The Debate

The Debate

By FRANCE 24 English
Download on the App Store

The Debate episodes

  • The fall of El-Fasher: A turning point in Sudan's brutal civil war?

    First it was a revolution confiscated, then a dispute between coup leaders that became a civil war. Three years on, Sudan is wondering if the fall of a key city in the western Darfur region is the cue for a second partition of the country. The massacre of civilians in Darfur is drawing comparisons with the genocide there two decades ago. That’s hardly surprising as the paramilitary leader who led the 18-month siege of El-Fasher is the same Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo – aka General Hemedti – who was an instrumental leader of the notorious Janjaweed militias that operated in Darfur under deposed dictator Omar al-Bashir.

    We ask if Hemedti, himself a Darfuri, wants a South Sudan-style break with Khartoum or to take the whole of the country with help from his Emirati backers. 

    Human rights monitors accuse both sides of war crimes. The forces of General Abdel Fattah al-Burhan also have their foreign backers. Who, then, can stop what's currently the world's bloodiest conflict, where the overwhelming majority of casualties are civilians?

    Read moreWarnings of executions and ethnic cleansing mount in Sudan's El-Fasher

    Produced by François Picard, Charles Wente, Rebecca Gnignati, Riham Mahir & Jean-Vincent Russo

    44 min
  • Trump backing boosts Milei in midterm elections: An offer Argentina couldn't refuse?

    "Speak softly and carry a big stick." That was US President Theodore Roosevelt's adage to stake out Washington's turf in the Americas. More than a century on, it's being evoked by some after an upset win in Argentina's midterm elections by a close ally of the current occupant of the White House. Only Donald Trump didn't speak softly. He bluntly warned that rejection of the party of far-right libertarian Javier Milei would imperil Washington's $20 billion lifeline for a peso that's teetering.

    We ask about Javier Milei's victory, his bid to dismantle the state spending system of his predecessors, whether this result is enough to save a currency that's somehow never very far from its next crisis, and whether Washington owns what happens next in Argentina, Latin America's third-largest economy.

    On that score, what lessons can be drawn for regional rivals Brazil and Colombia, where a left-wing leader finds himself cut off from US aid and with US navy ships blowing up alleged drug trafficking vessels off his shores?

    Produced by François Picard, Charles Wente, Rebecca Gnignati, Guillaume Gougeon & Jean-Vincent Russo

    44 min
  • When does Putin feel the pinch?

    It has been a long seven days — even by Russia-Ukraine standards.

    Last week at this time, the talk was of Tomahawk cruise missiles. But instead of delivering missiles, Donald Trump gave a closed-door earful at the White House to Volodymyr Zelensky. Then came talk of a mano à mano U.S.–Russia summit in Budapest.

     

    Now the tide has turned again. No summit—just U.S. sanctions on Russia’s top two oil companies, an announcement coinciding with China and India reviewing their orders of Russian imports and the price of crude is soaring.

    Why the sudden about-face?

    And is Vladimir Putin actually feeling the pinch? Ordinary Russians are grappling with inflation and shortages, a well-documented reality. But do the elites of Moscow and Saint Petersburg even realize they are under economic pressure? We’ll ask about the current mindset there.

    Finally, on the frontlines, Europe’s bloodiest war in living memory continues to grind on, accompanied by a steady stream of populist rhetoric and nuclear threats.

     

     

    Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Ilayda Habip and Daniel Whittington

    44 min
  • France's Heist of the Century

    The Louvre is reopening for the first time since Sunday’s heist of the century. We will follow leads in a daylight robbery now estimated at 88 million euros and check security at the world’s most visited museum.

    For now, the shuttering on the getaway window looks as tenuous as the standing of under-pressure authorities, the president of the Louvre answering earlier to a French senate panel said.

    Beyond security lapses, is the 800-year-old fortress-turned-palace-turned museum simply too big to deal with the age of overtourism and shrinking public funding?

    And after the 2019 fire at Notre Dame Cathedral, it is another cherished landmark making world news for all the wrong reasons. How much can a jewelry caper fuel the general feeling of citizens that they are being ripped off by elected leaders who do not deliver?

     

     

    Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Ilayda Habip and Daniel Whittington

    44 min
  • Nicolas Sarkozy behind bars: Is jail time justified for former French president?

    Sometimes former presidents do go to jail. Nicolas Sarkozy has begun his five-year sentence over the illicit financing of his 2007 presidential campaign by Muammar Gaddafi’s Libya. Is this proof that justice is truly blind? Or, as his supporters contend, are we seeing revenge by magistrates who were often maligned by the 70-year-old conservative when he was in power? France is split on that debate.

    Meanwhile, Emmanuel Macron welcomed Sarkozy to the presidential palace last week ahead of his incarceration and his justice minister says he'll go visit the former leader at Paris's La Santé prison. So does jailing a former head of state really erode faith in institutions, which are already put to the test with the current showdown between a lame-duck president and a splintered parliament?

    Or should it be about the facts of the case, the dealings with Gaddafi and his head of intelligence Abdullah Senussi, seen as the mastermind of the 1988 Lockerbie bombing and the 1989 downing of a French passenger plane over Niger? That all depends on which echo chamber you live in.

    Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Ilayda Habip and Jean-Vincent Russo

    43 min
  • Gunning for Maduro? Trump targets vessels off Venezuela, Colombia

    Why is the United States suddenly in the business of blowing boats out of the water in the Caribbean? And why without summation? More than 30 people have been killed in seven strikes that started in early September, all under the orders of the same Donald Trump who wants a Nobel Peace Prize and who questions 80 years of US military presence in Europe, Korea and Japan. He's now gone beyond a war on drug trafficking in the Caribbean with not-so veiled threats to overthrow Venezuela’s regime. We ask about the operation and the resignation of the head of the US Southern Command that's in charge.

    This regional policy harks back to Trump's Inauguration Day nostalgia for William McKinley, his predecessor who started the 1898 war that wiped out Spain’s foothold in the Americas. Is all this really to please anti-leftist Latino voters in his secretary of state’s native Florida? 

    We also ask what’s next for Venezuela, a nation whose leader by all accounts stole the last presidential poll. How much support can Nicolas Maduro garner in this showdown, both at home and abroad?

    Produced by Delphine Liou, Rebecca Gnignatti, Ilayda Habip and Jean-Vincent Russo

    42 min
  • The Tomahawks are coming? As Trump sours on Putin, Ukraine asks for missiles

    Whenever Donald Trump boasts of solving eight wars in eight months, the US president always adds a sigh of regret and repeats that he thought Ukraine and Russia would be the easiest one to solve. He did it again at Monday's signing in Egypt of the plan to end the war in Gaza. So if rolling out the red carpet in Alaska and bringing Vladimir Putin in from the cold didn't work, what will?

    More pressure on Russia, it seems, with NATO allies like Germany pledging to purchase military hardware for Ukraine that's made in the USA. We ask about those Tomahawk long-range missiles that will figure top of Volodymyr Zelensky's wish list when he travels to the White House on Friday.

    The Oval Office dumpster fire that was their first encounter back in February is now a fading memory. And since Trump divides the world into winners and losers, could his calculus be shifting, what with Ukraine resisting Russia's summer onslaught and hurting Moscow's pocketbook with successful long-range drone strikes against oil installations deep inside enemy territory?

    We ask about momentum and prospects for what's already a very, very long war.

    Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Daniel Whittington, Juliette Laffont, Ilayda Habip, Charles Wente.

    42 min
  • Gen Z's moment? From Nepal to Madagascar, youth-led protests go global

    Can we really draw a link between Nepal and Madagascar? Bangladesh and Peru? Indonesia and Morocco? Why are waves of defiance sweeping nations that are oceans apart? That defiance now bears a name: Gen Z protests. The generation born after 1997 has had its fill of corrupt elders clinging to power – and their offspring flaunting excess on social media. There too, new hashtags have taken root: nepo babies and nepo kids. The contempt of the ruling classes is as old as French queens quipping, “let them eat cake”. So what is it about the digital age that seems to rub it particularly hard in young people’s faces – or rather, on their screens?

    Back in 2011, when the Arab Spring erupted, leaderless movements in Tunisia, Egypt and elsewhere were often branded “Facebook revolutions”. What’s changed now that young people have migrated to Instagram, TikTok and Discord? And what happens to leaderless movements today?

    Just ask the citizens of Madagascar, whose Gen Z movement led to Tuesday’s toppling of a president – and to a military coup. More broadly, how do we meet the aspirations of a generation that has moved to the cities, paid its dues in underfunded schools, endured blackouts and inadequate hospitals – and has finally had enough?

    Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Daniel Whittington, Juliette Laffont, Ilayda Habip, Charles Wente.

    43 min
  • Second time’s the charm? French PM Lecornu offers concessions to hostile parliament

    Was it enough for France’s minority government to clear the first hurdle of a trigger-happy, hostile parliament that can call a vote of no confidence at any time? Reappointed Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu is offering a suspension of Emmanuel Macron's flagship reform – the raising of the retirement age. We’ll review the general policy speech of a Lecornu who, this time at least, made it to the National Assembly. Last week, his initial coalition government imploded spectacularly after just 14 hours.

     

    Lecornu may be willing to bend – but what about his boss? Throughout one and a half terms in power, Emmanuel Macron has rarely been one for compromise … until now. The French president knows that a snap election would only further shrink his support in parliament.

    Markets may be unsettled by France’s spiralling public spending – but not as much as by the prospect of prolonged political paralysis or a populist surge. On that front, Macron is not alone in refusing to compromise. Just look at a splintered political landscape that stretches from the far right to the hard left. What does that say about the times we live in?

    Can Macron compromise? What should we make of his cabinet and Lecornu’s speech?

    We’ll need two pie charts of the National Assembly: one showing the blocs in simple terms, and another highlighting the Socialists. A suspension may be a concession – with Sébastien Lecornu offering to freeze the retirement age reform that Emmanuel Macron forced through parliament in 2023 over the objections of trade unions and public opinion.

    In May 2024, Macron’s decision to dissolve parliament backfired. His centrist bloc lost seats, the far right made historic gains, and the left united in an electoral alliance. That alliance has since unravelled, but the current makeup of parliament means that the Socialists, with their 69 seats, and the conservatives, Les Républicains, with 50, now find themselves as potential kingmakers.

    This time, under the leadership of Bruno Retailleau – a conservative with presidential ambitions – Lecornu has assembled a cabinet with fewer political heavyweights.

    Will the Socialists implode if they choose to compromise? What will the French accept in the name of reducing the deficit? What counts as politically acceptable?

    As for the far right’s Marine Le Pen – the National Rally leader staged a theatrical walkout during the parliamentary speech that followed the Prime Minister’s, this time during remarks by conservative Laurent Wauquiez. Le Pen’s party remains firm in its stance from last week, when she was not invited to the consultations at the Élysée Palace.

    Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Jean-Vincent Russo, Lila Paulou, Ilayda Habip and Charles Wente.

    44 min
  • What's next after the Israeli hostages-Palestinian prisoners swap?

    There are tears of grief, tears of anguish ... and on Monday, there are also tears of joy. For the first time in two years, Israelis and Palestinians are allowing themselves to exhale. We’ll discuss the return of the last hostages with our correspondent in Tel Aviv, the release of 2,000 prisoners from Israeli jails, the ramping up of aid into Gaza, and the silencing of guns. In a region accustomed to dashed hopes, could something positive emerge from what Donald Trump calls a peace deal?

    There was the hero's welcome for Donald Trump in Israel, hailed by both supporters and detractors of the Israeli prime minister. In his speech, Trump turned to the Israeli president and asked Isaah Herzog to pardon Benjamin Netanyahu in his corruption trial. In the Egyptian resort of Sharm el-Sheik, the love in continued with everyone from the leaders of France, Germany and the UK to those of Iraq and Indonesia present for the signing of the 20-point plan.

    Produced by François Picard, Rebecca Gnignati, Lila Paulou, Ilayda Habip, and Charles Wente.

    43 min

About The Debate

From the publisher's feed

A live debate on the topic of the day, with four guests. From Monday to Thursday at 7:10pm Paris time.