Welcome to Yore Town, where we delve into the shadows of unsolved mystery. In this episode, we tackle one of Ireland's most enduring and frustrating true crime cold cases: the baffling disappearance of Conor and Sheila Dwyer from Fermoy, County Cork, in 1991.

The last confirmed sighting of the couple was on April 30th, 1991, walking toward a funeral near their home. Just days later, their house was found orderly, with all their possessions—including clothes, passports, and a large amount of cash—left behind. The only things missing were Conor and Sheila and their white Toyota Cressida.

This is a missing persons investigation that has spanned decades, involved international inquiries (including a strange sighting in Germany linked to Conor's employment with a German millionaire), and included multiple exhaustive searches of the River Blackwater. Despite the passage of time, every avenue leads to a dead end, leaving family and investigators seeking answers.

We explore the strange elements that make this 1990s cold case so unique: the rarity of a couple vanishing together, the fact that their memory remains so vivid for locals, and the profound questions that linger about their intentions and their fate. Gardaí believe locating their vehicle is the key to solving this enduring puzzle. Join us as we dissect the known facts, the wild theories, and the sheer impossibility of how two people, and their car, could simply cease to exist.

Key Moments

Unsolved Mystery: Why this missing persons case remains one of Ireland's most baffling cold cases.

Crucial Missing Clue: The vital importance of locating their missing white Toyota Cressida.

The German Connection: Analyzing the strange international leads tied to Conor's employment.

The True Crime Toll: Reflections on the time that has passed and the impact of this unsolved murder on the family's memory.

If you're invested in true crime and believe in justice, hit the like button and subscribe to Yore Town Podcast!

The case of Conor and Sheila Dwyer is featured on the YouTube channel Crime World, providing context for this baffling Irish cold case. Ireland's most baffling missing persons case - Couple vanish without trace

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.