On the Season 4 finale of Untoasted, Peach and Meyer discuss the 2015 film Mr. Right starring Sam Rockwell and Anna Kendrick. They also talk about a Butler family reunion, a set-up, and living a double life as an assassin. 

On this special Thanksgiving edition, Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including taking a pop quiz, curds in the third, and the new segment: "Dave and his Uber Drivers". 

Peach and Meyer discuss the 1992 comedy Mr. Saturday Night starring Billy Crystal and David Paymer. They also talk about David Letterman, one-liners, and a trip to New York. 

Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including a dire situation, Steely Dan, and the streaming wars. 

Peach and Meyer discuss the 1973 film Jonathan Livingston Seagull starring James Franciscus and Juliet Mills. They also talk about lawsuits, expensive real estate, and the life of a seagull. 

Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including the Starland Vocal Band, Curt Cignetti, and the going on the plane ride home. 

Peach and Meyer discuss the 1988 rom-com Cocktail starring Tom Cruise and Elisabeth Shue. They also talk about Tom's real name, the life of a bartender, and being trapped in Jamaica. 

Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary including eggcorns, Kevin Harlan, and Cheez-It Pizzas. 

Peach and Meyer discuss the 1988 comedy Tucker: The Man and His Dream starring Jeff Bridges and Joan Allen. They also talk about the Tucker Torpedo, an Indy 500 tie-in, and Quantum Leap.

Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including getting censored, tearing the playhouse down, and sports movies.