Yore Town

A young woman is found dead. Her husband insists nothing suspicious happened. Her mother says her daughter came back from the grave to tell a very different story.

And then the body is dug up.

In January 1897, Elva Zona Heaster Shue was found dead in her home in Greenbrier County, West Virginia. Her husband, Erasmus "Trout" Shue, reportedly interfered with the doctor's examination, and Zona was buried.

But her mother, Mary Jane Heaster, refused to accept that her daughter's death was natural.

Mary claimed Zona's ghost appeared to her four times, revealing that her husband had killed her and describing the injuries that caused her death.

What happened next turned a small West Virginia community into the setting for one of the most extraordinary murder cases in American history.

Authorities exhumed Zona's body. Doctors discovered devastating injuries to her neck. Trout Shue was arrested, and the case went to trial.

Then came the twist that made the Greenbrier Ghost a legend.

The defense brought up Mary's alleged ghostly encounters in court.

And Mary insisted it wasn't a dream.

This week on Yore Town, Matt and Meg investigate the strange, dark, and unbelievable true story behind the Greenbrier Ghost.

IN THIS EPISODE:

One thing is certain: a young woman was murdered, her mother refused to let the matter rest, and a jury convicted the man responsible.

The haunting remains a mystery.

ABOUT YORE TOWN

The strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

Join Matt and Meg as they uncover the history, mysteries, disasters, and extraordinary events that make places unforgettable.

Follow Yore Town on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and wherever you listen.

Watch the video version on YouTube.

THE QUESTION OF THE WEEK:

If you had been on the jury in 1897, would Mary's story about her daughter's ghost have made you more likely to believe her, less likely, or would you have focused entirely on the medical evidence?

Share this episode with someone who loves strange history, true crime, or unexplained mysteries.

Content advisory: This episode discusses murder, domestic violence, death, and exhumation.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

THE ALIEN BURIED IN TEXAS: THE AURORA UFO CRASH OF 1897

Welcome to creepy season on the Yore Town Podcast!

More than 125 years ago, something extraordinary supposedly happened in the little town of Aurora, Texas.

On April 17, 1897, a mysterious flying machine reportedly appeared above the community, lost altitude, and crashed into a local judge's windmill.

According to a newspaper report published two days later, the wreckage contained strange metal, mysterious documents, and the remains of a pilot who was believed to have come from Mars.

And what did the people of Aurora supposedly do?

They gave the alien a Christian burial.

Yes. An alien funeral in Texas.

In 1897.

But there's a fascinating twist.

The original newspaper article really exists. Aurora Cemetery really exists. And people have spent decades searching for evidence of the supposed extraterrestrial burial.

However, historians have raised serious questions about whether the entire event was invented.

At the time, Aurora was struggling. Disease had driven residents away, and a proposed railroad connection had bypassed the community.

Could a bizarre story about a crashed Martian have been an attempt to put the town back on the map?

THIS WEEK ON YORE TOWN:

• The mysterious airship reports sweeping America in the 1890s

• The alleged April 17, 1897, crash in Aurora, Texas

• The supposed discovery of a pilot from Mars

• Strange metal, mysterious writing, and an extraordinary newspaper report

• The alleged Christian burial of an extraterrestrial visitor

• The historical circumstances that may have inspired the story

• The possibility of an elaborate newspaper hoax

• UFO investigators searching for evidence decades later

• The mystery surrounding Aurora Cemetery

• Ned, the alleged alien who became a Texas legend

Matt and Megh examine the claims, question the evidence, and explore how one extraordinary story became part of a small town's identity.

Was Aurora the site of an extraterrestrial encounter decades before Roswell?

Or did somebody create a legend so unforgettable that people are still investigating it more than a century later?

One thing is certain.

Aurora, Texas, will never be remembered as just another little town.

ABOUT YORE TOWN

The strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

Hosted by Matt (Beard Laws) and Megh, Yore Town explores the bizarre events, forgotten disasters, historical mysteries, and unbelievable legends connected to real locations.

New episodes every week.

Listen, follow, and share Yore Town wherever you enjoy podcasts.

QUESTION OF THE WEEK:

Do you believe the Aurora alien crash actually happened, or was it an elaborate hoax?

We want to hear your theories!

Remember, sometimes the strangest stories aren't about what happened.

They're about why people never stopped believing.

Rest easy, Ned.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

On October 17, 1814, a 700-pound iron hoop fell from a massive wooden vat inside London’s Horse Shoe Brewery.

The vat held more than one million pints of porter.

About an hour later, the vat exploded.

Over the next two centuries, the London Beer Flood became a legend filled with stories of people rushing into the streets with buckets, drinking free beer and turning the disaster into a giant drunken party.

The contemporary historical record tells a very different story.

In this episode:

Eight people died.

Yore Town

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Virginius Island was built because of the river.

Factories harnessed the power of the Shenandoah. Workers followed the factories. Homes, roads, gardens and a school followed the workers. Before long, a tiny island beside Harpers Ferry, West Virginia had become a thriving industrial community.

Then, on September 30, 1870, the river rose.

Fast.

Reports preserved by the National Park Service describe water rising six feet in just four minutes. Bridges connecting Virginius Island to higher ground were destroyed. Around 70 houses were swept away, industries were devastated, and 42 people died around Harpers Ferry.

Jonathan and Emily Child survived with their family while trapped inside their home as the flood raged around them.

And somehow, people came back.

They rebuilt their homes. Industry returned. Life continued.

Then came another flood.

And another.

And another.

In this episode of Yore Town, Matt and Megh follow Virginius Island from its rise as a water-powered industrial village through the Civil War, the catastrophic flood of 1870 and decades of repeated destruction that eventually forced people to abandon the island altogether.

Today, Virginius Island is part of Harpers Ferry National Historical Park. Visitors can walk through the woods and discover stone foundations, old waterways and industrial ruins left behind by the community that once lived there.

The Shenandoah River gave Virginius Island everything.

Eventually, it took it back.

Yore Town tells the strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

THE GREAT DIAMOND HOAX OF 1872

What if you traveled hundreds of miles into the American West, discovered genuine diamonds with your own hands, and still got scammed?

In 1872, Philip Arnold and John Slack convinced some of California's wealthiest businessmen that they had discovered an enormous diamond field. Their evidence was convincing. They had real gemstones, a secret location, and a mining engineer who personally inspected the site.

But the entire discovery was a carefully constructed fraud.

The two prospectors had purchased genuine diamonds and other gemstones, buried them in remote Western terrain, and guided investors directly to the planted treasure. Even Charles Lewis Tiffany examined the gemstones as the investors prepared for what they believed would be an extraordinary mining fortune.

Then geologist Clarence King arrived.

A strange pattern involving gemstones, disturbed anthills, and an empty trench exposed what everyone else had missed. The diamonds were real, but the supposed mineral deposit was not.

In this episode, Matt and Megh uncover:

• How two prospectors convinced wealthy investors they had discovered an American diamond field.

Hundreds of thousands of dollars changed hands, and an even larger proposed stock offering was stopped before it could move forward.

The diamonds were real. The field was real. The fortune was not.

ABOUT YORE TOWN

Yore Town explores the strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places. Join Matt and Megh as they uncover the history hiding behind extraordinary locations, forgotten events, and stories that sound too unbelievable to be true.

Subscribe or follow Yore Town so you never miss an episode.

QUESTION OF THE WEEK

If you personally found diamonds in the ground and an expert confirmed they were genuine, would you have invested your money?

Share your answer with us!

Yore Town is part of the Bleav Network.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

On Sunday night, September 5, 1926, the people of Dromcollogher, County Limerick, gathered for something special: a night at the movies.

There was no cinema in the village, so roughly 150 people climbed into a wooden loft above a hardware store where a traveling film show had been set up. The room had a narrow staircase, barred windows, highly flammable nitrate film and candles being used near the projector.

Then one of those candles fell.

Within moments, the nitrate film ignited. Fire spread through the loft, the main staircase became impassable, and desperate moviegoers turned toward the windows. Some managed to escape. Others found themselves trapped as one possible way out after another disappeared.

By the following morning, 46 people had died in the ruins. Two more later died from their injuries.

48 people were dead in a village of roughly 500. Fifteen of them were children.

In this episode of Yore Town, Matt and Megh tell the story of the Dromcollogher cinema fire, the families devastated by the disaster, the questions over how such a dangerous screening was allowed to happen, the bizarre fate of organizer William "Babe" Ford, and what became of the site afterward.

Because this story has one remarkable final chapter.

The place where dozens of people died while gathering to watch stories eventually became a place where the village could gather for stories again.

A library.

One hundred years later, Dromcollogher still remembers September 5, 1926.

They call it The Burning.

Yore Town tells the strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

New episodes weekly.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

In 1901, Buffalo, New York, built a city that wasn't supposed to last.

The Pan-American Exposition was a spectacular World's Fair designed to show millions of visitors what the new century could become. Enormous buildings surrounded illuminated fountains, hundreds of thousands of electric lights transformed the grounds after dark, and the power of nearby Niagara Falls helped create a spectacle unlike anything many Americans had ever experienced.

Then the President of the United States walked into the Temple of Music.

On September 6, 1901, William McKinley stood inside the exposition greeting members of the public. One man approached with a handkerchief wrapped around his right hand. McKinley apparently assumed the hand was injured and reached out to greet him.

Hidden beneath the handkerchief was a revolver.

Two shots changed American history.

McKinley survived the initial shooting, and for several days it appeared that he might recover. The news became optimistic enough that Vice President Theodore Roosevelt eventually left Buffalo for the Adirondacks.

Then McKinley's condition suddenly collapsed.

In this episode of Yore Town, Matt and Meg uncover the incredible story of the 1901 Pan-American Exposition, the assassination of President William McKinley, the medical battle to save his life, Theodore Roosevelt's frantic journey back to Buffalo, and the private home where a 42-year-old Roosevelt unexpectedly became the youngest person ever to assume the presidency.

We also dig into the strange Robert Todd Lincoln connection, what happened to McKinley's assassin, how the assassination helped change presidential security, and the bizarre fate of the World's Fair itself.

Because just weeks after one of the most important moments in American history unfolded there, Buffalo's spectacular temporary city began to disappear.

The Temple of Music vanished. The Electric Tower vanished. Most of the exposition grounds were dismantled and eventually replaced by Buffalo neighborhoods.

But not everything disappeared.

More than a century later, Buffalo still holds pieces from both sides of the story: the place where one presidency ended and the home where another began.

Yore Town explores the strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

Big towns. Small towns. Big stories.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

On September 1, 1894, Hinckley, Minnesota was a booming lumber town surrounded by forests dried by months of drought and littered with highly combustible logging debris.

By the next morning, much of the town was gone.

In this episode of Yore Town, Matt and Megh revisit the Great Hinckley Fire and the terrifying hours when an ordinary Saturday became a fight for survival.

As the firestorm closed in, residents had almost no warning and no reliable way of knowing which direction offered safety. Some climbed into wells and root cellars. Others fled toward rivers, swamps and a gravel pit. Hundreds raced toward the railroad.

One evacuation train carrying roughly 400 refugees was forced to cross a bridge that was already burning. Minutes after the train made it across, the bridge collapsed.

Another train picked up more than 300 people before being struck by an explosion and catching fire. Its crew somehow kept the burning train moving until reaching Skunk Lake — which turned out to be little more than a shallow marsh. Hundreds of survivors climbed into roughly 18 inches of muddy water and waited while the fire burned around them.

By the time the disaster was over, Hinckley and surrounding communities had been devastated, hundreds of square miles had burned, and at least 418 people were dead. The true death toll may have been even higher.

We also explore how Hinckley's lumber industry helped create the conditions for disaster, why seemingly sensible escape routes became deadly traps, the incredible role of the railroads, the aftermath of the fire, and how the catastrophe helped change Minnesota's approach to wildfire prevention.

Episode Chapters

00:00 — The Horizon Is on Fire
02:28 — Hinckley Before the Disaster
07:17 — The Forest Becomes Fuel
09:42 — The Warning Everyone Got Used To
12:06 — A Firestorm Is Born
14:31 — Hinckley Starts Running
16:27 — Every Escape Could Kill You
18:43 — The Train and the Burning Bridge
20:58 — Trapped in 18 Inches of Water
22:54 — Hinckley Is Gone
25:20 — Burying the Dead
27:23 — How the Fire Changed Minnesota
29:27 — Would We Have Survived?
31:34 — Hinckley Comes Back

More than 130 years later, Hinckley still exists. The town rebuilt after a disaster that took only hours to nearly erase it.

Yore Town tells the strange, dark and unbelievable true stories of real places.

If you enjoy forgotten disasters, strange history and unbelievable stories hiding in real towns, follow Yore Town so you don't miss the next episode.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

On the afternoon of August 26, 1926, 57 men were working underground at the Clymer No. 1 coal mine near the small Pennsylvania community of Clymer.

At exactly 1:00 PM, the mine exploded.

Five or six minutes later, it exploded again.

The second blast ripped through the already-damaged underground workings, destroyed parts of the ventilation system and sent flame and coal dust more than 100 feet into the air.

Outside, families ran toward the mine while rescue crews headed underground. Smoke, debris and poisonous gases repeatedly forced rescuers back, but amid the destruction came incredible stories of survival.

One miner was forced to leave his own father behind after his father realized that trying to save him could kill them both. Another group crawled roughly a mile and a half through smoke and toxic gas, passing dead and dying coworkers as they searched for a way back to daylight.

By the end of the disaster, 44 men were dead.

Some families lost more than one loved one. In several homes around the community, two or even three coffins were placed together in the same front room.

And somehow, the death toll could have been far worse.

Clymer No. 1 normally employed hundreds of workers, but the mine was operating on reduced “slack time” that day. Only 57 men happened to be underground when the explosions occurred.

Nearly a century later, the Clymer Mine Disaster has largely disappeared from American memory, but not from Clymer. A memorial outside the borough building still carries the names of the 44 men who never came home.

In this episode of Yore Town, Matt and Megh travel back to August 26, 1926, to uncover what happened beneath Clymer, Pennsylvania, the miners who fought their way out, the families waiting above, and how one terrible afternoon changed a small coal town forever.

Because the explosion happened underground.

The disaster happened to the town.

Yore Town Podcast

The strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

New episodes weekly.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

On the night of August 21, 1986, families living beneath Lake Nyos in Cameroon went to sleep with no reason to believe they were in danger.

By morning, roughly 1,700 people were dead.

There was no massive fire. No flood had swept through the villages. No lava had destroyed their homes. In many places, almost everything was still standing.

The killer was the air itself.

Lake Nyos had suddenly released an enormous amount of carbon dioxide stored deep beneath its surface. Invisible and heavier than the surrounding air, the gas traveled downhill into valleys and villages, displacing the oxygen people and animals needed to survive.

In this episode of Yore Town, Matt digs into the unbelievable true story of the Lake Nyos disaster, including:

• How a peaceful crater lake became a massive natural reservoir of carbon dioxide

Forty years after the disaster, Lake Nyos is still there. It's still beautiful. And deep beneath its surface, carbon dioxide continues to enter the lake.

That's what makes this story so unsettling.

Yore Town explores the strange, dark, and unbelievable true stories of real places.

Follow Yore Town so you don't miss next week's story.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.