Hy and Christopher take on the 250th birthday of the United States, and we discussed whether the term “evil” should be used against one’s political opponents. However, most of the discussion on this edition of the Founders’ Show centers around the results of the June 27, 2026 runoffs. Letlow, Cao, and Hilferty won their respective GOP Primaries, but John Young may be the first true victim of the new closed primary system.
The June 27, 2026 runoffs demonstrated the political strength of Gov. Jeff Landry, the comparative weakness of the LA Republican activist grassroots in relaying a message to the general public, and the dominance of the party’s establishment at delivering the result that Republican party leadership sought. Voter turnout proved anemic on June 27, amounting to just 17 percent of registered voters according to Ed Chervenak, a political science professor at the University of New Orleans, down from 28 percent in the May primary. In theory, fewer voters should have aided the GOP activist base in their effort to defy the LAGOP establishment and Donald Trump. Instead, Jeff Landry’s support along with President Trump’s thwarted what looked like a last-minute grassroots surge for LA State Treasurer John Fleming, delivering a 57-43 victory for US Rep. Julia Letlow over him, or a margin of 43,411 votes statewide in GOP Senate runoff.
More particularly, Fleming lost the core of his one-time congressional district in Shreveport, losing Caddo Parish to Letlow 48-52 and literally tying the Congresswoman in Bossier Parish at 4351 votes each. Conversely, Letlow won every parish in her 5th Congressional District—and most everywhere else outside LA’s 4th Congressional District except for Orleans Parish. Throughout the runoff, the Fleming campaign had excelled in earning local and parish party endorsements. His supporters even blocked a Republican State Central Committee endorsement for Letlow, despite the governor’s and the president’s active pressure. Nevertheless, endorsements from elected officials from the White House-on-down proved enough to sway most of the GOP and “no-party” electorate to vote for Letlow in the closed primary runoff.
A similar, but much closer result provided a victory to interim BESE member (and former 2nd District Congressman) Joseph Cao. He beat fellow Republican Ellie Schroder for the multi-parish Board of Elementary and Secondary Education position despite the fact she was the well-known wife of a former State Representative and State Treasurer—with much of the same grassroots support (often the same people) as Fleming—but without Donald Trump‘s personal intervention.
The President demurred from picking a favorite in the open Public Service Commissioner’s contest to replace the term limited Eric Skrmetta as well. As such, eight out of ten of the Republican Parish Political Executive Committees (which comprise the GOP-leaning PSC District) endorsed John Young, the former Jefferson Parish President. Conversely, almost all of the elected officials lined up behind his opponent State Rep. Stephanie Hilferty (R-New Orleans), even some of Young’s oldest political allies.
The reason centered on the influence of one man, River Birch owner Fred Heebe, and his vendetta against Young. As Jefferson President, Young had canceled the trash-magnate’s contract to to assume control over the Jefferson Parish landfill, as an independent study had said that River Birch’s contract would raise garbage rates for the average homeowner. Heebe never forgave Young for the loss of his company’s lucrative contract, and the River Birch owner subsequently spent over $3.5 million in independent PAC expenditures to defeat Young in his last three bids for public office. In the PSC race alone, Heebe spent $1.2 million in attack ads against Young and reportedly used his influence with local elected officials to endorse the (admittedly already popular with her colleagues) Hilferty over Young.
Ironically, Young, who had kept garbage rates and other governmental consumer fees low during his time in Jefferson Parish government came to be perceived as the candidate who would raise utility rates because of the contributions that Young received from Louisiana-based utility companies. The fact that Hilferty earned contributions from many of these same utilities was left relatively unreported in the torrent of negative advertising which descended upon Young.
Ultimately, Young lost on June 27, receiving approximately the same vote that he earned in the primary, 29,801 versus 29,459 in runoff. He only lost 342 votes overall, despite the fact that 16,890 fewer people voted in the runoff. Instead, Hilferty gained almost all of the votes which went to third place primary finisher Mark Wright, winning 49,047 votes in the runoff versus 26,500 votes in primary. From a counterfactual standpoint, speculation on how this PSC race might have ended differently if Democrats had been able to vote in this GOP runoff has abounded in the past week.
Arguably, Young would have gotten the lion-share of the Democratic vote. He was endorsed by the AFL-CIO as well as many of the elected democratic officials in and around the district. Conversely, Hilferty, who represents lakefront Orleans and the small Bucktown neighborhood of Jefferson in the state legislature, had received little institutional Democratic support. Moreover, only a very, very small piece of her current State Rep District actually sits within the PSC seat.
In the past, Young had proven very popular with Democratic voters. In his three runs for Parish President, (even against Cynthia Lee Sheng), he had earned a substantial share of the Democratic vote, as he had in his run Lt. Governor—even with a popular Democratic candidate standing in that open primary. The barring of Democratic participation in this closed party contest, however, saw Young lose even in his home parish 44-56 to Stephanie Hilferty. This occurred despite the fact that pre-election polling data across all demographic groups showed Young with strong Democratic support prior to the June 27 election.
In other words, the closed GOP party runoff may have claimed its first true victim in John Young, who likely would have seen a much closer election (and possibly victory due to the low turnout) if the more than 50,000 Democrats who cast a ballot in the US Senate Democratic primary in the parishes comprising this PSC seat had been allowed to cast in the GOP partisan PSC runoff.
Nevertheless, Democrats will have their chance to vote. Stephanie Hilferty is not elected yet. She will face “No Party” candidate "Chris" Justin and Democrat Connie Norris in the November 3, 2026 General Election.
Likewise, Democrat Angela Hershey will face off against Republican Joseph Cao for the open BESE seats. Like Norris, she was the only Democrat to run. Julia Letlow will face the victor of the US Senate Democratic primary, Jamie Davis. He won his closed party runoff against Gary Crockett with 80 percent of the vote on June 27th. Davis, enjoyed almost ubiquitous Democratic support after earning 47 percent in the May 16 primary.