This is a wonderfully constructed chapter by Paul. It addresses an issue that I think many people hold up as being ‘the issue’ when they try to make the argument against faith. It addresses this issue at several angles.
So here it is in 2 forms:
Does God really call himself fair and send people who have never heard of him to hell, just because they don’t believe in the whole resurrection thing? I mean, what if they’ve never heard of Jesus...that doesn’t seem right.
I can’t get on-board with a God that treats everyone according to Grace...some people are better than others.Both of these arguments come from a place that seems well-intentioned, and they are, at first glance, reasonable positions to take. But, Paul addresses them bluntly and simply. Later in Romans, Paul actually circles back to this same idea and addresses this in a more empathetic fashion, expressing a level of understanding in why someone would make this argument. Here though, the blunt reality is that if you and I get to make a decision. God gave us over to sin in chapter 1, allowing us to decide to love the moment and indulge in unproductive behavior or love ourselves and our neighbors and Him and discipline ourselves to find and follow our real purpose. We get the choice. And, similarly, we can choose, here in chapter 2, whether we want to be judged by the law or by grace. If we use the law to judge others, seeing other’s sins against the backdrop of the law rather than against the backdrop of God’s grace, so be it to us. Now, in reality, we aren’t really a judge of anything, because we have no say over where people will spend their eternity, and whether or not they will have relationship with God, so we aren’t really judging anything...we are simply putting on goggles through which we see the world...and if we choose to see the world through lense of the law, Paul is telling us that God will choose to see our lives and our sin through the same set of goggles. BUT, if we choose grace, if we choose Jesus, if we choose to be forgiven in God’s eyes, we dawn the goggles of Grace and we see ourselves as saved by faith, saved by Grace, and we see others in the same vein - then God will look upon us likewise. It is up to us.
I have heard it said that most of us tend to want to view Grace like we view an air-freshener. It is something we hold in our hands and that we spray in the direction of the things we don’t want to have to deal with. Something smells over there - spray, solved. Over there, spray, solved. The thing is, WE are holding the air-freshener in this analogy...not God. Once we take the air-freshener out of our hands and we ask the question, do you want God to spray you to clean you, or do you want Him to erase you when you create some stink, it becomes a little easier to get at the right mindset. And some will say, “Well, I know I stink a little...but those people over there REALLY stink.” “To which God would respond...I am not talking about those people, I am talking about you. Stink is stink...you are either erased or sprayed...you choose.”
That’s one of the main areas of struggle, comparison. God didn’t send Jesus as a ruler, in terms of a measure stick. Jesus wasn’t here to help us all figure out how we stack up...he was here to show us that we don’t, that we can’t, and that we need to play a different game. We need to accept Grace, forget the comparison game, and we need to follow where God is leading. It’s just that simple.