these more tangible value Laden, positively stated goals, it’s like the strategy starts to become more narrowed in it’s like the strategy starts to become more centered.

                            And less, frantic less anxious, but I guess I don’t have a full way to clearly hone all that in. Those are just some of the spacial kind of tangential pieces that I’m trying to kind of fit together. That’s the constellation [00:12:00] of things that I’m trying to make sense of.

                            Casey Jackson: Whats interesting when you say that because when you’re talking about the dimensionality of it, Literally, as you were talking, what I kept thinking about is because people are trying to use a one-dimensional intervention to get to a three-dimensional solution.

                            Matthias Barker: Yeah. Yeah. Great. Yeah. That’s a great way to put it.

                            Casey Jackson: And the thing that fascinates me, like when you’re talking about weight or looks or things like that, what struck me as well to take some of the psychological side out of it is like, even with parenting, because you can relate to this. Yeah. How people perceive one dimensionally of how they’re going to be as a parent, has no relevance to how they’re going to be three-dimensionally as a apparent, when there’s a child that’s born and it’s three in the morning and you’re, they’re two months old. Like you have no point of reference. So you have no point of reference of what would it feel like to walk around with six pack abs in a, you know, in a pair of shorts on the beach, it’s like you have no, we have a one dimensional assessment of what that would be.

                            We don’t have a three-dimensional assessment of what, what that reality means and, and all the things we project on that usually aren’t based in three-dimensional reality. [00:13:00] Um, it has it’s based in such a self-centered reality of what we think we would feel like we’re in that situation because of what we project on people that we see in those situations.

                            The problem is if you step inside the three-dimensional reality of somebody in that situation, it has no relevance to what you think it is that you’re projecting to. And so it is such a chronic kind of self centered perspective in the, in a non-negative way. But for me, I think this is why. What I believe is one of the first steps is getting so clear about what are my core values, stripping all other social context away just from that moral or values based perspective.

                            Who am I really, and, and starting from there, because this is a little bit of it. I think it’s related somewhat to the tangent. I, when I, when I was kind of young in my therapy as therapist, world, um, one of the things that struck me so profoundly. Was I started to look at the difference between especially in my age, growing up and as a therapist, then it was so much around dysfunction.[00:14:00]

                            And what I kept bucking against was that all the families I work with are functional, or they wouldn’t be coming in. They may not be healthy, but we keep labeling. This whole thing is dysfunctional, I think, but it is functioning. So it can’t be dysfunctional if it’s functioning, it may not be healthy, but it’s functioning and, and there may be all sorts of problems with it, but it’s still functioning.

                            From there. What I looked at with the whole healthy piece of it is I really looked from kind of a Darwinism perspective is we are drawn to, you’re attracted to health. Somebody can be not particularly physically the most attractive to us personally, but if they’re mentally or emotionally or spiritually healthy, there’s a gravitational pull towards that.

                            And I think that’s why when you start from within, you see this start to shift in a sense of confidence because you’re building on something that’s real. And other people that see something that’s real, there’s a natural gravitation towards wanting something that’s truthful and real. And that’s so good.

                            Matthias Barker: So what you’re saying, sorry, sorry to cut you off, but just to put the, put a little bit of a little summary on that. [00:15:00] Cause I think that’s so good. It’s not as simple as really just articulating the goal. Right. Because you could, you can say it in a shame-based way. You could say it in a really positive way, because ultimately we’re not in that experience, we’re going to have a one dimensional view of whatever a potential future could look like.

                            We’re not really going to know what it feels like. Would it be what it tastes like, what it feels like when we wear it until we’re in it? So, you, you could, you could tell someone, oh, I don’t have a shame-based goal. Um, you know, have a positively stated goal, but that’s still, you’re still kind of (casey-one dimensional dreams).

                            You’re still in the running around and the dreams there that’s exactly it. You still run around the trees. So something deeper is let’s get it, who you are as a person, let’s get at your deepest core values. And if maybe if we could connect to that, then that’s going to organize, you know, how that looks on the surface and really no matter what it kind of manifests later in life, you’re going to be connected to the thing that, that is healthy.

                            That is rejuvenative. Would you say it like that or would you, yeah.

                            Casey Jackson: I think that’s great. And I think this is where it goes from, because when you start from that square one, [00:16:00] then every time we take a step in that direction of who you are when your behavior starts to align with that, that can’t do anything, but start to increase your sense of self-confidence. When you deal with that relationship with a little bit more integrity.

                            When you deal with the situation a little bit more honesty, these core things you want to operate by the more you do that. And the more things sift out because the people that gravitate towards that are going to be bonded and stronger in that. And you’re going to get more positive reinforcement that people that don’t gravitate towards that.

                            I tend to care that more of a negative perspective around it anyway, so that they’re going to fade away a little bit more and this, and every time you make a step in that direction, all of a sudden you have a different friend group or a tighter friend group, or you have a stronger relationship and, and stepping in those directions is hard.

                            That’s the workout, trying to get your behavior in alignment with being honest and being integrous and being that that takes discipline. And it’s what builds up, self-confidence just as if you’re building, you know, six pack abs.

                            How values impact insecurity

                            Matthias Barker: Wow. So it’s the [00:17:00] alignment with your values, the core, like animating features, if who you are, that’s going to be the thing that gets you in touch with a personal sense of confidence.

                            Casey Jackson: We’ll just flip the word around instead of self-confidence it’s confidence in the self. Yeah. Yeah. Wow. So you’re looking at the self as the center, instead of the behavior as the center. Um,

                            Matthias Barker: Yeah. Okay. So, well then help me understand this part of it then, because I was looking into attachment theory, just kind of like revising some of my knowledge on that, studied it in school attachment theory.

                            I work in trauma work. I do, I use it a lot of something called internal family systems, which, um, there’s lots of different trauma modalities out there, but some of them lean into a theory of attachment more than others ifs doesn’t by, um, by large measure. So it doesn’t put a lot of stock in. You know, the work of Bowlby and Ainsworth and, and conceptualizing through it through an attachment lens, it kind of has a different approach to it.

                            And so just by, um, almost circumstance, I, haven’t done tons of reading in the attachment world. [00:18:00] And so I spent like a good two or three days just diving into kind of where attachment evolved since the times of like Bowlby and Ainsworth and like the fifties and sixties. And, and what were people’s theories?

                            Where do people take this idea? And. And essentially people started adding more and more categories to it. You can have an avoidant attachment, a, uh, an anxious attachment. You can have a, an ambivalent attachment. You can have a disorganized attachment and, and you can slice and dice and put them in all sorts of different buckets, kind of however you want.

                            But maybe like the core themes of, of that theory is there’s an aspect of avoidance and there’s an aspect of anxiety and those are kind of…. I mean it’s fight or flight in some ways that might be a little simplistic, but it’s, I can, I can try to con I get really anxious and I try to control everything and I try to fit everything into this uni dimensional way of understanding it and everything has to fit within my expectations.

                            And if it doesn’t, I lose my temper. I get volitle, I get naggy. Or maybe I internalize that and I get self-critical and I get frustrated [00:19:00] and I, I get stomach aches and headaches and whatever, and, or I get avoidant. And, uh, you just don’t hear from me and I seclude and I withdraw and I Stonewall and I, I push away.

                            Um, maybe that means externalizing blame. Maybe that means just literally distracting myself from even thinking about it. And in the process also disconnecting myself from my values because the reason it’s so triggering is because it matters so much to me. So in order to get rid of the triggers in order to get rid of that feeling of insecurity, I need to get rid of all the things that I wish I was secure about..

                            And, and then I totally divorced myself from it. And then there’s this security, this, and there’s lots of developmental psychology that really liens that articulates this in a lot of sophistication, but there’s this dimension of what a secure attachment looks like is feeling securely attached. To a parental caregiver feeling a sense of confidence to be able to explore out from, so the idea of a secure base, like I have this [00:20:00] place that I can always return to, I can explore what’s novel.

                            I can explore it’s unique and different, but then I can always return back to this place where I know I’m going to be okay. So if, uh, if I encounter a stranger, I can run and always kind of hide under mom’s skirt and just kind of be, you know, right there with her. I was thinking of, because I kind of maybe approach confidence in a similar way to what we’re talking about.

                            I think of it through the lens of values and connectedness to values. And then I was thinking about it through the lens of developmental psychology in this attachment theory. And then, and that kind of dawned on me is his values for the adult person. Is it that I connect to the values and maybe you could copy and paste that same template over from, for, from a child that used to connect to my parent.

                            The secure base was my parent. The secure base was the attachment relationships that I had as a young child, as an adult, I don’t run to a parent. I am the secure base. I am the place of security. I am the place of, of, um, subtleness of groundedness. I find that in myself, um, And then the way [00:21:00] that I perhaps increase the security or solidify that security is by coming in to deeper contact with my values.

                            I know that’s a little tangential. I’m kind of bringing you into a stream of consciousness and we try and put things together.

                            Casey Jackson: Oh God, I just got my oar in my kayak and I’m totally in that stream with you. So you’re doing good.

                            John Gilbert: I’m just ready to get into the flow, but I’ll wait.

                            You respond Casey. And then at some point I’m going to jump into here Matthias and so very articulate and so intelligent and so interesting all at the same time. I’ll comment in a second Casey.

                            Matthias Barker: Oh, that’s, that’s kind of to say I was worried that it was just completely tangential in nonsensical, but that’s, that’s my like free association.

                            I’m trying to like, what are the common themes here? What’s the, what’s the common thread that all these different theories are trying to say. And I guess that’s what I’m trying to zero in on what comes to mind for you?

                            Casey Jackson: There there’s two overarching thoughts that I have when you were talking about. One, is it just fascinating to me because I think of in my own evolution as professionally [00:22:00] from being so psychotherapeutic to shift into more of a solution focused perspective and not because it was this huge shift in fundamental model, I think it’s just that you can spend so much time trying to uncover like years and years, working with people and uncovering all these different insecurities and, and sources and trauma there’s value in that.

                            And I think after years of doing that, what I saw for some people is it didn’t mean that they felt like there were any more comfortable in their own body, just because they understood themselves better and try to do that restorative things. And he was CBT and DBT and EMDR are all great. Evidence-based interventions.

                            Empowerment and building confidence

                            There’s something from an empowerment of who do you want to be and moving in that direction today forward. Because that’s what we have control over instead of focusing on the past or the things that so, and I believe heavily in having accurate assessments. So knowing those things and where the sources are really critical for the repairative side of it.

                            So there’s that one side of things, but when you’re doing the whole thing about attachment and going back to, you know, your source and center to the [00:23:00] base, I think with that totally tangential or stream of consciousness is I think it’s also. If you can’t run back to your parents and as an adult, you’re running back to yourself and that your source and center, I think it’s also an evolution from a Maslow’s or whatever we want to look at.

                            It’s also where we go to a spiritual perspective too, is what is not going to fail. My spouse could fail me. My friends could fail me. They could tell me no, they could, they could reject me, but where do you find a source? And some of that doesn’t, if you don’t have that source and center within yourself, Or a source and center that’s above yourself.

                            You could be in for a world of hurt. You’re going to have a lot of insecurity because the ground, you will never have. Terrafirma the ground will always shift depending on which social structures individually or collectively you’re trying to gravitate towards and they will let you down. It’s just, it’s impossible for human beings to be perfect. They are going to be imperfect. They’re going to let us down. And if we don’t have a source and center, there’s going to be some extremely excruciating zingers that hit you, [00:24:00] that are going to kind of crumble your security. Um, if that source and center either individually for yourself or, you know, above yourself, if those things, if you don’t have a solid foundation in that, our connection to that, you can just see where we’re insecurity is going to flourish.

                            Matthias Barker: Well, and so you’re saying it has to be a, like a transcendent value. Not, it’s not based on. Something like, how do I put it? I, cause I like what you’re saying. So like the idea of being honest, I sometimes am honest. I sometimes am dishonest, but my value for being honest is stable regardless of my performance of it.

                            The value. Yes. Right? Yes. And so that’s, that’s the security, my security isn’t in my ability to stay honest. And then when I’m dishonest, I’m crumbled. It’s no, I have this principle. I have this transcendent value. I have this thing that I desire to live by that is authentically connected to what I want to see in the world and in myself that when all else fails, when I’m insecure, when everything around me is when there’s a [00:25:00] crisis, you know, I lean into this secure base of principles or values something transcendent to then ground myself to know what to do next.

                            Does that, is that what you’re saying?

                            Casey Jackson: Yeah, because I think what it is there is then you have, you have a book or you have, uh, an instruction sheet to go back to instead of if somebody sends you an entire kit and there’s no instruction. It’s like, oh, I didn’t put the washer in where I supposed to and I’ve got it in the wrong.

                            I put a into C instead of a and to B it’s like, oh, okay. So it’s not insecurity. I, I messed up. I can go back and I can correct that. So it’s not about me. It’s about, I can reconnect this. I can get back on course, but we have to have that in. We have to have that base to go back to, or, or somewhere where there.

                            Uh, clarity and basic structure. You were either honest or not honest, what’s going to come down is either going to make excuses and blame for it, or you’re going to say right that situation. I was nervous about telling the truth. So that’s why I, wasn’t completely honest [00:26:00] then it’s like, well, why were you nervous about telling the truth, but I didn’t want to hurt their feelings, but what is that about?

                            I think that I think is worth exploring because what it is is I don’t feel like I’m being as honest as I want to be. And I want to be somebody that can be honest and it’s all of a sudden it gets into this. Okay. Let’s be clear. Well, this goes into, so I’m going to throw one more thing out there, cause this is when they go there.

                            John and I…

                            John Gilbert: And then I’ve got to jump in at some point and I want to contribute to this insane. How many directions this could go.

                            Matthias Barker: We’re swimming around in the weeds here.

                            Casey Jackson: John and I used to travel a lot together and we get into these, you know, late night deep conversations about all these things. And one of the things when he and I had this significant period of time where we were just not meshing, we just weren’t getting along well, um, professional, we’re doing fine, but just personally, we’re just having a rough go of it.

                            And we were just, and we both have so much integrity and trying to run it through our core values. Where is the conflict coming from here? And to this day, it’s been one of the most profound conversations for me about [00:27:00] myself. Because we both live off that whole focus mountain construct, like, okay, let’s go to the values.

                            Let’s go to the values. Let’s get out of the tree. Let’s go to the values. And it was fascinating because what it came down to is John and I were both talking about, but I have integrity. And he said, but I have integrity. I’m like, but I have integrity. And it’s like, but we believe in being honest. And it’s like, I believe in being honest too.

                            And when it came down to, is that the way that I live my life and my source and center is between hurting someone. Um, or if I know it’s going to do damage. There’s a, what is integrity around that? And John was like, I’m going to be honest for me. That’s being integrous. And for me, what it came down to is part of integrity for me is, is maintaining connection.

                            So John’s kind of combination for his operating mode was not only just integrity, but he has to be honest, about that. And for me, it was about integrity, but maintaining sense of connection because I value connection so much. So it was like, oh, then when you look through both of the drivers of that, that moral [00:28:00] compass for each one of us, like that makes sense.

                            And then there’s no harm, no foul. It’s like, Hey, I get why you’re going to be completely honest. Even if it does damage the connection, because that’s what integrity is for you. For me, integrity is I’m not going to do damage to connections. Uh, you know, in all sacrifice, uh, honestly, to an extent, not abandon it, but if I know it’s going to do long-term damage and it was just like, no one is how can it either one of us be wrong in those situations.

                            That’s just our core. And the fact that we both knew our base so well of who we were, it just was like, it became not personal any longer. It was just like, I just kind of that I honor and respect that is how do you argue with somebody that they know that that’s their core of who they are? I, I will live by honesty and I’m gonna live by integrity.

                            Matthias Barker: Well then what’s the protective feature. What’s what protects against just kind of rushing into these almost static expressions of values. So for example, like the idea of like me being honest, me being integrous means me always speaking, what I think is true. Like there’s [00:29:00] certain contexts where that makes sense in certain contexts where people are just gonna be like, Hey, no one asks you, bud.

                            You know, versus me, I’m protecting the, you know, the collaboration of the group and people’s feelings being an integral thing, but there’s times you need to set a boundary or step in. So what, what protects against falling into these really rigid? My value can only be expressed in this one dimensional way.

                            John Gilbert: There’s so many, so much here. So many layers of lacquer to just go back and just keep going deeper and deeper. So first to respond to that piece of it, from what I have learned so far is the depth and so much more, we have to, uh, discover and practice and, get into practical ways of being with emotional intelligence and what that encompasses is a wide degree of all sorts of managing of our own emotions, to having accurate [00:30:00] emotional, cognitive Impathics empathy with empathic concern, to all these areas.

                            And it appears in my life experience that it might be, that different people due to their life experiences, be it adverse childhood experiences or things that you are working with, people with traumas related to sexual experiences or whatever it is that that becomes impaired and, or just affected in a more neutral way and affecting creates an ease or a lack of ease in being aware in these ways where context really shapes decisions. Different people based off of belief systems and culture and that Daniel Conaman and other people through various research and books will point us that we are so shaped by our context. And the things around us that we don’t even realize that. Right? So to me at a certain [00:31:00] point, yes, let’s get practical and powerful around helping people get clear about core values and what matters between what at a certain point to your point, our context, our culture, and the context of the situation is going to change how we express those things.

                            And then at a certain point, there’s so many other things you were talking about of am I now clear about what I really care about and I’m being proactive or am I being reactive? And for those that like to associate with being intuitive, they having a various experience in that world. They will come from a place of my reaction is my intuition and scientifically speaking, if you practice something and get immediate feedback like in social settings, right? It’s a higher likelihood, your intuition attunes with some emotional intelligence, unless maybe that [00:32:00] is not as calibrated or something, and then it comes into this whole, well, how do you feel more confidence? Well, one way is to blame outside the self and another way is to go, I’m amazing. And what a concept of many notes I’ve been taking that there’s no way in one fell swoop. I’m going to get to all of them now, but some of them. Like what Dr. William Miller brought up at one of the, um, motivational interviewing network of trainers conference, which was this wonderful, simple depiction that YouTube has psychology focused might know very well, but just this Venn diagram where I have two circles out here with my left hand on my right hand. When you’re severely depressed, your sense of who you wish to be, or how you want to be in the world is way over here, way to the left. And then how you see yourself related to that is way distant from that. And it’s this severe sense of depression. And so off from, from your sense of how you want to be in the world or feeling of the world or something like that.[00:33:00]

                            And then when they come together and you align them one in front of the other, like this, now once they’re completely aligned, that’s where you likely get Machiavellianism or, or sociopathy or narcissism where there’s absolute alignment and nothing wrong at all. And then to be in this range of a little bit discomforted and a little bit aligned in the ways we might say in this conversation with values that is, not just normal, that can be healthy. And that paradox of we’re never perfect. Each one of us here is never perfect. And we are always going to feel some level of discomfort is to me what wisdom traditions be a Buddhism or otherwise are tapping into this potential consistent suffering. If you go there.

                            So how do you not suffer? And. Not put the power outside of yourself and take the ability to respond and take [00:34:00] responsibility, but also not let that destroy you. And how do you construct and produce and become and blossom while also recognizing you’re flawed and that you’re trying. That to me is where I don’t know the answer.

                            I think that MI comes in motivational interviewing. I think ifs is incredible. We haven’t talked about acceptance commitment therapy and how that deals with values because that’s very much about values alignment. I have a big bias on how we talk about values. The context, the culture informs all our beliefs and then how we are our ability to assess the situation now is impacted by our life experiences, trauma included. Now then comes the clarity from within and now comes the comfort of who you really are as a flawed individual that really cares and is trying. And now how comfort can you be in that? Well, you got to focus on your way of being versus what you’re seeing [00:35:00] or what you’re having. And our culture is not doing well about our way of being with people and there’s people in the theory of, oh, and enchantment is a new thing coming out about the theory of enchantment is becoming more popular about diversity in corporations, because it’s about this, this way of being in the world.

                            Not about skin color as much and genders it’s about how you are with people and how they are with you. And it’s in enchanting, which is why they call it that way. Then there’s other things. Then it’ll shut up about things you tapped into about meaning about discipline. And this is why things like Jordan Peterson to people like that are becoming more popular, I believe is it gets into union psychology about there’s a place to just, go, gosh, you know what, let me clean up my room and that’s really unfair and hard for someone that’s been through trauma or disenfranchised to say that. Right. So how do you empower someone in a really crappy situation that there [00:36:00] seems to be a thread of truth? No matter the context though, to empower yourself. And whatever that thread is through some sort of empowerment we can do in society through some kind of support for it, through some kind of therapy.

                            That’s what I want to contribute to is whatever we’re talking about right now, because it seems to bring the power back to every individual. No matter your context, no matter your life experience. So that’s my little bit.

                            Matthias Barker: Oh John,. That was so good. Gosh. Yeah. You, you were sitting on a gold mine the whole time.

                             I had like 10 things pop in my head as you’re, as you’re going through that. Here’s, here’s one thing that stood out, especially it was this relationship between personal responsibility, feeling empowered to like make change and make, um, advances towards what I value and what I want while also, doing so from a place of acceptance and maybe, maybe this is more of a question than a summary it’s there, there seems to be the, the conflict, the paradox, [00:37:00] as you were explaining it there, what popped up for me was how do I move towards what’s valuable, accept that I’m not there yet, but still get in contact with it in the present.

                            Um, without then maybe spinning off into a lot of, self-deprecating criticism, which then ironically undercuts my motivation. So put another way if I want to feel more confident, like I have these values, these core parts of me that I really want to move towards and maybe the more in contact with that, I get the more confident I’m going to feel.

                            But then I also noticed the deficit. I noticed the gap between who I am now, how I’m acting now and how I wish I was acting. And then there’s an implicit shame in that there’s an implicit guilt that I feel when I notice all the ways I’m not being dishonest. And then we can say, well, okay, let’s take personal responsibility.

                            And, and instead of avoiding, instead of externalizing the blame, instead of just giving excuses for why the status quo is what it is, um, You know, I’m gonna, [00:38:00] I’m going to own it and then move forward in that. But there’s this huge boundary of shame and guilt and feeling how, on a small, in the face of that, what, what comes up for you in that?

                            Casey Jackson: It’s interesting when you say that, because they, I think it’s just as we work on ourselves, like, I know what I’ve worked on myself over the years, how that does shift. How, for me, it shifted as what I’ll say, ’cause when I see those, when I get the assessment information, there’s times that the shame or guilt that can come up, but more often than not.

                            And I, it may be an age thing. It may be just as what I try to evolve. Is it, it’s more of an assessment. And knowing, how far I’ve come and that, oh, now I’ve got an idea of where I want to go. Um, and it doesn’t bring up the shame and guilt that he used to bring up. Now, for me, it’s just like an assessment of going, oh, you fell short there.

                            Oh, this is what I need to do to try to get to the next level of that. Um, and I don’t get bogged down in historically what I could have with the insecurity or depression or, or, [00:39:00] um, you know, shame. Now it just, the narrative just seems to be. It’s kind of the vision board part side of it. It’s just like, I am so blessed.

                            There’s nothing for me to feel guilty or shameful, as long as I’m contributing and being who I believe myself to be. It just it’s motive for me to keep moving in that direction because it just seems like every time I take a step in that direction, It becomes self-reinforcing. So it’s not the digging into why I didn’t do it right. It’s like, oh, that’s not who I want to be. Now I want to correct and move to who I want to be. This is the whole thing I was saying earlier with how to increase this confidence versus always going, God, I screwed up again. Oh God, I screwed up again. I’m so stupid. I’m so bad.

                            I’m so dumb. So, you know, all those narratives, it’s more like, oh, this is an opportunity for growth. Oh, this stopped pay for growth. Oh, I’ve got some afford to put further. Wow. Look how far I’ve come. There’s just a, a narrative shift that happens. And I haven’t deconstructed enough just to know that just experientially the difference between the way I was when I was younger.

                            And, and just from just the years [00:40:00] of being immersed in these things that you’re talking about, you know, you and I both just, you know, John, just, we get versed in this stuff. It’s so obsessive that I just want to keep staying on that path. The last thing I want to throw out there as well too, is that. I keep going back to the social reality thing.

                            And I don’t want to, over-generalize like to an indigenous perspective, but I think in the absence of all of these swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe until I go to bed and then wake up and swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe. From the moment I get up, that’s not an indigenous perspective.

                            How can you have security when you’re swiping all day long? Swiping so many reference points to find, okay, that’s not, that’s not satiating me. . Okay. That, that satiated me for 10 seconds. Wow. That’s a good data point that satiated for 10 seconds, let’s give them more of that to satiated them for 10 seconds, because it didn’t say satiate for one second.

                            And that is the antithesis of an indigenous perspective.[00:41:00] When you’re just sitting there for an hour, waiting for an animal to go by, um, and just being so concentrated on those things around you and being so in touch with your environment, we are living the antithesis of that. We’re not even touching.

                            We, we, we get perilously close without me being nihilistic. We get perilously close to being plugged in like the matrix, like literally we are plugged in and we were powering something that is not us. It is not power. It’s powering data sources. It’s, it’s powering all sorts of things, but it sure as hell is not powering us.

                            It’s disempowering us. The more we’re sucked into all of these stimulators around us, we become less in touch. How can you be secure in that environment? I mean, it just, the metrics of it wouldn’t make sense of how you can be secure in such an insecure swipe, left everyone second environment, because you are disclosing.

                            And that environment you are disposable.

                            John Gilbert: And to me, that there’s, there’s so much [00:42:00] that, uh, I enjoy about speaking about the matrix in society. And I think the math of sorts or the physics, uh, you brought up of that, that we might call philosophy. But I think that I align with that so much, Casey, that it creates a context in which is more difficult.

                            To feel secure or confident in healthy, we might say non narcissistic way yet at the same time, it kind of pushes us in one direction or the other as much. Uh, immediate kind of thought to that because now we’re constantly comparing ourselves to other people and just, I mean, I’m going to get involved in this competition.

                            I just signed up for, uh, on Saturday dealing with, uh, swinging around a bunch of bars and stuff, and it’s going to be fun. I’m going to be a big little kid. It’s going to be great. And there’s people there that are going to crush me. And I am not used to that in sports, like to just, you [00:43:00] know, like that’s been so much of my life.

                            And so. How much is it about, let me post on here, let me be seen as this. Let me get to see, so I can be seen and all that stuff. Versus as you know, Casey you said to me many years ago, that was really helpful of like, how much am I, being about life versus documenting it.

                            And I’ve kind of gone on one side of the spectrum that maybe I need to focus on documenting and connecting with people in certain ways more. But the idea is that there’s so much about documenting, and creating a living through how you appear and the psychological way that, that gets perpetuated, that then gets inspiring to other people, but then it inspires them in a particular way of being seen and how I’m seen and how I’m looked at versus how I am.

                            And that brings me back to Casey, a point of what you were bringing up of. How would, you know if you’re a (mumbling). And this is [00:44:00] to me all the more important regarding humility and curiosity and openness and different personality traits. According to personalities, you know, different kinds of the big five and all that stuff, you can be more open or less open.

                            So that’s going to matter too, but there seems to be a there there about remaining open or at least semi humble that maybe I could be wrong with the feedback that I’m perceiving. And that’s, what’s so much of the scientific method is about, is proving your hypothesis wrong and seeking feedback from this place of equipoise equal position, and really trying to recognize maybe I could be wrong and that’s uncomfortable.

                            And how do I use that constructively and productively to be more of who I want to be in a non stagnation way that justifies, you know, what I’ve done or blames [00:45:00] outside the self, that is so hard. That I don’t have the answer other than the privileged few that can maybe get therapy or something, but like, especially for the, the populations of people that need it most, I don’t know, but there’s, there’s a, there, there, which is why I think last but not least here, there’s a certain bias we’re always bringing to the table, that’s going to justify or perpetuate shame, which can be healthy in certain ways. There’s a whole book called shame that came out the other year on that. But the idea is, does it help us align with more of who we want to be, or does it justify decisions in ways that maybe don’t.

                            And maybe I’m a grandizing growth, right? Maybe growth is not always better. There’s a whole conversation we had around that. But I do think to wrap this back around that it’s a) about improving to some degree, which is a grandizing growth to some degree versus proving. So instead of proving, it’s about improving.

                            And [00:46:00] then there’s something also about, I believe was psychedelic therapy and things are becoming more of a thing for people because it seems to be tapping into this, whatever that experience, that way of being an experienced. Whatever you could put a belief system on it. You don’t have to put a belief system on it, whatever that is, seems to be a they’re there for what people are now experiencing.

                            Be it. In assisted with, the maps group and MTMA assisted therapy. Be it very ketamine, be it psilocybin, be it the sound bass that can combine all this there. And that does tend to be a more higher socioeconomic. So I don’t think that’s the answer and it could actually create separation, but I do think there’s a, there, there that people are experiencing that we’re talking about for what is your self.

                            Who are you really? And what are you really trying to be with people? How are you trying to be with people in the world? To me, whatever we’re talking [00:47:00] about is pointing us to some sort of experiential thing. That’s not, uh, yeah, we can answer right on. And,

                            Casey Jackson: And/or what I would say, John, because everything is.

                            Is a way to block out all of the other noise, whether you’re talking about the drug, whether you’re talking about any of those interventions, or are you talking about the sound room? What most of that is, is blocking out all of the chaos. It’s trying to, it’s trying to get you focused away from that. So, so it could be and/or.

                            As far as, you know, you know, sparking something in your brain to go that direction. But I think in so many ways, what it is, is just trying to block all this massive amount of stimulus outside of us, that we are we’re habituating to that it’s just not healthy. And you look at any one of those interventions is listed and most of that is like, it literally suspends you from all of that and gives you a space where you’re suspended out of that zone.

                            Matthias Barker: Yeah. Yeah. And you brought up act earlier. This was, something I was really trying to figure out through [00:48:00] the lens of act for awhile too, because there’s the fusion to a, um, to a thought that in the way the act would conceptualize it is your fuse to a thought. And what it’s doing is it’s shutting down your openness to, to viewing other factors in the environment that might be informing you.

                            Something that might be more adaptive. Um, so I’m insecure. I suck on first dates. You’re on the first date, all you’re thinking about are all the ways that you’re probably coming off weird. You’re not noticing she’s actually having a great time. And so, uh, you’re you’re so self-conscious about coming off funny or coming off charming.

                            They actually start to come off a little bit self-absorbed and then. You know, the date goes terrible. Not because you’re anything terrible, but because you were just being so fused to this idea that it’s going to go terrible, unless I just like mingle it and get it under my control, but it was, it’s like a self-fulfilling prophecy.

                            Right? So there’s this, there’s this sequence of function that I think, especially in relational frame theory, they do a really good job at explicated . I got to [00:49:00] do supervision under Matthew Valette for two years. He’s a, he’s an expert in relational frame theory wrote the book, mastering the clinical conversation.

                            And I got to talk to Steve Hayes about this, like on a podcast once too. And the thing I was trying to drill down for both of these guys on, um, was how do you know what the values are? And it’s like, because it’s not, it doesn’t feel obvious when you have like this intrusive thought. Um, or when you have, you know, any sort of thought for that matter, which ones I’m like fused onto.

                            And I actually need to have more flexibility around or like which thoughts, um, are actually grounded to this like essential nature of who I am. And I need to explore with more detail and like what’s, what’s the chaos. And then what’s the, the soft voice underneath that has like the essential wise true quality..

                            That, that for me, it’s just been so hard to narrow down on or to explain well, but, and then, and, and they, they probably had great answers to [00:50:00] that. I don’t want to mischaracterize, like they don’t have an answer to that. They have their answers to that. But the answer that I actually found to be most that resonated with me personally was actually the, an answer I got from Frank Anderson.

                            Who’s the lead trainer for ifs. And he said, it’s like, you can feel it in the energy. And that’s such a, non-science the word that I just didn’t like, but there was something about it. That was true because. Like, I was like, how do you categorize where the values are at? And what’s what’s right. And true. And we could, we could put all these positive, you know, adjectives on it.

                            It’s the compassionate self. It’s the, um, it’s the aligned and the calm, the, uh, the caring self it’s, it’s the, that’s a part of you that does this. The party does that, but there’s just this energy that they call it an ifs, self energy, which feels like such a foofy word . But I, I feel it it’s like when you’re in the room, there’s this resonance with like something that’s true and something that is grounded, not in fear and not in a positioning and performing and [00:51:00] managing. It’s not this tight fisted thing. It’s like the confidence in there is in there and it just releases and it’s stabilized in this moment. Sometimes it’s an aha moment. Sometimes it’s it’s when you share a story from your childhood and you realize something you’ve been doing is connected to a wound from your past.

                            Um, and then I brought that to Matthew and I was, I was telling him, I’m like, Hey, what do you think about this idea of like this self-energy thing? And then he’s like, yeah . That’s right in line. We’re just describing it in different ways. And, um, it’s this centeredness in on what matters most to you.

                            And I guess the reason is so hard to nail that down is because it’s different for different people. And then, like you said, John, it’s, there’s a, there’s a cultural factor to that that is deeply ingrained as well. Um, that we’re not always aware of, but, but we can feel it and we can sense it. And then we start getting into like spiritual and theological categories to try to describe it.

                            And then that’s where psychedelics feel like they bring us a little bit closer to it and it’s, [00:52:00] um, Yeah. So to bookend it, like, how do you, what do you do about insecurity? It’s like you get in touch with this transcendent self energy thing that, that you, uh, let’s connect it to your values and organizes your behavior.

                            It’s like, how do I get to that? And you’re like, well, we have a bunch of different ways to describe how to get to that. But ultimately your path is going to look different than mine. And, and, uh, and that’s why I like Motivational Interviewing, because Motivatonal Interviewing doesn’t pretend to have the answer to that question. It’s not, it’s not listen to my advice.

                            I’m the guide. I’m the sham. And that will bring you to the values. It’s, it’s just, I’m going to hold up a mirror and I’m going to reflect the crap out of this session until you discover it yourself. I mean, it’s a crude way to put it, but yeah.

                            Casey Jackson: And then the thing I think of when you say that the, the quote that resonates with me is from Dr.

                            Moyer is Dr. Theresa Moyer is, is, you know, there’s definitely more than one, right way. And when you think of the peak of a mountain, there’s definitely more than one right way to get to the peak of the [00:53:00] mountain. There’s all sorts of ways. And some people are more skilled than others of getting to the top of the mountain, but there’s definitely more than one right way.

                            And there there’s something empowering about that construct as well, too, as long as you don’t feel like you’re tripping and it’s dark and you’re hurt and crying and lost, then that’s not fun. Um, but yeah, knowing that there is a right way to get up there, there’s more than one right way I think is pretty potent.

                            John Gilbert: Yeah, because I got to get one more Motivational Interviewing thing in there is that MI communicates, you know, you have answers within you that are worth discovering. And I think you could add some different words that however you wanted to, but I think that’s the power in which we’re talking about. That if you can provide that container for someone, a friend, anyone that there are insights within people that are worth discovering and motivational interviewing is one way to do it.

                            That the power of that is the discovery of getting more confident and secure within yourself. If you [00:54:00] can feel safe enough to do so with someone and you can be that for someone and the power and the simplicity, but the significance of that, I just cannot emphasize enough. And I can’t emphasize Matthias, I really want to have you back and have more conversation. This is so amazing on so many levels. I really, as always appreciate getting the opportunity to geek out with, uh, Casey. I just have a little bit more access to that from time to time now, uh, versus you and your perspective with all you’ve researched is clearly so deep and rich has a depth and a breadth, and really, really would appreciate having you back on and even, you know, if we don’t, uh, you’ve really expanded my mind a lot here and hopefully the people that have listened to this too.

                            So thank you. And I just want to give you the opportunity for. Anything we haven’t asked or anything else you’d like to add. And then also where people can find all the wonderful work you were talking about, uh, with your conversations or contact or anything else. [00:55:00]

                            Matthias Barker: Um, well thank you. That’s so kind. I would love to come back.

                            Absolutely. I feel like we just got warmed up. Like we, like, we opened a lot of threads and I think created more questions than answers, but like, I guess I’m just appreciative that you guys, uh, went on this kind of trail with me. I think this is. This is part of like the reality. I think even isn’t when I talk to quote unquote experts in their fields is there’s, there’s all these kinds of spaces where we’re starting to get close and touch the substance of something really real and really true.

                            But there’s so much mystery and maybe that’s what invigorates us in this field. And that’s what keeps pushing us as clinicians is it’s almost like when we solidify down on all the answers, something gets stale and something gets, you uni dimensional but when. Kind of get tangential and run around.

                            And what about this and what about that and how does this intersect with that? And what about this theory and how does that blend? And it just, it almost comes alive for me. It feels alive for someone listening. Maybe they’re like, I don’t know what the heck these guys are talking about. I don’t know. It’s a, so [00:56:00] this has been energizing for me and really helped me explore this topic because I never want to just zero in and be like, oh, I got this insecurity.

                            Nailed it. I think there’s, there’s a lot that I took away from this. I’m really thankful. Um, as far as my stuff. Yeah, I do. Um, I do different workshops on different topics in mental health. It’s just, they’re just kind of meant for just kind of your regular person wanting to kind of improve their relationship or work through, um, emotional winds in the past.

                            So it’s not like clinician training or anything like these, these, uh, um, you know, intelligent gentlemen here. Uh, it’s just kind of for your everyday guy. Or gal and, um, and then I, I have some free eBooks on online, around grief, um, around burnout. Uh, I have tons of posts on Instagram and tick talk and have a podcast.

                            So I don’t know, I’m just kind of everywhere on social media, doing whatever that platform is doing. Just look up Matthias Barker, there’s not many of them.

                            John Gilbert: I was going to say what’s your handle..

                            Matthias Barker: Yeah. Matthias Jay Barker. If you search Mathias, you borrow. Just about anywhere. You’ll see. You’ll see up to somewhere. Yeah. [00:57:00] Thank you again on I echo, I just feel like this needs to be at some regular interval that we, that we get a chance to touch base.

                            Cause it just, it, it helps my brain grow and, and just overstimulates it, which I just love, love, love, love, love. So I just appreciate it so much for taking time to do this with us. Yeah. This is so fun. Thank you so much. Thanks guys. All right. We’ll sign off. Take care everyone. Bye bye-bye. Thank you for listening to the communication solution podcast.

                            As always. This podcast is all about you. So if you have questions, thoughts, topics, suggestions, ideas, please send them our way at [email protected]. That’s [email protected]. For more resources, feel free to check out IFIOC.com. We also have a public Facebook group called motivational interviewing every day.

                            We have an amazing blog and we have lots of communication tips on our website. In addition to all these amazing resources [00:58:00] we do offer online public courses, on our website on motivational interviewing and effective communication strategies. Thanks for listening to the communication solution by IFIOC.

                            Want to learn more about building confidence and affirmations?

                            Check out our Introduction to Motivational Interviewing class!

                            Want to learn more about affirmations?

                            Check out this #MIminute on affirmations

                            59 min

                          About The Communication Solution

                          From the publisher's feed

                          Changing the way we see communication. Teaching evidence based communication skills.