The Decision Intelligence Lab

The Decision Intelligence Lab

By The Decision Intelligence LabBusinessEntrepreneurship
Download on the App Store

All The Decision Intelligence Lab episodes

  • #41 Carl Spetzler: “More Than Half the Value Came From Framing”

    What makes a decision good, regardless of how it turns out? Carl Spetzler, the chairman of Strategic Decisions Group, has been helping companies like Chevron and Eli Lilly make high-stakes decisions with 30-year horizons. He joins Vijay Mehrotra and Michael Watson to walk through the six requirements of decision quality. He also tells the story that launched his career: as a graduate student, he analyzed Amoco's unleaded gasoline launch and changed how its board saw the risk.


    Carl explains how decision analysis grew into decision quality, why commitment to action is as important as analytical clarity, and why most "execution failures" are designed in when the decision is made. He also introduces Norma, an AI-assisted "decision vehicle," and the Universal Decision Quality Initiative, which aims to bring this rigor to everyday decisions through AI.


    Timestamps

    0:00 - Preview & Intro

    1:51 - The six requirements of decision quality: frame, alternatives, information, values, reasoning, commitment

    3:59 - Why framing matters most

    5:22 - Clarity isn't commitment

    7:03 - Universal decision quality and why you need decision records to beat hindsight bias

    8:42 - What a decision record contains

    10:31 - How Delaware's business judgment rule mirrors the six requirements

    12:00 - Case study: Amoco's unleaded gas decision

    17:10 - The key choice: a 75% chance of losing about $15M vs. a 25% chance of making $360M

    19:06 - "The only thing I took to the board was the decision analysis"

    20:03 - $900K of a $1M budget went to cost data that never moved the decision (value of information)

    23:09 - From decision analysis to decision quality: the SRI "teaching hospital" and owning the inputs

    25:47 - Most decision failures show up in execution, but they were designed in

    27:20 - Two complexities, analytical and social, and the dialogue process ("organizational therapy")

    30:15 - Norma: an LLM front end with decision science under the hood

    34:30 - A standing agenda item: which decisions should we be facing?

    36:10 - The bottleneck shifts to information and context

    37:00 - Carl uses Norma on his own decisions



    What you'll learn

    - The six requirements of a quality decision, and why framing may be the most valuable one

    - Why a good decision and a good outcome are different things, and how decision records protect against hindsight bias and blame

    - How value-of-information thinking would have saved most of a $1M analysis budget

    - Why many "execution failures" are really decision failures that were designed in when the decision is made

    - Why the analytical side of a decision is only half the work, and the people side is the other half

    - How AI can put decision science in the hands of everyday decision makers

    - Why teams should keep a standing "decision agenda"



    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠


    Connect with guest

    - Carl Spetzler: ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/cspetzler/

    - The Universal Decision Quality Initiative: UDQHub.com

    - Strategic Decisions Group: sdg.com

    - Decision Quality: Value Creation from Better Business Decisions (Spetzler, Winter & Meyer)- https://amzn.eu/d/09f5DGQW


    Connect with hosts

    - Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠

    - Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠


    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    42 min
  • #40 Soren Little: Optimization Inside the Database

    What if your database could make decisions?


    In this episode, Vijay Mehrotra and Michael Watson talk with Soren Little, co-founder of OSM, about making optimization a built-in part of the data stack. Databases already have SELECT for descriptive analytics and PREDICT for forecasting. OSM Data argues the missing keyword is DECIDE.


    The conversation covers why predict-then-optimize falls short, how scale makes stochastic optimization practical, and the challenge of trading battery storage in volatile energy markets. It ends with what Soren calls one of the defining questions of the next five years: scheduling AI compute without destabilizing the power grid.



    What you’ll learn

    - Why optimization should be a first-class citizen in the database

    - How separating what you want to solve from how to solve it mirrors what SQL did for data retrieval

    - How a system can spot a cheaper problem type, such as bipartite matching, before reaching for a general MIP solver

    - Why data scientists can move from dashboards and forecasts to recommended actions

    - Where predict-then-optimize breaks down, and how large-scale methods could make stochastic and robust optimization practical

    - The SELECT → PREDICT → DECIDE progression in database analytics

    - Why data centers, batteries and the grid can be treated as one supply chain


    Timestamps

    0:00 - Preview & Introduction

    1:17 - Meet Soren Little

    2:45 - What OSM does

    4:10 - The founding team: Soren, Jakob, and Matteo

    7:25 - The Decision House and its Lakehouse inspiration

    11:44 - Separating the business problem from the problem-solution method

    15:40 - Picking the best formulation automatically: the GPU scheduling example

    20:45 - Bringing optimization to the VLDB database community

    22:35 Beyond the dashboard: data scientists as decision makers

    24:45 - Handling uncertainty and the limits of predict-then-optimize

    28:40 - SELECT, PREDICT, DECIDE

    31:00 - Real-world use cases: airline scheduling and battery storage

    36:12 - OSM's vision: AI compute, energy, and the grid



    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠


    Connect with guest

    Soren Little: ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/sorenlittle/

    OSM: https://www.osm-data.com/


    Connect with hosts

    Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠


    Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠


    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    43 min
  • #39 Jerry Yurchisin: The Skill Data Scientists Ignore — Companies Save Millions With It

    Make better business decisions with data and AI—subscribe to The Decision Intelligence Lab Newsletter at ⁠⁠https://decisionintelligencelab.substack.com/⁠⁠.


    What happens after your ML model makes a prediction? When Jerry Yurchisin asks that at data science conferences, the answer is usually "I don't know." In this episode, Gurobi's senior data science strategist joins Vijay and Mike to talk about the tool that turns predictions into decisions: optimization.

    They cover why you don't need a PhD to deliver real value, why solvers never forget a constraint the way an LLM can, how GenAI helps experts model faster (while confidently getting things wrong) and why finance may be leaving optimization value on the table.

    If you're wondering what comes after prediction, this one's worth listening to.


    Timestamps:

    0:00 - Preview

    0:42 - Meet Jerry Yurchisin

    4:25 - What a Senior Data Science Strategist does at Gurobi

    5:45 - Spreading the word beyond OR conferences (Gartner, Databricks, ODSC)

    7:00 - Statistics + OR at UNC

    9:30 - The pitch to ML practitioners: "What happens next?"

    11:11 - Optimization as a career differentiator

    13:40 - Is optimization too math-heavy?

    17:42 - "I tried MIP ten years ago and it was too slow" - try again

    21:02 - When "optimization" means different things to ML people

    22:35 - Building Optimization 101 for data scientists

    25:10 - Do executives confuse data science and optimization?

    26:30 - Teaching with realistic (but solvable) examples

    29:10 - Applying GenAI and optimization together

    32:10 - Advice for the OR community: join the AI conversation

    35:40 - Hard constraints vs. context windows

    37:15 - Underutilized frontier: optimization in finance

    39:20 - Learn more at gurobi.com/learn



    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠


    Connect with guest

    - Jerry's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mathwithjerome/

    - Gurobi: https://www.gurobi.com

    - Gurobi learning resources: https://www.gurobi.com/learn


    Connect with hosts

    - Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠

    - Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠


    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    42 min
  • #38 Dr. Rich Staats: 41 Years in Uniform, OR in Every Job

    Make better business decisions with data and AI—subscribe to The Decision Intelligence Lab Newsletter at ⁠⁠https://decisionintelligencelab.substack.com/⁠⁠.


    What does it take to lead when the stakes are literally life and death?

    In this episode, Vijay and Mike sit down with Dr. Rich Staats — retired U.S. Army Major General, MIT Operations Research PhD, Hertz Fellow, and former Commanding General of the U.S. Army Reserve's 75th Innovation Command. Rich shares the three leadership principles he published in every command he held, the story of dining across the table from a man who threatened to kill him — and the one sentence that defused it — and why operations research sat at the center of every decision in his 41-year career. The conversation covers how much data a leader really needs, his "law of risk", lessons from running MITRE's OR department on briefing senior decision makers, and a candid take on generative AI: where it genuinely helps, and why he worries young analysts are losing their analytic muscle memory.


    Timestamps

    0:00 - Preview

    0:47 - Meet Dr. Rich Staats

    2:00 - How Rich and Mike met at an INFORMS conference

    3:05 - What ties a career across combat, think tanks, and startups together

    8:25 - "If it hadn't been for the war, we'd have retired several ranks earlier"

    11:03 - The Iraq dinner story: "I could just kill you now"

    14:14 - Double down on strengths or fix your weaknesses?

    15:50 - Innovation in the military & the 75th Innovation Command

    19:43 - OR at the center of 41 years of decisions

    22:30 - How often did he actually build a model?

    24:06 - The Red Pen Award: rewarding the best mistakes

    25:23 - How much data do you need? The 80/20 lesson

    28:10 - Advising senior executives: decision space, ranges, and the ORmadillos

    32:40 - Generative AI: biggest hopes and red flags

    37:30 - IP ownership and liability: the next 15–20 year challenge

    38:58 - Where to find Rich



    What You'll Learn

    - The three leadership principles (Perrin, Stafford, Peterson) that work in combat units, think tanks, and startups alike

    - Why respect and relationships (not command-and-control) kept Rich alive in Iraq

    - How an OR mindset can shrink 2-hour meetings to 15 minutes

    - How much data you actually need before deciding and why waiting for certainty is its own risk

    - How to brief analysis to senior senior decision makers: decision space, ranges, and the value of information

    - Where generative AI helps and how it can quietly erode analytic "muscle memory" and creativity


    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠



    Connect with guest

    - Rich's Website: https://zhalindor.com/

    - Rich's Music: https://zhalindor.com/dreams

    - Rich's Books: https://zhalindor.com/books


    Connect with hosts

    - Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠

    - Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠


    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    41 min
  • #37 Jeff Camm: Why the ROI Is in the Decision

    Make better business decisions with data and AI—subscribe to The Decision Intelligence Lab Newsletter at ⁠⁠https://decisionintelligencelab.substack.com/⁠⁠.


    Jeff Camm, Professor and Inmar Presidential Chair in Analytics at Wake Forest University School of Business joins Vijay and Mike to explain why so many data science projects fail to deliver ROI, and what his analysis of over 1.4 million job postings reveals about the skills that actually drive decisions.


    He shares how he built Wake Forest's MSBA around "the bookends" (problem framing and influence), his blueprint for a new undergrad core(Artificial Intelligence, Business Intelligence, Decision Intelligence) and why managers want choices, not answers. check against transcript for factual accuracy


    If your models aren't changing decisions, this one's for you.


    What You'll Learn

    - The measurable skill-set differences between data science and decision science roles, based on a decade of job posting data

    - Why data science projects fail and why the reasons echo OR project failures from decades past

    - How to design an analytics program around "the bookends": problem framing and influence

    - How to actually teach problem framing (experiential learning, real client messes, no data up front)

    - A three-course blueprint for the undergrad business core: Artificial Intelligence, Business Intelligence, Decision Intelligence

    - Why prescriptive analytics should deliver families of solutions, not single answers

    - Why you should ask an LLM for choices, not answers and what that means for teaching analytics in the AI era


    Timestamps

    0:00 - Preview

    1:01 - Meet Jeff Camm

    1:40 - Why "decision scientist," not "data scientist"

    4:20 - The research outcome: academia versus 1.4M job ads

    9:10 - Why data projects fail

    12:50 - Building Wake Forest's Masters in Business Analytics from scratch

    14:42 - The bookends: problem framing and influencing

    18:22 - Teaching problem framing: the practicum and "Mess to Model"

    20:35 - Team charters and learning to work in teams

    22:50 - A new undergrad core: AI → BI → Decision Intelligence

    29:10 - Problem-centric teaching and just-in-time technique

    33:30 - "Nobody likes to be told what to do": choices, not answers

    34:50 - LLMs, families of solutions, and the risk/return trade-off

    38:40 - Jeff's papers and where to learn more



    Resources:

    - "Data Science and Decision Science Skills: Are They Different and Does It Matter?" (Camm, Fry & Shafer, Harvard Data Science Review, Summer 2025): ⁠https://hdsr.mitpress.mit.edu/pub/9ir6e1j6/release/1⁠

    - The INFORMS Journal on Applied Analytics: ⁠https://pubsonline.informs.org/authored-by/Camm/Jeffrey+D⁠

    - "Stop Modeling Just the Data, Start Modeling Decisions" (forthcoming in MIT Sloan Management Review digital at time of publishing)



    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠


    Connect with guest

    - Jeff Camm: ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/jeff-camm-395b366/


    Connect with hosts

    - Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠

    - Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠



    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    42 min
  • #37 Cyrus Safaie: Inside DoorDash's Three-Sided Optimization Problem

    Make better business decisions with data and AI—subscribe to The Decision Intelligence Lab Newsletter at ⁠⁠https://decisionintelligencelab.substack.com/⁠⁠.


    What does it actually take to run a marketplace across thousands of micro-markets in real time?


    Cyrus Safaie, Former Director of Engineering and AI/ML at DoorDash joins Mike and Vijay to pull back the curtain on how DoorDash balances supply and demand, pays dashers, and predicts delivery times at massive scale. Cyrus shares why the company started with spreadsheets instead of algorithms, how a surprise Netflix boxing match drove a Super Bowl-sized demand spike with zero warning, and why the best automated systems treat human judgment as an input rather than an override. He also previews his new venture: using AI to build operationally heavy companies run by a single domain expert or tiny team.


    Timestamps

    0:00 - Preview

    1:01 - Meet Cyrus Safaie

    2:00 - What people underestimate about DoorDash: hyper-local markets

    3:28 - Scaling by doing things that don't scale

    6:48 - Optimizing a three-sided marketplace & the trade-offs

    11:20 - Who resolves conflicts between dasher, merchant, and consumer teams

    13:00 - Balancing supply/demand and dasher incentives in real time

    16:48 - Reactive Real-time decisions and the Netflix Tyson fight

    21:30 - Human input vs. human override: how to automate the right way

    27:27 - Fixing ETAs by predicting your own model's errors

    29:35 - Cyrus's new venture: AI-native operationally heavy companies

    33:38 - Where the human stays in the loop: one-expert companies

    36:36 - Advice for students: curiosity and "torturing your brain"


    What You'll Learn

    - Why DoorDash is really thousands of tiny, semi-isolated markets and why it optimizes locally before globally

    - How DoorDash scaled by starting with spreadsheets and manual judgment before building algorithms

    - How a three-sided marketplace balances dashers, merchants, and consumers

    - The difference between proactive and reactive dasher incentives, and how real-time mobilization works

    - Why human input into automated systems beats human overrides of them

    - How DoorDash improved ETAs by building models that predict their own errors

    - Cyrus's vision for AI-native, operationally heavy companies run by a single domain expert (or tiny team) plus an AI operating system


    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠


    Connect with guest

    Cyrus Safaie: ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/hsafaie/


    Connect with hosts

    Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠


    Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠


    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    43 min
  • #35 William Swelbar: How Airlines Became the Ultimate OR Playground

    Make better business decisions with data and AI—subscribe to The Decision Intelligence Lab Newsletter at ⁠⁠https://decisionintelligencelab.substack.com/⁠⁠.


    Airline veteran William Swelbar joins Vijay Mehrotra and Mike Watson for a tour through nearly 50 years of airline economics(from 1978 deregulation to today's premiumization era).

    William Swelbar's path is one of a kind: flight attendant at North Central in 1979, local union president in Detroit within a few years, and part of a 1982 employee coalition that had all but raised the $400 million it needed in a bid to buy Republic Airlines.

    The conversation digs into the analytics behind the industry: why hub-and-spoke networks turn 10 routes into 230 sellable city pairs, how Pan Am's $99 cabin became an early pricing wake-up call, why "capacity is a bad drug," and how Delta and United decommoditized flying through cabin segmentation, basic economy, and credit card revenue - while the end of labor arbitrage killed the low-cost carrier era.



    Timestamps

    0:00 - Preview

    0:44 - Vijay's Caddy Master Turned Airline Veteran

    5:10 - What deregulation actually changed

    8:00 - The overnight flood of new entrants

    9:30 - Pan Am's $99 cabin and ~120 bankruptcies

    11:43 - The fall of TWA and Pan Am; American's innovations

    14:23 - Network design: Hub-and-spoke vs. point-to-point

    16:32 - Southwest and the Southwest Effect

    19:40 - High-speed rail: too late for the US?

    22:15 - Capacity is a "bad drug"

    25:15 - How Delta and United segmented the cabins & won during COVID

    29:05 - Airfares never covered the cost of flying

    30:45 - Basic economy as a weapon against Spirit and Frontier

    33:50 - The end of the value airline sector

    36:55 - Wrap-up


    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠


    Connect with guest

    William Swelbar: ⁠https://swelbar.substack.com/


    Connect with hosts

    - Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠

    - Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠


    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    40 min
  • #34 Geoffrey De Smet: Solving Real-Time Scheduling Problems

    Make better business decisions with data and AI—subscribe to The Decision Intelligence Lab Newsletter at ⁠⁠https://decisionintelligencelab.substack.com/⁠⁠.


    Geoffrey De Smet built a scheduling solver as a side project and ended up with a NASA supplier, big telcos, and pest control companies running on it.

    The Timefold co-founder and OptaPlanner creator joins Vijay and Mike to talk field service routing: hundreds of technicians, tens of thousands of jobs, and the chaos of a real day in the field. They also discuss why plans are useless but planning is essential, why a 90% feasible schedule is 100% useless, why operators reject schedules they can't interrogate and what it took to leave a steady job when his life's work became roadkill after the IBM–Red Hat acquisition.

    If you've ever wondered why the world still runs on scheduling spreadsheets, this one's for you.


    Chapters

    0:00 - Preview & Introduction

    1:00 - Meet Geoffrey De Smet, Co-founder Timefold

    1:20 - What is field service routing?

    3:05 - Non-disruptive replanning and uncertainty

    10:25 - What-if simulations

    11:35 - Who uses Timefold Users

    14:45 - The telecom case: ROI and trade-offs of optimization

    18:05 - Spreadsheets and scheduling problems

    19:10 - From OptaPlanner to Timefold: The Origin story

    26:23 - Customising the model

    28:20 - Explainability deep dive

    30:28 - Where LLMs fit

    31:50 - Trust, feasibility, constraints and the operator's never-ending world

    35:23 - The Leap: leaving a steady job, six months of burning savings

    38:07 - Go-to-market challenges

    40:40 - Closing thoughts


    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠


    Connect with guest

    Geoffrey De Smet: ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/ge0ffrey/

    Timefold: https://timefold.ai

    Timefold Solver: https://timefold.ai/solver


    Connect with hosts

    Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠


    Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠


    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    42 min
  • #33 Connor Lawless & Madeleine Udell: What Really Slows Optimization Down

    . Make better business decisions with data and AI—subscribe to The Decision Intelligence Lab Newsletter at ⁠⁠https://decisionintelligencelab.substack.com/⁠⁠.


    Optimization powers decisions in everything from healthcare to logistics, but for most practitioners it stays a "magical box": powerful, opaque, and locked behind PhD-level expertise. So what actually gets in the way of putting these models to work?


    In this episode, hosts Vijay Mehrotra and Michael Watson sit down with Stanford's Postdoctoral Researcher Connor Lawless and Madeleine Udell (Assistant Professor at Management Science and Engineering Department, Stanford University) to unpack their paper "It Was a Magical Box": Understanding Practitioner Workflows and Needs in Optimization. Based on interviews with 15 optimization model developers, the research uncovers a surprising truth: the hardest part of operations research usually isn't the math. It's the people, the data, and the endless back-and-forth.


    We dig into the six-stage workflow of building an optimization model, why nearly every project becomes an iterative "flywheel," why machine learning feels so much easier than OR, when "good enough" beats provably optimal solutions, and how LLMs might finally close the accessibility gap. Connor also shares what's next as he joins Percepta to work on the "last mile" of analytics.


    Whether you build models for a living or just wonder why so many great models never make it into the real world, this conversation will change how you think about optimization in practice.


    The Research Paper:

    "It Was a Magical Box": Understanding Practitioner Workflows and Needs in Optimization (2025) - https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.16402



    Timestamps

    0:00 - Preview & Introduction

    0:57 - Meet Connor Lawless and Madeleine Udell

    2:04 - OR's accessibility problem vs. ML

    3:07 - The six stages of building an optimization model

    5:38 - Iteration as a flywheel: the "99% of the time" finding

    7:45 - Why is ML so much easier than OR?

    10:45 - The role of visualization and pattern recognition

    12:00 - Optimization as a distribution-shift problem

    13:24 - The big surprise: the human bottleneck, not the math

    15:32 - Implications for teaching in the age of AI

    18:00 - Handling uncertainty: data-scarce vs. data-rich problems

    20:00 - Solver friction: Gurobi, CPLEX, and parameter tuning

    22:20 - "Good enough" beats optimal

    24:16 - Practitioner innovations: data and constraint validators

    26:00 - Separating data from the model

    27:37 - Preventing silent wrong answers

    29:00 - Documentation, debugging, and LLMs as intermediaries

    30:30 - Connor's next chapter: Percepta and the "last mile" of analytics

    32:00 - If not us, then who?



    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠


    Connect with guest

    - Connor Lawless (Postdoctoral researcher, Stanford University): https://www.linkedin.com/in/connorlawless/

    - Madeleine Udell (Assistant Professor, Management Science & Engineering, Stanford University): https://www.linkedin.com/in/madeleine-udell/


    Connect with hosts

    - Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠

    - Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠


    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    37 min
  • #32 James Taylor: Why Your Decisions (Not Your Data) Are the Problem

    Make better business decisions with data and AI—subscribe to The Decision Intelligence Lab Newsletter at ⁠⁠https://decisionintelligencelab.substack.com/⁠⁠.


    What if the biggest mistake organizations make isn't in their data or their AI, but in never actually defining the decision they're trying to make?


    In this episode of the Decision Intelligence Lab, hosts Vijay Mehrotra and Michael Watson sit down with James Taylor, the author of Digital Decisioning, and Executive Partner at Blue Polaris. James traces the idea back 25+ years to a simple observation in financial services: fraud, origination, and collections systems all ran on the same technology stack yet were treated as entirely separate things. Naming that pattern changed how a whole industry approaches automation.


    The conversation digs into why decisions should be isolated as their own unit of work, why you should aim to automate everything to discover the parts that truly need people, and how a disability-claims team once saved 15 months of work simply by understanding the decision before building the model. James also shares where decisioning is going next, why he partners so closely with IBM, and his three durable principles for anyone trying to improve how their organization decides.



    Chapters

    0:00 - Preview & Introduction

    1:00 - Meet James Taylor & the origins of "decision management"

    3:20 - Economies of scale and cross-team learning

    5:25 - Task automation vs. true decisioning

    11:35 - Decision maps and who successfully adopts them

    13:25 - What to do when companies say "our data is no good"

    18:26 - Why data science teams get undermined presenting without business input

    19:35 - Automating decisions with uncertainty and multiple objectives

    23:05 - The case for "automate first" as a default mindset

    28:30 - Beyond financial services: healthcare payers and personalized care plans

    32:45 - The Blue Polaris business story

    38:15 - 3 principles for aspiring decision leaders


    Follow the show

    Apple: ⁠https://podcasts.apple.com/in/podcast/the-decision-intelligence-lab/id1811085064⁠

    Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/0lFoAVKqJHTYSZNpeN61ou?si=0ae973aab0174b3b⁠


    Connect with James

    Email: [email protected]

    LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jamestaylor/

    Website: https://bluepolaris.com/

    James's Book: https://www.amazon.de/stores/James-Taylor/author/B001IOH7UI



    Connect with hosts

    Prof. Vijay Mehrotra (University of San Francisco): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/vijay-mehrotra-ba9498/⁠


    Prof. Michael Watson (Northwestern University): ⁠https://www.linkedin.com/in/michael-watson-07600a1⁠


    About the podcast

    The Decision Intelligence Lab podcast delivers real-world insights for data professionals, business leaders, and anyone seeking to leverage data & AI for smarter decision-making & successful business outcomes.

    For business inquiries, email at ⁠[email protected]⁠

    41 min